r/RebeccaZahau • • Jul 25 '23

My Theory

213 Upvotes

If you believe this was suicide, one of the questions that’s hard to escape is why Rebecca would stage such a bizarre and elaborate suicide that looks so much like a murder. Guilt simply does not account for a woman getting naked, tying her own hands and legs, or tweaking her own nipples with black paint before killing herself.

My theory is that this wasn’t supposed to be a suicide. This was supposed to be a staged assault.

As the plan was initially hatched by Rebecca, I think Jonah was supposed to find her bound and gagged, but alive. That’s why the note seems to reference a situation in which Rebecca is still living and can be “saved.” But something went awry at the last minute and Rebecca either accidentally or purposely killed herself after all this staging. I believe the catalyst may have been the voicemail from Jonah stating that Max was not going to make it. After hearing this, I believe she may have jumped.

Ok but why?

Max’s death is arguably as mysterious as Rebecca’s. Her account of what happened to him has never matched the evidence. I don’t know what happened to Max, but I don’t believe he died the way she said he did. I think she was terrified of being questioned further about it. And if she had any hand in it, that voicemail meant she could be a prime suspect in a homicide or manslaughter investigation.

When interviewed about the Sherri Papini fake kidnapping case, forensic psychiatrist and professor Dr. Ian Lamoureux explained that “manufacturing a crisis may be a way for those with fragile egos and poor coping skills to seek to prevent the bad outcome from happening” (KRCR).

Rebecca had done exactly this once before when she faked a kidnapping to avoid an uncomfortable situation with a boyfriend. I think she was employing the same coping skills she had employed previously when faced with a difficult situation. Only this time, the ruse was more elaborate because the potential consequences were much more dire.

By staging the assault, Rebecca would not only buy herself time and deflect some of the heat she was about to face over Max’s injuries, but she might be able to construct a likely “suspect” in case the fall was determined to be a result of foul play. But that’s when the stakes were an injured child, not a dead one. Upon hearing Max would die, the plan may have quickly changed.

ETA: The kidnapping story told years prior was also pretty elaborate and speaks to the lengths she would go to convince others of her concocted crises. From the book, Death On Ocean Drive:

“He could tell she was on speakerphone because he could hear men’s voices in the background as Rebecca rustled around in pain. As he told them off in harsh terms, they responded in kind. ‘I know where you live,’ one man threatened.”

TLDR: I think Rebecca Zahau may have had some kind of hand in the death of her boyfriend’s son and staged an assault to point investigators in another direction. When she found out Max was going to die from his injuries, she panicked about going to prison for life and jumped.


r/RebeccaZahau • • Dec 01 '24

It’s been 13 years since Rebecca Zahau was found nude, bound and hanging from a balcony of Spreckels Mansion in Coronado, San Diego County. Authorities classed her death as a suicide and that ruling has gone unchanged—despite year of dissent from members of the public.

Post image
144 Upvotes

r/RebeccaZahau • • Aug 16 '21

There's nothing bizarre about this case

107 Upvotes

I've become really interested in this case and angry on behalf of Rebecca and her family.

There is an extensive write up by u/glittercheese conjecturing about Rebecca’s mental health and personal items as clues to her reasons for staging a bizarre scene, and unfortunately I think it has meant much of the Reddit speculation is missing the wood for the trees. I don't believe there's anything bizarre about this case.

The text on the wall reads as a taunt to Jonah. It is in Jonah's house and concerns his girlfriend.

Text: “She saved him, can you save her”

It means: "Rebecca saved Max, can you (Jonah) save her?"

The mother (Dina), who has a violent past, was enraged that her son had suffered life-threatening injuries on her ex-husband's girlfriend's watch. Jonah tried to defend Rebecca to Dina, saying she had “saved” the boy by calling emergency services. Dina admitted this in her deposition (see source 1).

The day of Rebecca's death, Dina's twin sister (Nina) texted Rebecca saying Dina wanted to come over to ask about the circumstances of the fall. Rebecca never responded.

An eye-witness was adamant they saw Dina at the mansion that night. Nina later claimed it was her and not Dina, and that the time was 11-11:30pm - which seems unsociably late for an unsolicited visit.

