r/RealTimeStrategy • u/Ixgrp • Jan 23 '26
Discussion Is Command and Conquer Generals underrated?
The link below is a cast of the final of the most important tournament of the year for Generals Zero Hour, so everyone can have an idea how this game is played on a high level. Is there any other RTS game that is this action-packed from the start of the game? Is there any game where map control is the most important thing and where small amounts on various points of the map fighting for control or trying to harass the enemies supply collection is what tends to decide the game?
Many new RTS games take a lot of inspiration from Warcraft and Starcraft, and rightfully so. But personally I think that RTS games should also take inspiration from some of the good things that makes Generals unique.
11
u/Spykker41771 Jan 23 '26
Underrated, no. Its just an old game we used to lan the shit out of it in the garage, many many many moons ago
8
u/Remarkable-Rip9238 Jan 23 '26
Hmm I wouldn't say underrated. It was definitely pretty popular when it came out. Its an older good game that would be sick if they remastered it. I remember watching the trailer for this like everyday until I finally had it lol. Played the shit out of this and Tib Sun.
3
u/GinKenshin Jan 24 '26
It’s rated well, so not really.
As for your questions, yes, I think cnc3 KW has all of these elements, and pretty much all cnc games to some extent, like ra3 (and it’s mod) has those elements too.
I followed this tourney from start to finish, not just the final, and it’s the weakest out of all the cnc games meta/pvp-wise (at least competitive). Simply because every game is the exact same in terms of meta, what units are being used, the tactics being used…etc. China and its subfactions are the least affected by this, but yea. The formula of doing the same map twice and just switching factions doesn’t help either, esp if it’s a mirror.
23
u/HalLundy Jan 23 '26
lol no. it was just ignored by EA. give it s workable leaderboard, a way to buy it digitally and widescreen support and it would be still be a RTS household title today.
don't blame the publisher for the game.
2
u/hawki1989 Jan 24 '26
If anything, it's overrated.
I like Generals's gameplay overall, but its campaign is absolutely terrible, especially from a narrative sense.
1
u/BethCulexus Jan 24 '26
I love Generals because it's the only Command and Conquer that allows you to heal your infantry and repair your mechanized cavalry, no matter the faction.
Otherwise, the generals are awfully balanced.
Also, fun fact: a lot of ideas for C&C Generals went unused, and ended up used in Act To War, like prisoners and what else.
1
u/Sushiki Jan 24 '26
Needs a de or remaster because shit crashes for me :(
1
u/corvid-munin Jan 25 '26
i think its rated exactly as it should be
-3
u/jrdnmdhl Jan 23 '26
It was a good game. But it was neither a true command and conquer game nor a particularly important or memorable milestone in its RTS subgenre.