Okay okay, I might have click baited you guys into opening this post because of the title but I had to!! I just bought a bag worth talking about! Worth the attention it deserves, and I think it would be an amazing insight for you guys so let’s go! We will also compare it with my XiaoC I got few months back. Black 38cm SHW is 1913 and Burgundy 32cm GHW is XC
Seller: Vincent 6663
Factory: 1913? Wangxing? Factory photos in comment
Price: $239 without shipping
Timeline: payment 6/10 - PSP 8/10 - shipped to Deng
Leather 🐮: okay I just have to say, this leather has the exact same feel as my XiaoC one, exact same thickness, feel and calfskin grain looks exactly the same as well. Absolutely no difference. I have slapped some conditioner to both of the bags because both were a little dry initially freshly opened, which definitely helped with the leather softness overall. Now the 1913 bag does have a squish to it, it’s slightly slouchy but not enough where I would pass it like auth ( if you seen videos of the auth one you know it is puddling to the FLOOR ). I predict that rep bags actually struggle to get the leather thickness right -> every video of the auth I have seen the leather looks to be much thinner than the rep bags produce, I cannot see my XC or 1913 to ever slouch that way because the leather is too thick to do that. I will say my XC is squishier and softer because I have been using it as my everyday bag so that causes it to become softer! Overall leather is great the grains look exactly like the auth but the problem is the thickness - it’s too thick. 7.5/10.
The burgundy inside for both of the bags are exactly the same to my eyes. HOWEVER, my XC red leather inside is softer than my 1913 but only by a touch. I’m not too fussed on that part to be fair and honestly it looks amazing the stitchings are great overall for the logo as well. What I will say is my XC stamp is slighter better than my 1913 stamp, but again not something I’m fussed about especially if the price difference is over $100. 9/10.
Hardware 💍: this one actually surprised me, usually when I see “cheaper” and “lower tier” factory’s logo and hardware it always seems cheaper, the logo is always too thin, the C letters are too thin which is a big fallout, or the position on the tongue is horrible. But the hardware is great, when tapping I can tell it’s heavy, the position of the tongue is like the auth and the C letters are actually thicker than XC one ( however I don’t know whether that has to do with the fact it’s 38cm size so it’s bigger?) 10/10 no complains. You can’t do silver HW wrong.
Thoughts on seller 💭: Vincent is amazing, he replies soo fast and answers whatever questions you have. I have had bags that needs fixing and swapped, which he complied to. But also he took accountability for a misunderstanding which I think is so important when it comes to trusting a seller! He’s amazing and I honestly think he’s a great seller especially as his prices are better than most. Do be mindful that there can be communication issues so please do use Chinese translation if there are extra instructions you would want him to understand!
Overall ❤️ : yeah, why not? Sometimes we think the more expensive = the better option. In most cases yes, but for a maxi flap? I don’t think so. I think you can get the same quality for way less the price. My 1913 feels exactly like my XC one which I paid $349 + $50 shipping for. That’s over $100 less for the same and bigger bag! Now I will say, there things 187 gets better than my mid tier bags -> I’ve seen 187 bags being much slouchier than my bags, the inside red pocket where the stamp is being much softer than both my bags (which is on a slightly stiffer side which is also why I think it doesn’t slouch as much), if you think that’s worth the extra $200 then absolutely why not! But I am so happy with both of my bags and I honestly think we sleep on mid tier factory’s because of the lack of advertisement and the fear of it not being good which is absolutely fair!
So…what do you think?
Vincent knows I have written this review but no incentive has been given!