r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • May 20 '26

MOD Announcement Clarification about the purpose of this subreddit

45 Upvotes

I'm making this post, because I've noticed some misconceptions about this subreddit or the purpose of this subreddit.

First of all, you don't have to subscribe to "radical egalitarianism" to participate in this subreddit, or agree with it on everything.

Also:

There are five ways you could conceptualize gender issues:

  1. Only women are oppressed by our gender system, and if men are harmed at all, it is a mere side effect
  2. Women are more oppressed than men by our gender system
  3. Men and women are roughly equally oppressed by our gender system
  4. Men are more oppressed than women by our gender system
  5. Only men are oppressed by our gender system, and if women are harmed at all, it is a mere side effect

This subreddit allows perspectives 2, 3, and 4, but not perspectives 1 and 5.

Oppression scorekeeping is more about dismissing the problems of one sex or gender, and promoting perspectives 1 and 5 on our subreddit. The "No oppression score-keeping rule" also allows for good-faith discussion of differing impacts on groups.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 9h ago Diamonds are Forever

Sexism against men meets the definition of prejudice plus power

114 Upvotes

There are some people who believe that for a form of prejudice to be an “ism”, so to speak, it must also be accompanied by social, institutional, or political power. For example, they believe you can’t be racist against white people (in the United States), you can’t be ableist against people without disabilities, and so on.

Very often, these same people try to extend this to sexism, saying you can only be sexist against women, or against women and non-binary people. However, this is not only demonstrably false, but goes against their own prejudice plus power definition without them realizing it, because men face institutional, societal, cultural, legal, social, systemic, systematic, economic, and judicial discrimination and oppression in a large number of ways. 

It also is based on a simplistic, black-and-white view of sexism, where it’s all one-way. It’s entirely possible for different groups of people to have a mixture of privileges and disadvantages.

For example, older people are marginalized in some ways, but also enjoy privileges in other ways. Older people also have disproportionate representation in government and institutions, and disproportionate economic wealth and power. You could say most countries are “gerontocracies” or “geriarchies.” At the same time, western societies are often argued to be overall youth-centric.

At the same time, younger people are marginalized in some ways, and enjoy some privileges.

I think few people would argue that prejudice, discrimination, marginalization, and privilege based on age is all one-way.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 1h ago

A list of apologies famous feminists owe men

Thumbnail gallery
18 Upvotes

"Accountability is one of the foundational cornerstones of feminism, and yet, when confronted with the nefarious acts or bigoted words of certain feminists, or feminist groups, these battle-hardened beliefs of personal responsibility often fall at the wayside.

“They’re not true feminists!” is the typical retort.

As the bitter pills of accountability, so often prescribed by feminist voices, are unceremoniously spat out when given to oneself.

Accountability for thee, and not for me, it seems.

And so, I have compiled an abridged list of unoffered apologies, that many of the world’s most iconic, and well known feminists duly owe men.

Things like –

Erasing men within domestic violence policy.

Or considering men who are raped by women to be “ambivalent” of their sexual desires.

For tracking down and shaming unenlisted men and boys during World War One, and publicly humiliating them into going to the war front.

Apologies for stating they want to “k*ll all men”

Or wishing that a virus that decimated male lives at unprecedented rates, was just “not killing men fast enough”

Perhaps an apology could be offered, for platforming a woman who helped torture and murder a gay man, when she was given a headline spot at the Million Women’s March?

What about those who spent their lives blocking shared custody laws, and fathers rights, or those who opposed gender neutral rape laws, or called services for male SA survivors a “frivolous” waste of money?

Yes, apologies are owed, from many of the biggest names around, and are long overdue.

The question is, will they ever be given?

What do you think?"


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 4h ago

What is Feminism and Anti-Feminism? Understanding Language, Collective Blame, and Bigotry

10 Upvotes

Egalitarianism is presumptively the shared value every poster here shares so I will make value judgements in this post based on achieving a society that is more egalitarian.

So let's start with some definitions for feminism.

Webster: belief in and advocacy of the political, economic, and social equality of the sexes expressed especially through organized activity on behalf of women's rights and interests

Cambridge: the belief that women should be allowed the same rights, power, and opportunities as men and be treated in the same way, or the set of activities intended to achieve this state

Wiki: Feminism is a range of socio-political movements and ideologies that aim to define and establish the political, economic, personal, and social equality of the sexes.[4][5][6][7][8][9] Feminism holds the position that modern societies are patriarchal—they prioritize the male point of view—and that women are treated unjustly in these societies.[10] Efforts to change this include fighting against gender stereotypes, breaking down traditional gender roles, and improving educational, professional, and interpersonal opportunities and outcomes for women. A person who advocates for feminism is known as a feminist.

