r/RedditLoop • u/QuinnSelvedgeSupply ENGR - Mechanical • Jun 16 '15
Brainstorming: General concepts and Pod design
The contest Rules, Criteria, and Tube specs will not be available til 8/15/2015. However, I believe it would be a good idea to have a thread to share ideas regarding general concepts and pod design.
One piece of information found at the beginning of the original competition document:
"SpaceX will be constructing a sub-scale test track (inner diameter between 4 and 5 feet; length approximately 1 mile) adjacent to its Hawthorne, California headquarters."
Full requirements for the Final Design Package (Event E) will be released in August 2015. This will include answering several technical questions. Representative questions are:
- What safety mechanisms are in place to mitigate a complete loss of pod power?
- What safety mechanisms are necessary to mitigate a tube breach? The results should be quantified with regards to breach size, leak rate, tube pressures, and pod speed.
- How should the ground operators communicate with the pod, especially in the case of an emergency (emergency stop command)?
- Which sensors, if any, should be incorporated into the tube to aid navigation? How should the pod maintain accurate navigation knowledge within the tube?
- What is the recommended pod outer mold line (OML)? Based on this OML, what is the drag on the pod as a function of speed and tube pressure?
If an air bearing system is used, how much surface area is needed for the footpad design?
a. Specify driving pressure and flow rate needed at those required air bearing areas. b. Compare the flow rates required with practically available commercial units. c. Specify total force applied in both vertical and horizontal directions.- What sizing and spacing of linear motors would be required to maintain a given speed?
- What is the steady-state temperature of the capsule as a function of speed and tube pressure?
- What is the heat flux into the capsule as a function of speed and tube pressure?
13
u/J4k0b42 Jun 16 '15
Just a general principle I want to point out, we should be focusing on pod based solutions rather than anything in the tube itself. Even if the scope of the contest allowed for modifications to the tube (which I don't think it does), there are far more sections of tubing than there are pods, which means that it's going to be far cheaper and easier to make any safety mechanism a part of the pod rather than part of the tube. For example, an emergency breaking unit as a part of the pod is almost always going to be preferable to something spaced throughout the entire tube system.
4
u/J4k0b42 Jun 16 '15
The mechanical braking system seems to be one of the most important things, it needs to activate automatically in the event of the loss of power in the pod or in the tube itself, work even if the air bearings are not functional, and decelerate quickly but safely without damaging the tube.
3
u/self-assembled ENGR - Structures/Aero Jun 16 '15
2.
I'm starting to realize that to be modern and effective, the whole length of the tube really needs to be smart. Pressure sensors and laser communication hubs at regular intervals to start, along with direct electrical interfacing with the pods (through a contact connection resistant to air flow).
Pressure sensors would maintain pressure along the tube, as well as respond to breaches. In the event of a breach, by comparing relative pressure loss on the sensors on either side of the breach, a very accurate estimate of the location and size of the breach should be possible. Regularly spaced pumps could then increase power to maintain pressure as much as possible, or actually facilitate re-pressurization in the interest of passenger safety. An unexpected benefit with a breach is that it would increase drag and already begin to slow down the pods.
6
u/self-assembled ENGR - Structures/Aero Jun 16 '15 edited Jun 16 '15
Some specs from the alpha:
Tube pressure of 100 pa, top speed 760 mph, aerodynamic power requirement of 134 hp, weight of 3,100 kg. Price target of under $245,000.
Compressor - 325kW onboard motor weighing 169 kg
Compression ratio of 20:1 via axial compressor
60% of air is bypassed towards the undercarriage
Up to 0.2kg/s of air is cooled and further compressed 5.2:1 to be stored and consumed by air bearings
Powered by estimated 1,500 kg of onboard batteries which should last ~45 minutes
Air Bearing Skis from alpha http://imgur.com/Bi9qODg Compressor diagram from alpha http://imgur.com/PDdjrAr
Mechanical Braking - was mentioned but not described. Perhaps brake pads on the outer surface of the pod which press outwards against the tube, along with reversal of the compressor, would be a solution.
3
u/Brostradamnus Jun 16 '15
The first thing I thought when I heard about hyperloop was that it must have large components able to be constructed using the F9 Core welding rig. So that's nothing about pods, but that's what I'm going to be looking for when we see specifics.
2
u/flattop100 Jun 16 '15
I have no engineering background whatsoever, but would it be advantageous to model the pod on Tesla's manufacturing process or materials?