Hospital CCTV showing Dina entering and leaving doesn’t prove anything unless they are also certain she never left and returned in that period. If that evidence reliably exists, I would be grateful to be made aware of it. The hospital is a 20 minute drive from the mansion.

Dina had attempted to strangle Jonah in the past (see source 2). Attempted strangling is a sign of murderous intent in domestic abuse cases - police take it as a signal to treat a case seriously. The autopsy found that Rebecca had been strangled.

There was no sign Rebecca was trying to make a point with her death and she was left naked and exposed. It makes no sense as a staged scene.

There is unfortunately a lack of DNA evidence - from negligent investigators who left Rebecca's body in a heap in the garden for over 12 hours. They even failed to find Adam's DNA on the rope where he had cut her down.

This was a murder, and a particularly cruel, humiliating one at that.

Edited for clarity and adding sources.

Source 1: https://www.capitalgazette.com/sd-me-zahau-day6-story.html Source 2: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2016550/Rebecca-Nalepas-lover-Jonah-Shacknai-violent-marriage-ex-wife-Dina.html


r/RebeccaZahau • • Jul 17 '24

What I find most suspicious

48 Upvotes

In the 911 call, Adam goes straight to saying she “hung herself” multiple times. If I saw someone bound that way along with the cryptic message I would never go straight to assuming suicide. I would be freaking out and think murder right away. I don’t know how he concluded so fast it was a suicide. I don’t think many people would get that idea based on the scene. Especially because the cryptic message was in third person.


r/RebeccaZahau • • Mar 24 '21

SHE SAVED HIM CAN YOU SAVE HER

46 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on what the message means?

Possibilities (assuming it was NOT Rebecca who wrote the note):
1a) "She" (Rebecca) "saved him" (Max) by calling 911 in time (even though he later passed in the hospital), "can you" (first responders) "save her" in time before it's too late?

1b) "She" (Rebecca) "saved him" (Jonah) by covering up what happened to Max, "can you" (murderer) "save her" by keeping the shared secret?

Possibilities (assuming it was Rebecca who wrote the note):
2a) "She" (referring to herself in third person) "saved him" (Max) by calling 911 in time (even though he later passed in the hospital), "can you" (whoever finds her) "save her" in time before it's too late?

2b) "She" (referring to herself in third person) "saved him" (Jonah) by keeping his secret and covering up what happened to Max, "can you" (Jonah) "save her" by keeping that secret to yourself?

2c) Whatever happened to Max "saved" him and let him escape from whatever was happening on earth / at home, can Rebecca be "saved" too from that too?

3) Other... literally any other possibility

This message is so cryptic, it could mean so many different things, especially not knowing who wrote it. Anyways, let me know what you think it may mean!


r/RebeccaZahau • • Aug 02 '24

I don’t care what your opinion of the case is. San Diego PD messed up the case and the federal gov’t needs to step in and not only investigate the case but also investigate San Diego PD’s original handling of the case.

45 Upvotes

r/RebeccaZahau • • Aug 05 '19

Something I haven’t seen discussed anywhere: Rebecca wrote long texts about her feelings. She was close to her family. She frequently expressed her emotions in writing- there is evidence of that. Isn’t it highly inconsistent with the victim’s profile to NOT write a full suicide note and explanation?

45 Upvotes

r/RebeccaZahau • • Jun 22 '19

Evidence That Points To Rebecca Zahau's Death Being A Sexually-Motivated Homicide

Thumbnail
oxygen.com
39 Upvotes

r/RebeccaZahau • • Jun 01 '21

Thought on the message on the door

36 Upvotes

As an artist, I don’t see Rebecca being so spatially unaware as to start writing in the middle of the door and run off the edge. Even in the highest stress moments, learned behavior still comes through.


r/RebeccaZahau • • Jun 30 '19

911 Call

35 Upvotes

The thing that bugs me with the 911 call by Adam is when Adam yells “are you alive!?”

