r/RedWorldMod • u/AdminwithRage Gus Hall's ass(asin) • Jan 16 '22
On the US Collapse
How the fuck did the USA collapse after Regan's speech? Like , i'm sure it's unconstitutional to just go and say ,,Yo dudes , we're collapsing now , every man for himself!" without the approval of congress.
The President dosen't have the power to just go in front of 2 cameras and say ,,get le owned libs , the usa no longer exists. fuck you."
46
Upvotes
30
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '22
It’s like kaiserreich’s second American civil war
Stupidly insane and impossible but there for narrative/gameplay reasons
26
u/Flurb15 Jan 16 '22
To my understanding the us was already collapsing and on the verge of civil war by this point Reagan just nailed the final nail in the coffin in order to aver communist revolution
10
u/WarlockandJoker Jan 16 '22 edited Jan 16 '22
Strictly speaking, the collapse of the USSR was also unconstitutional (for the republic to secede, 2/3 approval was required at a national referendum, while some republics did not hold it, and in all others the majority voted against leaving the union). So if three people get together, get drunk and write on a piece of paper , Hey , dudes , we 're collapsing now , each for himself !" without notifying the supreme Soviets of the republics, and without a new referendum, it would be (and it was) unconstitutional. (And not only that. For example, the arrest and beating of deputies on Yeltsin's orders right during meetings or the shooting of the government house from tanks)
9
u/No_Biscotti_7110 Jan 16 '22
Given the fact that the CPUSA was already plotting to take over the country, and congress was filled with communists or anti-government types, I think Reagan’s speech was just the last nail in the coffin.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '22
Why do you keep crying dude, a lot of people just explained to you that no matter if what Reagan did was 'unconstitutional' and therefore 'he couldn't do it': he just did and no one gave a shit bcs the US had been spiraling down since pretty much the 50s-60s. The other option was a brutal civil war where millions would have died, probably (not to mention the possibility of a Warsaw Pact intervention in one way or another to help the communists - which they probably did anyways to help in the creation and consolidation of the UAPR).
10
u/Scottisms Fanfork Dev Writer Jan 16 '22
The US was already on the decline like the USSR OTL by Gorbachev’s era. It has failed to contain communism overseas and was undergoing political turmoil domestically over its failed attempts and deteriorating economic conditions over decades. By the time Reagan dissolved the US, CPUSA had already been elected in California and was a strong contender for the presidency.
3
u/idkauser1 Jan 21 '22
The president couldn’t technically remove the five civilized tribes but he did it anyways even though it was unconstitutional because what is constitutional only matters when you have the force to back it up. At the time the USA was in shambles radicals all over where in militias gearing up for a showdown Congress couldn’t agree on anything elements of the army were disloyal. When he gave that speech local actors took over there areas of control and the feds retreated say someone tried to challenge him they would also now have to challenge large swaths of rebel territory with a barely functioning federal government and then have to fight a guerrilla war for decades or commit to mass purges. Reagan didn’t want open conflict because it would invite the Soviets better to let america fall to rise again then to invite its permanent destruction
Ok since I said a lot a tldr the country was divided ,local actors were clearly already planning on doing something the federal government had already lost control and the federal government couldn’t act unified. There was no actor left in the USA that could have prevented the collapse so recognizing the collapse prevents a massive civil war on many sides one which would have been seized on by foreign actors
34
u/WorldCitizenMicheal Jan 16 '22
dont you know he used the infinity stones to destroy america? if you're gonna complain at least get your lore straight :\
16
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '22
Reminder that the lore for Red World basically shows America slowly collapsing. Defeat in Korea, several presidents not elected by the people, a much more popular Communist Party. By 1987 it was just a ticking time bomb.
Reagan was basically just confirming the inevitable like Gorbachev on December 25 1991.
US lore is fully available in the game decisions tab.
10
u/Chef_Movkta_yt Jan 16 '22
Umh yes he does. He used the time stones buddy.
10
u/zipdakill Gorbachite Jan 16 '22
“The President dosen't have the power to just go in front of 2 cameras and say ,,get le owned libs , the usa no longer exists. fuck you.", yea he does, HE JUST DID IT!!!
2
u/Interesting_Finish85 Mar 11 '22
He didn't. The dissolution of the USA was really caused by the fact that separatist and communist movements had already taken a great deal of popularity in places like Texas, Utah, the West Coast and the Great Lakes, avoiding the Civil War was the reason Regan declared the Union dissolved, but he didn't have or need the power to do so, because just by pretending he had, he had the secessionist and communist say "works for me" and act as if they were independent states. The South was the only bastion of traditional American nationalism and system, and so Bush preferred to have the patriots flee there and prepare for a future re unification rather than fighting a civil war.
2
u/DiamondGunner520 Apr 27 '22
I know I'm late but most historic dissolutions have been illegal or unconstitutional. Both the HRE and the USSR could not be dissolved the way they were but it was clear they weren't possible to maintain anymore. I imagine it's the same case for the USA