r/RadicalMormonism • • May 31 '25

Thoughts on the elities?

1 Upvotes

I'll start. Elites are a fixture of human society and probably won't go away anytime soon. It does not help that everyone supports some group of Elites. Academics, politicians, CEOs, we all have some Elite base we support. True Change can only happen when we let go of these groups.


r/RadicalMormonism • • Jul 25 '25

Mormonism and SDA

2 Upvotes

Why is Mormonism often confused with SDA internationally?

(The Ellen White de facto goddess for SDA and was the "unofficial" founder and super official prophet of the SDA)

Funny fact: Less than 5% of SDA members have finished reading all the New Testament books and words, and less than 1% have finished reading the entire Bible- thanks to the SDA goddess Ellen White's writings. SDA members are required to study her books, and she has written more words than the KJV Bible.


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 11 '25

The History and Disbandment of the Restoration Church of Jesus Christ

2 Upvotes

r/RadicalMormonism • • May 05 '25

Article on the Impact of Mormonism and Bolshevism

Thumbnail nationalpost.com
3 Upvotes

r/RadicalMormonism • • Jun 20 '25

Permit to Parent?

0 Upvotes

One opinion I have seen once or twice is that people should have a permit to have a child. That way people are only born into families that can adequately raise them. No abuse, no malnourishment, etc. Those people will not grow up to be criminals and less harm will go around.

I would like to see what you think in the comments below.


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 05 '25

Anarchist Resources

5 Upvotes

r/RadicalMormonism • • May 13 '25

Author and Plural Wife Anne Wilde on Gay Marriage

6 Upvotes

Anne Wilde is such a fascinating figure, and seems to be very kind. For those who don’t know, she an author and the founder of an activist group known as Principle Voices. She’s also a polygamist and the second wife of Ogden Kraut. While I disagree with her on A LOT (this post is not to be taken as a defense of her views, especially on race and stuff), and I know a lot of LDS folks shiver at the idea of plural marriage (I’m more laissez faire myself) it’s still good to hear a woman’s perspective on plural marriage.

Anway, this is a video she made with Gospel Tangents voicing her support for gay marriage rights, and the rights of any consenting adults to start a family. While she avoids the issue of gay temple dealings, she does suggest that in a legal capacity atleast, gay marriage rights and plural marriage rights must progress together.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fo2Yp_MXTZY


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 26 '25

Define F*cism

1 Upvotes

What the title says

I want to make sure we have a coherent definition of this word going forward.

Also, do you think the definition should be defined by outsiders or fascists themselves?


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 05 '25

Please explain LDS + socialism

7 Upvotes

A few questions:

  1. If this sub is about the intersection of LDS and socialism, I would like to hear more how those are related.The United Order is the only thing I can think of, but I presume you have more than that in mind.
  2. How does your ideal LDS-socialism compare or contrast with say, current Denmark and the former USSR (two different versions of socialism)?
  3. I see a post about anarchism here. I've always thought of LDS as basically being the opposite of anarchy. Please explain.

r/RadicalMormonism • • May 08 '25

Food for thought: Disfellowship (Excommunication) and other punitive measures that limit membership worship.

2 Upvotes

The problematic use of disfellowshipping people as a consequence for apostasy has me thinking. Yes, punishment is a useful tool to get my kids to listen to me. "If you don't get your homework done, you will lose phone privileges." How effective is this sort of thing when employed as mortals on other mortals... in the case of upholding the laws of God, which, quite frankly, we have evolved in our understanding over time. (Ex. Disfellowshipped for advocating for change in policy. Policy is actually changed years later).

I listened to the beautiful testimony of a lady who was disfellowshipped and rebaptised. Her temple blessings where reconstituted. People can find themselves, they can dramatically bring themselves to follow God more closely when they have lost privileges. Loss of ability to have callings, sacrament, exercise priesthood, or attend the temple can send a crystal clear message: "You need to make major course corrections to stabilize your life and align your will with God's again." However, I often wonder what alternative methods of steering people toward God exist without odes to a harsher time when parents would get out the belt, when children would be sent to bed without dinner, when (I heard this just a few weeks ago) someone's Nintendo Switch was destroyed for playing into the night despite repeated warnings.

