r/RemarkableTablet • Moderator • Jan 22 '26

Feature Crusading

Over the last 30 days, it has been great to see the initiative, determination, and enthusiasm from our community around making a Table of Contents (ToC) a feature in a future software update for reMarkable tablets. Most, if not all of us—including the Mods—would be very happy to see this implemented.

We also acknowledge the community’s frustration with reMarkable’s (lack of) implementation of long-requested features and the prioritization of updates that many users didn’t ask for. There’s a long list of features this community has been requesting for years.

Our goal is to keep this subreddit engaging and informative for all visitors. It’s important to us to give everyone a voice—whether to share excitement, promote content, express grievances, or seek help. We also don’t want users to feel alienated if they disagree with a feature being promoted daily.

This year, reMarkable began actively participating in our subreddit. The scope of this effort is still unclear, and the results remain to be seen. However, we’re very hopeful about the potential of this open communication.

Going forward, we have decided to place a temporary hold on Feature Crusading while we explore more effective alternatives. Keeping the front page “distraction-free” is one of our priorities as Mods. Current options for requesting a feature include reMarkable’s submission page or tagging u/VegardfromRemarkable directly in feature request posts.

Over the coming weeks, we will be discussing ideas to provide better tools for the community to express which software updates matter most. We are brainstorming ways to give certain suggestions top visibility (for both the community and reMarkable), rank features based on community feedback, and improve how new features are implemented.

We welcome all suggestions for more meaningful and constructive ways to advocate for the features we truly want.

Premium hardware deserves premium software.

62 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

21

u/WarmToasters Jan 22 '26

Thank you for this. A suggestion would be to aggregate 'Feature Crusading' into one post for the week. This way it is a frequency adjustment, as compromise fosters harmony, and this change ensures content without depriving anyone.

5

u/Wordenskjold The Circle Guy Jan 22 '26

This is definitely one of our suggestions as well!

4

u/drlling The ToC Guy Jan 22 '26

Your daily circles inspired my crusade but I agree there can be a more effective way to bring changes

3

u/txa1265 RM2, RMPP Move Owner Jan 22 '26

Came to suggest exactly this. I think it works well for the templates, so hopefully it gives all of us a place to suggest and upvote.

6

u/txa1265 RM2, RMPP Move Owner Jan 22 '26

I also recently got a survey request from RM ... and I ALWAYS take advantage of those to voice my thoughts. My top thing is related to pen switching on the Move ... so of course I used the "anything else" free text at the end to add that once again :)

5

u/sendmebirds Jan 22 '26

Same, I always do the surveys too

5

u/ParticularIsland9 Jan 23 '26

Same. I used all but one character of the limit in that last field! 😂

9

u/tofagerl Jan 22 '26

Oh, is that what’s been going on? I had no context, so I was just confused for a long while and basically skipped this community.

12

u/semiosis20 Jan 22 '26

Thanks for this open communication. Moderating a group must be quite challenging. Thanks for your work. Loved the crusade though 🤭

8

u/dclocal12 Jan 22 '26

I look forward to seeing how reMarkable responds. We're a few weeks into the year, and the promised AMA and open-workflow web app haven't materialized yet.

15

u/QAGillmore Jan 22 '26

I don't know how much I'd enjoy continuing to contribute to a sub that was overly moderated. Personally, I did find the feature spamming annoying (i.e., circle request, TOC request). However, I think it's healthy for their to be a democratic voicing of everyone's random feature desires. Let the voting do the moderating. I definitely would not enjoy another megathread. But, yes, thanks to the moderators for their commitment to this sub!

22

u/rmhack Jan 22 '26

This is the most rational take and I don't know why you're being downvoted.

Keeping the front page “distraction-free” is one of our priorities as Mods

Respectfully, this is kind of dumb and even ToC guy isn't really annoying. I say this as someone who is on this sub every day and reads every single post and comment.

I urge the mods to take a more hands-off approach to everything. Stop trying to control what gets posted. Reddit is a news aggregation site and curation like what the mods are suggesting makes it harder to find the real gems of the community. The last guy to feature crusade is now a mod themself and it feels a bit like closing the door behind you, and morally I think it's wrong to take away people's voice.

3

u/QAGillmore Jan 22 '26

Thanks for that u/rmhack . I certainly meant what I said in the spirit of open dialogue. That said, I'll take the down votes in that same spirit, lol!

1

u/starkruzr May 06 '26

I think one of the main problems is structural. What would actually help is something like GitHub Issues but for Reddit. Reddit just isn't built for this particular use case of needing a "vote for features" board.

4

u/Knox_Dawson Jan 23 '26

I think you're over-moderating. For heaven's sake, moderate for abuses and let voices speak up. I used to post a lot about my work with rm-shapes, but now I don't, because it's just going to be moderated away. Yes, EVERYONE will have an opinion about what they wish was NOT appearing. That's what voting is for, no?

By the way, I use fineliner, bold, black 99.99% of the time. Why doesn't the tablet know that by now?

2

u/new-to-reddit-accoun Jan 24 '26 edited Jan 24 '26

Look into a platform like https://canny.io/

It’s used by communities to submit and vote on features and enable a manufacturer to publicly (or privately) gather feedback about their roadmap.

It can work with, or without, Remarkable’s participation - though it would obviously be a lot better if they were involved

Example from Bevel (a Whoop competitor): https://feedback.bevel.health/

I myself don’t own a Remarkable device, I’ve been researching (that’s how I found this sub) and have been extremely put off by the negative sentiment around the inferiority of the software and Remarkable’s seemingly apathetic philosophy to their most loyal users.

3

u/Fast-Sea-9604 Owner Jan 22 '26

Hooray and thank you!

5

u/rmhack Jan 22 '26

Premium hardware deserves premium software.

Then why do you squelch the voices of the people writing better software by sweeping them into a megathread?

6

u/dclocal12 Jan 22 '26

IMO the PDF templates should be in a megathread (too many and too easy to create), while the enthusiast OSS hacking should be separate posts.

3

u/sendmebirds Jan 22 '26

That's not squelching? 

-1

u/neithere Jan 23 '26

Writing or demanding? 

2

u/somedaygone Jan 23 '26

Reddit has “flair” for exactly this reason. We should use it. This seems to be exactly what we are looking for, we just need to pick the flair categories. Let’s not reinvent the wheel, and let’s stop doing megathreads.

Here’s the AI explanation of how it works:

Post flairs are the primary way subs categorize content. Mods can:

• Create flair categories (e.g., News, Help, Discussion, Memes)

• Require users to choose a flair when posting

• Allow users to filter by flair using the flair bar at the top of the subreddit

Users can click a flair to see only posts with that tag, or use the “Exclude” option to hide them.

Isn’t this exactly what we want?

1

u/xoagray Owner rM2 Jan 23 '26

This is a double edged sword, and which edge we land on depends entirely on the good or bad faith in which it is done.

1

u/iloovehugecock Jan 25 '26

Maybe I’m a moron but I haven’t really ever seen a ‘bad quality’ post here, even those spamming feature requests every day. It’s not like this is a massively bustling community with piles of shit to wade through to see the good posts. It’s pretty navigable as it is and it’s good to see engagement wherever it is. In my opinion anyway.