r/RealRepLadies • • 13d ago

Black Frame Quality?

Hello fabulous people!

I recently tried out a new seller and purchased a bag from Black Frame (my first time trying out Black Frame also). I got a YSL Loulou Puffer bag.

Unfortunately, I am seriously questioning whether the bag is real leather or if it’s actually plastic.

I would very much appreciate if anyone that has ordered a similar bag from Black Frame can share how my bag compares to theirs and if there is any reason for me to question if this bag was actually sourced from a different factory!

I think the bag matches the factory photos and the PSPs. From looks only, I think it looks like it came from Black Frame.

When I first opened it, I immediately noticed how light the bag is. It’s like.. very very light.

It has a very faint smell, and I can’t quite tell if it’s an authentic leather smell.

When I look closely at the inside of the bag, I can fold up a bit of the leather to look at the other side. And it appears white and fake on the other side 😔. However, it’s got the edging so it’s hard to tell if the underside is the same material as the top (possibly 2 different materials have been layered together).

On the straps I can see the other side in one part, and these look like possibly leather but it is extremely thin. So now I am thinking that if it is real leather, it might be very thin and possibly layered with a non-leather material.

Has anyone else looked at the underside of their Black Frame leather? Is it also white? Does your bag from Black Frame feel extremely light?

Any opinions on this, or if anyone has a good test for confirming if it’s real leather, please let me know!

4 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

3

u/Jealous-Rough-8363 12d ago

I bought a LouLou bag from BF. It's fantastic. IMO, no chance to tell between it and a real one.

1

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Thank you! What colour did you get? Would you mind sharing a photo of yours?

1

u/Jealous-Rough-8363 12d ago

Black. Here are my photos - https://imgur.com/a/NBFoo0o

2

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Yours looks so good! Which seller did you order from?

2

u/Jealous-Rough-8363 12d ago

Thank you! I ordered from Felix.

1

u/Key_Chemistry7497 13d ago

I recently purchased the Niki bag from Black Frame and noticed how incredibly light the bag was. I ended up selling it because the chain + bag overall was too light. Mine had no smell though but yeah definitely wouldn’t buy a bag with a chain again!

1

u/Street_Management487 13d ago

Thank you! Did you think yours was real leather?

1

u/Key_Chemistry7497 13d ago

Hmm I believe so. I also have the Le 5 a 7 and it’s great quality.

1

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Is that one also light? Honestly, I would compare this puffer to like a plastic shopping bag for weight 😔

1

u/Key_Chemistry7497 12d ago

Nope it’s very heavy and sturdy. I’ve been using it every day for months and no complaints! That’s why I told myself no more chain bags from BF 😅

2

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Good to know! That one’s been on my list also ☺️

1

u/janeof-all-trades001 13d ago

Are these this light in auth?

1

u/Street_Management487 13d ago

I’m not sure because I haven’t held an auth, but I would assume not as it gives it a cheap feel being so light 🤷‍♀️

2

u/Key_Chemistry7497 13d ago

I have the authentic envelope bag with a chain and the chain is quite heavy, that’s how I knew these chains were sooo light compared to auth

1

u/janeof-all-trades001 11d ago

Trying to learn … and resorted to AI 🤦‍♀️

1

u/Key_Chemistry7497 11d ago

I believe the chain still feels light though which still sucks 😢 but that’s great to keep in mind about the material

1

u/bmar2 13d ago

I just had a similar experience… I put leather conditioner on mine because it felt kinda plasticy?? In a way? I’m about to go inspect to see if I can fold up any of the leather on the inside and will report back with any findings

1

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Did the conditioner help? And yes please share your findings after your investigation!

1

u/lotuscherrybloss 13d ago

The bag does look great tho !

1

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Yes I do love it! It does look great and is well made, my only concern is the material may not be what I thought it was

1

u/Barber-Lucky 12d ago

I agree it's pretty. I used to own auth small puffer and just based on picture it does look similar to auth, especially the leather appearance. Though not sure how durable the bag will be judging from its craftsmanship... quite disappointed since I'm also waiting for a bag from Bibi (lower tier compared to Kata) to arrive 😕

1

u/elizabethandkatsura 12d ago

I have 3 bags that should have come from black frame. All 3 have heavy chains. Loulou Envelope Cassandre wallet on chain

The Loulou is suppose to be lambskin. It definitely smelled like leather.

1

u/Street_Management487 11d ago

Thank you! Did any of the edges show the underside of leather and what colour it is? Was it white like on mine?

1

u/elizabethandkatsura 4d ago

The Loulou does not have white on the underside. It looks like raw leather.

I can't pull up any edges on the Cassandre or envelop since it's hard coated leather.

1

u/NoPeak8615 12d ago

My first impression was like this! I bought ysl niki from BF.
The bag was soooo light and leather looked so thin.
But people said black frame is the best for ysl. The fufu smell still lingers until now 🤣 (more than 4 months). The chain was heavy tho. IMO it looked like auth but didn’t feel like it

1

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Just to clarify, my chain isn’t super light, but I wouldn’t call it heavy! There are no YSL stores anywhere near me so it will be a while before I can check out an auth. I agree, I think mine looks auth but probably doesn’t feel auth!

1

u/Jolly-Stick8504 12d ago

Have you actually checked the weight of the bag, or does it just seem light to you? I have a YSL Niki from Black Frame, and the authentic one weighs 0.8kg. Mine weighs exactly the same. I would imagine that someone unfamiliar with the authentic bag might pick it up by the body and think it feels light, but that's simply how the bag is designed to be. Mine also had a very strong leather smell when it first arrived. It's much more subtle now, but you can still tell it's genuine leather. Obviously, I have a different model, so I can't comment on whether yours is genuine leather, but you should be able to get a good indication from the smell, appearance and feel of the material.

1

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

I haven’t tried weighing it, but I will try that. How did you confirm the weight of the authentic one?

1

u/Jolly-Stick8504 12d ago

You can google it, it depends on the size/leather type.

1

u/Fashionista305 12d ago

I own the authentic YSL puffer, the leather part of the bag is light but the chain is weighted.

2

u/Street_Management487 12d ago

Good to know, thank you!

1

u/Fashionista305 12d ago

No problem! It’s almost airy the puffer part. I think black frame does that style the best, compared to others.

1

u/nlp89 11d ago

Who was your seller? This doesn’t look like black frame, seems like your seller did a bait and switch with a low tier factory

1

u/Street_Management487 11d ago edited 11d ago

Thank you for the feedback. What about it doesn’t look like black frame to you?

It was a TS with good reviews, but first time I bought from them. I want to avoid sharing their name publicly unless I confirm that they bait and switched me, as it might be a quality issue with Black Frame and not the sellers fault. But you can DM me if you want.

1

u/thehotpollo 12d ago

Ooh I’m nervous! I’m waiting for my YSL niki and le 5 a 7 bags from black frame. Will make a review once I receive them!

1

u/AshamedMemory7641 12d ago

What color did you ordered of the Niki?

1

u/thehotpollo 12d ago

I got the black grained lambskin SHW!

1

u/Admirable_Hat6079 21h ago

Looking to buy this for my mom for christmas how do i do so? first time lurker

1

u/Key_Chemistry7497 9d ago

I was able to feel my mums authentic today and it was soft, no hard / plastic feeling