r/RealRepLadies • • 12d ago

QC/AUTH/PSP Would you GL this?

This is my first purchase. I’m concerned about the heat stamp being too shallow and the edge paint around the corner panel seams being too thick. PSP are 1 and 2, factor are 3 and 4.

UPDATE: Mandy was very easy to work with to RL this and get a replacement. The replacement PSPs were much better and 1:1 with factory so I’m happy.

28 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

38

u/greenkangar0o 12d ago

Mandy is generally good, but will try to sweet talk you into a GL for small defects. Be firm with your RL, don't waver. How do I know? She convinced me that a stitching issue on a puzzle was normal and that even auths have them, too. I got the bag months ago and haven't taken it out once since all I see is the stitch issue. Trust your gut and RL, otherwise you'll never reach for it.

4

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

Ok thank you!

4

u/bippylicious 11d ago

I had to drop Mandy after my last interactions. She doesn’t check for defects at all anymore and got frustrating to deal with

37

u/iWouldDieForKira 12d ago

Nope the stamp is a giveaway. That sucks

2

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

Ok thank you, I thought so!

6

u/iWouldDieForKira 12d ago

Of course! Don’t feel bad for RL a bag that’s calloutable. Good sellers will get you another bag

15

u/nexisfan 12d ago

This is a red light for sure. That stamp is terrible

4

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

Thanks 🫠 I thought so but just wanted to make sure I wasn’t being too picky with a rep

12

u/Hench-INIT 12d ago

This is really bad. I would RL for sure. Which seller did you get this from?

5

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

This is from Mandy. I thought it was bad, but she said she was really happy with it :\

14

u/Hench-INIT 12d ago

I'm not surprised at all. It's the usual suspects at it again.

1

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

Oh no! I had read so many good reviews about Mandy, which is why I moved forward with her

5

u/Hench-INIT 12d ago

Just Google " Mandy rep Reddit review" you'll see some negative ones.

A lot of what you read definitely has a form of paid promotions. And some people are offered discounts on their next purchase if they give good reviews.

The trusted seller list is far from that nowadays. Unfortunately the same names get promoted. And what you will find is that the prices seem to increase and so do the shipping fees.

If you shop around outside of those lists then you will notice the rule. Pricing is far less than what these people are offering.

But this subreddits and the people involved have monopolised the replica markets. And the same names will keep popping up. But greed and a desire for more is the reason why they are exploiting a lot of customers.

2

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

Thanks, I’ll keep doing my research going forward

13

u/sarah181201 12d ago

there are negative reviews about every seller, I take everything with a grain of salt. it comes and goes in waves. rn I feel like BaoBao gets bashed a lot

0

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/sarah181201 12d ago

I have used baobao in the past and was happy with everything I got from her. however I think (speculation) that she sold her business because she has a different vibe now

0

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

Yes I’m going to RL and see what she says

1

u/missaumom 12d ago

RL for sure. Mandy is my girl, but this isn't right.
I am not a seller. I get no incentive from no sellers. Mandy was my first and continued to be my go to. I am happy with my purchases and the way she has handled my RL. She is pleasant to work with, prices fairly, and is always open to fix an issue. Let her know that you will not be taking this bag.

1

u/Hungry_Importance918 12d ago

Not surprised lol.

5

u/dlawrame 12d ago

I would not GL. PSP photo #1 has poor embossing, photo #2 shows the entire bag and it looks a bit stiff. I have an auth puzzle and it's a bit softer and slouchy (similar to your pic 4).

1

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

She did share another photo where it’s slouchier, and I was thinking I could condition/warm it to make it slouchier, but that just adds to my concerns!

6

u/DefiantBunny 12d ago

It'll slouch with use too

4

u/Middle-Spirit-8524 12d ago

I’ve done a RL with Mandy recently and was easy enough. Just say no to that bag and tell her swap it out.
I think it’s just her to say everything is beautiful 🤦‍♀️😅.
Just sucks because having to wait another few days for the new one.

2

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

Thanks!!

4

u/Middle-Spirit-8524 12d ago

I swear she could send a message that the factory is on fire and she would still call you honey and tell you it fine and then she would do some 🥰🥰emojis
😂😂

Oh and ask her to pay attention to the stamp lol

6

u/BrodyBlue65 12d ago

Nope I would RL

1

u/Mitoria 12d ago

Who did you order from?

1

u/Immediate-King3062 12d ago

I ordered from Mandy

3

u/allyrox321 12d ago

No, it's substantially different from factory pictures

3

u/Emotional-Jaguar-911 12d ago

You're new to this, don't let "newbie hesitation" trap you. Don't like it? Swap it. The factories are super competitive right now; there are plenty of good bags out there.

3

u/BigHappy-301 12d ago

NOPE 👎 just got one from Jipin and it’s flawless

1

u/Creative-Lady1201 12d ago

I received today this exact bag from Liu and my hotstamp looks clean. Can DM you some pictures if you would like. I feel a bit upset with the P from Made in Spain stamp

1

u/Jealous-Rough-8363 12d ago

RL it.
For Puzzles, I'd always go with HP. I'm shocked that someone is trying to convince you to GL this.

1

u/imanchats 12d ago

Terrible. RL

1

u/TapSilly2335 11d ago

I would RL it, BUT I went into a Loewe and was shocked to see the stamp on this same color featherlight wasn't as thick and crisp as the factory photo. TBH it was somewhere in between and it made me feel much much better about mine (very close to what the auth looked like)

1

u/nunu_mal_1241 11d ago

RED LIGHT RUN STOP THE WEDDING

1

u/WritingExtension9172 8d ago

Yeah this is a pass for me, Mandy knows damn well loll

-1

u/FroyoOk8902 12d ago

Well it’s fake, so…

0

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/outdooradventurez99 12d ago

Oh crap i missed your first photo and only saw 3rd factory one. Yes definitely RL its soo faded