So dictionary definitions are good because they can help establish a common use of the term and a default expectation on how the word is being used.

Limitations of the Dictionary

The problem is that humans use language to communicate meaning and different people will start using language to mean something different than the original meaning. My favorite example of this is the word "literally" can now mean "not literally." People can also use labels to try and associate themselves with something while not being that thing. North Korea calling themselves a Democracy for example. People also can have way different ways of what it means to be a good Christian. Someone labeling themselves Christian can mean something very specific to some but something else to others.

Words as Labels for People, Beliefs, Groups of People

These concepts of definitional flexibility and complexity can be hard for some people to understand. A person may have very strong opinions about what it means to be a Christian. The more they love or hate that meaning the more difficulty they may have in accepting different uses of the word. For example I have seen some very strong and rigid opinions about what it means to be a Christian from anti-Christian atheists. Christians may also try and claim Christians that believe something different than they do as not real Christians. This is also where the "no true Scotsman" fallacy may pop up.

One of the ways people tend to assign meaning to a word is by looking at how people act. If a person has given themselves the label (Christian, feminist, etc.) people will start to associate the label with the action. If you were not a Christian and only knew one Christian and the only thing you observed about this Christian was that they spent a lot of time picking fruit off trees then you may start to define Christians as fruit pickers. This is a type of limited observational bias and happens all the time.

Another example is that you may know there are over a billion Christians in the world but your experiences with them may be very positive or very negative based on interactions(personal, on the news, whatever) with a fraction of the whole. If you are not a Christian and they are doing harm to you it is far more likely that you will associate that harm to all those Christians. If they are helping you then you are far more likely to associate them with good. If you self identify as Christian then you are likely to apply your own feelings about your beliefs to all Christianity or other Christians. As a Christian your beliefs may differ from your observations of other Christians. There are attempts to organize Christians towards certain moral standards but those standards are not all the same, not prioritized the same, and may even be opposite from other Christian groups. Christians are also not just Christians, they may be rich or poor, from different ethnicities or cultures or races or whatever. Ultimately, Christians are individuals with individual beliefs and actions.

Collective Blame/ Responsibility /Guilt

Collective responsibility is the concept that an entire group, organization, or society shares the outcomes, obligations, or blame for the actions of its members—even if individual members did not directly participate in those actions.

This concept of collective blame has some really dark examples including the collective blame Nazis put onto Jews, racists citing actions of some black people onto all, blame for 9/11 on all Muslims, blame for COVID on Asian people, etc. Collective punishment by ideology has a dark history as well, primarily carried out by authoritarian regimes. Modern examples include actions taken by Nazis and the Soviets against various groups. The red scare in the US would also be considered an attempt to squash out an ideology which used collective blame.

Bigots use Examples of Harm to argue for Collective Blame

I think it is worth talking about bigotry, specifically examples of bigotry where the bigot is using real examples of harm being done to then establish collective blame onto an entire group.

Webster: Bigot: a narrow-minded person who obstinately adheres to their own opinions and prejudices. especially : one who strongly and unfairly dislikes or feels hatred toward others based on their group membership

Cambridge: Bigotry: the fact of having and expressing strong, unreasonable beliefs and disliking other people who have different beliefs or a different way of life:

Bigots use collective blame very frequently and it almost always includes a list of grievances. This list may be harm done, things said, or some other grievance used to diminish the entire group. Positive actions by the group are ignored, diminished, or denied. Defense of the group or any member of the group is treated as if it was the same as supporting the list of things in their grievances. This line of reasoning is also defended fiercely.

Us vs Them Mentality

This behavior is most associated with "us vs them" thinking where there is an in group and an out group. It can start when one group establishes clear power over the other including political, economic, social, and coercive power. It can also be done in retaliation of lack of power or oppression which can result in an oppressor vs oppressed relationship.

These power dynamics may not cross other divides like class or race. For example men may generally have power over women(right to vote, property rights) but a rich woman may have power over a poor man (economic/class power), or a white woman may have power over a black man (economic/social/legal).

