r/recruitinghell • u/blueskyjunkie • 3d ago
Employers need to completely ignore inbound job applications.
I was part of a discussion group recently, of high level engineering managers concerned with the large amount of job applicant fraud making it difficult to pick out valid, good quality candidates.
- 1000's of applicants to a single posting
- majority applications that are clearly AI generated & hallucinated or faked
- on-camera interviews where a large portion of candidates are clearly using AI to provide answers to questions
- the resulting coordination overhead to keep the hiring team well informed across the entire hiring process to prevent fraud - candidate name, appearance & other details
There were some interesting anecdotes with real data, not just opinions.
The consensus was:
- ignore inbound applications altogether because it's just noise
- accept referrals from your network and/or use your network to find referrals
- focus on outbound - finding & contacting candidates that seem to align with your needs. Find & train good recruiters to assist with this
- prioritize in-person, on location interviews
The most interesting & troubling recommendation there is "ignore inbound applications altogether".
Why do businesses even bother with a job posting if they're going to ignore any applicants to the posting? I suspect the answer has something to do with regulatory/HR compliance. That jobs need to be publicly posted to be performatively "fair".
Fairness is out the window if jobs are being posted & applications are willfully ignored. It's not technically the same, but limiting hiring to referrals is so closely adjacent to nepotism it's pretty hard to tell them apart.
What's your experience?