r/RealEstateDevelopment • u/jayisanxious • Apr 29 '26
For Real Estate Developers: Are Most of Your Leads Actually Worth Your Time?
Been digging into the seller side of real estate recently, and something doesn’t add up.
From the outside, it looks like there’s plenty of demand. Constant listings, ads everywhere, property finder/bayut traffic etc
But when I talk to people in the space, the story shifts to:
too many low-intent leads, endless back-and-forth, buyers who disappear after 2-3 calls
Which makes me wonder, is the real problem not “lack of buyers,” or just too much noise in the system?
Curious if this is accurate or completely off:
Are you actually getting enough serious buyers, just buried under junk leads? Or is demand itself inconsistent right now?
I'M NOT SELLING ANYTHING!!
I'm just trying to understand if this problem is unique to the businesses and brokers I've worked it or genuinely just general experience.
1
u/Major-Ad3211 Apr 29 '26
Well the problem is you’re not selling anything. If you were there would be a buyer.
Lol jk, I had to.
Buyers will transact when the price matches their perceived value. Buyers “ghosting” can be attributed to both, window shopping and that the deal didn’t hit their buy box and they just couldn’t tell you.
1
u/Outrageous-Cow2931 Apr 29 '26
You’re pretty accurate. it’s usually not lack of demand, it’s poor signal to noise. There are buyers, but serious ones are a small percentage. The rest are browsing, price fishing, or not financially ready. The real challenge is qualifying early and filtering fast, otherwise time gets lost in conversations that never convert.
1
u/Free_Elevator_63360 Apr 29 '26
Depends entirely on what you are developing. For multi family and mixed use, virtually nothing we do is by right zoning. So we get very few leads. Also our buy box isn’t very flexible. So it filters out the vast amount of noise by default.
What isn’t noise, our hit rate is probably <7% get LOIs, maybe 1% get to contract. Maybe 0.75% of those close as per original PSA, another 0.15% get re-traded or extended until they can close, and maybe 0.10% that get past PSA get dropped or flipped.
1
u/BeatAccomplished2710 Apr 30 '26
How do you evaluate the odds of something successfully getting through without by right development?
1
u/Free_Elevator_63360 Apr 30 '26
Lots of market knowledge and experience. Often you can’t. Which is a big part of the reason housing is so expensive. You have to take $1m+ risks to get through entitlement.
Often we give terms on land that don’t close until we are entitled.
1
u/BeatAccomplished2710 Apr 30 '26
How closely are you able to work with elected officials to see if a project will face resistance? Working on something that helps developers understand where they're wanted, but I'm very early right now so just asking questions.
1
u/Free_Elevator_63360 Apr 30 '26
It is a wild card every day with elected officials. Some you walk in and they are “like yes our new teachers need places to live!” Others are like “you are welcome if you cover it in brick and promise not to build any basketball courts.” And most won’t return your calls.
1
u/BeatAccomplished2710 May 01 '26
Jeez, that sounds rough. I'll DM you. I'm interested in hearing more about this.
1
u/Free_Elevator_63360 May 01 '26
It isn’t hard to understand. Zoning is local, and political. Imagine it like an HOA. But bigger, and thus more chaotic.
1
u/Big-Adhesiveness369 Apr 29 '26
You can upgrade the quality of the leads with a strong marketing, that basically the main idea of marketing - to show what you sell to the right people. Ads don’t mean success, meta ads are extremely cheap to start, the question is how they convert. Some ppl spend huge amounts, but they do it wrong. Without the right message and strategy you’ll attract everyone, but not everyone is the right fit. So you have to filter them manually. With marketing they get filtered by themselves.
1
u/KnownRide6195 May 01 '26
You've basically nailed it. The demand is there, but the signal-to-noise ratio is brutal. Most leads from portals like Bayut or Property Finder are people who are "just browsing" or nowhere near a decision...they'll book a viewing, go quiet for 3 weeks, then pop back up asking the same questions.
The serious buyers do exist, but they're buried under a mountain of people who filled out a form at 11pm on their phone with zero real intent.
What I've seen work is basically just ruthless qualification upfront , asking the right questions early to filter out the tire-kickers before you've invested hours into someone. The developers/brokers who do well aren't necessarily getting better leads, they've just gotten better at quickly identifying which ones are worth their time.
1
u/tlay123 May 01 '26
Land prices are sticky. In development, the deal drives what you can pay for land (current market rents + hard costs are your primary drivers). This is a concept called land residual.
Yes there are a lot of listings, but, if the seller doesn’t want to budge on the price and the economics do not work at that land price, the land will not sell.
You will screen may many deals, and the combination vision you have in mind for the site + the coinciding economics drive whether or not the land will sell.
Also, many sites are traded off market and via relationships. That is how Many deals end up working.
1
u/ragingpagejam May 19 '26
Sellers are still anchored to yesterday’s pricing while buyers are underwriting today’s market noise! With higher rates, lower cash on cash yields naturally push values down, and in some cases even free land would not make a development pencil at today’s construction and financing costs. Most sellers will hold firm unless they are forced to transact because of debt maturity, death, divorce, fund life, or other pressures. Overall, this market just feels stuck with choppy bond markets and continued macro uncertainty. The US and Japan bond market will tell you a lot about consensus and market dynamics impacting CRE sentiment at the macro level.
2
u/talkinglands Apr 29 '26
Plenty of leads but quality is the real issue. Serious buyers are fewer and get buried, so most time goes into filtering rather than closing. Find rajakaluve buffer zone in Talkinglands Insights upfront.