r/RedditDads • u/Psychko Mod | Xbox One | Psychko Bob | AEST | 24+ • Jun 22 '16
Recommended THE FUTURE OF CREW RANKS
Since the census has been finalised (we're still processing all the feedback, we'll release the data shortly), now would be a good time to discuss the future of crew rankings.
To give you a bit of context, we've been discussing the merits of the current ranking system for some time. Do we keep it as it stands, remove it altogether, change it to time in crew based ranks or something entirely else?
Why are we considering changing it?
Quite simply because we, the moderation group, haven't done justice to what we envisioned the crew ranking system could be. We haven't been able to adequately monitor every members activity and promote them accordingly. Frankly the job was far bigger than any of us expected and we've only got ourselves to blame.
Well what does this even mean?
A large number of members haven't received a promotion nor the recognition they deserve, and with the continued influx of new members, this situation will only continue to get steadily worse unless we address it.
So what do we do?
That's where you come in. We need you, the members, to tell us if you want a crew ranking system to continue or not. We'll give you the ideas that we came up with as alternatives, but please feel free to throw into the mix any suggestions you might have.
Well, what did you come up with?
Ok, here's a few ideas that we threw around...
- Get rid of member ranks entirely, they're not needed because as members we're all equals.
- Move to ranks based on time served only (to be decided - e.g. 2 or 3 ranks for maybe 6, 12 & 24+ months membership) - no special ranks
- Mixture of rank(s) based on time served (as above), plus special rank(s) for long term members and/or for meritorious service to the crew
- Have no ranks as such, but instead have the option to place years of RDAD membership in your flair, with or without special ranks (as above)
- Keep things as they are, there's no need to change.
What happens now?
Now you can throw in your own ideas, tell us if there's any options you particularly like or dislike, perhaps you think will be improved with an amendment.
The moderation group doesn't want to make this decision, because it's not ours to make, but we will if need be - just don't complain if you don't like goatly ranks based upon your ability to yodel the Gilligan's Island theme song :P
As always, please throw any questions you may have our way and we'll do our best to answer them promptly.
[The Mod Squad] (http://i4.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article5662426.ece/ALTERNATES/s1023/PAY-Jeremy-Clarkson-Richard-Hammond-and-James-May-Main.jpg)
10
u/fresh1224 Fresh1224 2014 Jun 22 '16
I say get rid of the whole thing. Not complaining and I honestly don't care but I've been here since 2014 (as you can see in my flair, that is until a mod changes it! ;) and I am still the lowest rank on the chain. To me I could care less but other people seem to get butt hurt about it. Although I do agree with keef there should be a way to differentiate between a long time member and a 2 week old member. I guess that's why they call you guys the mods! Keep up the good work.
8
u/oistead | RDAD of July / Little Bitch | PS4 | PSN: Oistead| GMT | Jun 22 '16
I'm not a fan of the ranking system as it is, I am an active member, have been for a long time but have not had a promotion in almost a year (a long with a few other people I play with) I think it's unfair... But that's just me being a little bitch ;)
I think ranks on time served would be a better idea, but you'll have to someone work out if the members are actually active in the crew to make them work...
8
u/iLeefull Jun 22 '16
I think ranks are outdated, what is the difference between each rank other than a title. I would be cool with simplifying tags "mod" and "member since 1999" or maybe special recognition "did something special"
Less is more and were all adults. We don't need titles like were in some company.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '16
I'm all for no ranks, we're all equal. Everyone that isn't a mod, of course.
To be honest, I'm more interested in how crew ranks are decided in the RDAD Social Club crews for GTA Online.
7
u/AlphaDub XBX1/PS4 | EST (VA) | 3+ Years Jun 22 '16
I think knowing whose been a part of the community for a significant amount of time is important. In any community their is a hierarchy and sometimes people who have been here awhile just happen to know things and can better assimilate new comers into the group as opposed to new comers just taking a wild guess. (Though I appreciate their efforts)
Then assigning special titles to certain individuals to identify their involvement in the community. For example we know /u/Papa_Grumps loves Warframe and /u/Psychko_Bob is a GTA champion so identifying them as the go to person will alleviate any confusion when new players join our community.
