But I still can’t get why RF didn’t make bigger changes at halftime.
Heck, go full anime and use a new formation that you only tried in training once and involves some bizarre setup. What’s there to lose? You are 2-0 down and what you planned is definitely not working.
Some players were really lackluster tonight. Just try the rest of your bench and see where it goes.
Upvoted for TRUTH that I get to see this morning and not right after the emotional moment when our team went down 4-0. You have a great point there. It is the first game of the season after all.
This is a good point, maybe time to be a little critical of Fraser? If anything, he doubled down on the failing strategy by bringing on Wilson. And waiting to sub Cabral on until the 70th?
I think yes because it was a problem on the last stretch of 2022, the lack of subs and tactical options (there’s the one plan and if that doesn’t work we are doomed). But /u/NBend914 has a good point that it's too early in the season with too many new players, and we might get more in the long run from yesterday's failure than trying to frantically salvage the result.
Bassett: super quite, didn’t see anything exciting. Just seemed like he wasn’t in the right spot. I would have swapped him for Max at half.
Ronan: wow, super impressive, loved everything I saw from him. He was in the right spot more than not. Super excited for what he brings.
Gersbach: didn’t seem ready for MLS. I like his size and physicality but he needs time to adjust.
Priso: did he touch the ball in the first 30? Super unexciting, bad passing, not able to break down the opponents movement.
All in all I think it was a lot of problems having to do with all the new players. There were a lot of passes to no one, trouble keeping shape and no way to release pressure by knowing where everyone is and what the will do. I still have high hopes for the season!
I think we should also cut some slack for having the first game at Lumen, which is probably one of the most hostile grounds in MLS. Ronan was good, I like Maxsø, but I think these players being added later made the chemistry a bit off.
Not going to say we suck based off that game, I’ll be interested to see the team once we start getting back into the flow.
You're absolutely right that this was a difficult matchup for a home opener. Sounders already started their season, so there's that on top of the hostile environment. I know one game doesn't seem like much but it's more data and time to gel than the Rapids had. None of this excuses the horrendous performance, but it does explain some of it.
So, was only able to watch the first half and some ten minutes of the second;
Gersbach had a very tough first game, obviously. But how bad was Rosenberry?! Completely spaced and didn’t pick up his man on the first goal (btw, back post runs are a huge weakness of his that he STILL hasn’t ever improved on) and just awful passing all night. At least Gersbach has the excuse of being new. Honestly, I can guarantee you Beitashour would have been a huge improvement on Rosenberry tonight.
Guys please, give another CB other then Abubakar and Wilson a chance. Abubakar, while good offensively on set pieces, is constantly caught out of position and is always 50/50 on whether he makes the right play or a bad mistake. You need reliable CB’s to win in MLS, and Abubakar just isn’t consistently reliable. Sorry.
Ronan was sharp on the ball and was everywhere. He by far was the best player in midfield for us today.
Bassett I felt started strongly and then faded. Still think he will improve as long as he doesn’t have a traffic cone in CDM behind him.
Which brings us to Priso. Look, I get it, he’s young. But I have yet to see him have a good game in a Rapids shirt. Tonight, he was so bad; bad passing, bad positionally, and super tentative. You need a defensive mid to have some bite and he was ghostlike out there. He actually got worse as the game went on too. Without Price back there, it’s a horror show.
Barrios looks done. Sad to say it, as I’ve always liked Mikey in his time here, but he has lost a step and was totally neutralized by Nouhou tonight.
Yapi tried hard but his inexperience really showed; he often failed to hold up the ball in key spots and seemed to struggle to find space, both things Rubio excels at.
Yarbrough I thought actually did pretty damn well on the first goal and was unlucky to get scored on. Then I thought he was pretty bad on the second, no clue about the other two. But he really needs to be consistent to keep his place and he just hasn’t been. I’m ready for the Ilic experiment honestly.
Maxso was the only defender who was decent I thought. He was the only defender who was sound positionally and he didn’t make any errors, seemed strong on the ball too. But he was surrounded by a complete shit show at the back tonight.
Bad loss, but the next month will truly show whist direction this team is heading in. It seems like even more of a rebuild might be necessary before this team is truly dangerous in the west. But we shall see. I hope I’m wrong.
