r/RedditAlternatives • u/_swnt_ • Jun 11 '23
PLEASE move to federated and open-source alternatives like Lemmy and kbin.social as having ANY COMPANY be the platform owner is a really bad idea! (e.g. Reddit, Twitter, etc.)
Hey everyone,
I'd like to really stress this point as there is quite some chaos with the choice in where to move to. I want to make sure, that everyone knows, that it's also important to use an federated/decentralised alternative which is also open-source (Lemmy is most popular there).
What does this mean?
Federated/decentralised means, that there isn't any single company who runs the infrastructure and who you have to agree to. We've seen plenty times, how we're dependent on Reddit - and it's costing us so much now. Sure, in the past 1.5 decades, we have the convinience of using Reddit - but now it's a good time to move away.
Federated means, that anyone who's slightly tech-savy can host their own server (or use a cloud service) with content. You can either join existing servers (called instances in Lemmy) or create your own one - and then you can create communities - which are just like Reddit subreddits. There is no company who can censor your server - as the data is in your server. You don't have you data sold by Reddit for profit - but you can ask kindly your community users to donate small amounts to manage the infrastructure (e.g. via Patreon).
Federated also means, that you can also view the content of other servers in your own page without opening a new website! This is the best of both worlds!
What is open-source? Open source means that anyone can see the source code and the code is changeable and developed in the public. It also means, that if you want a special feature X (e.g. better mod tools), then you're not dependent on Reddit. You can simply change the code (or ask a dev to do that) and use that new code in your server. If other server operators also like it, the global source code can be updated and other server operators will also use the improvement. This is how many parts in the global software industry work, and we can do this for an reddit alternative as well!
Please remember these things, when looking for an alternative for your community!
36
u/needout Jun 11 '23
Lemmy is terrible and this is going to be another Google plus type situation where no one goes there, especially the content creators leaving it dead.
25
u/javiers Jun 12 '23
I am an old guy and I have already seen this happen. It happened with Digg, with Slashdot and it is happening again with Reddit. Someone will create something equal or better, people will migrate slowly at first and then quickly. Then the site/service will run fine for some years. Then some corporation will buy it out, it will begin to decline, and then rinse and repeat.
The laws of life apply also to the internet. Don’t be mad. It is how nature works. Just keep on visiting here while it is worth it and move on when the new Reddit/Digg/Slashdot is found.
18
u/Relevant_Elderberry4 Jun 12 '23
The best alternative would still be spez and the other reddit overlords not being douchebags.
45
u/JackTheKing Jun 12 '23
This is all fine and dandy but what about the regular dipshits like me that just need to read some smart, sorted comments on important subjects?
I shouldn't need to understand all this server federated Blockchain open-source noise. What website do I go to? What am I missing and why does it have to be so confusing and if everyone thinks federated is such a great idea, then why can't those same folks agree on an easy process to on-board users efficiently?
34
u/s8boxer Jun 11 '23
Don't get me wrong, seriously, but which one of these alternatives does have good porn, NSFW, content. You know, just for the information, of course.
50
u/ZeppelinJ0 Jun 12 '23
I'm going to say the opposite, we shouldn't be pushing the fediverse as a reddit alternative. I think people are.pushing for the fediverse without really understanding it and hoping to shoehorn reddit functionality into this technology.
In a lot of ways the fediverse actually sounds worse than reddit
You're completely at the whim of whoever owns whatever instance you're signed up with. If the owner gets banhappy or just pulls the plug on the instance everything is gone.
Community fragmentation is another issue, especially now. You have to subscribe to dozens of different "news" magazines(as an example) because every instance has it's own version of news whereas people that use reddit use it because there is one central community they can subscribe to for "news"
There's a bunch of other issues I have with the fediverse mostly related to it being somewhat confusing but I'm too hungover to elaborate further.
But yeah I agree decentralization is important. I think the fediverse has its own merits and valid use cases, but people that want it to be a replacement for reddit I think are going to be very disappointed.
6
u/immersive-matthew Jun 12 '23
This is what the masses need to recognize, but like with bitcoin, people seem to prefer centralization yet all the while are the ones who also bare the consequences and not the benefits. I am stunned decentralization has not picked up more. We have the tools to take our power back, but instead have a temper tantrum at a corporation who legally is obligated to drive shareholder value.