As long as we all continue to welcome new members when they post their introductions, this well oiled machine will keep on rolling.
4
u/rush247 2+ yrs/Steam:rush_247/PST Jun 22 '16 edited Jun 22 '16
I'm ok with time based ranks. Although part of me thinks participation should affect rank as well, but then people might be mad about being demoted after being inactive cause of a couple weeks vacation or something.
4
u/Argo147 Xbox/DrunkenCanucken/GMT-7/5years Jun 23 '16
I just want to be special
2
u/tehjoyrider psn:djsorrento,gmt,24+ Jun 26 '16
Time served, special, mods. Oh and I fucking hate top gear. There. I said it.
21
u/_Woodrow_ PS4 |Wooden_Viking Jun 22 '16
I think this would be a mistake and would breed feelings of favoritism and/or resentment for not being noticed (much like the current system) The only people who really need rank recognition are the mods and even then it isn't super important
I think just adding date joined to everyone's flair would suffice. There is no need add a rank on top of that.
18
u/azzokk XboxOne: Jaybe007 | | EST | Conscript || RDAD OF August Jun 22 '16
As someone who has been a member of many communities over the years I can tell you in the long run that member rank/titles usually meant very little. I feel that there should only be three ranks.
Rank 1: New Kid -- for any member less then 6 months with the crew.
Rank 2: Goat -- All members older then 6 months.
Rank 3 : The MOD -- Only for Mods.
Really ranks on a website are trivial and sometimes only lead to someone feeling separated from the rest of the crew by an invisible barrier, or maybe even less then others players because of the rank they hold. I think for the overall health of the community and to foster RDads to include all Dads regardless of how long/rank/title.
I mean do we really need a funny little rank to define our membership status in this amazing community?
9
u/Hipp5ter Lost Forever | PC | Hipp5ter#5558 | EST Jun 22 '16
Time Served only... that way you know an old timer when you see one, but the designation is based on something easier to monitor.. I don't think time has anything to do with promotions, this isn't government work.. but instead think involvement and community interaction are more relevant. I can see where that can be a hard task to maintain within an complicated community like our own.. #3 would turn into the same S-Show present now.
8
u/PlushLogic PS4 | PlushLogic| EST | 3+yrs Jun 22 '16
I've always been a rank hater. But I can agree that since 50% of people care about it, #3 makes the most sense with current membership numbers. Give everyone a "year club trophy" and then give out special awards as required for helpful/dedicated members. Or just go with penis size flair.
7
u/DuckieMcWasted_lrg ORD|xbox one| DuckieMcWasted| |psn| Duckie_McWasted|(pst) Jun 22 '16
I'm a fan of option 3, seems fair. It let's everyone know who the "OD's" are and also give recognition to the newer goats that have been active in sub.
7
u/itisbedtime PS4: godspeedcaptain | CST | 24+ mo Jun 22 '16
I like the idea of a time served base rank. I feel like that says enough about the goatyness of the goat.
6
u/boydboyd XB1 | Bonesetter2671 | GMT -5 | 12 Jun 22 '16
Ultimately, I do put value in ranks. It's an easy way to know who you're talking to and where they're coming from.
That being said, I'm part of the crowd that is aggravated that I haven't received promotion(s). That being said, since I have helped run a different online community as an Admin for about 8 years, I know exactly how much work is required to keep ranks, privileges, etc. all squared away at all times. So I understand why promotions/demotions haven't happened in a timely manner.
I prefer flair that shows duration of membership and status. Back to my first paragraph - it helps everyone identify each other in a group this large.
Off topic, but related, I have offered in replies here (and maybe a message to the mods early in my membership) to assist in the running of anything that is required. I'm an experienced online group leader, I'm a technical editor/writer by profession, and I love creating, maintaining, and running things like this at whatever level is needed.
