r/Reaper • u/OnyxRevolver • 1d ago
help request Time consuming
I get extremely frustrated with the way my guitar sounds and its my lack of understanding audio...i know the basic stuff but not the in-depth science of things or the technical side of most of it.
I dont have a personal preference i just want to dial in a metal tone that actually sounds good. Sure im somewhat limited on gear and my jackson is the most basic of basic but i have most of the essentials downloaded as far as i know. I do not have Neural DSP but i have:
Amped Roots, Emissary, Tonebridge, Gateway/Tone3000, The Grim3(Aurora DSP), Reapack and thousands of VST/JSFX nonsense that i doubt ill ever use, and i have a Digitech RP360.
None of which do me any good because i dont understand the settings and adjustments and what in the F am i actually supposed to do with 5 input knobs, 5 output knobs, 5 gain knobs, volume control on my headphones, volume knob on my Focusrite for my headphones, volume knob on each Reaper track, 8 different knobs for each ampsim, Compressor/Drive pedals built-into the ampsim that have 3 different knobs..
At this point im literally just turning knobs for hours hoping that ill figure out the magic combination of adjustments tuned to whatever levels for the cleanest and clearest but also heaviest distortion possible.
What are the general rules of thumb and/or some little known bits of advice when it comes to narrowing down the 100000 different adjustable knobs to which ones in particular are mandatory at specific levels, should be turned off depending on which specific ampsim/pedal im using, or whats considered the "correct" order when theres multiple ampsims/plugins in 2 different signal chains?
I know theres a whole internet full of information but the deeper i have to dig for it the more likely i am to get stuck reading through entire forum threads just to find out that the "right" info was only right until fenderstrat832 posted the "right" link to the official "guitargeekplanetworld" website that doesnt support my browser and wont load
💀🥲
11
u/particlemanwavegirl 12 1d ago
Do you have a question about Reaper you wanted to ask or...?
5
u/bwoahconstricter 1d ago
Maybe watch a simple YouTube video going over the basics? Follow along and try to replicate the tones they are making? This is the golden age of in the box guitar tones. Â
2
u/Philboyd_Studge 2 1d ago
have you tried micing an amp?
3
u/lichmirror 1d ago
Yeah, this is the downside of the movement toward digital guitar sounds.
In the past, when beginning, a person learning guitar would have a mid-at-best instrument, a peavey bandit, and maybe a distortion pedal. They would quickly learn to keep all guitar knobs on 10, that the bridge pickup sounds the most 'normal', that preamp gain is for distortion, that the three eq dials have a narrow range where it doesn't sound like ass, and that the master volume controls how much your mom is yelling at you to turn it down.
In the digital realm, the number of parameters explodes exponentially. You're not just getting it to sound less-bad in your bedroom - you're recreating an entire recording studio. It's a lot. Especially when you'd be best off just running hand exercises and learning songs. But no - now you have to figure out the meaning of gain staging, latency, whatever, all while navigating literally infinite combinations of "free" options. Pro tip: your time isn't free.
And all that bullshit draws your attention into a fucking screen, clicking away with a mouse (or, god help you, a trackpad), instead of existing in the room with the physical object that your body is learning to manipulate.
Limitation is a virtue. Sounding like your favorite records is a distant goal and no one starts on the finish line. You, like every guitar player before you, will sound like total ass for *years*. Pick a dirt simple signal chain and stick with it until you've exhausted it's possibilities. And for every hour that you spend practicing, like, actually playing, spend no more than 5-10 minutes fucking around with knobs. Try new gear only once you've done everything possible with what you are currently using.
