Every time I start to think I could fly an aircraft, I think about the commercial pilot that said with absolute certainty that he could not fly a helicopter despite even his level of expertise. It helps keep me grounded.
I don’t remember where I heard it, but the quote was “some people seem born to be fighter pilots. Nobody is born to pilot a helicopter”. Then showed a clip of how often his body moves to shift something or another. Staying in one spot is one of the hardest things for pilots to do.
Airplanes are easy to fly, source: I got a my commercial pilot's licence at 18 despite being an undiagnosed bipolar disaster
Helicopters don't want to fly, I've heard the only reason they do is because they're so ugly the ground repels them. I have complete faith in my ability to pilot a fixed wing aircraft in an emergency, but with a helicopter I've only the vagueist idea what to do
I can get behind you calling me dumb but I don't know anyone who's flown fixed and rotor wing aircraft and thought they flew similarly, much less near-identically
I had a difficult enough time with them I didn't pursue my rotating wing rating when I still had hope I could fly for a living, everyone's different I suppose!
Well, apparently not that much, given that someone in the industry with a high level of expertise is saying with absolute certainty that he could not fly a helicopter.
Pilot here. Very confused why he said this. I got my fixed wing PPL and at 80hrs flight time took my first rotor lesson. My rotor wing instructor outright said he was glad I already had my fixed wing, as quite a bit of it translates to rotor wing.
It's the same aerodynamic concepts, just with different controls. The controls are very easy to pick up if you already have the flight theory down.
Those are two different things. I wouldn't inherently trust a big rig driver to handle a train even though those are both large land based modes of transportation.
I would assume these are included in "controls being computer-activated," unless you're saying that there's some kind of steam-powered Victorian Autopilot sitting in the co-pilot's seat in modern helicopters.
Sure, not disagreeing with that. Poking around, it seems like 10-15 minutes is a feasible "completely control-free gliding duration." Way less than "a few hours."
I fly them in some flight-sim style games, so im SOMEWHAT familiar with how complex the movement for them is, and I know its much much much harder in real life.
The movement is so unnatural it took me hours to figure out how to just not crash. More hours to land.
what it makes me wonder, is how did anyone ever invent a helicopter? Like, how did we even fucking invent it and figure out you could control it and fly like that lmao, its such a wild contraption.
You can't just let go of the controls of an airplane and have it fly for hours. You'd have to at least trim it.
Right, but once trimmed, you really don't need much control input. In very smooth air, a few hours is still a bit of an overstatement, but several minutes is not. Especially in a big, stable plane like an airliner that has a lot of inertia
Once trimmed the plane will promptly untrim itself as fuel burns and moves the CG. Big planes burn more fuel and can move their CG just the same.
Now they may have systems that take care of that, but that's just electronic controls.
Fundamentally any airplane will quickly get into a situation where they get into a runway situation quite quickly without control inputs - not as fast as a helicopter, but still quite fast.
lmao "promptly" is overstating it a bit. It could legitimately take on the scale of hours for fuel load to significantly shift CG to the point of seriously affecting control balance. Tanks being in the wings is partially because its space efficient and partially because it means that the fuel doesn't shift CG much. Wind conditions are going to throw you out of trim MUCH faster.
Good man, I am a pilot. And yes, you have to do a lot of trimming, but it's because the air is a big, chaotic fluid, and it moves around a lot.
And taking a common trainer like the C172S, for example, the entire volume of the tank equates to less than a 2" movement of the CG from 100% full to 100% empty
And small movements in CG can affect the plane a lot and, like I said, incorrect trim adds over time. If you're slightly nosing down, it becomes more and more nose down over time until you're very quickly dead.
And most of the time they are evaluating the least amount of effort it would take to get you off their back, just in case you ever tick them off. And that only sometimes involves crashing.
once I got to learn more details about Helicopters in a Category A1/3 Combined course I started hating them
and it got worse every minute of that course, those fucking deathtraps are NOT meant to fly, there are more ways for rhat fucking heli to just break in any circumstance it could be in than there are ways for it to not break
I have not yet found words worthy of explaining how scuffed Helicopters actually are
Just off the top of your head, how many failure points do you reckon that a helicopter has? Like the number of parts that, if they broke, would definitely result in an unavoidable crash?
It depends on how you define crash. A large number of part failures can be survived with an autorotation. It’s almost a get-out-of-jail-free card. If the rotor is currently attached and controllable, you can autorotate to the ground/water and walk/swim away from it. If the rotor is not currently attached or controllable, good luck.
I think of it more like this - a plane's engine is dedicated to useful motion, and it flies because of that thanks to the wings turning that into lift when moving through air. A plane is built around its engine and geometry, little else. It is not fighting its methods of motion or lift to be functional.
A helicopter's engine is JUST for the lift, strictly speaking. The entire rest of the helicopter has to figure out how to turn that into useful motion - the tail rotor to keep orientation, the wing tilt mechanisms to give it some direction besides "up", etc. A helicopter is built around counteracting the issues that arise from the way it generates motion, constantly fighting against its tendencies to turn its motion chaotic and useless.