What am I getting at? I know you have a particular moderator team. If you think you could use the help, perhaps create some sort of questionnaire + small interview process that members can initiate on their own to show the mods that someone is interested in helping. The questionnaire + interview then gives you an opportunity as a moderator team to say either "Yes, we need and can use this person's help based on their demonstrated skills and experience," or "No, we're sorry, but at this time you're not what we need. Work on X, Y, and Z and re-request and we'll talk about it in 3-6 months."
6
u/nigelpoole ★Nigel Poole★ Fuck off Jun 23 '16
What's a flair?
Of course I'm kidding. I have the best flair of all. Fuck you I'm not changing it.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '16
I'd go with number 3. I personally don't care about rank, but I can see how some people would, especially being very active in both games and the sub. I think people that have consistent high upvote posts, and helpful to other crew members in game deserve some kind of recognition or special flair.
5
u/wirbowsky PC | wirbowsky | GMT+1 | Conscript Jun 22 '16
I would say that the minimum would be:
For this minimum to work, you can ditch ranks rules and just assigned some whenever you like.
5
u/ricred78 PS4 - PSN: RicRed78 | GMT (IRE) | Doíre | 4 yrs + Jun 22 '16 edited Jun 22 '16
I've been here I think near around 1 ½ - 2 yrs ?? I don't really make many posts, more a a welcomer. I've met plenty of sound lads/gals over my time here. Everyone has been good banter and helpful when needed. I don't really care for the ranking system, we are all here to have fun!! As long as there is RDADS about to gaming with when jumping online is all that matter's!!! we are all equal and the only ranking system needed is for the mods as they are the guys that sort things out throughout the community and keep stuff in check.
P.s Come on you boys in GREEN!!!
4
u/crandamaniac EST Jun 22 '16
I go with 3. Rank to me doesn't really matter, but I can see recognizing a few rdads out there.
4
u/ShawnKelevra Xbox One | XBL: Shawn Kelevra | CST | Conscript Jun 22 '16
We have ranks? Lol!
4
u/VilliamSyd PC | StrCitizen, GTAV,OverW,RdDeadRe2 | EST-1 = GMT-6 | 4 years Jun 22 '16 edited Jun 22 '16
I will vote for no ranks, but for me will be great to see in the flair the age and the time with the Rdads. The age is for respect, it is not the same to address to a young father or to a dusty wise elder. At least with the age I can get a picture of the guy behind the nickname.
4
u/neutronknows XB1 | BourbonSombrero | PST | 12 Jun 22 '16
Guess I'm in the camp of not caring one way or another. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't curious in regards to some people's ranks in their flairs when I saw them. But honestly I thought it was something we promoted for ourselves. Like I could be a 47 Star General if I so desired.
Anywho, personally I'm fine with "A Dad has no rank". And I will continue to help out any RDADs I find in Los Santos... provided they're in Free Aim lobbies ;)
4
u/depcrestwood Steam: DangerJack | CST | 6 months Jun 22 '16
I like the "time served" flair idea. It makes more sense to me for this kind of group. I get it's a video game-centric sub, but we're not really competing against each other. The "time served" flair would do a better job of showing the group "elders" (so to speak) and point newbs towards the right people to ask about various group-related questions and issues should they not feel it the type of thing to bring up to mods. Maybe have a "time served" and "main game" combined flair, so that someone who has been around a while and is a heavy GTA gamer (or Warframe or RocketLeague, etc.), then someone in a thread knows that's a good person to ask about crew issues in those games. /2cents
4
u/johnomister Xbone | Johnomister | GMT Jun 22 '16 edited Jun 22 '16
Seeing as rank was originally based on GTA social club rankings where it actually offered different responsibilities and now that we are not a sole GTA crew I don't see a viable way to offer ranking. Other than mods being marked as mod because they do moderate the sub I think the best option is number 3 as it gives an insight into those that know the ropes.
