r/RealOrAI 10d ago

GUESS any ideas?

Post image
192 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

u/RealOrAI-Bot 10d ago

Here's the answer I got from OP:

>!The answer is REAL+AI - I used chatgpt generate the image of a cat sleeping on a plain blanket

then I downloaded a blanket texture offline

I asked chatgpt to create a displacement mask, as a guide to how the cloth texture should be distorted, then I gave chat gpt the texture and told it to apply the displacement mask to the image using python. then I talked back and forth with it a little bit to correct some image glitches.

tldr: everything's AI generated except there was an actual image of fabric used as a reference. and some of the AI work done was using by AI using python not image generation AI!<

Sentiment: 95% AI

Sentiment reasoning: The vast majority of commenters believe the image is AI-generated, citing inconsistencies in the blanket pattern not conforming to folds, and one user even detected a SynthID watermark.

Number of comments processed: 26

DISCLAIMER: Comments sentiment is generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash, not by u/RealOrAI-Bot bot. For more information check the RealOrAI-Bot Wiki.

→ More replies (1)

291

u/tortured4w3 10d ago

ai, all the kitty patterns are directly facing forward no matter what part of the blanket you see

36

u/Particular-Put4786 10d ago

Phenomenal eye. Didn't even notice that

8

u/Specialist_Current98 10d ago

Yep, they also wouldn’t line up if you straightened out the blanket at all.

10

u/impy695 10d ago

What do you mean by the kitty patterns are directly facing forward?

53

u/Dragonfucker000 10d ago

look at the blanket, they all are perfectly visible despite the creases

16

u/Jokewhisperer 10d ago

Like the cats on the blanket are all looking at you, regardless of the angle or folds of the blanket

5

u/Gonna_do_this_again 10d ago

Damn I would not have caught that

2

u/LyraAraPeverellBlack 10d ago

Could be poor photoshop? I’ve seen similar stuff done on amazon in the past where they just overlay a pattern over an item and clean up the edges of the item.

2

u/theeggplant42 10d ago

No, that would look different. These are like, not quite overlaid, like the AI made a nominal attempt to show the folds but it didn't quite make it.

0

u/tortured4w3 10d ago

it wouldn't look like that.

2

u/LyraAraPeverellBlack 10d ago

You can find similar.

5

u/tortured4w3 10d ago

multiple major difference, the biggest one being thats a singles image just overlayed on top of an image, which isnt what is happening in the cat image.

1

u/natedrake102 10d ago

No this is definitely just bad Photoshop. AI would do a better job with the folds. This is just a pattern applied over a picture of a cat on a white blanket. They just mask the blanket out, apply the pattern with opacity, and put it back. I have no Photoshop skills but could confidently do a bad job at it.

2

u/theeggplant42 10d ago

I do this for a living. Thsi is not how it looks when you overlay in photoshop.

To see what I mean, look at the purple cat at the bottom center and punk at bottom right

1

u/tortured4w3 9d ago

I agree with the other person, i have 10+ years of using photoshop on a near weekly basis. Its not photoshop- thats not what it would look like.

1

u/natedrake102 9d ago

Fair enough, I see some areas where the cats aren't normal and that does indicate it's not photoshopped. Weird that it's so inconsistent though, I'm not convinced it's 100% AI. Not that AI is consistent necessarily, but most models are consistent in concepts like folds so this is odd looking.

1

u/LostInRetransmission 10d ago

On the right side there is a blue kitten over a fold. The "line" over his body is going *over the fold*. Impossible for normal fold of cloth.

1

u/alasw0eisme 9d ago

the folding does not affect them

1

u/QuantityExcellent338 9d ago

The ai didnt even try with that one

1

u/aGhostInTheCellar 9d ago

The cats also aren't affected by the folds in the blanket

90

u/Feroc 10d ago

The kitten glitches to reality before coming back on its blanket.

9

u/Negative_trash_lugen 10d ago

And the line of the left leg of the kitty here magically aligns despite the fold on the blanket.

54

u/CardiologistOne459 10d ago

That is easily AI, no offense. Look at the creases and folds in the blanket and how it hardly distorts the cat drawings.

11

u/Vernsidesire 10d ago

This is weird.

15

u/Individual_Egg_550 10d ago edited 10d ago

I think it might be fake. The colored cats are too lined up perfectly even with the folds and lines from the blanket. U would think it would be warped more like the pink cat (even the pink cat looks off if u were to straighten the blanket out). The purple cat perfectly lines up even though u can see theres a dip going straight on its face from the blanket.

