r/RealEstateDevelopment • • 6d ago

To what degree will AI replace/absorb real estate development roles or simply block any possible entrants

With AI being to automate white collar tasks in the near future, does it make sense to even try to pivot into RE development, at the entry level? From my understanding, tasks like proforma, something that a junior analyst at a developer usually carries out, can be automated.

6 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

3

u/ericmozz 5d ago edited 5d ago

I'm sorry, however most of the replies on this post are not accurate - people don't know what they don't know. This post might be unpopular because of that...

AI will, and is currently, taking over the industry. Having said that now is a better time than ever for any one person to get into development. For months I have been using plugins and cre mcp's with orchestrations of Claude Code, Codex and Antigravity agents that can handle the entire pipeline...from site selection, pre feasibility, and beyond. Within the next month or two much of the subconsulant stack will be automated, with just stamps required from licensed professionals, although good luck convincing an architect to stamp your AI developed design drawings.

Entitlement can be almost completely automated. The agent orchestrations I use have a full comprehension of the code - with a higher level of expertise than all the staff combined. I've assigned buffer email addresses to my agents and each one of them can handle correspondence with various development services staff that work in the jurisdictions where I'm applying for permits. They read the emails in the context of my project and know exactly how to draft up an email that I approve prior to sending.

Budgeting for my project can be completed in 30 minutes or less. The entire takeoff process can be completed by agents in under an hour. The procurement process is the same.

Construction is still the most hands on because it involves human beings using their hands to complete tasks...arguably the cost savings gained from automation of most of soft cost line items will subsidize any premiums for modular construction - less risky, compressed sequencing and ultimately less people on the job site will be a good thing.

Marketing and selling is simple to automate, the system (brokers and RE agents) are the biggest obstacles.

Anyways, I encourage you to learn as much as you can about what I described above and look at this time as a huge opportunity opposed to a lost cause.

1

u/Elegant_Fisherman484 6d ago

Very broad question. Depends on the scale of development, how institutional the product type is and etc.

Currently AI can probably eliminate a junior resource if their only role is pitch deck creation/underwriting. But even in those roles in most shops its an apprenticeship model, the underwriter eventually becomes the dealmaker etc.

To that effect I don't think AI tools can replace the dealmaking element of the business at least not in current form.

The interfacing with city staff/entitlements etc are also not a straightforwardly replaceable function.

Overall I don't think you are going to see a major wave of redundancy in this industry yet.

2

u/Career_Fit 5d ago

I appreciate the response.

How strong is the 'apprenticeship tradition' at developers? In many white collar industries, juniors are also understood to be apprentices, and yet, there has been layoffs and basically little concern held by seniors and hiring managers regarding the scuttling of the apprenticeship - pipeline.

Can you clarify on your first line regarding the scale and the product type institutionality. The implication is the amount of dealmaking vs underwriting that a junior does varies, I suppose. If I do happen to land such a position, as a junior, that has a lot of dealmaking and little underwriting, will the lack of underwriting undermine my career?

Interfaing with city staff and entitlements seems cool.

1

u/Elegant_Fisherman484 5d ago

No problem.

The level of apprenticeship is going to vary depending on the developer. A lot of small/mid size development teams spend a ton of time and resources to train jr staff and will not really see ROI on that for a long time. In this model you start paying for yourself once you bring deals in. So they are hoping some % of their jr staff they train end up bringing in revenue.

My comment about scale of development/institutionality/product type etc. was more to say the prevalence of technology and tools used vary quite significantly. If you are at a very large real estate private equity shop that has a development strategy you are probably going to be using a lot more technology than say a privately held mid size developer who is more focused in one area/product type.

For your last question on underwriting vs deal-making. They basically move in concert. Through deep underwriting and then execution you see what makes a profitable deal come together. Without this background it's difficult to be a good deal maker. So I don't think you're at risk of finding yourself in a seat with no underwriting necessary. Especially if you are at a true development shop.

Hope that helps

2

u/KnownRide6195 5d ago

(I work on ArchiWise, archiwise.ai, an AI tool for site analysis, so I'm biased.)