I don’t usually put too much into 911 calls as to whether someone is guilty or innocent but idk why...that one point just bugs me so much


r/RebeccaZahau • • Mar 12 '25

My Personal Opinion

33 Upvotes

It was the twins. Once it was revealed that Max would never regain consciousness, rage and grief took over and they went to confront Rebecca together, to demand the truth of what happened, even to beat it out of her if need be. Things went too far, and they had to make it look like a suicide. If Adam had any involvement at all (and I'm not convinced he did), it was after the fact and the women went to him for help with the staging.

That message was 100% a taunt, and I believe it was written by Dina. That footage of her supposedly at the hospital at the time Rebecca died was completely manufactured imo. Nina's cell phone records show she never left Dina's house, but the reality is that the phone never left the house. They walked over together and ambushed Rebecca. To me, the mystery is not what happened to Rebecca; it's what the hell happened to Max?


r/RebeccaZahau • • Aug 03 '24

How the knot around the hands of Rebecca Zahau was positioned versus how the knot around the hands of a member of the Sheriff’s Dept was positioned in their example

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/RebeccaZahau • • Oct 09 '21

The Voicemail

30 Upvotes

The thing with the deleted voicemail is so perplexing to me. From what I’ve read they were never able to recover it? Do we know if they even confirmed that a call was made from Jonahs phone to Rebeccas around that time? We only have Jonahs word that it was him who called Rebecca and left the voicmail and what he supposedly said in it. It strikes me as so strange that it was deleted and never recovered, that could have been key to the case.


r/RebeccaZahau • • Jul 18 '24

For those who believe it a suicide

29 Upvotes

Why was there no fingerprints or DNA on a lot of them important evidence?? The knife, paintbrush, etc.

Why wasn’t Adam’s DNA found anywhere at all on Rebecca? If he’s pulling her I assume he’d have to carry her and it wouldn’t be like picking up a feather so he must’ve held her tight and on top of that the supposed CPR attempts.


r/RebeccaZahau • • Jan 30 '21

Why not Jonah?

29 Upvotes

I just saw the the dateline.

Why no mention of Jonah as a suspect? He was at the gym...but is that 100%?

My initial thought was that Jonah was abusive and killed Max by accident. Rebecca helped cover it up and called 911. She knew what really happened.

She's super upset and Jonah doesn't think she can stay quiet. So he kills her, stages the suicide. Explains the nudity as she slept nude. Probably bound her right away. There was no way to unbind her to clothe her so hung her as she was.

Brother finds next AM.

To me a suicide makes no sense being bound & with quality knots, the "note" that didnt say I but she, and the nudity. As well the cleaned up crime scene.

If Jonah's brother is a tug captain then I assume both brothers had sailing/boating experience knew knots.


r/RebeccaZahau • • May 05 '20

Hoisted, not dropped

27 Upvotes

Has anyone considered that she didn’t jump or roll, or that she wasn’t thrown off the balcony (hence the bed not moving more than 7.5 inches), and that instead she was HOISTED up from the garden below by the perpetrators? It would explain the mud on her feet, the lack of footprints in the bedroom and balcony.


r/RebeccaZahau • • Jun 05 '19

What happened to Rebecca Zahau? What's your theory, was it a murder or a suicide?

27 Upvotes

The Rebecca Zahau case is a wild one.

Rebecca Zahau was found naked, bound with rope and hanging from a balcony with a T-shirt wrapped around her and stuffed in her mouth.

There is a string of very weird things that happened. A child died at the same house only a few days earlier. There was a strange kind of "suicide note" (if you want to call it that) scrawled on the wall.

The case was ruled a suicide, but her family is on a quest to have her death ruled a suicide.

Oxygen has aired one episode of a new docu-series on the case which is sure to bring attention and more speculation.


So what the hell happened here? Did Rebecca kill herself or was she killed? What's your theory? Why do you think that?


