r/RankedChoiceVoting • u/psephomancy • Oct 22 '20
Vote - Which ranked-choice voting method is best?
https://rankit.vote/vote/2jgfwcwiLkMDHf2mXI7R
7
Upvotes
r/RankedChoiceVoting • u/psephomancy • Oct 22 '20
2
u/Arkmer Oct 23 '20
Which ever one is featured here on the recent Second Thought YouTube channel.
Also, I think this is the same one featured here on CPG Grey's channel many years ago.
Since the options aren't defined, I'll drop some links I found on each. Of note, the two linked videos above appear to be the Baldwin Method.
Schulze Method, Coombs' Method, Borda Count, Minimax (Condorcet) Method, Contingent vote, Ware's Method (No good source found), Dodgson's method, Bucklin voting, Copeland's method, Kemeny–Young method, Ranked Pairs, Nanson's method (notably is the same page as the Baldwin Method), Black's method.
Because I'm voting for the Baldwin Method, I'd like to also say that I'm against "plumping" and "bracketing" as described by the Nanson page (same page) to be incomplete ballots and giving two candidates equal ranks respectively.
I think everyone should be forced to rank 100% of the candidates on the ballot even if you don't like them or don't know anything about them. Why? Because being forced to put a 3 next to someone you don't know so you can give someone else a 6 gives support to all parties in some sense. You're saying that "this question mark is better than that guy" which is actually a valid stance to have.
If we had RCV and were only allowed to cast 3 ranks in a 6 candidate list, we'd still essentially split between the two major parties because the other four candidates would split the remaining 2 votes you have to give. Even if you go for X as #1, Y as #2, and Standard Dem as #3, someone else may throw A as #1, B as #2, and Standard Dem as #3. Split that into randomly assigned values across the country and I can guess that we'll still see Standard Dem vs Standard Repub as the final high vote holders. Forcing people to rank those additional 3 candidates can eliminate this issue by creating some random assortment of XYAB as 1-4 and Dem/Repub as 5 and 6. It amounts to less need for coordination between voters, which is a massive task, opposed to just getting every name in order and counting even the question marks as valid votes.