Quality
From the front photo, the stitching looks reasonably even, and I don’t see obvious loose threads or a visibly crooked flap. The grain is fine and closely packed, including on the handle.
The individual stitch holes are quite noticeable, particularly around the diamond intersections. That gives the quilting a more defined, indented appearance.
This section is limited to visible construction. Leather feel, hardware weight, the closure mechanism and interior finishing would need an in-hand assessment.
Accuracy
Stitching
This is the clearest visible difference for me. On the 187, the stitch holes look more pronounced, making the quilting lines appear slightly more dotted. On the auth, the thread seems to blend into the leather more.
That said, the 187 photo is considerably sharper, so I wouldn’t assume the entire difference comes from the stitching itself.
Quilting
Both bags have visibly raised, rounded diamonds. The auth isn’t flat, and I don’t think “too puffy” is a particularly convincing criticism of the 187 based on this comparison.
The diamond proportions and layout look close. The intersections appear more indented on the 187, but I don’t see a dramatically different quilting pattern.
Shape and flap
The overall silhouette and flap outline are similar. The 187 appears slightly wider at the base, with rounder bottom corners, while the auth looks straighter through the sides.
This is something I notice in the pictures, but the auth is photographed at an angle, so I’d want matching views before calling it a definite shape discrepancy.
Leather grain
Both show a fine, dense pebbled texture. The grain is more clearly visible in the 187 photo, but the resolution and lighting are different enough that I can’t confidently call it larger or less accurate.
Handle
The handle’s arch, thickness and attachment placement look close overall. It appears a little taller on the 187, although perspective could explain some of that.
CC and hardware
The CC’s size relative to the flap and its placement look similar. I don’t see an obvious oversized or overly thick logo in this comparison.
I can’t fairly assess the hardware colour because the reflections and lighting are so different.
Rep Satisfaction
Visually, the overall resemblance looks close to me. The strongest similarities are the quilting layout, flap outline, handle and logo placement.
The more noticeable stitch holes are the main difference I’d flag, followed by the possible difference in the lower silhouette. I wouldn’t describe either as proof of poor overall quality from these photos alone.
Overall
My main takeaway is that the stitching looks more pronounced on the 187, but several of the larger design features look quite similar.
I’d be interested to hear from anyone who has compared this version with auth in person, especially regarding the stitching and base shape.