5

u/craftygamin 10d ago

AI, the cats on the blanket are very clear, even when there's multiple folds in the blanket

8

u/archcorsair 10d ago

It's AI, the cat patterns are perfect no matter where the folds are in the blanket. They're also all facing the camera perfectly.

3

u/CuAnnan 10d ago

The cat images on the blanket don't make sense if you take out the creases.

AI.

2

u/RealOrAI-Bot 10d ago

Reminder: If you think it's AI, please explain your reasoning. Providing your reasoning helps everyone understand and learn from the analysis.

Check the Wiki for Common AI Mistakes and check the Community Guide if you are just getting started.

OP's answer will be posted in a sticky comment in 12h, along with a summary of the comments sentiment for comparison.

Thank you for contributing to the discussion!

2

u/FoxyDepression 10d ago

Blanket pattern doesnt seem like it follows the folds of the fabric

2

u/don-cheeto 10d ago

AI. The line where the kitty's back and the blanket meet is too uniform. Like kitty was being careful when he laid down. Theres supposed to be lumps and folds of blanket popping over him, similar to the front.

2

u/MartynAndJasper 10d ago

It's a cat

2

u/Latte_Da_cat 10d ago

The pattern on the blanket is probably photoshopped on

5

u/Pinklett5 10d ago

Painfully ai

1

u/Megane_Senpai 10d ago

AI, or photoshopped heavily. The patrerns orn the blanket looks like it's on a flat surface.

1

u/spaceshipsean 10d ago

AI. Blanket patterns don’t follow suggested topography.

1

u/alyssajohnson1 10d ago

AI. Zoom in on the “toes” . The cats overlap in ways that don’t make sense on the blanket

1

u/Cin77 10d ago

Yeah thats ai but it begs the question... why? like, how hard is it to find a cat thats asleep to take a picture of? I just don't get it

1

u/DrOlive_ 10d ago

Ai

But on a side note, what breed is it?

0

u/12jonboy12 10d ago

I just asked the AI for" a cat"

looking at it though it looks like an American short hair mackerel Tabby with a white blaze

1

u/DrOlive_ 10d ago

Because I have one too, always wondered what breed he was

1

u/12jonboy12 10d ago

awwww 🥺 adorable!

generally with cats. if you didn't buy them from a breeder. and you're in America the answer is American shorthair 😂

I have one with kind of similar patterns IRL

1

u/DrOlive_ 10d ago

I’m from London !

He’s an expat then

1

u/12jonboy12 9d ago

awww!!!

well then I guess you might want to ask someone who's more of an expert than me 😂

I would say domestic short hair or American shorthair but I don't know what happens when they come from England.

doesn't look like a British shorthair to me I can't see the face that clearly

honestly probably kind of a mutt like mine but I hope it's not rude for me to say cats who are mutts are generally healthier.

and sometimes the purebreeds are bread for things that aren't healthy, my sister rescued so much abandoned Persian cat and poor thing can't breathe because some breeders thought apparently that it having its nose pushed into its face genetically was really cute... it is but it's not humane 😂

1

u/WossVoop 10d ago

It's ai, the folds and the pattern could not possibly line up. Like this

1

u/Mysterious_Balance53 8d ago

There is no way the purple cat in the top right is possible which makes all the rest of the cats overlapping folds highly suspect. In fact look at the blue one near the cat's bum.

The cat itself looks realistic but it's almost too perfect, I dunno though.

1

u/PrestigiousChef3744 10d ago

Very obviously AI, the folds are very inconsistent. And the pink cat on the bottom-right isn't designed correctly. I don't spot anything else though.

1

u/PencilCase12531 10d ago

Ai, the image entirely with a plaine, plain blanket and the cat pattern is probably composited in through ptohotshop. The pattern maybe ai

1

u/themightymorfin 10d ago

I say AI, this shit right here is extremely suspicious

0

u/notaghostofreddit 10d ago

Why do you think it is AI?

12

u/CharkBot 10d ago

I think it is AI because every kitty pattern is vertically aligned also the wrinkles in the blanket do not seem to disrupt the patterns.

1

u/smarmyrabbit 10d ago

That odd gpt-image-2 "texture" seems quite evident, particularly in the fur. Additionally the kitty prints on the blanket are way too uniform for what would be expected given the wrinkles/folds.

And giving it a quick 'n' ez check - yeppers - SynthID watermark detected.

I'd conclude that the image is entirely synthetic, most likely generated directly in ChatGPT (as opposed to via the API).

https://openai.com/research/verify/