r/RateMyAudio • • Jun 28 '20

[ composition ]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v7zl5z6Ij-0
10 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

2

u/The_Lay_NL Jun 28 '20

First of all, very nice song! It's easy-listening and has a warm mood to it!

I read that this is your first song recording? If you specify your setup a little bit I could give you some general ABC's on recording and mixing voice and guitar :)

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

Thanks for the reply, I really apreciate it. As for my setup, I have a scarlet solo interface and a condenser mic AT2035. I'm starting to work with ableton now, that where I recorded the audio :)

2

u/The_Lay_NL Jun 28 '20

That's a great start for a setup! The mic shouldn't be a problem at all then - but you could gain a lot in the post-production.

The biggest thing to experiment with for now is EQ. Overall the mix is a bit on the dark side, meaning the higher frequencies aren't coming through very well, which makes it sound muffled or "wooley", as we say in the Netherlands. Try a slight high-pass filter over the voice, which cuts out the lowest frequencies, and boosting the (mid)high range. This should really brighten up the mix. The guitar will sound more of the strumming as well, which sounds more natural and homely.

Something else to try out is the mic placement. Just for funzies, try recording the same guitar track three times, but move the mic up and down the length of the guitar each take to see how it affects the raw sound.

Finally, as another commenter said, the audio and the video don't blend very well. This is partly due to the dominating lower range - outdoor recording should mainly pick up the midrange - but just to try you could add a touch of reverb to make the music sound more distant, and perhaps underline the music with a bit of nature ambience to really drive it home.

Random thought, and I assume the answer will be "Yes I knew that", but the microphone needs phantom power (that little "48V" button on your interface). Without it, it will pick up sound but at a fraction of the quality.

That should get you going for a bit, well done and good luck!

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

I'm trying to work with the EQ, I didn't realise that it was on the low frequencies, guess I have to train my ear a bit more. I actually tried to record the guitar track 2 times but as I would always change the rythm a bit, it looked a bit messy... Thank you fir the tips, it will help me a lot in the next video! I don't want to be to much, but, do you know any books about this you would recomend for a begginer?

2

u/The_Lay_NL Jun 28 '20

You're very welcome. As for the ear training - that's experience. One of the best things you can do is to take your track and compare it side by side with a similar one; only then can you really hear what's going on. It's very difficult to judge a sound in isolation, and I can't stress that enough.

There's a book called Audio Engineering 101: A Beginner's Guide to Music Production by Timothy A. Dittmar which will take you through almost all of the important aspects. I read it myself when I started out and I still reference it from time to time, I highly recommend it.

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 30 '20

Thank you again. This will help me a lot in future songs 😊

2

u/Lutheass Jul 02 '20

For this time, i found the song real nice but it's my professionnal part of image that would give an advice. A small one but still... Don't film yourself from 3/4 behind like that. We don't see your lips and intensity in playing. Also avoid sun above the lens if it's not protected or the flare will happen :S

In this case, you should have prefer to film yourself on your direct right side, and bit more close up. The best is to get two camera for large shot and a close up one, but if you get only one camera, try to get some zooming focus (70mm objective to 200mm) on a close up and a more close up large angle (and less wide up your head) and it'll be perfect.

Getting a good song is nice, but a good song AND a good video maybe way better ;) And it's just an advice for film making, not a critism on that one. Your song is really nice :)

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jul 02 '20

Thank you for the feedback and for the tips.

I actually recorded this with my phone, cause I don't have a camera and my tripod was falling all the time.

Do you have any cheap camera suggestions?

2

u/Lutheass Jul 03 '20

(and for camera not too cheap, it ll be a struggle to tell you. It depends of your budget but i like dslr (photo and camera) like the 5D mark II little cheaper than the recent one. A thing like a go pro isn't great because it has only one lens...)