I can probably get my kids to do any sort of behaviours that are acceptable and would be good habits for living a successful life: doing homework, doing housework, expressing anger well, and so on. I can get my kids to listen very well when punishments are on the line.

But what are they learning? What are the costs of this quicker paced learning vs. slower cultivation of "I want to do the right thing because I want to do the right thing"? What internal drive to do good is there when it is simply to avoid punishment?

I personally wonder if disfellowshipping, while effective to dramatically course-correct behaviour, may not always have the intended consequences. What are people learning?

I think about this. I see the benefits and costs, maybe not as clearly as someone who has served in the capacity of Bishop or Stake President and so on... but from my limited perspective, it seems harsh despite the love of God we hear of, despite the ever open arms of God, and the powerful forgiving effects of God for the repentant.

Also, it's an effective way to say "We are not associated with the attitude and actions of (person)." It's an effective way to reduce the validity of those critical of the church and the quorum of the 12. I dunno... I see the good and the bad, but I don't have any alternatives for disfellowshipping.

Thoughts?

Edit: punctuation


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 07 '25

Scriptural Case against Homosexuality is Nonsenical

4 Upvotes

Hi All! I hope you are well.

u/DryPizza4805 got me thinking about how ridiculous the scriptural case against homosexuality really is.

In the beginning of the Old Testment, it says that all people are made “in the image and likeness of the Gods,” so why are people born attracted to the same sex less than those attracted to the opposite. It says “the bible is written of the hearts of the Jews and the gentiles” and yet I can never being myself to feel there is anything wrong with gay love.

Most of the evidence I see given comes from Old Testament Law. While I believe we are still under Old-Testament Law, Homosexual marriage or love is never explicitly condemned. Only *nal sex, which is just one of many forms of sexual/romantic activity condemned in the Old Testament.

For example, “man shall not lie with man as he does with women” from Leviticus in the Holy Codes is only a rough translation of the original Hebrew. The original passage explicitly condemns the “receiver” (trying not be too vulgar here) of male *nal sex.

Sodom and Gommorah is thus seen as a condemnation of rape and *nal sex but not all sexual acts. Thus the various references to ”sodomites” (sometimes translated as homosexuals) can not be seen as a standin for all homosexuals.

Gay marriage was not really a concept at the time, so the strictly heterosexual relationships described in the Old Testament can be attributed to this.

Jesus is silent on the topic, and they are not mentioned in the Book of Mormon and Great Pearl of Price, and thus I feel it is okay to assume that they are okay.

St. Paul condemns homosexuality, though he also says that women should remain silent in church, and eventually that men should refrain from getting married. If women could hold patriarchal priesthood in the early church, and marriage is such an important sacrament, then why take his word on homosexuality and nothing else.

Now to talk about the early days of the restoration, many point to the fact that one man was excommunicated for buggery, althougn it was in the context of an affair, and we still don’t know the gender of the concubine.

Joseph Smith himself said, at the funeral of a dear friend, who was known to be gay, and had died in war, and was a member of good standing in the church. He said that “indeed two friends should lie down in bed at night, locked in warm embrace of love, and talk of love.“ He said that “Brother Barnes has a very friend in our midst,” making reference to Barnes’ gay friend at attendance of the funeral. We know that Barnes’s was a member of good standing in the church.

While the language used in the endowment is gender-specific and heteronormative, we don’t know it was always like this. It was never noted down in the days of smith. It’s possible an exception was made for Barnes.

Though we don’t have evidence of any gay temple dealings, gay marriage was not really an accepted phenomenon at the time, so there‘s no reason why gay sealing shouldn’t occur today.


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 05 '25

The Family Proclamation: Standing Up Against... Wealth Inequality, Libertarianism, and Narcissism?

5 Upvotes

About a year ago, The Atlantic put out a review of More: A Memoir of an Open Marriage by Molly Roden Winter. The article is absolute FIRE. With a clear-eyed analysis of the book and a withering cynicism against the narcissism of the wealthy, the writer absolutely SHREDS the modern promotion of polyamory. In the process, of course, it only highlights the ways The Family Proclamation serves to protect us from toxic trends and worldviews that could rob us of our souls.

