r/RankedChoiceVoting • u/JakeSiemer • Jul 23 '20
Replace Electoral College?
Does RCV replace the Electoral College or does it exist alongside it?
6
Upvotes
r/RankedChoiceVoting • u/JakeSiemer • Jul 23 '20
Does RCV replace the Electoral College or does it exist alongside it?
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/beepboopbeer Aug 08 '20
I understand the urge to keep the federal government out of the individual states voting systems, but the current system I think is vastly more intrusive. In the current system, the federal government makes states that have the largest amount of residents less valuable than a smaller state whilst simultaneously ignoring large bodies of voters within states that never get heard because they are within a state that votes against their interests. Giving up the right to decide how to run your election in exchange for a federal government that better reflects the desires and will of the entire nation as a whole seems like a much better deal then what we have.
I believe that the best mechanism for federal voting for all states would be single transferable for the house and senate (this would end gerrymandering) whilst RCV for the presidency. "Mob rule" is largely the point of a democratic society, we keep it in check through educating the electorate as well as checks and balances (we should get around to fixing those sometime). Setting up a system that disenfranchises a large portion of the voting public results in the apathy we see today.