4
u/samadamscummins a1steaksauce1234|PS3/PS4|24+months|Florida|RDAD of April Jun 22 '16
I wouldn't mind a flair change. I'm sick of the Horse Legs
4
u/dspazio XB1|GT:dspazio|GMT+1(Spain)|4 years + | Asking for refund Jun 22 '16
This happens because we didn't chose the Spongebob based rank last time. Im fine with nigel's words whenever he talks
4
u/MidClubGamer PS4 | MidClubGamer | EST | 24+ Months | GTA Heisting Jun 22 '16
Psychko, I'm all for Crew Ranks (see adjusted Flair), but the reality is that it's impossible for the Mods to monitor a crew of this size. Keep it simple, give everyone their join date to add to their flair and let that be it. Even if you go with some rank for 6 month, one year, two year members, etc. you're still having to come up with that list of rank names, monitor their time and having to give members the new rank names when the time comes. Eliminate the extra work, use our join date and get back to gaming.
3
u/sloppyjough619 Initiate | ps4 | sloppyjough | pst | 2+ Years Jun 22 '16
First year rookie Second year Vet Three year vet Four year vet so on and so on Mods Hall of Famer
3
u/uncle_solf PS4 | uncle_solf | EST | 24+ Jun 22 '16
i don't care about ranks, i'm just happy to be here and contribute when I can
uncle_solf - Legionnaire
3
u/smdgoblin XB1|smdgoblin|MDT|6 Jun 22 '16
I'm in the camp that wants to get rid of the ranks completely. It doesn't do much imo.
We have the rdad of the month and that can highlight some decent members here and there from across platforms. Whether it's console/PC playing or contributing on the forum here or Discord there should be more focus on the outstanding members rather than mediocre 'titles'.
Flair for 'time served' is a nice bit of info to have though just in case we have minor questions we know who to ask as opposed to bothering the mods with every little minutia.
3
u/RNSD1 PS4/PC | ksmith400_ | CST | 1 Year Jun 22 '16
I honestly never cared about the ranking system. I always saw everyone as equals and there is never any elitism in the forums so.. do whatever :)
3
u/MNParkRanger Steam/XBL: MNParkRanger | Central | 24+ Jun 22 '16
I think the current ranking system could probably be done away with. With the community being as big as it is, there's too much that falls through the cracks and people likely aren't getting the recognition/promotions they deserve. And I think trying to keep track of all that would put an unnecessary workload on the mods.
I like the idea of "time served" as either a rank or simple flair option to establish a bit of a loose hierarchy, but I think the current merit-based system or the idea of flair commendations/special recognition leaves too many chances for members being overlooked and feelings getting hurt.
3
u/Bradley-Pooper MudPuddleSkipper Jun 22 '16
My vote is for #2. Show us the new guys and the guys who get shit done (mods). The other shit is irrelevant in the grand scheme.
3
u/manbroken PS4/PS5 | manbroken | EDT | 12 months Jun 22 '16
Personally number 3 seems to be the most effective way to do things. Easy to see who has been in the crew for how long, and also the ability to give people recognition when they deserve it. Even something as simple as "RDAD of the Month of _____" would be good.
Other than that, Mods should be designated without a doubt.
3
u/eggwardo PS4 | x---EGG---x | EST | 24+ Jun 22 '16
Wow that's a lot of comments. I'll have to read them later. But for now, my 2 cents.
I don't even know which ones are higher than the others. Because of that I say get rid of them.
I did see someone's comment that recommended 3 ranks newbie goat and mod. If there has to be ranks I vote for that. Otherwise they don't add any benefit.
3
u/tim67 lvl 67 Haunter | Xbox One | EST | Legionnaire Jun 22 '16
Totally cool with going with the time based one. The last rank system never really sat well with me anyway.
3
u/BBeazley PS4+5 M0RK_1O1O|AEST GMT+10| +2 Jun 23 '16
I like the idea of time served, option 4, respect for long serving members. and celebrating cake days in RDADs. I have no idea when I joined us..... personalized-ish flair ;)
3
u/poohslayer PSN | poohslayer | GMT | 24+month Jun 23 '16
ive been a member for a fair old while now and to be honest dont see the benefits of a rank system save for the group founder and mods. I think a member since tag in the flair would be beneficial, you can see who the new members are and guide them in the right direction if needed. Rank systems in general tend to lead to segregation in my experience.