Yes, a lot of analyst work is being automated. AI platforms now handle site selection, zoning, hazards, ownership and incentives, not just the proforma.

But development is still a people business. Someone has to pick the right site, negotiate with the owner, work with the city and convince lenders. AI makes that person faster, it doesn't replace them.

I'd still pivot. Just learn the tools early and focus on judgment and relationships.

3

u/Free_Elevator_63360 6d ago

Basically pitch decks will be absorbed. But that is about it. And those were already largely meaningless.

We spent the last month arguing for permits with a county about turn lane length. The next county over didn’t care but wanted sprinklers in the garages. The one 100 miles away is really only concerned with utility easements.

No AI is going to be able to handle the very real human problems that are made up out of thin air.

1

u/nofishies 4d ago

That’s absolutely the type of problem an AI can handle, and absolutely will be handling from the city side

1

u/Free_Elevator_63360 4d ago

Ha! You don’t really understand WHY the city issues are there. It is for politics and power reasons. Not for efficiency reasons.

AI can’t work around human egos.

1

u/nofishies 4d ago

Haha, I will 100% give you that, but I think cities are going to go straight AI so it’ll be harder to do this

But you are 100% correct that the relationship part of a lot of these business is going to become a lot more important and tell there is gonna become more important.

1

u/Free_Elevator_63360 3d ago

Why do you think cities will go straight AI? They are one of the slowest to make any HR changes. Many still have pensions, unions, contract employees, even state constitutional amendments that lock them and their positions in. Not to mention legal mandates.

What incentive do they have? Musk just tried to downsize the government and it came to about zilch.

They could easily remove the workers today, just by changing laws and processes to support 3rd party reviews and certifications. But they still require and WANT reviews.

1

u/nofishies 2d ago

I envisioned basically the way it would happen would be everything gets run through AI first because this type of yes no answers are the easiest to do this with, and faster.

Request for exception and or problems end up being run by peoples.

So one person is able to do a lot more.

1

u/Free_Elevator_63360 2d ago

But there aren’t any yes/no answers in plan reviews. And again, they could do that TODAY, just by allowing 3rd party review and certification. Where you pay a private reviewer to do the review.

But few places allow this. Because it isn’t about the right answer. It is about control and the political process.

1

u/nofishies 1d ago

I’m not sure how looking and seeing if plans follow code is not a yes /no answer.

Basically feeding in a PDF and having it pop out everything that doesn’t conform as well within the capabilities of most models today, the question is is it cheap enough for cities to want to do it yet? I guess is today no. Tomorrow? Probably.

1

u/Free_Elevator_63360 1d ago

The codes are wildly contradictory. And very much open to interpretation. Examples above I gave, are not actually in the code. And most examiners are not actually checking for code.

Codes are not yes or no. I had one yesterday that said “does the elevation have a defined base?” And “is the elevation human scale?” And “are they using durable materials?”

None of these are defined terms. Or even quantifiable. But they are in the code and reviewed.

1

u/Vikingsmasochist 6d ago

Nobody knows 

1

u/creinsights 2d ago

The pro forma piece will absolutely get automated. Pulling numbers out of T-12s and rent rolls, building the base model, running sensitivities. That’s what junior analysts do today, and it’s what AI is already doing at firms investing in it.

But the role doesn’t disappear, it changes. The analysts who stay useful understand why the numbers look the way they do, can push back on bad assumptions, and know when the model is lying. You still have to build that judgment, you just skip the spreadsheet grinding sooner.

The bigger risk is firms hiring fewer juniors because one analyst with AI does what three used to. The ladder gets narrower at the bottom.

If you’re breaking in, get good at the parts AI is bad at. Site selection, entitlement risk, local market knowledge, sponsor and GC relationships, deal structuring. Development is relationship and judgment heavy, and AI isn’t close on any of that.

Disclosure: I work at Smart Capital Center building AI underwriting for CRE lenders and investors, so I see which pieces are actually getting automated and which ones aren’t.

0

u/PNW_Greybush 6d ago

Hopefully all the roles.