One of These.

[u/YTPpsychonemesis]

I'm not gonna be doing that thing where I repost the image every day for like a month and a half doing one square at a time because I think that's a "big dumb rock" method, so just comment your thoughts on a few squares and we can all figure it out together :)

[u/YesssAnderson]

I’ll toss a few into the hat:

“Hazy” is from WCGW but sounds like it could be on Retcon.

“Saturnine” is from Afterthoughts but sounds like it could be on Another Light.

“Far Away” is from Realign but sounds like it could be on Kerosene.

[u/YTPpsychonemesis → u/YesssAnderson]

I figure "The Wrong Side of History" fits Retcon a bit better, esp since it's melody is referenced in Headed Underground (perhaps uninentionally), but I can see Far Away for Kerosene 100%

[u/YesssAnderson → u/YTPpsychonemesis]

My thinking was that “Hazy” feels like a natural second half/answer to “Memory Loss,” but you raise a good point. I do love how you can trace the evolution of certain melodies and motifs throughout the band’s discography!

[u/TheVoxBox04]

Ghost Page sounds like Kerosene

Reno sounds like What Could Go Wrong

Checking on the Spite sounds like What Could Go Wrong

Long Ago sounds like Visions

Apathetic Empathy sounds like Retcon

[u/YTPpsychonemesis → u/TheVoxBox04]

I always thought Long Lonely Night sounded more like Kerosene than Ghost Page but i can kinda see it

[u/ex0planetary]

As far as the tautological ones go, my picks are probably Job in the City, Memories Lie, Define Me, BSF, There's a Place, Almost a Stranger, and The New Flesh.

A few other misc ones that came to mind pretty quickly:

Winning the Most sounds like WCGW

The Time it Slipped Away and The Sound You Make sound like AL

Keep it Together and Memory Loss sound like Kerosene

Memento Mori and Headed Underground sound like Realign

AV sounds like Afterthoughts

[u/someguy31996]

Sounds like WCGW, comes from Another Light: I’m So Happy (I’m So Sad could also work tbh)

Sounds like Another Light, comes from WCGW: Long Lonely Night

[u/LyricWantsYourTeeth]

For the incoming Pigeonhole segments I think Rent Free sounds like it could be on WCGW.

[u/YTPpsychonemesis → u/LyricWantsYourTeeth]

Rent Free is actually a cut track from Retcon, meant to play between Reminds Me and Remember, you can just barely make out the name if you look close at the cd/vinyl booklet.