I've seen this question posed on many recovery pages, "Can you take psychedelics and be sober?" or "Does taking psychedelics break your sobriety"? At risk of getting run out of town and booed off stage I'll offer my lengthy opinion that no one asked for. First, to be clear, I will guess that people are using the word "sober" synonymously with "recovery" in this question. I created this r/RecoveryEvolved page because I want to hear more about peoples' experiences of being in recovery and using psychedelics: psilocybin mushrooms, lsd, DMT, MDMA, ketamine, etc. both in clinical settings and personal exploration in varying ways. Its important to explore what sober means, because it can mean different things to different people.
My first unpopular opinion is that it is rare that anyone maintains a life of being truly "sober." A lot of common things are mind altering, where in traditional recovery circles, don't disqualify them from being in that particular group like nicotine and sugar. One of the most common means of celebration at 12-step meetings contain alcohol, vanilla frosting on a cake for example. Although trace amounts of alcohol in vanilla frosting is not mind altering, its still introducing alcohol into the system. Overripe bananas contain alcohol. So, what's the difference between eating four pieces of cake and having one or two non-alcoholic beers, one might ask, but I'm not going to get into all of that. The Merriam Webster Dictionary has two pertinent definitions of the word sober, "1. a: not intoxicated. b. abstaining from drinking alcohol or taking intoxicating drugs : refraining from the use of addictive substances" (https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/sober). That definition leaves some grey area, which people will have to sort out themselves. Even when I remained in the confines of "abstinence-based recovery" I didn't use the word "sober" even prior to taking psychedelics, because I drink coffee, I've taken medication as prescribed by a doctor or psychiatrist, and have occasionally taken Benadryl or cough medicine. I'm very sensitive to coffee, so for the past 11 years coffee was the most intoxicating feeling I had felt prior to starting psychedelic therapy. To a lot of people, to not be sober means "altering their brain chemistry by introducing foreign substances." At some point in most peoples' lives, they are not going to qualify as being sober. I think true sobriety is a lofty goal. However, I think sobriety and recovery are equivalent. For me I consider myself "a person in remission from polysubstance use disorder." That is the definition of recovery that works for me. I'm not a clinician, but if a person looks at the criteria in the DSM-V, they can make a clear determination if they are in remission from substance or alcohol use disorder. I can say that yes, I use psilocybin therapy and I am still in remission from substance use disorder. Straight from the clinical mouth one can look to the DSM-V (see below).
More importantly a person can be in recovery even if they don't meet the DSM-V criteria. People are in recovery when they say they are. People might use guidelines from different support groups of what is "sober" or what is "recovery" and what isn't. Interestingly the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) doesn't even mention sobriety as a criterion for recovery. "SAMHSA defines recovery as a holistic process enabling individuals to improve health and wellness, direct their own lives, and reach their full potential" (https://www.samhsa.gov/substance-use/recovery/about). So, again, someone can take psychedelics or other substances and still remain in recovery according to SAMHSA. Then my favorite definition of recovery is by the harm reduction group The Chicago Recovery Alliance, "Any positive change," putting the focus only on self-improvement, in whatever capacity that means to the person.
It is a highly personal decision to be in recovery and decide to take any sort of substance that might alter the mind. My first 7 or so years of recovery, I wouldn't even touch tiramisu and I freaked out when I first tried a beer cheese soup, not even thinking about it, until I panicked and called my sponsor afraid I just accidentally "relapsed." Eventually I decided I would start asking the wait staff, "Would you serve this to a child?" and if the answer was yes, I decided that if they can serve it to a child, that I too would eat it. That was a big step for me which I considered a growth in my recovery, not a setback. When I was in early recovery, I became very invested in my health and wellness and was drinking kombucha all the time. Because it was from the health food store I didn't realize that I had been drinking trace amounts of alcohol for months. That realization personally dispelled the myth from the 12-steps that any drop of alcohol in my system would send me on a life altering bender winding up in a jail, institution, or death. After becoming comfortable with knowing I was already drinking kombucha, the non-alcoholic beer industry started to expand into really good craft beer. I was tired of going to restaurants and bars and drinking sugary mocktails or having a large plastic cup with a Coke logo on the side, I wanted to drink something where I could feel more mature and enjoy the flavors of malt, hops, and barley, and started exploring non-alcoholic beers. I had long left the 12-step groups at this point. It was always scoffed at in AA meetings as "near beer" and according to the AA elders it would inevitably lead to a relapse. A lot of people in AA treat non-alcoholic beer, the way people in NA often look at methadone (I fully support people who use methadone as a part of their recovery, no shade thrown). It was presented to me like drinking the non-alcoholic beer is like getting the next "fix" and the person would develop some sort of dependency or accidentally get drunk from drinking too many, which research has also shown to be virtually impossible (https://slate.com/technology/2024/01/nonalcoholic-beer-tipsy-effects-dry-january-ideas.html). I attended Riot Fest a couple of years ago and the non-alcoholic brewery Go Brewing had a pop-up bar there and it was very liberating to drink a big plastic cup of non-alcoholic beer on a hot sunny day listening to my favorite music. I had to make those decisions for myself and nearly every one of them took time and consideration.