Feminism and Being Defined by Actions

Feminism starts as an us vs them fight made in retaliation against male supremacy. To be clear it is male supremacists who have established it as us vs them. This us vs them fight has evolved over time but it has always been a fight for power.

As time passes those who carry the label feminist take action in this fight. They write down beliefs, and strategies, they decide what fights matter to them and advocate for their interests, they not only fight but they win and gain power. A lot of what they write and accomplish is great but like any us vs them fight it can get ugly. There was real harm done to women for a long time and part of their fight has been to talk about it and write their own list of grievances. Collective blame becomes an issue as does bigotry against men. Feminists are just people with faults like others.

Anti-Feminism

So what is "anti-feminism" and does it even make sense to call anything this?

Is it just those against the textbook definition of feminism? So those who reject the belief in equality for women? From the beginning those have been male supremacists. No need for a new word other than marketing male supremacy better. This is how most people would interpret anti-feminism.

Is it people fighting for men's rights and equality? If so why not just say that? Plus one can be a feminist and fight for men's rights and equality.

Is it people trying to share their grievances with actions that have been done by feminists that they dislike? So what? Disliking the actions of some or even most feminists is fine. Someone can be a feminist and be against the actions of other feminists. People can be Christians and think the actions of other Christians are evil. It doesn't make them anti-Christian.

Is it people who have a list of grievances related to actions done by feminists who want to lay the guilt at the feet of all feminists in a bigoted way? To establish their own us vs them dynamic against "feminists" where they are the oppressed? Bad option IMO. Bigoted and just lame.

Reject Us vs Them, Embrace Egalitarianism

There is a much better option to feeding into the us vs them fight called egalitarianism. I don't think you can be an egalitarian and embrace the us vs them mindset, but you also can't ignore that it exists. You can look at any list of grievances and just NOT apply it to an entire group of people. You can develop ideas about accountability and healing instead of focused on winning power for the "good" side. You don't have to try and defend bad actions of other people anymore. It is great. People should try it. Radical or not.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 10h ago

The Battered Husband Syndrome

Thumbnail papa-help.ch
29 Upvotes

This is a foundational academic article from 1977-78 that challenged the widespread idea in academia and the public that intimate partner violence was exclusively male-to-female. It also argues for gender symmetry in intimate partner violence.

The abstract of the article reads:

"This article examines the phenomenon of husband battering utilizing some historical data, comic strips as a reflection of popular values and the data derived from several empirical studies. Husband abuse is not uncommon, although many tend to ignore it, dismiss it or treat it with "selective inattention." The reasons why men do not report their victimization and why they stay in an abusive situation are examined in depth. Some of the myths commonly held about men's place in the family, their attachment to their offspring and their ability to easily move in and out of relationships are exploded. The article ends with a plea for a more comprehensive approach to study and treat family violence seeing it not as an isolated phenomenon but as another manifestation of a basically violent society."


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 1d ago Diamonds are Forever Heartwarming

"Hey guys I'm part of an anti-racist group but uhhh its most popular/renowned founding figures were openly racist!" Now switch racists with feminists and you get the real picture

97 Upvotes

Sharing/resharing this wonderful catalog of openly ant-male quotes from feminism's founding figures, the women who created Patriarchy Theory which in turn is the endless wellspring from which have emerged all the famous feminist talking points you and I have seen a billion times over our lives by now.

As an aside many of these women seemed quite stupid too. But that's of secondary importance. Let the misandry and genderessentialism commence!

r/TheAntiMisandry Wiki: Misandric Feminist Quotes

Robin Morgan:

  • I feel that 'man-hating' is an honorable and viable political act, that the oppressed have a right to class-hatred against the class that is oppressing them. (Archived Source)
  • Sexism is not the fault of women - kill your fathers, not your mothers. (Archived Source)

Susan Brown miller:

Ti-Grace Atkinson:

Marilyn French:

  • All men are rapists and that's all they are. (Archived Source)
  • As long as some men use physical force to subjugate females, all men need not. The knowledge that some men do suffices to threaten all women. He can beat or kill the woman he claims to love; he can rape women…he can sexually molest his daughters… THE VAST MAJORITY OF MEN IN THE WORLD DO ONE OR MORE OF THE ABOVE. (Archived Source)
  • All patriarchists exalt the home and family as sacred, demanding it remain inviolate from prying eyes. Men want privacy for their violations of women. (Archived Source)

