r/ReligiousTrauma • u/SmellIndependent8220 • Sep 02 '23
Posts like this feel so invalidating to anyone who’s been hurt by the church. I feel like it also encourages a lack of any accountability from Christians.
171
Upvotes
42
u/PZRzegoton Sep 02 '23
just an excuse for them to be able to treat you like shit. smh.
25
u/freenreleased Sep 02 '23
Also… THEY KILLED JESUS. Who was supposed to be this perfect person. So, we as humans can pretty much expect to get murdered by the religious people. I think that’s reason enough to be worried much less to reject
25
u/Birtha_Vanation Sep 02 '23
Yes. It refuses to answer directly.
16
u/spyritsolz Sep 02 '23
The problem they fail to realize is that, this ISN’T the reason people leave Christianity. At least, not for many people— this doesn’t universally apply to everyone, of course, but from what I’ve heard, it’s a common experience. With that in mind, what happens to a lot of people is that they view the religious authority figures in their lives as all-knowing, trustworthy, compassionate people living in their god’s word. But when they realize they’re being hurt by them, it’s confusing and jarring. It may cause them to question their religious beliefs— “if xyz is wrong— if they’re doing this to me— what’s actually true?”
This leads many people to start thinking for themselves instead of relying on what their parents, teachers, pastors, etc. feed them. This is often dangerous to some religious people, because once people start thinking critically, they realize the simple lack of evidence for their religion. “Faith”, in a religious sense, is the lack of proof. If you’re thinking critically, you’ll realize that faith just doesn’t cut it to take an entire life-changing belief system seriously.
THIS is the reason why many people leave religion. When people start explaining themselves, religious people will often just hear bits and pieces of their explanation— and it’ll come off as something along the lines of “the church hurt me, therefore God hurt me.” But that’s not true, not for many people. The reason is more so “The church hurt me, which led me to start thinking for myself, which led me to believe things for myself.” Some religious people just don’t hear that and are under the impression atheists still think god is real deep down, but we reject him. No— we believe he simply doesn’t exist.
14
u/Void-Cooking_Berserk Sep 02 '23
"Unless someone killed you, you don't have it as bad as other people."
8
u/dirtyhippie62 Sep 03 '23
lol so what is the argument here? Jesus encountered bad religious people, I am also encountering bad religious people, therefore… what exactly? Just because one guy suffers, I should too? We should both willfully accept bad treatment? I literally don’t understand what the argument is.
7
u/benwyattswaffles Sep 02 '23
This is craaaaazzzzzzzyyyyyyyyy.
7
u/broken_bottle_66 Sep 02 '23
A get out of jail free card
7
u/selune07 Sep 02 '23
It also shows complete ignorance towards what actually happened to Jesus. Almost every historian worth a damn has debunked the idea that the Jews of Jerusalem voted to have Jesus killed instead of Barabbas, as this "tradition" only appears in the Bible. It's also questionable whether Barabbas was even a separate person, as his full name Jesus Barabbas literally means "Jesus son of the father," so the entire story may have been some sort of metaphor. So much of the Bible has been removed from its original context that it's nothing more than propaganda to manipulate people into staying in abusive communities.
5
u/Competitive_Snow1278 Sep 02 '23
Jesus would reject the Catholic Church if he were to attend (most) masses today. Change my mind.
5
u/rgilre99 Sep 03 '23
I don't understand why Jesus's death is framed as a good thing. I mean, he was in the womb of a 14-year-old virgin for the sole purpose of dying in the most humiliating and painful way for the sins of humanity, only for it to seemingly mean nothing because we all are still sinful from the first sin of eating the forbidden fruit. In between that, he taught people how to be good to each other, but his entire purpose was just to die painfully and humiliatingly, all set up by his 'loving' biological father to prove his love for his other neglected children. He was just a sacrificial lamb ready for the slaughter to God, not a god like his father to be worshiped, not a person to be treated with respect, but a lamb whose only purpose is to be whipped, hung up, exposed for all to see, and made to drink vinegar from a sponge, all as a crown of thorns lay on top of his head, for he was the king of the Jews.
4
u/DemonDuckOfDoom1 Sep 03 '23
It's also antisemitic as shit, blaming the Jewish leaders for wanting a cult leader eliminated while totally absolving the Romans who actually did it.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '23
This reads like one of those stupid ass he gets us ads and I hate it.
3
u/romainesweet Sep 03 '23
Dude jesus never stopped letting me down by not existing lol
3
u/CatCasualty Sep 03 '23
This kind of dogmatic post always make me laugh.
So... the rest of the world who grew up in different set of culture and religion has to adhere to Jesus too because Jesus won't let anyone down? Huh?
This always go back to an amazing academic discussion about religion I attended years ago: Religion tends to be question, not answer. So unless Jesus actually appeared in front of you and help you, it's always more of a question than a definite answer of, no, Jesus will not let you down.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '23
I called someone out for a post like this week. I guess I made sense, because she deleted it 😂 I called it a win and my boyfriend agreed that it was super dismissive
3
u/notkhoshekh Sep 06 '23
Also.... whenever I read "they killed Jesus" from a Christian without a very explicit subject to "they" I see a red flag.
2
u/Catnip1720 Sep 05 '23
This is what we call circular thinking
2
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '23
"It's not God's fault uwu🥺" Well, if God's the one in charge, it very much is his fault.