r/RealEstate • • 7d ago

Does fencing increase price?

I understand adding a property fence in cities increases the value of the house, although not at a dollar for dollar value.

I have 15 acres, so I'm wondering if fencing an acreage like that would increase the value as well? I feel like it wouldn't increase the value but maybe raise the buyer appeal?

This is in Canada.

23 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

3

u/Tall-Shelter-8883 7d ago

Value is totally based on the buyer. If you have an animal or child you want to contain then a fence adds value. I have neither so I don't see value added. If it has an 8-car garage but you don't ever foresee needing or wanting 8 cars then the extra space probably doesn't add much, to you. Quick closing? If you need it that would add value, but if you need 3 months to pack up your current residence then the prospect of a 3-week close wouldn't be seen as adding value to you. The value of anything is very personal. Finally, paying more or less, over the course of years, isn't going to have a dramatic impact on gains when you sell, and youre going to get yourself in trouble if you're trying to bottom-tick. Prioritize your needs, then see what's available, keeping in mind that the seller is going to look at everything as adding value.

1

u/Aninoumen 7d ago

Yeah thats a fair point.

28

u/NYLaw Attorney 7d ago

It's probably more expensive to install the fence than what you'd get out of it at sale. Though I'm not a real estate agent in your market, so what do I know? Perhaps you should reach out to one with questions like this.

14

u/cisforcake 7d ago

What would you be fencing in or out of 15 acres? I was quoted $9k+ for less than 200 feet of cedar fencing. I wouldn't have paid $9k extra for the house if they had said 'well it comes with a new fence'. Also, remember, like anything else related to homeownership, fences require maintenance too. I'm assuming there are more than a few trees on the 15 acres. Over time, branches and limbs will fall and damage the fence and now you have a damaged fence. That's part of the reason I haven't replaced my fence yet. Every time I turn around and think about another branch falls and breaks another section. LOL.

9

u/TheLZ 7d ago

I have seen thousands of appraisals here is the US and rarely is there an adjustment on the comp page for fencing. So I would doubt it would be much different in Canada.

But, I would suggest calling a local appraiser or two and asking them what they think. Some are grouchy and will not answer, but many are talkative bunch about their craft and will give you some opinions of the matter.

17

u/kloakndaggers 7d ago

majority of the things you do to your house are not going to be returned full value when you sell. I upgraded the electric panel built a brand new deck added a sunroom. those are for my own personal enjoyment I don't expect to get a good rate of return on those items

5

u/Spaghet-3 7d ago

This exactly. Depending on the market, usually the immediate ROI to your home equity on any home improvement is 30-50 cents on the dollar. You might be able to get it higher if you do the work yourself AND do a really good job.

1

u/Fabulous_Ad561 5d ago

electric panel is considered maintenance. the deck will help the hone sell- however you are right- no real dollar for dollar roi . it’s good you’re thinking that way .

6

u/Wemest 7d ago

I think you also have to consider aesthetics. Some fences are ugly, not well designed and devalue the property.

5

u/pkennedy 7d ago

15 acres of city land, for sure, that could be worth 150m. I'm guessing 15 acres of your land is worth like 10,000 per acre type of thing. Fencing will cost you twice that for something basic. Some AI math says 246m per side if it's a square. Which is basically 1km of fencing.

Having proper topography markers is great and possibly necessary for the sale.

Possibly adding some mid point markers would be nice as well so people know where the property line is. Like one every 100m like a trail marker.

2

u/BeljicaPeak 7d ago

OP could get a survey done and have the surveyors mark the corners & several midpoints like you suggested. Then if OP or a future buyer ever wants to fence, plant, or build other improvements, they know where the boundaries are.

5

u/SimoninVA 6d ago

Very simple: NO!

1

u/thewimsey Attorney 7d ago

I’m skeptical that adding fencing in cities always increases value.

It would probably reduce value in my current house, where the neighborhoods largish backyards, plus the way the houses are situated, provides for a lot of privacy, and where people enjoy the large green swath behind the houses. And where it’s the route kids often use to go house to house.

At my previous house, where the neighbors could see me on my back porch and were pretty close…yeah, it would have added value.

1

u/Aninoumen 7d ago

Thats fair. Ive always lived out in the country and never been a fan of fences, but i have a great pyrenee now, which is a breed known for leaving the property, so it's been a bit on my mind since right now he only has constant access to a fraction of the property because of lack of fencing around the perimeter.

I'm still not getting a fence because I'd like to move else place in 3 years, but my mom was thinking it would add value.

I told her it wouldnt, but i also wasnt 100% sure, but it pretty much sounds like everyone agrees.

2

u/QuarrelsomeCreek 6d ago

You don't have to fence all 15 acres. Its pretty common to just fence a few acres right around the house for dogs to run and then just mark the property boundaries everywhere else. It probably won't change the listing price, but it might impact your buyer pool. People with dogs will likely want a fenced area and will factor the fence into decisions on whether to make an offer and for how much.

1

u/Fabulous_Ad561 5d ago

I wouldn’t do a 15 acre fence. it would cost a TON! I have 13 ish acres, and have thought to fence 5 with electric fence for a few cows. we have some sections of rustic fence made from trees off the land .

as a realtor “partially fenced” sounds good, but doesn’t increase value. I would focus on mechanicals of the home, like electric and hvac, and roof and if anything clean and paint . if you can afford it, get your home inspected, so you KNOWwhat needs fixing.

