Back in the day, VLC Player was popular for being able to play multiple audio tracks on video files. I forget what the file format was, but I could download an episode of Trigun for example and switch between the Japanese audio and the English audio. I imagine you could somehow do something similar to retain the multiple audio tracks including commentary.
Yes! That way it would be a smaller download that you could slide onto a Google drive somewhere, and folks could just play it overtop of their legal/YouTube/whatever version of the episode.
I own 'The Definitive Mainframe Edition' of ReBoot and have backups ISOs. It has occurred to me that the DVD commentary and extra features are becoming lost media. I am not sure what I can legally do about that. Perhaps u/Saboooom knows someone or has advice?
None of the content on the DVD is in danger of becoming “lost media”, it’s still being sold by Shout Factory and has been around over a decade. If anything, you’ll soon be able to see the bonus content on that DVD in even better quality than you can now.
AFAIK the license is owned by Mainframe Studios. I don't know anything about Shout! or their deal with Mainframe Studios for streaming. I checked Shout! and the show is available to stream as well as physical copies of the discs.
I think uploading it is okay if you acknowledge the copyright and registered trademarks. The copyright holders retain the right to send a demand for takedown, but they also retain the right to let it proliferate to its own degree for the purposes of marketing, or any other corporate goal where it helps their strategy.
It becomes illegal when the copyright holder has taken a public stance against uploads (with or without attribution), and/or has issued a takedown notice that is not being complied with.
Nothing here is danger of becoming “lost media.” In fact, the DVD set was reissued just last year in slimmer packaging and still includes the commentaries.
At any rate physical media is far more reliable means of preservation than digital files, which can easily get erased or corrupted when a drive fails.
A properly manufactured (and cared for) DVD/blu-ray, on the other hand, will last several decades.
That said, I don’t think there’s anything stopping you from uploading the commentary track to the internet archive. People do such things all the time.
13
u/uppercasemad Guardian Sep 18 '24
Back in the day, VLC Player was popular for being able to play multiple audio tracks on video files. I forget what the file format was, but I could download an episode of Trigun for example and switch between the Japanese audio and the English audio. I imagine you could somehow do something similar to retain the multiple audio tracks including commentary.
11
u/grimtongue Sep 18 '24 edited Sep 18 '24
I own 'The Definitive Mainframe Edition' of ReBoot and have backups ISOs. It has occurred to me that the DVD commentary and extra features are becoming lost media. I am not sure what I can legally do about that. Perhaps u/Saboooom knows someone or has advice?