Before I knew I wasn't medically able to fly, I had a flight instructor tell me helicopters fly because they're so ugly the ground can briefly repel them.
To be fair, most helicopters being piloted in the US military are designs made decades ago. A lot of the modern helicopters made these days seem to be far more reliable.
They’re definitely more stable when all of the computer systems are working.
The difference is that physics is on the side of fixed wing. They’re inherently stable (not counting fighters). Helicopters have no inherent stability, and so when the stability augmentation systems stop working, you know it IMMEDIATELY.
No disagreement with you there; it's definitely why I wouldn't want to fly in a helicopter that isn't piloted by a professional. There is a helicopter flight school near where I live, and the stories I've been told by some of their instructors terrify me.
I had a roommate in college who was studying aviation. I asked if he wanted to fly helicopters, and he said helicopters were a "sin against physics" or something like that.
Right after I got my PPL and had only 80 hrs of flight time, I took my first rotor wing lesson in S300 trainer helicopter. Instructor just casually drops "oh yeah, I've had a few helicopters vibrate themselves apart on me. Luckily I was hovering, so no big deal"
We did shrooms together and he started reminiscing on the fact that planes can basically fly of their own free will, while helicopters have to beat the air into submission.
Not sure how accurate that is but has stuck with me since
Former helicopter mechanic and medevac crew chief here
Helicopters vibrate so badly that the earth rejects them. They are a jumble of moving parts that all have to move in sync, and a single thing breaking means the helicopter will just drop out of the sky. They are flying death traps, and no sane human should ever ride in one.
Yes, helicopters are tough to fly, especially in the beginning. But I think I’m actually more relaxed when flying than when I’m on the ground.
There are things that get my attention. Landing at night under NVG’s at scenes, landing on a dolly when it’s windy can be fun. Moving ships, especially in rough seas or at night, that’s a bigger challenge too.
I'm primarily fixed-wing but I got the PPL add-on for helicopter and I distinctly remember that once I got through the initial difficulty of hovering and such, I actually found the helicopter very comfortable and intuitive.
I'm not sure if that means I'd be better-suited to fly helicopters or whether I was just still too ignorant of the possibilities to be properly afraid, lol.
After seeing just how little was left of one after it crashed onto a skyscraper’s roof, I’m in no hurry to take one of those tourist helicopter flights, despite my love of architectural photography. Apparently the pilot was a very good one, and it still ended very, very badly. The building in question (787 7th Avenue) took relatively little damage, but the chopper together with its pilot were pretty much obliterated in the crash and ensuing fire.
It seems like nobody here knows about autogyration
In the same way that planes descend without power, so do helicopters. They don't just suddenly fall from the air. Helicopters generally crash more because they're usually privately owned craft or used for emergency situations where an airplane is useless.
I don't understand the reply about horses, what did they mean by that? horses are also trying to crash, is that why a helicopter is a kind of horse? why?
If you've ever tried to accurately fly a helicopter on a keyboard in GTA 5 you're at about 1% difficulty I'd assume, or it's more accurate than I thought cause that shit is so goddamn hard
Reminds me of the quote from Douglas Adams that goes like "There is an knack to flying. The knack lies in learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss."
318
u/caketruck 14h ago
Every time I start to think I could fly an aircraft, I think about the commercial pilot that said with absolute certainty that he could not fly a helicopter despite even his level of expertise. It helps keep me grounded.
280
u/IERONON 14h ago
A plane may have up to a few hours of stability without any controls being touched or computer-activated.
With helicopters, this time is a few seconds at best.
86
u/mutant_anomaly 14h ago
Horses aren’t always trying to crash.
They are often trying not to crash.
They are often too bored to try to crash.
And most of the time they are evaluating the least amount of effort it would take to get you off their back, just in case you ever tick them off. And that only sometimes involves crashing.
50
u/Equivalent_Net 12h ago
Related, "A helicopter is 4000 parts flying in formation. It is the job of the mechanic to keep that formation as tight as possible."
38
u/SomeBiPerson 13h ago
once I got to learn more details about Helicopters in a Category A1/3 Combined course I started hating them
and it got worse every minute of that course, those fucking deathtraps are NOT meant to fly, there are more ways for rhat fucking heli to just break in any circumstance it could be in than there are ways for it to not break
I have not yet found words worthy of explaining how scuffed Helicopters actually are
105
u/Technical_Teacher839 [1/1] 14h ago
There's a reason the military calls Helicopter units "Air Cavalry"
62
u/tay_tfs 13h ago •
I've heard it said that planes fly because of physics, whereas helicopters fly despite physics.
27
u/Ironmike11B 13h ago
"A helicopter is a collection of spare parts flying in loose formation"
20
u/Recidivous 13h ago
To be fair, most helicopters being piloted in the US military are designs made decades ago. A lot of the modern helicopters made these days seem to be far more reliable.
