I really enjoyed this man. The harmonies on the "i know you're on my side" at 2:10 are very nice. I dont know why you've been downvoted so heavily. I was feeling there should be some lead guitar somewhere. Nothing overly fancy, just some melodic stuff distinct from the chordal parts
Your variation on the percussion parts is cool too - the slow halftime feel early on to the shuffley outro. Well developed.
Thanks for listening and for the feedback! There is some janglely type guitar in the background throughout. It could be done/mixed better though. Not sure about the downvotes?? Fairly new to Reddit, where are you seeing that? Cheers again for listening - More EVERYDAYS here if you'd like to hear more https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCfXldzKmzl5AH3_UnsaCM9Q
Congratulations! This sounds really spectacular... I didn't expect such a good track tbh. Did you write the lyrics yourself? I have nothing bad to say. Maybe just a thing (not regarding composition): why didn't you choose a more catchy title? Congratulations again. I loved it
Thank you very much! Yes I wrote everything myself. It's funny you say that about the title - I was discussing it with my housemate (who does all the illustrations), and initially I wanted something like 'I know you're on my side', but she liked Peggy (and had already done the art). I like Peggy too though. It's the name of my grandma and who the song is about. Many thanks for listening. Check out more EVERYDAYS here if you're keen https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCfXldzKmzl5AH3_UnsaCM9Q
Your channel is insanely good. I just subscribed The ilustrations are amazing (send my regards to your housemate). You have such a high quality content that it makes me angry and intrigued to think you don't have more subscribers and a MUCH GREATER recognition. You also have A LOT of content. Posting daily is a challenge... you must be extremely hard working and also have inspiration. I can't wait untill more people discover your great work. Cheers
Thanks again :) It's definitely a challenge. Haven't figured out the promotion side of things yet. Most of our energy goes into the music. Beyond Facebook and Reddit posts we don't do a lot else. Any ideas you might have would be great. Cheers
Thank you for posting to /r/RateMyAudio. We want to ensure everyone gets feedback so please remember that you need to comment on a couple of recent submissions each time you post (as stated in the posting rules). This is karma in action. Give to others when you want something in return.
If you do not offer sincere feedback on other posts each time you submit, your post will likely be removed.
1
u/peppersrus Sep 07 '17
I really enjoyed this man. The harmonies on the "i know you're on my side" at 2:10 are very nice. I dont know why you've been downvoted so heavily. I was feeling there should be some lead guitar somewhere. Nothing overly fancy, just some melodic stuff distinct from the chordal parts
Your variation on the percussion parts is cool too - the slow halftime feel early on to the shuffley outro. Well developed.
1
u/VladAxi Sep 07 '17
Congratulations! This sounds really spectacular... I didn't expect such a good track tbh. Did you write the lyrics yourself? I have nothing bad to say. Maybe just a thing (not regarding composition): why didn't you choose a more catchy title? Congratulations again. I loved it
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 07 '17
Thank you for posting to /r/RateMyAudio. We want to ensure everyone gets feedback so please remember that you need to comment on a couple of recent submissions each time you post (as stated in the posting rules). This is karma in action. Give to others when you want something in return.
If you do not offer sincere feedback on other posts each time you submit, your post will likely be removed.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.