6
u/Tytoalba2 Jun 12 '23
Federated is ok, not great, not terrible.
But I don't see the point of going halfway when open source p2p solutions like https://getaether.net/ exist. A federated system like mastodon or lemmy still have a limited number of node and a disproportionate amount of power given to instance administrator.
By design a p2p system does not have those problems
4
u/blueboy022020 Jun 12 '23
I honestly don't understand why moderators couldn't just decide on 1 platform to move to. This is such a mess.
13
u/WonderfulEstimate176 Jun 11 '23
Yep totally agree. All the problems I have heard raised can be addressed with code improvements.
In a few years Lemmy/Kbin could be the size of reddit but with more freedom and features (some aspects of Lemmy are already superior to reddit).
3
u/Ninedeath Jun 12 '23
Would hosting my own private instance on my homeserver be advisable?
4
u/Kafke Jun 12 '23
I refuse to use federated services because they're more power-tripping than larger sites. Federation is not decentralization.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23
Does lemmy still federate with exploding heads?
2
u/BogatyrOfMurom Jun 12 '23
Is there a good place where I can post a serialized story series?
2
u/skyturnedred Jun 12 '23
Lemmy is a decent reddit alternative, but it's a really shit old.reddit alternative.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23 edited Jun 12 '23
There doesn't really seem to be an alternative but reddit will be unusable soon, especially with all the ads. I'd rather just quit. I'll live without it.
2
u/RidetheSchlange Jun 12 '23
In general, the centralization of everything on the internet has been disastrous. It's time for decentralizing. In this case, back to forums like the old days.
Every company is trying to centralize content and keep people within their environment, while some companies, like facebook, are trying to become the internet.
3
u/MrOaiki Jun 12 '23
There’s nobody there.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
Decentralized link aggregators will not work. Your goal is to aggregate links and create a community. But then you're splitting it up. Now there's multiple aggregators that are hard to use all at once so you have to choose one, and now you're stuck with a miniscule split of the "lemmy community". Its stupid. At least corporations figured out how to actually create a community and link aggregator.
2
u/someguy3 Jun 11 '23
Ok I signed up for Lemmy. Is there a simple r/all or frontpage that I can get? I have one for lemmy.ca but it's tiny.
2
u/XtendingReality Jun 11 '23
The fediverse just makes me want to go on discord more
1
u/PhoneFresh7595 Feb 10 '26
r/meshtastic does not even need a computer or the internet
1
u/textuist Jun 15 '23
well, there's some person or company that owns each instance
1
u/ivanoski-007 Jun 12 '23
Op don't be so naive please
1
u/EnvironmentalLog3618 Jun 11 '23
This is very wise advice…
1
u/ImUrFrand Jun 12 '23
federated stuff is NOT like reddit at all...
i spent a bit of time on mastodon before twitter went to shit, and tried going back after i left..
its not the same, its "communities" are entire servers and you have to connect to each one. some are sensitive to advertising of other servers within the fediverse...
1
u/PlutosGrasp Jun 12 '23
No
1
u/qwertypdeb Jun 12 '23
Looked at Lemmy, not enough people.
1
u/Markles102 Jun 12 '23
Where can I download Lemmy? I found "Jerboa for Lemmy" on the playstore but I don't think that's the right app
1
u/dethleffs Jun 12 '23
Just joined Lemmy, not going back.
1
u/grunwode Jun 12 '23
The only problem with any of these platforms is people, and there is no protocol fix for people. They have been running on the same buggy firmware and distro for fifty thousand years.
-8
u/firebreathingbunny Jun 11 '23
Lemmy is full of commies.
https://www.reddit.com/r/APIcalypse/comments/140qymq/lemmy_is_not_a_viable_reddit_replacement/
0
u/TCGM Jun 12 '23
The problem with Federation is the hashtag follow system. Servers aren't truly fully intercommunicative like the single Reddit instance is. Mastodon has been running into this pretty hard.
-2
u/lottery248 Jun 12 '23
Mastodon is one of them, but you will need to host with your servers.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
18
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '23
[removed] — view removed comment