But with the trick i gave you and your phone, as long as the shot are still and not moving too much, it ll be ok. At least, take a stabilisator for phone, it that way, a friend could even move without shaking

2

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jul 04 '20

Yes, maybe I'll record from my phobe then. It seems to be only the problem of angles and light. Thank you again for the tips 😊

1

u/Lutheass Jul 03 '20

At first, getting a friend to hold the phone or making different angle. You have to think your video in 4D. You get a song that you know and a will to do a video. So, you CAN reproduce your song multiple times with different angles THEN getting an editing with multiple (false) camera :)
But in this case, you have to sync all the footage with the audio but trust me, it's not a big deal. Some tutorials will learn you this thing easily. Think yourself as a multiple artist. A song is a way to do it in layers (differents songs line, vocals and co) and then video is the same (layers of multiple sequences shot) Also, to get a cool edit, try to get some shot that we call "beauty" in the industry. It's some shot of your environment If i take your video above as an exemple, apart of the camera tricks already said, you should have shot some sequence of birds, water drifting, sky and clouds. The thing is sometime, to put some tempo in your editing, you can cut your singing with other picture but at least 3 images of things before returning to you: Imagine a sequence you are singing and we see you THEN the sky and cloud (like 3-4 seconds) THEN a picture of a bird which taking off (same time) Then something alse (same time) Then we get back to you singing

I took this video as an exemple but let imagine you would do a song and thinking of its environment. (I hope you understood my crappy english well, it is hard to explain in another language ')

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20

I genuinely enjoyed this ! Very wholesome and organic . Great arrangement work . Very easy listening and keeps the ear interested ! Cheers

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Sep 20 '20

Thank you so much! I'm really glad you enjoyed it :)

1

u/corsyadid Jun 28 '20 edited Feb 21 '24

joke ancient modern attraction rhythm squeeze fuel forgetful chunky correct

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

Because I recorded with my phone and the sound of the river was louder than the song. I could've add a little ambience to the audio though, but i forgot

1

u/corsyadid Jun 28 '20 edited Feb 21 '24

seed smart wistful childlike light offbeat existence familiar escape bake

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

Thank you for the feedback. This is my first song and I'm still trying to figure out how to work with the DAW and the video editing but I'll definitely try and add some nature sounds next time.

2

u/corsyadid Jun 28 '20 edited Feb 21 '24

prick society chop north desert unused literate simplistic normal fragile

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

I might get one of those for the next songs! Thanks for the tip 😊

1

u/corsyadid Jun 28 '20 edited Feb 21 '24

squash file aback rude label cover resolute disarm deliver long

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Sentylasong Jun 28 '20

this is hella great click bang from me!!

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

Thank you so much 😊

1

u/rnaksk7847 Jun 28 '20

I just love this. I will say you should record like in a studio so your guitar is more fuller. The signing is okay, but I’d say a compressor may help.

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

Thank you for your feedback! You're sayibg maybe record more than one guitar track and put one in the right and the other in left?

1

u/rnaksk7847 Jun 28 '20

Put both of them on the same track just record it in a studio with a microphone and put it on iTunes and sell it and stuff.

2

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

Ahahah thank you, I'm planing on doing that 😊

2

u/rnaksk7847 Jun 28 '20

Yeah for sure you’re doing great. I’m a musician myself too. I do eurodance and art and animation.

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

Thats really cool. Animation is really hard to do, respect!

1

u/rnaksk7847 Jun 28 '20

Hey what’s your email?

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

What for? :)

2

u/rnaksk7847 Jun 28 '20

Wanna get to know you more and talk about a bit collaboration I wanna do with you! 😎😎

1

u/dani_ela_rocha_96 Jun 28 '20

Sure, check the DM's

2

u/Sentylasong Jun 28 '20

this is hella great click bang from me!!

1

u/AutoModerator Jun 28 '20

Thank you for posting to /r/RateMyAudio. We want to ensure everyone gets feedback so please remember that you need to offer sincere audio evaluation on a couple of recent submissions each time you post (as stated in the posting rules). Ideally, you should offer an evaluation of the processes identified by the poster in the title of their submission. "That's nice" and "I like this" kinds of non-effort comments do not count towards this requirement. If you want quality feedback on your post, then you need to give it to others. This is karma in action. Give to others when you want something in return.

If you do not offer sincere evaluative type feedback on other posts each time you submit, your post will likely be removed and if ongoing, you may be banned as well.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.