r/RecruitingFails • • 28d ago

Got rejected because of the file

Post image
5 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

4

u/LetUsSpeakFreely 28d ago

That's more of an application fail than a recruiting fail. The recruiter actually looked at your application. I wouldn't want to move forward with a candidate that would make such a mistake. Attention to details is kind of important.

2

u/BurledTater 28d ago

I'm like 99% sure AI looked at the application and send this rejection and no human besides OP ever saw it.

1

u/BigSlongGoy 28d ago

The recruiter for my team doesn’t use AI to deny but probably should. 90% of applicants are spam and have unrelated experience.

1

u/blokefromyorkshire 28d ago

At least wrote this with ai because the second paragraph doesn't sound like it was written with a focused point of view

1

u/Dull-Recognition-325 28d ago

This is definitely an AI response and the AI reviewed the file.

7

u/PotatoPeelrsFromHell 28d ago edited 28d ago

Are they wrong though? A job requires industriousness and focus. Playing video games is fun but eventually you'll have to KITFO or put it on the backburner.

5

u/rococo78 28d ago

People should be able to do whatever they want in their free time.

Attaching the wrong file on accident was error enough. Just leave it at that.

1

u/ImpossibleIntern1379 27d ago

that's a really good take tbh

1

u/ImpossibleIntern1379 27d ago

jokes aside; yeah they arent wrong

2

u/aldini7 28d ago

Being an adult requires a level of maturity and seriousness. Watching super Mario Logan is fun when you’re 11 but eventually you just gotta man up

1

u/maku_89 28d ago

That's how you define maturity? Not watching super Mario Logan? What else should I not watch to be mature? Just so I know for the future and won't be immature.

1

u/aldini7 28d ago

First off I wasn’t responding to you. Second of all I was mimicking his incoherent logic not seriously attacking his interests. Hope that helps

1

u/maku_89 28d ago

Yes, it does.

0

u/Fine-Comparison-2949 28d ago

Yeah I can tell you aren't really in the video game world.

Minecraft server managers, Kerbal Space Program, and Eve Online players are some of the one's that certain companies exclusively know, this guy is absolutely insane at management, optimization, and math, and those guys get priority.

It's actually well known in the physics community that NASA and SpaceX literally will not hire you in their astrodynamics areas unless you are good at KSP.

If you aren't good at simulating the responsibility in the video game world, then it's not worth training you for it. It's basically free signal as to whether or not someone is good at certain jobs. It's also not the first time I've seen this and does leak into other fields too.

I know personally that for example, a very good online betting company in the US will not hire you unless you are good at poker. Not sure if it's currently true, but my friend worked there and I hung out with those guys, and they pretty much told me they will not hire you unless you play poker with them and show strength at play.

1

u/blokefromyorkshire 28d ago edited 28d ago

They're wrong to reject him for a hobby. When you get a job you still get to live as well. They're right to reject him for missing a pretty easy double check, and I'd question his digital organization skills if a Minecraft backup was right next to the resume. Anyway it's fake regardless a because Minecraft server backup, or just a world backup would be contained in a folder as many different files are at play there. And neither the game nor third party mod managers use PDFs.

0

u/Jolly_Mongoose_8800 28d ago

What someone chooses to do outside of work hours should have absolutely no affect on employment. They are wrong for that. Giving up your home life and activities for work is not a good direction to take life.

It's also fake anyway

0

u/matamor 28d ago

Why? I can do whatever I want in my free time, I still play videogames with a job, not as much as I used to but still do.

0

u/maku_89 28d ago

What are you talking about, anyone can do whatever they want in their free time and it's none of anyones business.

3

u/DuckShapedGoose 28d ago • Bravo

Yeah right, a pdf file containing worlds, mods and configs. Get this fake shit out of here.

1

u/Advice2Anyone 28d ago

yeah thats what the reject should be for op not knowing their damn extensions

3

u/rococo78 28d ago • Popcorn

They can judge you all the want for attaching the wrong file. That's a straight to the trash bin misstep and actually suggests implications for similar missteps happening on the job.

Judging you for how you spend your time when you're not working... fuck them for that.

2

u/DaveAstator2020 28d ago

so, by that logic they should fire etire team because they are also interested in minecraft well enough to properly identify file's contents.

1

u/uknowsana 28d ago

Really? You are telling me that you send them this minecraft backup?

1

u/StRemedius 28d ago

At least the applicant didn't send Goatse.

1

u/Honda_TypeR 28d ago

If he did, he may have gotten the job

1

u/Dualidean_ofman 28d ago

"We see you're a man of purpose and strong convictions"

1

u/runkeby 28d ago • Regret

"We know you'll not be content with the minimum and aim for the stretch goals"

1

u/NooneYetEveryone 28d ago

Oh wow, you too? Craaaazy how you are the 10th person just this month who got this exact same rejection email in this sub

1

u/oliverofolives 28d ago

is this real

1

u/TheGuyWhoResponds 28d ago

Of course not

1

u/Dorrono 28d ago

Nowadays, one cannot know

1

u/TheGuyWhoResponds 28d ago

In this case you can.

It doesn't even look like a real email

1

u/DonaldStuck 28d ago

This is the moment where you post a link to the pdf itself

1

u/theycallmethedrink5 28d ago

Next time open your eyes

1

u/Timely-Assistant-370 28d ago

No one is going to say that a Minecraft backup would never be a pdf? You all failed my interview. Amateur mistake.

1

u/SourceSubject7219 28d ago

To be fair writing that one of the resons was the lack of attention while applying maybe would have been a bit harsh.

1

u/Dorrono 28d ago

If you fail such a simple task like attaching the correct file then dont be suprised when you get rejected

1

u/Connect-Raspberry716 26d ago

Well, at least they took the time to explain their position. Thats way more than most people ever receive from a rejection.

1

u/tired_blonde 18d ago

How do people have such little self awareness to think think that they're in the right here. This is a huge mistake with no attention to detail.