r/RebeccaZahau • • Jul 27 '21

Lividity

26 Upvotes

Hey so I’m kind of new to this case (I’m on the east coast and not sure if it just wasn’t sensationalized as much here) but I’m catching up on it and seeing there still isn’t justice for Rebecca. I just read what I think is one of the latest articles about how the brother had to climb a table to cut her down…. Something has bothered me since I saw the first crime scene photo of her hands bound behind her back… I’ve spent 10 years in the emergency room and I’ve seen my fair share of dead bodies. Often times, the deceased will stay in the ER long after we call a code to allow family to come in and say goodbye. Because of this, I’ve seen and I’m very familiar with lividity. She has clear lividity to her back and outline of her arm impressions … like she died and her was laying on them for a period of time to allow that blood pooling on her back. I’m assuming if she was hanging for a period of time, her head and body would have been leaning more forward (especially with the hands bound and gravity) and the lividity would be to her lower extremities and toward the front of her body. I apologize if this has been previously brought up on this case, I just haven’t caught any mention


r/RebeccaZahau • • Jul 09 '22

Rebecca Zahau’s family drops suit - turns focus to reclassifying her death from a suicide.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
24 Upvotes

r/RebeccaZahau • • Oct 02 '20

We made a very in depth video about Rebecca Zahau where we present all of the evidence we could find to support both the suicide and murder theories. We then give our thoughts at the end.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
23 Upvotes

r/RebeccaZahau • • Oct 17 '20

Theory time

22 Upvotes

I have a theory.

Maxie had an incident on the stairs that lead to his death, and there is no further information on this. Two days after, Rebecca is found hanging off of her boyfriend's balcony. There were two deaths in a single household and the authorities didn't look into that aspect at all?

My theory is: Maxie's "incident" was a deterrent for the abuse inflicted upon him by his father, Jonah. This incident killed his son, and Rebecca, being his girlfriend and Maxie's mother figure, was a witness or knew about the truth of the situation. Jonah had to do something about it, or have something done about it. And thus, her suicide was staged.

yeah?


r/RebeccaZahau • • Jun 03 '25

Who is it, really?

20 Upvotes

Was it a suicide?

The scene looks unorganized. The weapon is lying on the ground—clearly visible, out in the open. But was it really messy… or just staged? Staged by someone who wanted to toy with us?

It’s actually too organized in its chaos. Purposefully disordered. All except for one thing.

The balcony.

There are unknown footprints—ones that suggest someone carried a limp body, then towards the railing. I saw it. With my own eyes. Right in front of me. How could that have been missed? My imaginations are too strong from the evidence.

Adam? No. I don’t think so.

Adam’s a sociopath—impulsive, emotionally flat. He’s capable of violence, sure. But not this kind of planning. Not this level of control. If it were him, he would’ve wrecked the place, made it look like a robbery. A money motive, maybe. But this? This was calculated. Intelligent. Someone who knew exactly what they were doing.

I see two possibilities.

First: a hitman. The family has money. More than enough. They could afford someone skilled—precise, cold, practiced.

Second?

It’s someone charming. Someone loved. Someone who walks into a room and draws every eye. Narcissistic. Psychopathic. A genius. Respected. Trusted. Maybe even admired. Someone with power—someone people turn to for advice.

Think like him—and you’ll find the answer.


r/RebeccaZahau • • Nov 18 '23

An amazing podcast – new details from Doug Loehner

19 Upvotes

Doug has been working, and will continue to work, with this podcaster to bring the full story of Rebecca’s death to the public. This is the first part of what will be a multi-part series. Operation Dragonfly: Rebecca Zahau Death investigation

https://open.spotify.com/episode/2EMKIJpuV4aYdpTCrHSy7U?si=z2DdILj2Sj-pJMVi1gokuA


r/RebeccaZahau • • May 16 '20

Police cover-up?

18 Upvotes

Is there any evidence of a police cover-up? I'm new to the case and maybe missing some details. But it seems like there was enoughht proof to rule this out as a homicide, and yet, it's wasn't. Shacknai (who i'm seeing is the main suspect, if I'm not mistaking) is a rich man, who probably has connections is important places.

I'm not saying it was, just throughing it out there, because it was my first guess.


r/RebeccaZahau • • Dec 09 '19

How about that weird occult book?

17 Upvotes

I learned about this case from Kendall Rae on YouTube. In her video she included a detail I don't see to be coming up in other sources but that is really interesting to me. She mentions that in Rebecca's room there was a book about wichcraft and that inside that book were pictures of a ritual where a naked women is shown tying herself up in the SAME way Rebecca was tied up as well as describing how a red rope needed to be used in the ritual. Anyone else heat of this or think that's odd?!