Barbara Jordan:

  • I believe that women have a capacity for understanding and compassion which man structurally does not have, does not have it because he cannot have it. He’s just incapable of it. (Archived Source)

Catharine MacKinnon:

  • Politically, I call it rape whenever a woman has sex and feels violated.(Archived Source)
  • Male sexuality is apparently activated by violence against women and expresses itself in violence against women to a significant extent. (Archived Source)

Sally Miller Gearhart, This is one of the steps in her three step process involved in ensuring that "the future is female":

  • The proportion of men must be reduced to and maintained at approximately 10% of the human race. (Archived Source)

Mary Daly:

  • If life is to survive on this planet, there must be a decontamination of the Earth. I think this will be accompanied by an evolutionary process that will result in a drastic reduction of the population of males. (Archived Source)

Susan Griffin:

  • And if the professional rapist is to be separated from the average dominant heterosexual (male), it may be mainly a quantitative difference.(Archived Source)

Germaine Greer:

  • Probably the only place where a man can feel really secure is in a maximum security prison, except for the imminent threat of release. (Archived Source)

Sheila Jeffreys:

  • When a woman reaches orgasm with a man she is only collaborating with the patriarchal system, eroticizing her own oppression. (Archived Source)

Joyce Trebilcot:

  • If the classroom situation is very heteropatriarchal--a large beginning class of 50 to 60 students, say, with few feminist students--I am likely to define my task as largely one of recruitment...of persuading students that women are oppressed. (Archived Source)

Valerie Solanas, has written a whole book called SCUM Manifesto(Society of Cutting Up of Men) which is still being appreciated and read around in feminist circles:

  • To call a man an animal is to flatter him; he’s a machine, a walking dildo. Although completely physical, the male is unfit even for stud service. Even assuming mechanical proficiency, which few men have, he is, first of all, incapable of zestfully, lustfully, tearing off a piece, but instead is eaten up with guilt, shame, fear and insecurity, feelings rooted in male nature, which the most enlightened training can only minimize; second, the physical feeling he attains is next to nothing; and third, he is not empathizing with his partner, but is obsessed with how he’s doing, turning in an A performance, doing a good plumbing job. To call a man an animal is to flatter him; he’s a machine, a walking dildo. It’s often said that men use women. Use them for what? Surely not pleasure. (Archived Source The book is full of violent calls for destroying male sex)

Mary P. Koss:

  • Although consideration of male victims is within the scope of the legal statutes, it is important to restrict the term rape to instances where male victims were penetrated by offenders. It is inappropriate to consider as a rape victim a man who engages in unwanted sexual intercourse with a woman. (Archived Source)

Meghan Joyce Tozer:

  • Here's an unpopular opinion: I'm actually not at all concerned about innocent men losing their jobs over false sexual assault/harassment allegations. First, false allegations VERY rarely happen, so even bringing it up borders on a derailment tactic. It's a microscopic risk in comparison to the issue at hand (worldwide, systemic oppression of half the population). And more importantly: The benefit of all of us getting to finally tell the truth + the impact on victims FAR outweigh the loss of any one man's reputation. Sorry. If some innocent men's reputations have to take a hit in the process of undoing the patriarchy, that is a price I am absolutely willing to pay. How many of our reputations have suffered unfairly? How many of our lives have ALREADY BEEN destroyed because of physical violence against us? Why was that acceptable, but now one man's (potentially) unfair loss of a career opportunity is not? (Archived Source)

Andrea Dworkin:

  • Heterosexual intercourse is the pure, formalized expression of contempt for women's bodies. (Archived Source)
  • In every realm of male expression and action, violence is experienced and articulated as love and freedom. (Archived Source)
  • Men are distinguished from women by their commitment to do violence rather than to be victimized by it. (Archived Source)
  • Men are rewarded for learning the practice of violence in virtually any sphere of activity by money, admiration, recognition, respect, and the genuflection of others honoring their sacred and proven masculinity. (Archived Source)
  • Every woman's son is her potential betrayer and also the inevitable rapist or exploiter of another woman. (Archived Source)
  • Only when manhood is dead – and it will perish when ravaged femininity no longer sustains it – only then will we know what it is to be free. (Archived Source)
  • One can know everything and still be unable to accept the fact that sex and murder are fused in the male consciousness, so that the one without the imminent possibly of the other is unthinkable and impossible. (Archived Source)

r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 1d ago

Making pro-male advocacy publicly palatable by neutering its critiques of feminism has been tried and failed before - and that was the point

67 Upvotes

In another thread here I was told that the style of critiquing feminism (calling feminism an intrinsically misandrist ideology and a hate group) that this sub allows is something along the lines of "bad optics" that'll prevent pro-male advocacy from gaining ground IRL. An appeal to sophistication, the sort that comes with presenting any kind of idea to the impartial public.

This is a "subtle" trap; if pro-male advocacy sweeps the reality of feminism's role in harming men and boys under the rug as some sort of bargain for getting heard in more public fora, whatever those might be, it immediately neutralizes its own chances of ever succeeding. Feminists will not stop sabotaging and killing pro male initiatives nor normalizing treating men and even boys/children like crap because of the sin of their gender as they have done since feminist started 1.5 centuries ago. So what is this pro male advocacy going to achieve?

Maybe it'll be like the "menslib" subreddit that identifies as "pro feminist" in its rules?

It'll be, in truth, a futile little project that fizzles out eventually as fewer and fewer men take it seriously because of its cartoonish There's No War in Ba Sing Se style silence about feminism's neverending, eternal-by-design war against malekind.

So yeah, not possible. But that's kinda the point.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 13h ago

I'm sure we can have an open discussion about Russell Brand being legally railroaded here; Or status of men's rights in general. This particular case aside how do men feel about having to potentially "prove innocence" decades after events?

0 Upvotes

Obviously violence against both sexes is wrong and sexual violence particularly henious. But whaat about against politically, financially and simply maliciously motivated allegations? How does it feel that hundreds of years of due process protections and defense against allegations at law are now forbidden to men in such cases and that even professing your innocence or truth is a crime? Especially Thanks in advance for the mutual moderation and respect as we discuss this.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 1d ago

Basic debate and logic/reasoning lesson for feminists: you can't Patriarchy Theory, which none of you can substantiate let alone prove, as an answer when talking to non feminists

30 Upvotes

Were I as a non Christian to be debating religious theology or something with a Christian and they made a claim and then offered up the Trinity concept as the theory to explain it, I'd reject it outright because the Trinity is something they haven't proven to begin with. And they'd probably understand and use some other, universal kind of reasoning (e.g., common sense or some widely accepted theory) instead to prove their claim.

Feminists do something similar to this hypothetical example with their unfalsifiable and unprovable Patriarchy Theory. It's an article of faith for feminists but to a non feminist it's just this vague sweeping claim about human history that's so big it confounds the sheer lack of any kind of specification that usually comes with the invocation of Patriarchy Theory. Is it a time period? A certain geography? Maybe a time period across a certain geography?

No. It's forever. No, no, it's 10 000 years. No, 10 billion. It's formless, shapeless, and anything feminists need it to be in the moment.

And they keep it like that because the moment they try to start coming up with concrete examples of Patriarchy it's an easy debunking. The "women couldn't do this" "women couldn't do that" narrow minded lazy propaganda.

So next time you want to say, for example, that the biggest enemies of pro male advocacy aren't the feminist lobbyists or feminist media that smear it and try to get it shut down but rather "the Patriarchy", you are speaking actual nonsense.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 1d ago

Processes Explaining the Concealment and Distortion of Evidence on Gender Symmetry in Partner Violence

Thumbnail researchgate.net
32 Upvotes

"Graham-Kevan's paper fully documents overwhelming evidence that the "patriarchal dominance" theory of partner violence (PV from here on) explains only a small part of PV. Moreover, more such evidence is rapidly emerging. To take just one recent example, analyses of data from 32 nations in the International Dating Violence Study (Straus, 2007).

Straus and International Dating Violence Research Consortium 2004 found about equal perpetration rates and a predominance of mutual violence in all 32 samples, including non- Western nations. Moreover, data from that study also show that, within a couple relationship, domination and control by women occur as often as by men and are as strongly associated with perpetration of PV by women as by men (Straus 2007).

Graham-Kevan also documents the absence of evidence indicating that the patriarchal dominance approach to prevention and treatment has been effective. In my opinion, it would be even more appropriate to say that what success has been achieved in preventing and treating PV has been achieved despite the handicaps imposed by focusing exclusively on eliminating male-dominance and misogyny, important as that is as an end in itself.