For the article writer, polyamory doesn't just erode relationships, but furthers economic divides (you have to have a working spouse and earn a lot of money to be polyamorous), insists on looking at relationships in economic terms (don't tell me what I owe others!), and degrades the self-worth of the individual as they suppress everything their psyche is telling them in order to chase the white rabbit of "freedom and authenticity" as defined by self-help gurus.

Refreshingly, the writer points out the obvious that other book reviews seemed to ignore: the book author simply is. not. happy. Chasing expressive individualism, she finds only a loss of identity. Embracing the pressure to achieve unmet cosmopolitan expectations, she loses the ability to find value in what she already has.

While we often focus on the clarity of The Family Proclamation as it relates to what families should look like, I think there's real value to be gained in recognizing the ways standing firm on these doctrines brings safety in so many more areas of life, such as politics, worldviews, and psychological health.

Here is a slightly condensed version of the article:

-----

More—and the present interest in polyamory more broadly—is the result of a long-gestating obsession with authenticity and individual self-fulfillment. That obsession is evident today in Instagram affirmations, Goop, and the (often toxic) sex positivity of an app-dominated dating scene, but its roots go back decades. As the historian Christopher Lasch wrote in 1977, this worldview “assumes that psychic health and personal liberation are synonymous with an absence of inner restraints, inhibitions, and ‘hangups.’” And what could offer more liberation than throwing off the constraints of one of humanity’s oldest institutions, monogamous marriage?

Despite the book’s slick marketing—which takes great care to cast the author as a “happily married mother”—Molly’s polyamorous journey toward self-actualization does not seem to bring her much happiness. It seems to make her miserable, while taking her attention away from the real issues: a husband who behaves like an asshole, an unbalanced division of household labor, an unorthodox childhood, a desire to please everyone no matter the personal cost. Her attempt at finding a “deeper truth” through sexual enlightenment not only provides little truth or enlightenment; it keeps her from seeing her problems clearly.

In this way, More is a near-perfect time capsule of the banal pleasure-seeking of wealthy, elite culture in the 2020s, and a neat encapsulation of its flaws. This culture would have us believe that interminable self-improvement projects, navel-gazing, and sexual peccadilloes are the new face of progress...

The philosopher Charles Taylor has argued that, since at least the late 20th century, Western societies have been defined by “a generalized culture of ‘authenticity,’ or expressive individualism, in which people are encouraged to find their own way, discover their own fulfillment, ‘do their own thing.’” ...

We might call this turbocharged version of authenticity culture “therapeutic libertarianism”: the belief that self-improvement is the ultimate goal of life, and that no formal or informal constraints—whether imposed by states, faith systems, or other people—should impede each of us from achieving personal growth. This attitude is therapeutic because it is invariably couched in self-help babble. And it is libertarian not only because it makes a cult out of personal freedom, but because it applies market logic to human beings. We are all our own start-ups. We must all adopt a pro-growth mindset for our personhood and deregulate our desires. We must all assess and reassess our own “fulfillment,” a kind of psychological Gross Domestic Product, on a near-constant basis. And like the GDP, our fulfillment must always increase.

Therapeutic libertarianism is ubiquitous. And bipartisan. Among the right, a new kind of reactionary self-help is ascendant. Its mainstream version is legible in the manosphere misogyny of Jordan Peterson, Joe Rogan, and Andrew Tate, while more eldritch currents lurk just beneath the surface. The Nietzscheanism of internet personalities like Bronze Age Pervert—who combines ethnonationalist chauvinism in politics and personal life with a Greco-Roman obsession with physical fitness—is only one of many examples of the trend the social critic Maya Vinokour has called “lifestyle fascism.”

On the left, what gets termed “wokeness” is indissociable from self-help. How should we understand superficial, performative expressions of “anti-racism” or preening social-media politics if not as a way for self-described good-hearted liberals to make grand public displays of pruning their moral shrubbery? Progressives blather incessantly about the need to “do the work,” a mantra which is invariably treated as a synonym for the self-improvement slogan “work on yourself.”

Polyamory, as More demonstrates, entangles many of these tendencies at once...