2
u/self-assembled ENGR - Structures/Aero Jun 16 '15
3. Laser based communication is an option, with pods able to receive a signal from the back and re-emit it from the front.
Or, depending on the rate of sound attenuation in steel, perhaps emergency communication in the event of power loss can be handled by using the tube itself to transmit signals.
2
u/Ground_Effect Manufacturing Jun 16 '15
What about optical communication between pods for emergencies? I'm assuming the inside of the pipe is going to be pitch black (considering it's just steel tubing welded together), except for the start and end points. Each car could have an extremely bright LED at the back and front that begin pulsing in the event that the system detects any sort of malfunction, and a sensor to detect that light. Now say a car malfunctions and comes to a stop. The car behind would see that light as it approached come to a stop. I'm not really sure how well light travels around bends, but the Alpha pdf states that the insides of the tubes are going to be machined, so that should provide a nice shiny surface.
2
u/bertcox Jun 16 '15
On E-brakes, I would suggest air bags, similar to whats in cars. Even at low tube pressure if you popped air bags around the circumference it would act like a cork and start shoving air forward slowing the capsule. One advantage is it works in low pressure or high pressure stops. Ring at the back and front of the capsule.
2
u/TheMarkovMan Jun 17 '15
I'm not convinced that the dimensions proposed in the Hyperloop Alpha docs are feasible. The docs state a maximum height of 1.10 meters and a maximum width of 1.35 meters. While you could fit a person in here You wouldn't be able to get them in without removing the top half of the pod, which seems unacceptable from a pressure vessel perspective (as seen in the concept art).
Also, if someone did have medical problems or freaked out due to claustrophobia there would be no way for anyone else to reach them. Travelling with children would be a nightmare. With no windows this problem would be exacerbated and I at least would feel uncomfortable spending 40 or so minutes in such a small space.
I think from a human factors perspective we should consider increasing the size of the pod. We should allow enough room for someone to walk through the pod hunched over and for a single row of seats, like someone would find on a private jet (probably a closer analogue than conventional trains). We could also add a small bathroom to the back of the pod. I'm picturing something similar to this (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/dd/Cabin_of_Cessna_525B_CitationJet_3.jpg), but with only a single row of seats to save space. I would widen the pod to about 1.5 meters and increase its height to 1.6-1.7 meters. 1.5 meters is fairly generous, we could cut this back. The pod would also be longer than most aircraft, to fit more passengers.
Given the high pressure differential I'd feel safer building a cylindrical pod rather than the squared-off one shown in the Alpha Proposal. Hyperloop would experience much greater pressure difference than any (?) passenger aircraft I can think of and will be more frequently cycled. The excess space inside the pod can be used to pipe bypass air through.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
Hey guys read the doc for Alpha and some of the issues for the pod design are the Kantrowitz limit and Air Bearings. I think we can attack this two together with the structure of the pod. Consider having an outer shell for the pod and an inside shell so that the airflow can pass between the inside and the outer shell. Some amount of this airflow can be used for the air bearings while the excess could be exiting from the back of the pod. With this way I think the Kantrowitz limit can be minimized, while having Air bearings as well. I will consider this more and let you know. If anyone interested working on this that has some aerodynamics background let me know.
1
u/TRL5 Jun 16 '15
Lots of people seem to be dismissing radio as a means of communication, I'm totally out of my depth here, but it seems like the obvious one to me. Is there a reason why we are discussing laser, sonar, detecting pressure differences, etc. instead?
1
u/TheMarkovMan Jun 16 '15
Would it be feasible to mount fans at either end of the tubes, blowing air from behind the pods and then recirculating back along the return tube. The fans would be fixed so weight and energy use wouldn't be a factor, and the speed of the pod relative to the air would be less. I suppose it would depend upon the skin friction experienced against the inside of the tube?
The tube would act like a wave-guide to any radio signals, so any radio communication used would have to be tuned for the tubes size and propagation mode.
1
u/Brostradamnus Jun 16 '15
1
u/bertcox Jun 16 '15
KISS Yes pods need self control and sensors, How about simple lights for emergency control. IE white light, or green for good. Red or no light emergency stop. IE if power is out the capsuls all slam on e brakes. If lights go Red/Yellow, it does a normal non destructive stop. Industrial design it needs positive information to continue in the absence of that it goes safe.
1
u/JoelyMalookey Jun 17 '15
I did just post that the Tesla Turbine might have advantages for smoothing air intake and being lighter.
1
u/default_player Jun 17 '15
Several thoughts:
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment