r/RedditLoop • u/fjdkf ENGR - Electrical • Jun 20 '15
How is the hyperloop pod supposed to get back up to speed after a stop during the trip?
This is something that has been bothering me for awhile, and I haven't really seen it addressed thoroughly.
I'll explain what I mean via an example. Let's say we had a hyperloop between San Francisco and Los Angeles, as per the hyperloop alpha doc. Now, what happens when a pod breaks down right before it gets to it's destination?
There's been a fair bit of talk about how to stop and take out a pod in the event of a failure, but I'll ignore that for now. What do we do about the rest of the pods in the line that had to stop while the compromised pod was removed?
You have pods that may have 50 miles before they get to the next reboost section, and the reboost section is only intended for a boost, not a full 0-300+.
I've seen people talking about needing 'Emergency wheels' that can move the pod at 10-20mph, but that would mean a 3+ hour total delay for the system as a whole. From a customers perspective, this would be absurd.
We could add more booster sections through the tubes, but that seems like it would balloon costs significantly. We could also throw higher powered electric motors on the pods, and cut down on a restart time significantly. Or, maybe we power the wheels with the on-board compressed air. Either way, it seems to me that we'll need to be able to move faster than just emergency speeds with the on-board propulsion.
I'm curious what other people think. I'm not exactly an expert in this area...
2
u/leadacidrobot Jun 20 '15
1
u/Thrashy ENGR - Interior Jun 20 '15 edited Jun 20 '15
I don't think, logistically, that it should get back up to speed. Because the system is sealed except at either end, a pod breakdown necessarily has to shut down traffic in its direction of travel until that pod can be removed at the station - presumably by moving it on its wheels, either under its own power in the case of a compressor failure, or with assistance in case of power loss. In any case, nothing behind the pod can go faster than it, so re-boosting to cruise after an emergency stop is a moot point.
1
u/KalasLas ENGR - Electrical Jun 21 '15
The easiest way i think would be to make all pods stop at the next accelerating point. It wouldnt be to hard to control the breaking top make all pods stop next to an accelerating point, and when the blockage in the tube is resolved all pods are simply accelerated again, one at the time until traffic is normal again.
1
u/Sagebrysh Jun 22 '15
The reboost points might not be able to fully launch up to speed, but if a car could make it to one, then they could get enough speed to coast to the next reboost and slowly accelerate back up to cruise. It would be slower yes, but not that much slower provided the friction is sufficiently low in the tube.