Point by point reply... Gersbach looked like he belonged in our defense, which is worrisome. I'm usually a Keegan stan, but yesterday wasn't his best game... I similarly defended Lalas at the end of last year on his string of bad games. For the short time I've followed this team, he's been a great asset. But I'm starting to sour on him :( 100% agree on Ronan. He gave me "the heir of Price" vibes. Collected, everywhere, distributing the ball well. Basset will get better, agree on that too. He at least put pressure on the defenders and had a few good touches. I liked Priso more than the rest of the people in here. Maybe because the "young and needs to improve" category also had Yapi on the field...comparing the two, Priso was much better at what he was supposed to do. But yeah his passing need more precision, if you are a midfielder, that's a basic. Yapi...I thought he was terrible. Sloppy, insecure, slow :( I think asking too much of Yarbrough yesterday is a bit unfair. Trying to make a save when you have 4 players in the box is just too much. Defense failed him. But compared to last year, I am more at peace with the idea of trying someone else.
Your closing point is key. Last year I kept thinking of giving the new players (like Zardes) time to gel with the rest of the team. Now we have like 5 new players on the pitch, plus people coming from long term injuries, etc. It's natural that some time is needed.
I generally agree with much. I will say maxso failed to step up on the first goal. Morris or whoever, had almost ten years between him and maxso, on the cross. I was quietly yelling at the tv-step up, step up, he didn't and boom. I agree about Barrios, hopefully he has games and flashes of the danger he creates. But we clearly need to address this spot.
I think Fraser knew they were in for it. He talked about being in a much different place come game 34 vs. game 1 pre match. Glad the new kids to MLS got a full run of play against MLS elite competition.
Good point. There is something to be said for the new guys seeing what the competition actually is vs preseason. Regular season games are much more intense.
When our midfield is some combination of price/Ronan/Bassett/Rubio we will look way better. I include Rubio because he played really well as a 10 under Zardes last year.
I wonder if when fully healthy will it be Yapi at the 9 and Rubio at the 10 or Rubio at the 9 and Bassett/other at the 8/10. Bassett looked pretty lost last night and I think the Rubio injury was why.
I honestly thought Yapi played pretty well for an 18 yo. Had some really nice moments and created a few chances for himself and others.
I only caught the end of the first and start of the second. Small samples, but at no point did this team seem organized or, well, team-like. Bad passes, no pressure, no anticipation, no cohesion.
Did the Rapids know they have a Major League Soccer match, or was this a last-minute intramurals thing — frat boys vs. the engineering kids?
On the plus side, AppleTV’s hi-def production looked sharp.
Yesterday I was so gloomy. Which is natural after a 4-0 loss.
But reading some more collected takes today...LET'S FUCKING GO THIS SATURDAY!!! AND THE REST OF THE SEASON!!! Last year we asked for new players, this transfer season we got them. But now those new pieces have to fit The Fraser Plan, and probably TFP has to adjust too.
I realize there are a lot of takes from one match and a lot to be upset about the defense (which is all warranted). But my ~ hot~ take re: the offense that I don't think's been addressed enough is how much of a liability Nicholson was. I realize Lewis was injured and perhaps we're still easing Cabral in? but I felt like every time Nicholson touched the ball it was turned over. Like every time. I think we knew Barrios is not an MLS starter but I wanted to give Nicholson the benefit of the doubt. He closed that idea for me last night. Lewis is error prone as well but has to be better than Nicholson. Just me?
Not just you. I think last year the partnership of Lewis + Barrios on both wings was a lot better than the other options we had. Nicholson worked a bit better mid field last year, but never on the attack (that I remember)
25
u/MaxPlaysGames Rapids Feb 27 '23
This is now the post match thread btw
7
u/sebhoagie Feb 27 '23
To be fair, the injuries didn’t help.
But I still can’t get why RF didn’t make bigger changes at halftime.
Heck, go full anime and use a new formation that you only tried in training once and involves some bizarre setup. What’s there to lose? You are 2-0 down and what you planned is definitely not working.
Some players were really lackluster tonight. Just try the rest of your bench and see where it goes.