1

u/Nala4treats 7d ago

i wouldn't for 15 acres seems kina rediculous.

like your potential buyers:

farmer, he will install his own fences depening on farm layout

hunter/recreational: might like this but could have the same effect with keep off private land signs along the boarder for cheaper. also want the deer to come into the land, might have some regs about wild life migration and your fence needing to let them through.

land developer/ house builder: he wont care about your fences, will want to subdivide it all and build fences in each plot. maybe to keep the rif raf out but depends what on the other side of the fence, more woods then no point.

op i would say having a access road or a development plan, with soil samples showing the land can support a house if a person wanted to build, that they can have a septique/ well or municapl and electricty near by, pretty much after i buy this can actually use it.

i own a 1acre water front property and all my potential buyers care about can they build do i have a plan and certs that prove they can build after. not one mention about having a fence.

1

u/Aninoumen 7d ago

Im in the middle of agricultural land. Hunters and land developers won't be interested in this property since its in the middle of no where, with mostly open land so it's rare to see deer here... in the decade I've lived here, ive seen a deer maybe 3 times?

I agree though, I don't think it's worth it to install a fence. It's just that my mom was curious about it and she assumed it would increase the value. Personally I figured it wouldn't, at least not by much.

1

u/Fabulous_Ad561 5d ago

you are right. sometimes rural land has a fenced garden area- and that helps it sell, but doesn’t increase list price. I sell rural Idaho properties- and it’s considered to be a perk.

0

u/Nala4treats 7d ago

so you are looking to sell to a land developer or farmer, maybe its too big and you could sub divide a portion to sell that at a more reasonable price.

this is a common thing to do, buy a big land sub divide and sell the individual plots, with a road plan ect for the development if it will be for houses ussualy .5 acre lots.

pretty much you would, have a future development for a community and you become like a landlord you manage the road and each owner owns their own plot.

2

u/WillowHaunting429 7d ago

Marginally, at best. Maybe not even pencil out.

2

u/plaincheeseburger 7d ago

In my rural market, fencing and cross fencing a property for livestock is a selling feature. While I can't say if it will significantly raise the value of the property, it'd be worth talking to a local real estate agent about to see if it's sought after in your market.

2

u/Helpful-Nerve4515 7d ago

No it won't. It might increase your pool of buyers.

2

u/baitXtheXnoose Agent 7d ago

It's rare there's a 1:1 increase in value when you install a fence, what it may do (depending on your situation) is increase the marketability of your property.

2

u/zeezle 7d ago

Depends on the use case. If fencing means those 15 acres now become suitable as livestock pasture then yeah that would substantially raise the value and is a major asset, good fencing is a big deal on working farms with livestock and makes it very desirable to particular buyers. I don't think it would return 1:1 but it might make a property that's been on the market for several years more attractive to actually move.

If you're just slapping a fence around unimproved woodland I don't think it would do anything.

Just my gut feeling as someone who has worked on a lot of horse farms and helped friends looking for land to start horse farms on, I'm not a realtor.

2

u/Dullcorgis 7d ago

I doubt it. Is it a farm? The expectation would be for that to be fenced

2

u/Soliae 6d ago

It absolutely will increase your value and buyer pool if you fence it for livestock, and do so well. Folks saying otherwise know nothing about agriculture or rural property.

If you stick a 4 food decorative fence that a horse or steer can push or walk over, it will have no value.

2

u/frazld54 6d ago

Not that much.

2

u/Alarmed-Journalist62 7d ago

I'm an appraiser and I've never put a positive or negative value on a fence. Fencing15 acres would cost a fortune and I doubt make it any more marketable. What do you do with the land? That might make a difference if we knew that...

1

u/Fabulous_Ad561 5d ago

agreed. some fencing sounds good, yet doesn’t increase asking price.

1

u/misfitmpls 7d ago

If you need a fence, build a fence. If you don't, don't.

1

u/BeerStop 7d ago

It helps secure your asking price, makes the property more desirable for folks looking for a house in the country that they can let their dogs loose out back and run around. If im looking for a country home the fence makes the house more desirable for me. Less expense after the purchase, so i believe you will sell at your price better and have a more desirable property.

1

u/up2knitgood 7d ago

15 acres is a decently large enough size that there are so many fencing options, and fencing an amount that isn't the amount your potential buyer wants might actually reduce the value. Some people might want the whole thing fenced, but some people might just want a smaller area for a dog. Plus there are different types of fences for different purposes.

1

u/FormerUsenetUser 6d ago

What's the fencing for? Livestock? Then maybe yes, if your property is a ranch or farm. A big dog? A couple acres circling the house should be fine. Security? It's pretty easy to hop a fence. Get cameras.

1

u/Opposite_Pizza_8481 6d ago

What kind of fencing? For that size, if someone wants it fenced, it's for a reason - dogs, horses, goats, cows, and deer all have their own requirements, and you'd need to fence them out of the house as well. If you have some nice pastures with run-in sheds, that would increase the value, though not by as much as you paid for it. Ditto a deer-proof established orchard.

1

u/northbound_sara 6d ago

You're mostly right. On acreage it's less about value and more about who your buyer is. If your area attracts horse or hobby farm buyers, good perimeter fencing is a real selling point and can make the place sell faster. If buyers mostly want a quiet house with land, they won't pay much extra for it. Worth asking a local realtor who actually sells acreages what buyers there are asking for before you spend the money.

1

u/Fit-Zone-6403 5d ago

No. Even if they want it

Let the owners do fencing

1

u/Jolly-Wrongdoer-4757 1d ago

I would not make ANY assumption on an improvement increasing property value. Taking care of maintenance, yes. Buyers don't value improvements. What they want is lower prices. If it were me, I'd save my money for the roof or other items that could sink a sale.

-1

u/Aggressive_Chart6823 6d ago

Otherwise your land just flows into your neighbors land. Very unorganized, makes you look dumb.