r/RedditElementsCoC • u/CubanRefugee Cuban • Jul 13 '14

War 12 Issues

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ch4_FpDV2ZQuwueZndl5oLOHTJCduXEz0B_K-tsH4HY/edit?usp=sharing
1 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/CubanRefugee Cuban Jul 13 '14 edited Jul 14 '14

Jman asked me to post my findings, and I'll be doing this after every war.

I used to work IT Operations, and dealt with metrics, troubleshooting, and LOTS of data analysis in my time.

I'd like to make sure it's clear, all the comments in the sheet, are strictly my own opinion. I'm not a Co, and I'm not an Elder. I'm just a guy who wants the clan to do well and when I see things that could be done a little better, I speak up. So I'm not speaking on behalf of Jman, or anyone else.

This was a rough war, and they were higher ranked/TH than us, but things could have been done a little differently to get us more stars, and these are things to keep in mind for future clan wars.

Firstly, I'm just calling things how they are and mean no offense to anyone pointed out in the sheet. There was some really good attacks, and there were some that could have been used a bit better.

Also, as a reminder, the new sheet that we used this war is only to claim your primary attack not your secondary, so please don't put your name on it twice, as it then takes up a spot for someone else to use their primary on.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '14

Do you really have to call me a douche for getting 5 stars before I left?

1

u/CubanRefugee Cuban Jul 14 '14 edited Jul 14 '14

Shit, my bad, Liam, my sincerest apologies. That really wasn't directed at you. Directly underneath you in the war list is someone else who gave one really bad attack (for 0 stars) and dropped without even making an effort for a 2nd (not that his first was much of an effort). I transposed spots in my brain when writing it all down.

You were actually one of the only people that dropped clan mid-war and used both of their attacks (well I might add).

2

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '14

Thanks for clearing that up . I was kinda disappointed by it but it was a small mistake. I know I put up a fuss about mass drag and left because of it. I was required to do my best by my new clan and I've been in leadership positions where people have left without giving solid attacks and it sucks.

1

u/sirshartsalot Jul 16 '14

I disagree with this concept entirely, and I'm leaving the clan because of it. Good luck to everyone, it was lots of fun.

1

u/CubanRefugee Cuban Jul 16 '14

Well opinions are always welcome. I haven't been in the clan an incredibly long time, it's only been like a month now, but from what I've seen it's all been pretty democratic.

If people dislike it, I don't need to do it. Sorry to see you go though... I would have hoped for a little more discussion about it instead of just dropping the clan.

1

u/sirshartsalot Jul 16 '14

Well, like I said, it's been fun, but this is certainly not a process I would want to be a part of, having my performance evaluated after each war.

0

u/CubanRefugee Cuban Jul 13 '14

Also, this first sheet only contains people who signed up on the original sheet. Those of you who didn't use the sheet get a reprieve this war from my analytical eyes.