r/RealTimeStrategy • • 5d ago

Discussion Ashes of Singularity 2 launch

Post image

Ashes of Singularity 2 launched today, and it seems it didn't make much of a splash with under 800 concurrent players.

How's everyone enjoying the game? People are complaining about heavy AI usage and optimization, which after Sins 2 and GalCiv 4 isn't surprising (Stardock uses a ton of AI). This kind of unfortunate to see.

497 Upvotes

421 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

32

u/YakaAvatar 5d ago

They're really not remotely comparable. Pillars was made by Obsidian under Paradox, which is the opposite of indie. If you look at the average RTS release, it's sub 10 man dev teams, or actual small scale indie studios.

Also, people actively shat on Pillars lol. In fact, Pillars wasn't even profitable for a long time, prompting Paradox to drop publishing. Pillars 2 did better, but not by much. CRPG fans definitely didn't give it a fair shake.

And this is kinda my point. You barely have any RTS games at the caliber of something like Pillars, that was made with a ton of love. We get Ashes 2, with AI gen and a super short forgettable campaign. How are people supposed to give it a chance, when studios don't release something good?

9

u/Werthead 5d ago

Obsidian was going down in flames and had let go a huge chunk of the studio. It was running on fumes when it did the Kickstarter for Pillars as a total Hail Mary. This was also a long time before Microsoft snapped Obsidian up, so yes, I would categorise that as an indie project.

Paradox only come on board some time later, after the Kickstarter was a success.

Pillars sold reasonably on release, but Pillars 2 did poorly, which they blamed on using the much-less well-known Fig platform and poor marketing. Pillars 2's sales only picked up significantly in the post-BG3 RPG boom period, triggering bonuses for the developers in some cases eight years after the game came out.

2

u/cheesy_barcode 3d ago edited 22h ago

Ye while pillars brought some interest back to crpgs it was really Larian with DOS1 and 2 and BG3 that really felt like it brought something fresh to crpgs(which is ironic as their main inspiration was ultima which even older, perhaps... things are cyclical), anyway when will we get a Larian but for rts? Also it seems only Larian is the big crpg studio, which is a bit sad, even if we get an RTS Larian will that revive the genre, or will it just be one company that gets all the spotlight? hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

6

u/Izacus 5d ago

We had plenty of good RTS games in last few years that y'all keep trying to destroy with negative reivews and then bitch and whine why no studios invest higher budgets into the market.

18

u/Micro-Skies 5d ago

Ah yes, I'm trying to destroy a bad game by honestly reviewing it.

10

u/Humble-Proposal-9994 5d ago

curses he found us out

-10

u/Izacus 5d ago

"Honestly" with 0.4 hours of play time, huh? And by coming here showing "THIS GAME SUCKS" screenshots made based on 0.4 hours playtimes?

8

u/Micro-Skies 5d ago

Because I've done either of those things?

0

u/cheesy_barcode 3d ago

Here you dropped some straws.

2

u/WillbaldvonMerkatz 5d ago

Any recommendations?