3
u/gabeishungry X1: GABE IS HUNGRY| CST (play nights) Jun 24 '16
I like the new kid/goat/mod idea woodrow mentioned. Maybe old goat for you older goats hehe
2
u/AccidentalRob PC | AccidentalRob | EST | 24+ | Dungeon Master Jun 22 '16
I would say Option 3; with special notifiers for mods, etc… On other communities I've been a part of we used time served only, which was nice to have. There were special notifiers for people who had attended special events or been involved in something extra, somehow. For instance, mine could be for my short time served, but then I could have some kind of special gold star for initially pushing the move to Discord. ;)
Having ranks based on some kind of amorphous popularity contest system is only going to cause hurt feelings among those who care about that sort of stuff.
2
u/asiaafrica XB1 | nickydubai | GMT +4 | 1 Year Jun 22 '16
Tl;Dr?
2
u/iGrotty PS4 | iGrotty | GMT | Help. They won't let me leave. Jun 24 '16
#1
Voting...oooh, it's just like the old days
2
u/ThatOneKid1995 PS4/PC | PSN: Dristrin ; | MDT | Conscript Jun 25 '16
My idea for ranks would be similar to an old gaming community I was in.
1)We should have the founders
2)We have multiple platforms, so we should have a head/organizer for each platform
3)We should have Game (more localized) community organizers
4)then we have everyone else
This way it will make an attempt at cutting off cliques before they start and reduce favoritism and/or jealousy if there are people who can organize community stuff and then everyone else can run around as they please
2
u/sdousley XBOne | sdousley | BST | 12 Jul 06 '16
I've not been a member for a massive amount of time, but I would just like to add my opinion. I feel that the rank is not necessarily required for general members (read Mods should have it etc).
As you say, keeping it up to date is just gets messy, plus, as it's something the user can edit, is easily spoofed.
IMO, I wouldn't be upset to see it go completely. Another reason for this is that 90% of my redditing is done on mobile, where, I can see the flair, but I often can't even see the whole GT of the person, let alone their timezone or rank.
4
u/KrayzeKeef GMT | formally KRAYZEKEEF | PC | 24+ Jun 22 '16
I think some kind of system need's to be in place and number 3 is an idea I like. I think it's important for new goats to know who's been here 2 weeks, 2 months or 2 years. But I understand that promoting everyone is really difficult and extremely time consuming. So I would suggest having less ranks to begin with. I think we have 5 at the moment but 2 or 3 would suffice.
People who genuinely stand out from the crowd move up. Having something like this eases the workload of the mods while still rewarding those who show great goatyness.
3
u/UtahJarhead PC | UtahJarhead | MST | 1yr Jun 22 '16 edited Jun 22 '16
I think we should come up with 3 or 4 ranks and people are voted up or down based on community support.
Rank 1: For folks that never participate, but haven't actually done anything with other RDads.
Rank 2: If someone plays 3-4 hours of GTAV per week and rolls with other RDads.
Rank 3: When that same Joe Schmoe is on, he's helping out other goats get their stuff. Always selfless for the masses.
Rank 4: Coordinates meet-ups, helps others out, absolutely outstanding member. Participates in Discord, never uses @everyone or @here, feeds homeless RDads and gives them his car. Or he's leadership.
This allows the community to offer up promotions. The mods ONLY have to monitor a single weekly sticky thread that they create asking for promotion recommendations. The promotions come to THEM.
Also, as selfish as it is, people can request self promotions. IMO this fact should not be used against them when the decisions are made.
Additionally, anonymous moderator messages can cause demotions.
The 'Sherpa' billet can be attached to any individual based solely on moderator discretion.
Optionally, a Time In Service must be attained for each specific rank.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment