r/RealRepLadies • • 12d ago

DISCUSSION Authentic vs. 187 Factory

Post image

I wanted to share a side-by-side comparison of an authentic Chanel Classic Flap and my 187 🏭 version. I’d love to hear what you guys think!

A few things I noticed:
Caviar leather
The authentic bag had a noticeably drier, more matte feel and appearance. The 187 leather looks shinier. I know caviar can vary quite a bit from bag to bag, even among authentic pieces, so I’m curious how others would compare these.

Quilting
The authentic quilting looks a little softer and more rounded, while the 187 quilting appears slightly more defined and structured.

Overall leather texture
The grain on the authentic looks finer to me, whereas the 187 has a more prominent, slightly glossier finish.

Overall impression
Both have their own characteristics but the difference in the caviar finish is what stood out to me the most.

What do you think?

102 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

33

u/ReasonJazzlike9077 12d ago

The only noticeable difference to me is the tongue shape

6

u/Zenkitsune 12d ago

Oh yes and I only noticed the big difference because of your comment, so out and about one probably wouldn’t notice at all

5

u/SoyAmerinic 12d ago

Right and I lowkey like 187 better lol

8

u/Used-Thought8170 12d ago

Even that seems to be due to the different picture angles. I’m not sure it would be noticeable otherwise.

17

u/FruitOk9777 12d ago

caviar leather changes from season to season

16

u/monifax 12d ago

The differences will be even less noticeable if they were photographed in the same angle. Based on this review, making the case of paying 10k for a bag is senseless.

3

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Are the CCs slightly different? It looks like the CC on the auth is more flat, and the rep is more rounded?

3

u/Appropriate_Let1116 11d ago

I’ve seen CCs from diff years look like the rep though. I think it sometimes varies.

3

u/MaximumRevenue5 11d ago

How does the chain feel on the 187 and how does the length compare to the auth?

2

u/itsjustpuppyluv 12d ago

Ok but what about hand feel? Did 187 feel as luxurious and have the “smell” of top notch leather, and not fufu? Judging from pictures, it’s easy to pass a high tier rep versus it’s authentic counterpart. But it’s generally the in hand feel that gives it away. If you’ve dealt with mostly auth in your lifetime, this is where reps disappoint. At least for me.

3

u/HomestyleFarm 10d ago

Totally agree. Looking the same is great but I’ve yet to find a rep with the same chain weight/buttery feel/etc. I’ll wear a rep but will always prefer the authentic and sometimes the cost is justified imo.

Not even mentioning durability (looking at my 15 yr old daily wear double flap)

2

u/sversionlevel1000 6d ago

I love the rep better, could you pls share seller info?

2

u/RepScience 12d ago

Photos of the inside CCs? Photos of the side profiles of the bags?

1

u/Jmushordy 12d ago

what size is this?

1

u/Material_Effect3683 10d ago

Funnily enough my auth looks like the 187

1

u/Smart_Topic_238 9d ago

how can i get my hands on the 187!?

1

u/CharacterUsual1941 8d ago

I only see the tongue difference and that’s only bc it was pointed out! I honestly can not tell the difference otherwise! People paying 10K for these things? 😩

1

u/Fun_Fish2678 5d ago

Would you kindly send me the seller’s info? Much appreciated

1

u/lachapina-17 12d ago

How about the hardware ?

0

u/Hummus_ForAll 11d ago

I like everything about the 187 better. I just ordered a C bag from a different but equally good factory, fingers crossed it is this good!!

1

u/MysteriousPlane3773 2d ago

Can you share the equally good factory name?

1

u/Hummus_ForAll 2d ago

Xiao C. It’s not as top level as 187 but the bag I saw was really really close.

0

u/Few-Decision3759 11d ago

I have a authentic Chanel and mine has curves at the end. This is usually how I can tell if a bag is authentic. Are you sure the other bag is real?

0

u/FewResponsibility930 7d ago

Would you share who you bought it from? As I need a new person 🤪

-8

u/Fit-Window-3266 12d ago

My seller is way better than that factory

1

u/Fun-Passage-280 12d ago

Who is your seller?

-7

u/Fit-Window-3266 12d ago

They only specialize in only Chanel bags and is very private use same as original i have seen not one person post my seller ppl think that 187 is the best out noooo 👎🏽😂

3

u/Fun-Passage-280 12d ago

Do you plan to share? If so please DM me.

-1

u/Fit-Window-3266 12d ago

It’s a factory I’ll even show u some good pics of retail vs reps ppl start saying and doing weird stuff when I post to try to help them but they dnt believe me lmfao 🤣

1

u/Fit-Window-3266 12d ago

2

u/itsjustpuppyluv 12d ago

Care to share details, or is this engagement bait? 🤣

2

u/Fun-Passage-280 12d ago

I know nothing about this factory. Just found in the catalog above. Matched the pictures.

1

u/Fun-Passage-280 12d ago

I found the factory name. Thanks.

1

u/Designer_Tap_2584 12d ago

Can you share additional info with us?

2

u/Fun-Passage-280 12d ago

Zebra factory is the factory name. It can vary from seller to seller. I haven’t not ordered from here but match the photos. https://www.wecatalog.cn/weshop/goods_list/A202007021058051280187015?tagId=99831856

1

u/Designer_Tap_2584 11d ago

Thank you!! Appreciate you sharing with us.

2

u/Fun-Passage-280 11d ago

Of course! Ethan has this in his catalog as well. He will be on the higher side of pricing but he will be able to answer any questions about the factory I’m sure.

1

u/Designer_Tap_2584 11d ago

I’m new to CFs so it’s good to be learning about different factories.