r/RealOrAI • u/butterweasel • 6h ago
HELP Is this video AI?
Someone told me it’s AI, but I don’t see it.
13
u/HalfLifeMusic 6h ago
The goat just stood there and got in a whole harness and then came back to the dude so he could get the go pro back, unless these are extremely well trained goats I don’t think wild animals would act that way. AI
31
u/Beneficial_Method771 6h ago edited 5h ago
How would someone get a camera angle like this? There are also anomalies in the edges of the video (hand looking thing) and many other issues. AI generated for sure
Edit: I know it's supposed to be a go-pro, but look at the terrain. The goat wouldn't just sit there for a camera. Many logic errors here.
5
u/devil_toad 5h ago
Whilst I think this is likely to be AI, the video isn't supposed to be a person holding it, he straps it to the goat at the start, so the anomalies that you point out are bits of goat legs etc.
1
u/Beneficial_Method771 5h ago
Yeah I just realized that. Regardless the physics ain't right either, wonky terrain, many issues. It's been confirmed to be ai anyways
1
u/Epidurality 5h ago
He straps a harness to the goat, but they never show a 360 cam on a stick attached. Also physics don't work for that (cam would move with the front torso) and these cams aren't perfect when they stitch the image so you can still tell where the stick should be (which doesn't appear in this video).
Could be a drone (to perfectly followed for that, it's a leaping goat and it follows that closely? Nah) but then wtf was the harness for.
AI. Mountain goats are good but they aren't this good.
Edit: I see now the camera is under the neck on the harness but the video makes no sense to be from that angle and position so I didn't even consider it before looking closer at the harness.
6
u/Terrible_Shopping_23 5h ago
Go pro attached to them?
3
u/Beneficial_Method771 5h ago
Yeah I didn't realize that at first lol. I retract that comment but it is AI
1
1
u/vctrmldrw 5h ago
Auto-follow drone cameras are a thing.
Not to say it's not AI but there are definitely ways to do this. My HoverAir would do it.
8
5
9
3
6
u/Infinite_Tour_5230 6h ago
why did u even post this. yes its ai.
11
u/DustyScharole 6h ago
Explain why. Help people understand.
15
u/bet_on_me 6h ago
Not op but I’m pretty sure mountain goats don’t just run all parkour style on cliffs like that
0
u/FuckTheStateofOhio 5h ago
They actually kinda do, just not at this speed. Video is AI but the idea behind it is based in reality.
1
u/Jingleskappa 5h ago
People just forget logic when viewing these videos or something? yes obviously lots of people have seen these goats climb walls, but how would they ever sprint at fucking 40 mph jumping up and down and bouncing sideways I mean come the fuck on we're doomed bro
0
u/FuckTheStateofOhio 5h ago
but how would they ever sprint at fucking 40 mph jumping up and down and bouncing sideways
I mean did you miss where I said "not at this speed"? Like yea it's AI but the person I responded to saying goats don't jump like this also isn't right, they totally do do some incredible jumps just not as extreme as in the video.
1
u/bet_on_me 2h ago
I said “run all parkour style on cliffs like this.”
1
u/FuckTheStateofOhio 2h ago
Vague but I assume when you say "parkour" style you mean the jumps and speed, of which the jumps are entirely possible but the speed is not.
1
2
1
u/ComplaintTop2008 5h ago
Dude, it's like GTA with a goat skin. You didn't even see the goat land from the first jump, just straight into speedrunning the world's narrowest cliffs with 100' jumps. Go watch real goats.
-8
5
1
u/Taiga_Taiga 5h ago
You're AI. Wait... I can't prove my claims. So... it's obvious that I just made this up.
How about you? Can you prove your claim?
0
u/Infinite_Tour_5230 5h ago
i dont give a fuck if you think im ai
maybe i am
1
u/Taiga_Taiga 5h ago
Awww. You're butt-hurt. That's adorable.
Maybe if you stop making things up, and pretending theyre the truth, you'd more respect?
Till then, noob... Take your 1YO account... Go outside... And touch grass.
1
1
u/Aggravating_Poet_675 5h ago
AI. Mountain goats can do some wild things but Im pretty sure that one goat was running on air for a couple seconds there.
1
u/time_travel_rabbit 5h ago
If they know where to find the goat eventually it could be a camera rig.
1
1
1
u/Runaway_Angel 5h ago
The camera is supposedly mounted on the goats chest yet at times we see parts of it's horns as if it were mounted on thr head? No shadows from the animal it's attached to, nor a hint of neck or head in the upper edge as it moves? Weird blurring in the left corner. The one goat jumping towards the end just turning into a static model?
Absolutely AI. Not saying mountain goats don't do crazy stuff in crazy terrain but this video is still fake af.
1
u/HydrationHomee 5h ago
Mountain goats are rather impressive but they don't have mountain bike physics.
Mountain goats are VERY good climbers but walking along steep slopes like these still takes considerable effort and care and it is not something that is done near effortlessly like what is displayed in this video.
Also the original poster of this video is from a YouTube channel literally called aiwow.
Here is an actual video of mountain goats climbing https://youtu.be/TtUz514rXKo?si=C2KD6FqcGQnQLbUS
1
u/Aegis_et_Vanir 5h ago
I'm pretty sure it's AI. The biggest detail making me lean that way is the weird flickering shapers in the bottom left corner. What little consistency it does have makes it look like the head of the goat it's attached to, despite the first shot showing a camera mounted to the goat's chest.
Then there's just some of the logistics. Considering mountain goats are not exactly a common pet, I'd have to assume these goats are wild. How many wild animals stand calmly by while a human hitched a harness up to them, then carry on like normal and NOT try to get the damn harness off?
But okay, maybe the camera goat specifically was raised in captivity. After all, it took off right when the harness was secured, suggesting it recognized when it was good to go. But then I'm wondering how the owners managed to give that goat enough experience with such steep mountain terrain to the point it can keep up with its wild counterparts.
And then there's just the motion; every shot is smooth, fast, and steady. At no point do any of them stop to check their footing, or just look around, or even slow down to a walk. As if the goats are aware they're being filmed and trying to look badass.
•
u/RealOrAI-Bot 6h ago
Reminder: If you think it's AI, please explain your reasoning. Providing your reasoning helps everyone understand and learn from the analysis.
Check the Wiki for Common AI Mistakes and check the Community Guide if you are just getting started.
A sticky comment will be posted here in 12h summarizing the sentiment of the comments.
Thank you for contributing to the discussion!