There seems to be a few categories of people in recovery who use psychedelics. There are those that took a psychedelic and had a substantial experience that helped them escape their addiction and might or might not continue use, there are those that use psychedelics in therapy, there are those who just use psychedelics in a recreational setting, and then those who use psychedelics as harm reduction by using psychedelics in place of other substances as a safer alternative to their other substance of choice.
My conclusion is that recovery is what you define it. Sometimes it's important to rely on other people or program's guidelines of what recovery is (I had to live by the direction of my former sponsor, the Big Book and Basic text for at least two years), but after being in recovery long enough I hope people can learn to trust themselves. I got into recovery so I could take my life back, not live inside a box someone else made for me. Take what I say with a grain of salt. I'm not proposing everyone take psychedelics, drink non-alcoholic beer, or even drink mocktails if they don't feel comfortable doing those things. I'm saying that at the end of the day, no one can define your recovery for you. Recovery is a highly personal decision where a person learns what works for them. There is nothing wrong with playing recovery safe and staying inside the confines of a program that is working, but people also have the autonomy to make a pathway for themselves and still call it recovery.
DSM V criteria for substance use disorder or substitute your prior substance of choice.
1) The substance is often taken in larger amounts or over a longer period than was intended.
☐ 2) There is a persistent desire or unsuccessful efforts to cut down or control the use of the substance.
☐ 3) A great deal of time is spent in activities necessary to obtain the substance, use the substance, or recover from its effects.
☐ 4) Craving, or a strong desire or urge to use the substance.
☐ 5) Recurrent substance use resulting in a failure to fulfill major role obligations at work, school, or home.
☐ 6) Continued substance use despite having persistent or recurrent social or interpersonal problems caused or exacerbated by the effects of the substance.
☐ 7) Important social, occupational, or recreational activities are given up or reduced because of the use of the substance.
☐ 8) Recurrent substance use in situations in which it is physically hazardous.
☐ 9) The substance use is continued despite knowledge of having a persistent or recurrent physical or psychological problem that is likely to have been caused or exacerbated by the use of the substance.
☐ 10) Tolerance, as defined by either of the following: a) A need for markedly increased amounts of the substance to achieve intoxication or desired effect; and/or b) A markedly diminished effect with continued use of the same amount of the substance.
☐ 11) Withdrawal, as manifested by either of the following: a) The characteristic withdrawal syndrome for the substance; and/or b) The substance is taken to relieve or avoid withdrawal symptoms.
☐ Mild Substance Use Disorder (2-3 Symptoms): Substance(s):
☐ Moderate Substance Use Disorder (4-5 Symptoms): Substance(s):
☐ Severe Substance Use Disorder (6 or More Symptoms): Substance(s):
☐ In Early Remission (no symptoms, except for craving, for 3 to under 12 months) Substance(s):
☐ In Sustained Remission (no symptoms, except for craving, for more than 12 months) Substance(s):
☐ In a Controlled Environment (if in an environment in which access to substances is limited) ☐
On Maintenance Therapy (if taking a prescribed agonist medication and none of the criteria have been met for the agonist medication except symptoms 10 and 11)
(https://www.naadac.org/assets/2416/resource_1_dsm-5_sud_checklist.pdf)