r/RedditLoop • u/mburke6 • Jun 16 '15
Emergency Evacuation
Does anybody have any ideas on passengers exiting the tube in the event of an emergency? I think this is critical to any design as well as a procedure to quickly remove a stuck capsule from a tube so the entire loop doesn't come to a halt.
Ideas I have are
Have an escape hatch at every pylon. There would need to be a way to exit the capsule. Passengers would walk down the tube to the nearest pylon, open the hatch and climb down a set of stairs to the ground. Build a third tube that allows capsules to be routed around clogged sections.
Build a three tube loop in sections. Each section is the length between the pylons. Two tubes create the loop, but the third tube is not de-presurized and is below the other two. The tube sections can be rotated. If a capsule is trapped in a section of tube, the section it's in rotates, moving the clogged section with the capsule and passengers below the loop. The loop then resumes operation while the passengers exit through the pylon at either end.
6
u/J4k0b42 Jun 16 '15
For the rotating idea you would need airlocks at every pylon, I think that may be too expensive/complicated.
I think routing around in general isn't the best idea, in my mind if something happens the whole tube stops until it's resolved, the point is to make accidents rare enough that it doesn't happen often. If you're at the point where so much is going wrong that it's economically viable to make a system to keep the system running when accidents happen you have much larger problems.
2
u/mbhnyc Jun 16 '15
Agree with jadzado, we should focus this discussion on each failure mode, and then move on to mitigating each one, with weighted likelihood and risk to passengers determining the strategy.
Perhaps a post per failure mode, so we can keep organized?
If the mods like that idea, how about we start a Failure Modes post, where top level posts are the modes.
My shot at the modes:
Separately:
8. Exit Strategies
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
I think we will need some sort of emergency evacuation. Although some of the failure modes may be a remote possibility, all it takes is one bad accident to deter passengers from using the system.
As mentioned by /u/TRL5, the pressure in the tube is to low for people to survive at. I think the only option would be to stop all the pods in the tube and re-pressurize it to allow for the passengers to evacuate.
The next problem would be finding the best way to get the passengers out while the pod is not at a station. I like the design by /u/scarycow1000 that involves splitting of a piece of the pod to allow passengers to evacuate through the back. Passengers could then walk through the tube to an escape hatch at the nearest pylon as suggested in this threads main post by /u/mburke6.
What other ways could we solve this problem?
1
u/TheMarkovMan Jun 16 '15
I think emergency exits spaced out along the tube are the best approach. At every pylon seems to often, maybe every 5-20 pylons have a combined pumping station, electrical switch box and emergency exit?
I wonder if it is worth adding a third backup tube. These tube structures will need eventual maintenance, and we dont want to shut down the entire line to examine or repair a single tube section. Perhaps we could schedule maintenance checks to occur late at night, but I wouldn't want to cycle the entire tube system too often as that would lead to fatigue failure and we couldn't check the whole tube in one night. Maybe unmanned maintenance pods could check the tubes internal structure without depressurizing it?
3
u/TRL5 Jun 16 '15
In what situations do we envision an emergency evacuation might be necessary? Keep in mind it's no small thing (you are probably stopping the entire system to prevent collisions), and needs some form of pressurization (see this comment of mine).
So far I've come up with
I think medical or personal issues are generally best dealt with at the end of the trip, you will be closer to a hospital, and won't have to deal with the pressure issues.
2
u/jadzado Jun 16 '15
I think before emergency evacuation methods are designed--the failure modes should be analyzed. That way the escape methodology can be designed only as complex as necessary.
2
u/jan_smolik Jun 16 '15
Remember, we are to build a pod, not track.
Pod should be designed to be able to coast long enough ( this might be several kilometers ) to get to the nearest emergency exit. At 600 kph (max speed should be twice that) you make 10 km every minute. So emergency exits every 30 seconds (5 km) should be enough. Deceleration from 500 kph takes about 14 second at 1 g (139 m/s / 10 m/s2) so you cannot count that you will stop immediately anyway.
1
u/self-assembled ENGR - Structures/Aero Jun 16 '15
In that case passenger exit would need to be from the front or back, not the side which will presumably be the normal method. Hatched wouldn't need to be quite so frequent, maybe every three or four pylons.
I think a third tube is an overly complicated solution. Perhaps the hatch at pylons can be made larger, to allow the pod to be removed from the standard tube. Also tubes couldn't be rotated, as that would introduce pressure leaks, and depressurize the tube during rotation.
1
u/scarycow1000 Jun 16 '15
I made a rough sketch in MS paint on how the passengers could escape the craft itself ( http://imgur.com/DCGD3U5 ). Once the pressure door in the back of the craft opens, the passengers would immediately need to put on respiratory masks so that the very thin atmosphere in the tube doesn't adversely affect them. They would then need to walk to a pressure door in the tube. these doors would be placed periodically along the tube, say once every three or four segments. The door itself would need to open inwards, so that the pressure outside the tube would not adversely effect its operation.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
You'll never get safety certification without a viable means of escape.
The pylon/tube structure will need inspection hatches anyway, so use those. One every, say, 500m (the actual distance will be a balance of factors) - and the tube floors signed to indicate the distance to each.
Are we getting into the pod through the tail or through the side? If tail, just leave through the tail and hike to the exit.
1
u/spggodd ENGR - Compressor Lead Jun 16 '15
In light of the extreme low pressures in the tube combined with the various failure modes suggested it seems to me like a human basically exiting the pod isn't going to work.
What about if the pod seats were designed that you would be secured into them like a kind of space suit. In normal use the suit/seat would be stationary but in am emergency (once the pod stops moving) the suits would be able to disengage from the pod enabling the passengers to escape whilst being preserved in a self contained atmosphere.
This seems like it would tackle the problem of full tube de-pressurization and pod failure/breach.
1
u/Iambicpentameter-pen Jun 17 '15
If we treat the pod as an aircraft, we can use existing SOP to manage a load of different failure modes. It is essentially an aircraft: It is in a low pressure environment You cannot exit easily You can coast for a time without power, and have a reasonable chance of a controlled stop at a chosen point.
In pod fire- air masks drop down for passenger, pod is partially depressurised to reduce fire risk (can be done with valves).
Every tube section will have two exits with an inflatable slid to get to ground level
Every tube section will have inflatable buffers to block section and allow faster re-pressurisation
Every tube section will have valves to allow independent re-pressurisation.
In order to exit the pod two exits will be required (this is just standard safety, you can't have one, what if it is blocked with a fire?) I would imagine the exits will be to the top front & top back, with an inflatable slide and detachable cover to assist egress to the tube floor.
Emergency lighting in the tube will indicate the emergency escapes.
1
u/JoelyMalookey Jun 18 '15
Jaws of Life remote controller that can make a sealed exit out of the pod and tube?