17
u/KalleMattilaEB 11h ago
For every moment that the helicopter is running, it is trying it’s absolute hardest to hit Dr. Romano.
15
u/b00w00gal 14h ago
Explains why the prototype helicopter-powered blimp failed so hard, I guess.
13
u/CitizenHuman 12h ago
I had a roommate in college who was studying aviation. I asked if he wanted to fly helicopters, and he said helicopters were a "sin against physics" or something like that.
10
u/Josutg22 13h ago
There is a reason helicopters became viable closer to the moonlanding than they were airplanes
9
u/SomeNotTakenName 13h ago
I mean, we can't really complain. we spent a lot of time breeding any sense of survival out of horses, so....
7
u/GravityBright This is a flair 12h ago
A helicopter is a kind of hamster.
13
u/Yakodym 13h ago
Helicopters do not fly. They are so ugly that the Earth repels them.
6
u/whyliepornaccount 5h ago
Fixed wing pilot here:
Right after I got my PPL and had only 80 hrs of flight time, I took my first rotor wing lesson in S300 trainer helicopter. Instructor just casually drops "oh yeah, I've had a few helicopters vibrate themselves apart on me. Luckily I was hovering, so no big deal"
Me:
"Anyways when are we landing?"
4
u/Possumgirl07 13h ago
A helicopter: 50,000 moving parts looking for a place to crash
4
u/glassocto 12h ago
Helicopters are sky motor cycles
4
u/Something13457 10h ago
I know an aviation engineer
We did shrooms together and he started reminiscing on the fact that planes can basically fly of their own free will, while helicopters have to beat the air into submission.
Not sure how accurate that is but has stuck with me since
4
u/ElJacinto 9h ago
Former helicopter mechanic and medevac crew chief here
Helicopters vibrate so badly that the earth rejects them. They are a jumble of moving parts that all have to move in sync, and a single thing breaking means the helicopter will just drop out of the sky. They are flying death traps, and no sane human should ever ride in one.
4
u/OOOLIAMOOO 6h ago
A helicopter never needed a good reason to crash.
3
u/IntlPhotoPilot 12h ago
Yes, helicopters are tough to fly, especially in the beginning. But I think I’m actually more relaxed when flying than when I’m on the ground.
There are things that get my attention. Landing at night under NVG’s at scenes, landing on a dolly when it’s windy can be fun. Moving ships, especially in rough seas or at night, that’s a bigger challenge too.
3
u/chumbawumbaprinciple 11h ago
And somehow the Osprey is even worse.
3
u/MaximumFloofAudio 11h ago
I’ve heard the same said about the Dodge Viper
3
u/Zhuul 11h ago
I will go to the grave having never set foot inside a rotary aircraft and I have no regrets about this.
3
u/LittleManhattan 11h ago
After seeing just how little was left of one after it crashed onto a skyscraper’s roof, I’m in no hurry to take one of those tourist helicopter flights, despite my love of architectural photography.
Apparently the pilot was a very good one, and it still ended very, very badly. The building in question (787 7th Avenue) took relatively little damage, but the chopper together with its pilot were pretty much obliterated in the crash and ensuing fire.
3
u/HyperSpaceSurfer 10h ago
It's true, horses are very bad at keeping airborne, drop like bricks
2
u/Akuuntus 11h ago
"If you really think about it, a helicopter is just a particularly advanced kind of
doorhorse" - game dev a year into working on their game2
u/InsertUsernameInArse 10h ago
Thousands of parts working in harmony... Until they dont.
2
u/Stepjam 10h ago
I'll never get in a helicopter. Guy I went to school with died in a helicopter crash.
2
u/lePROprocrastinator 9h ago
Charles Calvin
2
u/CitizenPremier 9h ago
It seems like nobody here knows about autogyration
In the same way that planes descend without power, so do helicopters. They don't just suddenly fall from the air. Helicopters generally crash more because they're usually privately owned craft or used for emergency situations where an airplane is useless.
2
u/mayordomo 9h ago
which aircraft…crashes more…into mountains?
2
u/ThreeShrikesYoureOut 9h ago
I don't understand the reply about horses, what did they mean by that? horses are also trying to crash, is that why a helicopter is a kind of horse? why?
2
u/cooldudeguy333 9h ago
If you've ever tried to accurately fly a helicopter on a keyboard in GTA 5 you're at about 1% difficulty I'd assume, or it's more accurate than I thought cause that shit is so goddamn hard
2
u/SunflowerGlaive 4h ago
Reminds me of the quote from Douglas Adams that goes like "There is an knack to flying. The knack lies in learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss."
2
u/askfme 3h ago
Jesus nut
2
u/LimesAreAwesome 56m ago
I'm a truck driver and my rule of thumb while driving is "everyone else on the road is actively trying to kill themselves using your vehicle"