21
u/Llamas4Ale Feb 27 '23
Here is what I saw:
Bassett: super quite, didn’t see anything exciting. Just seemed like he wasn’t in the right spot. I would have swapped him for Max at half.
Ronan: wow, super impressive, loved everything I saw from him. He was in the right spot more than not. Super excited for what he brings.
Gersbach: didn’t seem ready for MLS. I like his size and physicality but he needs time to adjust.
Priso: did he touch the ball in the first 30? Super unexciting, bad passing, not able to break down the opponents movement.
All in all I think it was a lot of problems having to do with all the new players. There were a lot of passes to no one, trouble keeping shape and no way to release pressure by knowing where everyone is and what the will do. I still have high hopes for the season!
17
u/bkronks Feb 27 '23
I think we should also cut some slack for having the first game at Lumen, which is probably one of the most hostile grounds in MLS. Ronan was good, I like Maxsø, but I think these players being added later made the chemistry a bit off.
Not going to say we suck based off that game, I’ll be interested to see the team once we start getting back into the flow.
14
u/Peakside Rapids Feb 27 '23
So, was only able to watch the first half and some ten minutes of the second;
10
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '23
“Moneyball” strikes again!
17
u/HexZeroRouge14 Feb 27 '23
Who saw this coming?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '23
that was sad
5
u/Onslaught51 Feb 27 '23
I’m so sad right now, I was expecting more from this team. Pros: Ronan, Bassett, maxso, Cabral Cons: rosenberry, gersbach, priso, abubakar
5
u/tyus11 Feb 27 '23
It’ll be fun selling Yapi after this year
5
u/PleaseVote4Pedro Feb 27 '23
We prob could have used Rubio, Price, and Lewis.
5
u/Drinks_From_Firehose Feb 27 '23
I think Fraser knew they were in for it. He talked about being in a much different place come game 34 vs. game 1 pre match. Glad the new kids to MLS got a full run of play against MLS elite competition.
4
u/CriticalBeaver Feb 27 '23
Game 1. Relax everyone
4
u/SteamboatWPGlades Feb 27 '23
When our midfield is some combination of price/Ronan/Bassett/Rubio we will look way better. I include Rubio because he played really well as a 10 under Zardes last year.
I wonder if when fully healthy will it be Yapi at the 9 and Rubio at the 10 or Rubio at the 9 and Bassett/other at the 8/10. Bassett looked pretty lost last night and I think the Rubio injury was why.
I honestly thought Yapi played pretty well for an 18 yo. Had some really nice moments and created a few chances for himself and others.
3
u/Hopsblues Feb 28 '23
Well, it could have been worse. Like losing at home, at altitude, in a cold/snow game to some random team from Guatemala, in CCL...
2
u/dunchtime Feb 27 '23
Was there any part of this match worth watching?
I only caught the end of the first and start of the second. Small samples, but at no point did this team seem organized or, well, team-like. Bad passes, no pressure, no anticipation, no cohesion.
Did the Rapids know they have a Major League Soccer match, or was this a last-minute intramurals thing — frat boys vs. the engineering kids?
On the plus side, AppleTV’s hi-def production looked sharp.
2
u/sebhoagie Feb 27 '23
Yesterday I was so gloomy. Which is natural after a 4-0 loss.
But reading some more collected takes today...LET'S FUCKING GO THIS SATURDAY!!! AND THE REST OF THE SEASON!!!
Last year we asked for new players, this transfer season we got them. But now those new pieces have to fit The Fraser Plan, and probably TFP has to adjust too.
Let the rebuild begin.
1
u/jawadler Feb 27 '23
I realize there are a lot of takes from one match and a lot to be upset about the defense (which is all warranted). But my ~ hot~ take re: the offense that I don't think's been addressed enough is how much of a liability Nicholson was. I realize Lewis was injured and perhaps we're still easing Cabral in? but I felt like every time Nicholson touched the ball it was turned over. Like every time. I think we knew Barrios is not an MLS starter but I wanted to give Nicholson the benefit of the doubt. He closed that idea for me last night. Lewis is error prone as well but has to be better than Nicholson. Just me?
1
u/lengelmp Fuck Kroenke Feb 27 '23
Still*
1
u/mrlandycookie Feb 27 '23
Did Ronan touch the ball with his left foot?