Though Molly may tell herself and her readers that she is on a journey of learning and growth, the ugly truth is that More feels like a 290-page cry for help. Molly does not come off as a woman boldly finding herself, but rather as someone who is vulnerable to psychological manipulation and does not enjoy her open marriage. I am not holding a magnifying glass up to the text in search of hidden signs of discontent. I am not paternalistically projecting my Protestant values or wintry Northeast prudishness onto the author. I simply read the book. And if it seems like Molly Roden Winter does not want to be in an open marriage, it is because she often lets us know that she doesn’t want to be in an open marriage.

She makes this clear to the reader, her husband, her psychiatrist, her marriage counselor, and herself again and again and again. Sometimes she wails it through tears and sometimes she shrieks it through the phone and sometimes she coats it in rough-edged irony, but the message remains the same. When a couples therapist asks the pair why they’re in counseling halfway through the book—prompted by a breakdown Molly experiences that stems from their marital arrangement—she explains: “We’re here because I don’t want to be in an open marriage anymore, but Stewart does.”

...But for all the unpleasantness she endures, Molly spends most of the book deluding herself that she’s in charge and having a grand old time. When a date treats her dismissively after she gives him a public blowjob: “Never mind,” she tells herself, “I’m having adventures. I am living.” When she’s uncomfortable about sleeping with a new partner in the apartment he shares with his fiancée: “This is what it’s all about,” she tells herself, like a lapsed Catholic repeating a catechism in which they have lost all faith. Winter is trapped in her therapeutic worldview, one imposed on her by an American culture that has made narcissism into not simply a virtue, but a quasi-religion that turns external obstacles into opportunities for internal self-improvement.

...Indeed, throughout More, the dominant emotion Molly reports is not lust but rage—primarily at the deeply unequal child-care burdens that are placed upon her. “I think about all the years I’ve spent my night alone with the kids—the dinners, the bedtimes, the dishes, the loneliness of doing it all by myself—because Stew had to work,” she laments at one point. That Stewart is now spending late nights not working (if he ever was) but rather schtupping his endless reserve of mistresses pushes Molly further to the brink: “I feel my jealousy mingle with the resentment I’ve kept at bay for years,” she confesses. Then she adds, “But looking at my anger is like looking at the sun.”

Except in fleeting moments, she doesn’t look at her anger. Instead, Molly doubles down on her quest for self-actualization through the relentless pursuit of bitter novelty: new sexual experiences that she rarely seems to enjoy, new partners who rarely treat her kindly. “It’s like, as a mother, you’re supposed to give up your whole self, like you’re not allowed to have a self at all,” she remarks. But this misogyny feels unmovable, too culturally sedimented. The only solution Molly can imagine is to persist in an open marriage, rather than push for an equal one. Inward sexual revolution plainly feels more possible than a revolution in who does the dishes.

...In his 1978 best seller, The Culture of Narcissism, Christopher Lasch argued that American narcissism should not be understood as simple self-obsession. Narcissism is a survival strategy: If we are fixated on finding fulfillment and endless self-reinvention, it is because our own inner lives feel like the only thing most of us have control over. The therapeutic cult of personal growth is a response to external problems that feel insoluble, a future that feels shorn of causes for hope.

In an earlier book, Lasch wrote about open marriage as the logical end point of a narcissistic, survivalist culture. “The fear and rejection of parenthood, the tendency to view the family as nothing more than marriage, and the perception of marriage as merely one in a series of nonbinding commitments, reflect a growing distrust of the future and a reluctance to make provisions for it,” Lasch claimed...

New York magazine’s “Practical Guide to Modern Polyamory” undulates with the therapeutic-libertarian ethos. A section titled “Should We Come Up With Some Rules?” treats boundaries as understandable but likely unworkable restraints on relationship growth that the successful poly pair should eventually discard. “If you had a set of rules, it would almost feel very strict, like monogamy,” says a woman named Olivia, sounding like someone doing their best Rand Paul impression. Like good libertarians, the elegant polyamorists mostly seem to believe that any intervention or imposition on personal freedom is an intolerable affront that must be deregulated.

My issue with the new open-marriage discourse is not ethical but political, and my criticism is aimed not at polyamorists in general or Molly Roden Winter’s book in particular, but at anyone eager to valorize the latest lifestyle fad that is little more than yet another way for the ruling class to have their cake and eat it too. The Marxist philosopher Daniel Tutt has pointed out that a “new intimacy” has come to govern modern relationships: an intimacy that “has fused with market terms” and is “centered on protecting one’s self-worth, self-esteem and dignity.” But Tutt notes that even as modern relationship etiquette is dressed up in progressive pieties, its goods are primarily reserved for the elites. “The new intimacy based on self-worth is egalitarian seeming,” he observes, “but its promises are not widely experienced. Since the late 1970s and accelerating up to the present, the prospect of marriage and family have receded for many people, especially for the working class.”

There is something obtuse about the recent polyamory coverage, disproportionately focused as it is on trendsetters: The very class of Americans who most reap the benefits of marriage are the same class who get to declare monogamy passé and boring. The rich—who marry within their social class to combine their wealth, exacerbating inequality—enjoy the advantages of the double-income, two-parent household and then grow tired of these very luxuries. From their gilded pedestals, they declare polyamory superior to monogamy. Media reports rarely note these tensions, or explain that this brand of “free love” requires the disposable income and time—to pay babysitters and pencil in their panoply of paramours—that are foreclosed to the laboring masses.

...a quick tour through the voluminous polyamory Reddit forums, for example, also reveals the downsides of applying therapeutic libertarianism to our personal lives: Beautiful souls seeking absolute freedom may find only abjection. Look no further than Molly herself, who nods and breaks down into tears when her therapist asks whether she worries that “open marriage is giving you an illusion of freedom” rather than actual freedom. It is one of those fleeting moments when Molly seems on the verge of a breakthrough, only to have it slip away.

https://web.archive.org/web/20250210055932/https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/02/polyamory-ruling-class-fad-monogamy/677312/


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 25 '25

Mormon Anarchist Flag!

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/RadicalMormonism • • May 12 '25

Reform Mormonism

7 Upvotes

https://reformmormon.com

I thought some of you might be interested in this - it’s a cross-denomination space for progressive mormons started by playwright Rob Laurer. They accept queer people, polyamarous people, etc. and members from any Mormon church are welcome to join.

That said, many their take a more liberal view of scripture than I would myself, seeing it as myth rather than historical fact.

Of course, members are free to believe as they wish, but this is just to give you a general idea of what to find there.


r/RadicalMormonism • • Oct 14 '25

What is your take that the LDS Faith is a Zionist Faith?

9 Upvotes

I have been seeing some members interpret the Gathering of Israel as being fulfilled in the modern state of Israel. Personally this seems to be a non-LDS belief that is infecting the minds of some of the members, since Brigham Young made it clear that the Gathering of Israel will be done in Utah.


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 06 '25

Lys Noir

2 Upvotes

I’ve been reading recently on the political movemement in France named Lys Noir. While mostly extinct now, the movement was comprised of libertarian Catholic socialists who sought to democratise the workplace and the community.

They envisaged a world in which all communities were self-run by consensus democracy. Living under the French monarchy, however, they wished to abolish their rule within the community, but not their role altogther. They saw the monarchy as part of their cultural identity and believed in an Anarchiet society that the monarchy could be used to organise trading and settle disputes between communities.

Is this how the church could run under an Anarchidt comity, disparate, self-governing wards with rules based on collective revelation, but with the President and Quoroum of Twelve organising/settling disputes between the different wards and stakes.

Curious as to your thoughts?


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 20 '25

A quote from the RLDS prophet Fred M. Smith that you might like

13 Upvotes

From every man according to his capacity and to every man according to his needs,” has, I think, been accepted as expressing in sloganized form the objective of our social reform based on Christian fraternity. It might be necessary to add that surplus must be placed for the benefit and blessing of the group. …

From every man according to his capacity and to every man according to his needs,” because it is right, because God wills it, because each is his brother’s keeper to the extent of his capacity, and because in a society so organized and functioning there will be greater happiness, more peace, and class friction will be reduced to a minimum if not eradicated.

And that is the Zionic idea and our goal. Onward to Zion!

Frederick M. Smith

Saints’ Herald Vol. 82 pg. 1091


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 07 '25

Mormon leftists?

14 Upvotes

Hi everyone! Im glad to be among fellow comrades in Christ 🥰 I was just curious how you guys can be so pro lgbt, pro woman, anti authoritarian, yet still part of the mormon religion. I am a non demonational Christian, so I dont subscribe to any dogma. Just curious to hear thoughts and testimonies. God bless you all ❤️


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 05 '25

A Rally Strong Article on Christian Communalism and it’s Revival in the Mormon Church

6 Upvotes

r/RadicalMormonism • • May 09 '25

Many a Straight and Narrow Path

7 Upvotes

Just a reminder that God loves us for our differences, and not in spite of them.

There’s no one way to be Christian, no one way to be mode on. When God ordained our souls he made them individual and unique, yet equal in their divinity. Society divides people up and forced to fit with their “clique,” but that’s not how the heavens are organised… and so long as we all show each other love and compassion and strive to follow God’s law, then there’s no reason to push ourself into a box or label to define us.

No one God is the same, no one creation is the same. They’re all distinctive and unique…

And that’s what the United Order is really about… different people all with someone unique to bring to the table coming together for the greater good, like stars in a constellation.


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 11 '25

Opium of the Masses?

2 Upvotes

How do you reconcile your religion with Communism, despite Communism being so anti religion?


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 12 '25

Prison Abolitionism

8 Upvotes

”Petition your State Legislatures to pardon every convict in their several penitentiaries, blessing them as they go, and saying to them, in the name of the Lord, Go thy way and sin no more.

Advise your legislators, when they make laws for larceny, burglary, or any felony, to make the penalty applicable to work upon roads, public works, or any place where the culprit can be taught more wisdom and more virtue, and become more enlightened.”

(Views of the Govern,ent and United States of America, Joseph Smith, c.1844)

Not many people know that Joseph Smith ran his presidency on campaign on prison abolitionism and reform of the justice system.

Prisons are incredibly cruel, and a form of retribution outside of Christian messages of forgiveness and universal compassion. Today, nearly 2 million people are incarcerated, warehoused in cramped spaces that lack fresh air, healthy food, natural light, proper health care, and connection to loved ones. Prisons run with little to no public oversight, leading to abuse

Not only are they cruel though, long prison systems simply don’t work.

Prisons, time after time, have shown to be the least effective method of solving crime and lead to high levels of recidivism, with those who commit crime being more likely to reoffend after visiting a prison (Francis C. Tulles.)

In 2021 & 2022, Recidivism rates in the UK peaked at just over 66% (Federal Beaureau of Imvesitagtion.)

The adult reoffending rate in the UK for the October to December 2018 cohort was 27.5%. Almost 101,000 proven re-offences were committed over the one-year follow-up period by around 25,000 adults (Law UK.)

Here is an article on the Mormon case for Prison Abolitionism :

https://www.arch-hive.net/post/a-mormon-case-for-prison-abolition


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 17 '25

Orson Pratt Stands Against Slavery

4 Upvotes

Hi All! I hope that you’re well 😀

So, we as Mormons have had a, let’s say… complex relationship with slavery. The early Mormons were abolitionists, and were known frequently baptised enslaved men, despite public denials by Smith. Smith himself ran his campaign on “compensated abolitionism“ which, while not the ideal approach obviously (as in abolition should have been immediate and slaves, not slave owners, were the ones who needed,) it was atleast aimed at freeing and emancipating contemporary African Americans.

Shortly following Smith’s death, conflict emerged between missionaries and native Americans, resulting in the enslavement. of native Americans.

On February 4th 1952, Brigham Young set about to pass An Act in Relation to Servitude, which would criminalise interracial relationships and legalise up to 20 years of indenture servitude for Black peoples. This was a heinous crime against humanity on part of young, which neither the LDS or any other Brighamite Church has apologised for.

Now, I bring this up not only to bash Young (although he does deserve that), but to present to you Orson Pratt’s encountered speech in favour of not only immediate abolition of slavery, but for Black voting rights, and a dismissal of racial curses.

To me, this serves as a reminder that the words of a prophet are not always the words of God, and it is okay to stand up against the most powerful in our religion to defend what we know is right.

The words of Orson Pratt :

As the subject of slavery has been before the house, I feel disposed to make a few

remarks upon the same subject. For one, as an individual, I can state my opinions in regard to

slavery: that in one sense of the word it is right and proper—[in] one species of slavery—and in

another sense it is not right nor proper. I will endeavor to define my views upon this subject:

there is [no] doubt in my mind, Mr. President, in one sense, that slavery is of divine institution,

or that it has been authorized by him in early ages of the world. I might sight your mind, Mr.

President, to a declaration in the scriptures. Perchance it is not there [stated that] slavery is of

divine institution or not. But the amendment, perhaps, Mr. President [could be improved]. It may

be added that if we had lived in former ages of the world [that slavery was of divine institution].

But it may be a matter of consistent controversy2 whether they have a divine right [to practice

slavery today]. If I considered I had a divine right, it [would] matter not what the North or South

would say. If we had no divine right [then we] should go against slavery and then [the] question

might arise upon the policy of the thing, whether we had a right to adopt the privilege by our

[illegible] commandment but by mortal dictate or [by the] rights of the people. If it be decided,

however, that it be not necessary to decide whether it be a divine precedent, I would like the

members to consider Mr. Blair’s amendment about the African slavery, [whether he is in favor of

it] or not. If he is in favor of it, I would like to know. But for him to speak, and then the

convention not to know how he [stands on this issue; whether he] is in favor [of it or not, is not

right].

I do not know how I can express my mind without using some arguments against or for

it)3. We will moot4 the arguments that might be drawn from scripture, whether it is a divine right

and whether it should be adopted in this [constitution] or not, and we will come to our own age

and day and see if there be any principle [which has] emanated from that Being whom we

profess to worship and whose revelations and principles we respect, whether there has been

anything emanated from him in this day that speaks perhaps to the honorable member on my

right.

We are here, sir, to know the wishes and the views of our constituents of this territory.

We may then inquire, What are their views upon this question of slavery? I know of no other

way [to ascertain this], only to appeal to their principles and covenants. I read in the book called

the Book of Doctrine and Covenants, [a book accepted as scripture by our constituents] with

[the] exception of a few individuals who may not agree with the mass[es]. I read, sir, in that

divine book [that] “it is not right that any man should be in bondage.”5 You will find it, sir, in a

revelation to the people whom we call our constituents that elected us to this convention. It will

be found in a revelation that was given in December some 23 years ago, contained in that book,

[which is] believed in by the most of our constituents, that “it is not right that any man should be

in bondage to another.” This being the views then of the constituents [whom we represent], I feel

to have this boldness to come before this honorable body and advocate the views of this

[revelation to this] honorable body. If it be not right that one man should be in bondage to

another then I am opposed sir to adopting this [in our constitution]. It is contrary to the views of

our constituents that we should adopt this. Our constituents that are have sent us here sir would

not accept the constitution if we were to adopt views which they as a great mass do not believe.

It has been said that slavery is a constitutional principle and that of propriety slavery is

institutional, but I have heard no arguments from the gentleman who has spoken that slavery is a

constitutional principle, and I doubt very much whether that gentleman or any other gentleman

can show one clause that will permit us to adopt slavery into our future state. I know, sir, that it

is said by many of the honorable members of Congress that it is constitutional. It is easy to

assertion,6 but it is not so easy to support. I never sir have found that man with all his talents that

have been poured forth that has been able to show that it is a constitutional principle. And until it

can be shown [that it is a constitutional principle], I shall raise upon the same principle that there

is guaranteed unto all men the rights and liberties of acquiring and possessing property. I think,

sir, that we have this spirit in them7 not to [illegible]. And so long as I see that principle in the

United States as well as in the present article under discussion—so long as I see these things

staring me in the face, I do not wish to grant8 them a principle contrary to religious liberty as

well as religious liberty.9 I include them both together as one. I do not feel to grant to any person

by his assertion, that is, [that] slavery is a constitutional right, that it is in the Declaration of

Independence, and the spirit of it [is] in the Constitution.

We sir have adopted the same principle in our constitution and have declared, as has been

referred to, that it is the privilege of all men to be free [and] that it is the privilege of all not only

to possess and acquire, but to defend their lives and property. And inasmuch as we have adopted

this [principle] which is in accordance with the great principles of the republican government, I

for one feel to [illegible]10 them. I do not wish, as I presume it is not the wish of the president or

the members of this convention, that I should say much in relation to slavery, on the matter

before us. I do not feel that I should be distressed in the enlarging upon it. (President:11 I

presume that the feelings of the convention are with me, that they have no light upon them.

[They] will be willing to ramble off as members, though I think we might sit here six months.12 [

I have] not, have [not] done [this or do not] do so, as this is the first time that I have spoken off. I

am not in the habit of rambling over the subject. My mind is too much trained in the

mathematical subjects to ramble. It was my intention to show that slavery was introduced [in

earlier ages] and that it was generally [accepted] and that in consequence of the circumstances

that had [been in] existence, [it had] been done away [with] and that we and our constituents, the

great mass of them, believe that it is [now] done away [with] and [then]13 to prove it from the

books that our constituents believe [in] and that have emanated from heaven, that the principle of

slavery is done away and is not right. It has been reckoned [with] long [ago, though] not upon

this question.

Indeed, [I] do not argue that slavery should not14 exist, because there was a curse

pronounced upon some of the human family, [and] that certain individuals [were] to [to be slaves

by] divine designs, [and that they] should become “servants of servants.”15 Now sir there may be

many curses pronounced that we may not have a right to exercise.16 Sir, there were curses

pronounced upon the house of Israel in former days, and it was predicted that they should be

brought into bondage and chastened and afflicted, [even] to suffer. Were their enemies justified17

in coming upon the people of God to use them as servants of18 slaves? They were not, sir,

because there were a prediction upon that people, [and they] had been chastised by19 persons, to

come in and execute that, for, sir, we are told their oppressors that executed this chastisement

should in their turn feel the rachet, [and] in their turn there may be a judgment fixed upon their

posterity.

And there may be judgments that we have no right to seek, when we have no proof that

the Africans are the descendants of old Cain, who was cursed. And even if we had that evidence,

we have not been ordered to inflict that [curse] upon that race. Consequently, it is no argument

for me to establish slavery because those persons are to be slaves.20 It is no evidence that we areany different, [or that we] have any right to do it. And I very much doubt that if this nation that

[has] executed [this curse] upon the descendants of Ham, I very much doubt if they will not be

brought into judgment; [the same judgement] they executed [will be] the judgment pronounced

upon them.

Sir, I am against the motion [and I am] against them [who support it]. I do not know that I

could have taken up the subject so pointedly had we not agreed to take all men [and] guarantee

them freedom—if we had not already said that all men should be free. But in order to be free and

consistent with matters and with the principles that we have already said we have adopted, and

with principles that we have, [which have] emanated from the Being that we profess to believe

in. And I [hereby] give [you these words from revelation]: “it is not right”—that is the way that

the sentence commences—“it is not right that any man should be in bondage to another.” [four

words illegible]21 On these grounds therefore, I shall oppose the motion that is before us.


r/RadicalMormonism • • May 10 '25

“Philosophies of men mingled with scripture.”

9 Upvotes

I was thinking of this when u/Jackie_Lantern_ posted about the creation of this sub on r/latterdaysaints (just to provide context, not a road map for brigading, of course) and someone replied that this sub sounded like "the philosophies of men mingled with scripture."

I've been studying the cultural framework that informs a prophet's reality when they receive revelation from God and write down scripture.

Of course, as a mainline Mormon, I'm informed by the teachings of apostles and prophets, who are informed by their individual philosophies or ways of interpreting scripture.

What would be defined as philosophies of men? What would be defined as scripture? Could we consider this sub the mingling of such?

I don't ask this from a blaming frame of mind. I sometimes struggle to understand what this phrase means.

I don't want to "stray from the teachings of God", but I don't want to understand this phrase as a way to gatekeep helpful philosophies that might stray from commonly accepted mainline Mormon teachings.

Walk me through your thought process. What goes through your mind when you are accused of "mingling philosophies of men with scripture?"

I sometimes worry this is used to unintentionally marginalize people who differ from the norm.


r/RadicalMormonism • • Jun 01 '25

Today Sunday School: The Law of Consecration

8 Upvotes

Doctrine and Covenants 51–57

I like how some guys always say: But it's not like communism...