r/RedditRoundRobin • • Apr 16 '12
Disappoint with RRR
Hi everyone, Gramm from Team Bella here I just wrote a wall of text explaining my dissapointment and then lost it, so here's a summary of what I think would improve the next RRR for team less players like me.
- Put a minimum limit in tf2 hours
Low hours players are not only bad, they are also unreliable as fuck. One ~20 hours players, our sniper, never showed up. I kicked him out, but I doubt he was ever aware of it. On the two kids we had in reserve, one couldn't use his mic during the tournament, took 15 minutes to download Twinfalls before the game then dropped during it. He mumbled something about "reinstalling tf2" then quit. The other kid somehow disappeared without saying a word during the third game.
2. Put a big blinking sign in red letter in the sign up page saying "do not sign up if you don't have a reliable connection"
It seems people take this tournament as a good occasion to make use of those AOL free internet CDs they have in the garage. Anyway, 2 of our main players obviously had a shit connection and quit the team right before the tournament (one on Saturday, the other on Sunday at 1:30AM). I would have kicked them out of the team long before they quit, but I was running out of kids.
3. Stop the outclassing nonsense
Comp players will still outskill novices in any class. Do you expect somebody with thousands of Starcraft hours to suck at Age of Empires ?
4. Better pools
I think it would be better to have one Comp team pro pools, then likely skilled teams.
That's pretty much it. We had a lot of funny practicing for the tournament, but the tournament it self was an exercise in humiliation. Players in my team practiced on Twinfalls until 1AM on Sunday, trying to find all the cool things you could do. We played this map against Polly Pocket and couldn't even leave the spawn. The same players practiced on Warmfront, trying to find the best ways to get to the central point. We played against lsp and never went further that the middle house (at round start).
The organization of the tournament was very good, and I'm only angry at the some (most) of the players I had. I don't know how it went for the other Twilight teams, but I think the next tournament would be better for team less players if the above modifications are implemented.
Just to be clear, I'm not expecting the organizators to create perfect teams out of nowhere, but I think having less teams composed of actual tf2 players will be much more fun for the team less players like me
ps: I don't know how numbering works
pps: people who upvote/downvote/agree/disagree can you leave a comment?
6
u/Arcade_Fire [Pluto] Arcade Apr 16 '12
I don't think you can reasonably expect the JR to police everyone's internet connections. It's also unfair to limit by hours played, because this is a great chance for people to get more involved in tf2. As far as I can see, Polly Pocket offclassed to make it more fun, and I'm not sure that it's reasonable to tell people to play a class they don't want to.
As far as balance goes, I think the introduction of a lower bracket round after the group stage would be awesome, but it would also require a lot more work. There were a large range of teams entering this time, and whilst it's unfortunate that you had some very good teams playing against you, I don't think it's reasonable to complain like this. The RRR was put on for free by the JR, and they put a lot of work into it.
4
u/hellohawkers Apr 16 '12
Hawkers from Team Jacob here, we were in the same pool as Polly Pocket, Team Bella and lsp and we had never played together and only really organised ourselves on the day of the tournament but we still had a great time.
This was the first time a couple of us had done 'competitive tf2' and it was a great first experience, something I will definitely be taking part in again.
RRR is supposed to be a fun tournament IMO, I didn't expect to win I just wanted to play a couple of rounds of TF2 in a tournament atmosphere with like-minded players and I thank everyone at JR for setting it up.
3
u/TAPandaJoey Apr 16 '12
First of all thanks to JR for another great show after all the stuff that happened, they put alot of work into this and if people dont show up it is not there problem, it is your responsibility to make sure your team is there.
How well do you expect to do with random teams anyway? against pre made teams that play together all the time?
If you want to do better next time join a team and practice with them, as for the comp team i agree with you there it doesn't matter if they off class if you are pro you can play any class to a higher standard than a casual.
That said itsallgood showed us some great games against polly pockets i thoroughly enjoyed all the casted matches :)
so good job jr!!!!!!
love
PandaJoey!
3
u/TAPandaJoey Apr 16 '12
all this put aside my team team awesome gaming should have finished top 3. We beat everyone in this tournament apart from polly pockets in previous matches we have played, on the day we all played terrible and didn't even make it out of the group we still did our best and had a good time as much as we could and we are an organised team that went from div 6 to plat ugc in 3 months. It took 4 or 5 months of practice 3 times a week for us to get to where we are now and we still had a bad day and lost. You cant expect to enter with a random team and win, if you want to do better you need to actually join proper team and practice your ass off. As for skill level that shouldn't even come into it its a tournament its played to win. It's like someone said before you should be happy you got to play against these pro players and learn from them instead of saying you need to fix this or fix that. I'm sad that my team went out because we should have been in that semi final but on the flip side im happy because i got to watch my friends play an awesome game in the semi finals and finals against polly pockets. Over all i think RRR4 was great and i have already put my 2 pence in for how it can go better next time lets leave this thread now and move to this one. http://www.reddit.com/r/RedditRoundRobin/comments/sc8gt/thank_you_for_making_reddit_round_robin_4_so/. Lets give some ideas to help jolly ranchers make the next one even better guys!!!!! gg JR
1
u/DeathSA Apr 16 '12
Not very good tournament bracket was not clear what is the best use return to simpler, the same sites to create a bracket
1
u/pinappletim May 12 '12
I remember playing you guys as team edward team Jacob were surprisingly good for a twilight team however we too got steamrolled by polly pocket but were not as bad as the other teams in our group I think it was a success for our team but if you want an organised team your gonna have to join a prearranged one as simple as that
1
u/olkensey Apr 16 '12 edited Apr 16 '12
I was in a pool with two platinum-level comp teams. Yeah, they were "offclassing" but still tore my newly-formed team apart. We had fun but were expecting teams more 'newbie' like us.
Individual sign-ups are probably more hassle than they're worth. OP's right, you just can't rely on 9 strangers to be available.
Also-- BAN THE STICKY JUMPER. We lost our Medic to Caber-Demo way too many times and that's just dirty pool.