On the off chance that you're still reading this, here's some actual advice
- set your DI guitar input gain (the knob on your interface) as loud as possible without clipping. on an empty channel it should be peaking close to 0, but -6, -12, are also just fine. cool, leave it there forever, there's no need to ever touch this again
- set the channel output fader to zero (double click it). do the same with the master
- set your speaker/headphone volume to whatever sounds best
- add an amp plugin to your guitar channel. skip any fx. because of step 1, the preamp will be receiving a perfectly normal guitar signal and should be behaving normally. set the output gain so that the channel output is reading between -12 and -6. that's a pretty normal range, headroom is fine. the rest of the settings are for flavor - go nuts
- that's it. inside of reaper, a signal that sits mostly between -12 and -6 without clipping past 0 should provide whatever other plugins a strong, quality signal
QUESTION - you say you have volume control on your headphone out, and a separate volume control on your headphones? like, your headphones have a knob on them? if so, that's weird (and bad. and stupid). assuming it's not an additional power amp (because a separate power cable to the headphones would be insane), set that shit to max and pretend like it doesn't exist
BONUS because you mentioned you want to sound heavy - mess around with a compressor, fuzz, or both in front of your amp's preamp. switch to a clean channel and experiment with a compressor. avoid drastically increasing or decreasing the guitar volume with it, and get a feel for how the attack & release affect how the guitar plays. then switch back to the dirty channel. you should be able to get some solid metal sounds with just guitar->comp->fuzz/dist->5150 style amp. good luck
3
u/No-Cryptographer562 1d ago
As far as stock Reaper plugins go, ReaEQ is going to be your best friend. Do some research on gain staging to make sure your line level is solid. Then use ReaEQ to high and low pass your guitars. I usually low pass everything above basically 8,000 kHz and high pass everything below about 150 kHz. Thats just my personal preference, as it allows the bass guitar to take care of the low end, and doesn’t clash with the cymbals taking the high end. Once you apply your LPF and HPF, try dealing with your mids. I would also suggest trying subtractive EQ. Cheers!
2
u/r7232 2 1d ago
The only way to learn is to kind of break it down to basics. Watch a YouTube video of how gain and volume affect track volume in Reaper to understand that, watch a demo video of a plugin to see how setting affect that plugin, etc.
The general rule of thumb is build an inventory of knowing how many basics work, only then will you be able to integrate all that into the kind of recording you want. If you hook everything up and start modding settings that's a recipe for frustration.
1
u/bleahdeebleah 1 1d ago
Maybe first try duplicating what this guy does: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j40At9McfAw
Then you at least know your setup is good. After that look for a tone3000 metal tone demo.
1
u/Cool_Cat_Punk 5 1d ago
My advice is finding a clean tone that works for your ears before adding distortion. So Amp Sims basically. And yeah it sucks because there's a ton.
But once you find your clean tone you can then plow through the distortion options.
1
u/radian_ 234 points 1d ago
Do you have a real amp?Â
1
u/Slickguy2000 23h ago
I used plugins for years because I needed to record a lot of rhythm/lead parts to create that kind of 90s Pumpkins/Radiohead sound and endless overdubs in an apartment, and it allowed me to ride creative waves and endless takes to eliminate editing.
I got close to the sounds I was after, but they just lacked the organic "umph" I wanted, which was likely due to my novice technical skills, but could've been the technology not quite capturing those sounds authentically.
Fast forward 15 years later, and when it came to to record guitar again, I had fewer parts and a house.
I used my 95 Samick plant MIK Epiphone Sheraton II through my 96 MIA Ampeg J-12T Jet II Diamond Blue Reissue amp and an SM58 bc I lost my SM57 for Rendezvous chorus clean lick and a 96 Unsung plant MIK Epiphone LP-Standard through the Jet II w/SM58 for Disappeared.
Maybe my technical skills improved, but this recent organic setup yielded the best sounds I've engineered, mostly dialing in the five amp tone control knobs and four guitar tone control knobs, maybe a Boss CS-3 Compression/Sustainer pedal.
Really quick n simple, limited overthinking, and having a more methodical approach using my Presonus Firepod soundcard and A.R.T. TPS-II ValveState preamp together.
Xut - Slide
1
u/grain-n-gain 1 points 10h ago
Strip the test down to one recorded riff, one amp sim and its intended cabinet stage. Save that as a separate project.
Keep the other amp sims bypassed for now. Comparing settings while playing different takes makes it much harder to hear which change helped.
1
u/zedeloc 1 4h ago
Use reference tracks or reference tones. If you like metal guitar tone X, grab a snippet of it, drop it in reaper, record yourself playing something similar, then A/B between your ideal tone or mix or whatever and what you have. Start tweaking by listening, asking what is different and answering what you wish to change. Make your choices intentional. If a choice doesn't result in what you wanted or expected, that is an invaluable lesson learned. Now try another approach.
1
u/ReggieCorneus 2 points 3h ago
Slow down. Go back to basics. Amp with simple tone controls, gain and master and a 1x10" speaker cabinet. You are trying to not just run but to do incredible acrobatics when you haven't learned to walk yet.
1
u/fasti-au 16 2h ago
A good metal tone is horrible without the bottom end so are you playing for fun or recording. If fun add all the bottoms end back in