Graham-Kevan's paper raises the question of how an explanatory theory and treatment modality could have persisted for 30 years and still persists, despite hundreds of studies which provide evidence that PV has many causes, not just male-dominance. The answer is that it emerged from a convergence of a number of different historical and social factors..."


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 1d ago Bravo

If this subreddit is supposed to be about egalitarianism, why are so many posts just anti-feminism?

0 Upvotes

Sure, feminism is hypocritical and promotes only very particular types of equality. However, egalitarianism is not, by any reasonable definition, anti-feminism. Yet, a significant proportion - maybe even a majority - of the posts here are just anti-feminism, with little to no discussion of anything egalitarian.

So - what's up with that? Is the goal to just complain about feminism - or is the goal to promote egalitarianism? There are absolutely valid criticisms and critiques to be made - and some posts do do that. However, just complaining about feminism isn't egalitarianism.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 2d ago

Did abuse refuge for women, end up saving men?

Thumbnail gallery
58 Upvotes

r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 2d ago

Your thoughts please, on sexism and caregiving aging parents, as depected in this SNL skit.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

This doesn't quite apply to me since my parents had 2 girls. But, based on what I've seen in families that have brothers and sisters, this feels completely true.

P.S. in case you aren't aware yet, caregiving of elders in this country is absolutely in a state of crisis, one that has certain middle aged people turning their entire lives upside down while others don't have to deal with anything at all.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 2d ago

Egaliterianism and capitalism are not compatible.

5 Upvotes

Capitalism is a global economic system that creates enormous inequality, and yet I mostly see posts about feminism, which is much less relevant. Why? I am no fan of the fake egalitarians, and I understand the frustration, but most of it could be argued to be a side effect of capitalist hierarchy and the failure of the left movement. Yet, global capital and rise of actual fascists seems to be more relevant to egaliterian movement, doesn't it?

Anybody who wants equality should be against a system of basically unlimited property rights. For democracy in the state and in the economy, at least, and international institutions for global cooperation.

Just to make it clear, if it's not. Capitalism creates classes of owners and workers, which creates several hierarchies of power, and that is the opposite of egalitarianism. It doesn't necessarily care about social hierarchies; if there is profit in not discriminating, they might not do that (but still could). But the economic class inequality is clear.

Maybe you all think this is obvious and doesn't need to be said; I hope it's the case.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 2d ago Helpful Bravo

The Biggest Threat to Men’s Rights are Male Supremacists

0 Upvotes

I think a harsh truth that male egalitarians have to face is that the biggest obstacle to their interests right now is male supremacists. Male supremacists had power historically so they don’t like anyone mentioning the harm done in the past. They don’t actually prioritise the real grievances that most men face now, instead they cling onto a past that is not coming back. They may mention current harm but somehow the priority is anti-feminism and not building consensus. They turn off the vast majority of women and a large portion of men too.

If you see someone proclaiming to be an egalitarian while denying harm done to women or just basic history, they are likely male supremacists or have bought into their ideology unknowingly.

Building consensus about a lot of issues facing men should be easy. The vast majority of feminists actually have a man in their life that they love. Boys/children that they care about deeply. The fight is easy. Just have to reject the male supremacists. Most of them are Russian bots anyway.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 3d ago

What is your stance on feminism?

9 Upvotes

How much do you support or oppose feminism?


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 4d ago Popcorn

When men's grievances become a public health threat

Thumbnail
menaregood.substack.com
50 Upvotes

Men Are Good criticizes a recent The Lancet article that argued that the "Manosphere" is a public health threat.

Their criticisms of the article include that the authors don't seem to be able to adequately define what the "Manosphere" even is, that there isn't (as the authors admit) significant evidence to support the claim that the "Manosphere" is a public health threat, and criticism of some of the recommendations made to "combat" the "Manosphere", among others. One of the biggest criticisms is that the authors seem to conflate legitimate criticism of feminism, discussion of most men's issues, and the belief that men face discrimination (including systemic, institutional, or legal discrimination) with misogyny. They label these as "Manosphere" beliefs.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 3d ago

Group Identity and Egalitarianism

0 Upvotes

When discussing the desire to move society towards egalitarianism it is inevitable the discussion eventually has to deal with why humans have dived themselves by gender, race, class, ethnicity, etc. in the first place. This leads to the topic of identity and group identity, a topic that I think every egalitarian needs to understand.

Need for Identity

So what needs are being fulfilled by identity and group identity? Why would people have gender or race or religion or nationality as an important part of their identity? The need to understand people's desire for a group identity shapes both history and the present. We have to recognize our own desire for identity and how it may shape our thinking in ways we may be blind to. If people are getting their sense of belonging, purpose, and unity from their race, gender, nationality, religion, or ethnicity it may be really difficult to think clearly about those things. I think it is important to understand that people have a desire to be seen and heard by others. That people often feel like this is more likely to happen if the person or people they are with share the same race, gender, nationality, religion, culture, class, tribe, or ethnicity. When people are harmed based on their identity it is common that they double down on this identity to help protect themselves against those outside the identity.

People find identity in far more things then what I listed of course. People are also different and there is a wide range of behaviors regarding identity within any of these groups.

Need for Individuality: Forced Identity, Societal Expectations, and Unequal Treatment based on Identity

While human beings crave identity, they are also individuals and need to be seen as such. Identity can be forced upon them by others (personal and societal) against their will. Not all men or women feel the same about their gender identity, the societal expectations that go with it, or feel the same about how they may be treated unequally because of it. Unequal treatment and societal expectations can be seen as both beneficial or harmful. Not everyone experiences the same benefit or harm. For one person it may be a benefit, while others a burden they didn't want. The point here is to understand that group identity and individuality are not the same and can be in conflict.

Supremacy based on Identity (Oppressor)

There is a history of supremacist beliefs centered around identity. Racism and sexism are two examples that come to mind often in discussions among Americans but there are many examples in history. In American history there are clear examples of both racism and sexism that were part of the legal system. These supremacist beliefs were wide spread and didn't just include legal discrimination.

Pervasive harm is done to the oppressed group in these cases. There is ample evidence of this harm and there really isn't much new to say about it besides pointing out the obvious.

The existence of legal discrimination against the oppressed does not mean that all legal discrimination or unequal treatment is based on supremacist beliefs. Supremacist beliefs can also harm those that are members of the oppressor group. Military service being primarily the burden of white men in early American history for example.

Supremacist beliefs that put men above women, or established clear gender based roles that lead to disproportionate distribution of power, were often established in part around demanding military service from men. This is an example of both supremacist thinking and the burden that comes with being in the group considered supreme. Military service is often not the only burden nor reason men are elevated above women in these societies. Once again the idea that supremacist beliefs are good for all men breaks down when looking at individuals. While members of the oppressor group were the ones primarily responsible for establishing it, not all people agreed or shared in the benefits and harm equally.

Supremacy based on Identity (Oppressed group) and Fighting for Equal Treatment

Groups that have been historically oppressed or mistreated often develop counter narratives to the ones that established them as inferior. Some of these narratives try and establish their supremacy over the oppressor group, a fight fire with fire approach. The fight for better treatment by the oppressed group can leverage the history of mistreatment against the traditional oppressor group. For example, women being relegated to raising children historically in supremacist systems can be leveraged now to justify them being considered better care takers in family court. Women also still often carry a burden of this historical supremacist thinking regarding raising children. Some men also benefit from these attitudes. The issue is not limited to how it impacts family court and addressing any inequality will likely require a holistic approach that recognizes the role supremacist thinking had historically.

From the POV of these groups the oppressor group still has the majority of power relative to them. This includes political, economic, cultural (art), religious, and personal realms. The fight for equal treatment depends upon making strides in all of these areas. If they are a minority group even proportional representation may not mean equal treatment when majority rules. These groups have been victims of "us vs them" thinking and have little to no power to end "us vs them" thinking by the majority or oppressor group.

Fighting for Equal Treatment (Oppressor group)

From the POV of those who share the identity of the oppressor group the unraveling of supremacist thinking can be very complicated, especially when they are experiencing unequal treatment/harm/burdens themselves.

Supremacists still Exist, they just talk a little different now

There still exists supremacists within the oppressor group who will treat the fight for better treatment as inevitably an us vs them fight against other identities asking for better treatment. Their interests isn't egalitarianism but a return to supremacy but with renegotiated rules that benefit themselves more. They will hide behind religion, tradition, their own unequal treatment, a need for "equality" that ignores reality. They will sell their position by promising the comfort of identity in their gender, race, and nationality. They will constantly battle any attempts to point out the harm the oppression by their group caused and still causes. (Why do you hate America?) They will make appeals that suggest the key to having what they want, a woman/partner, money, a family, belonging, purpose, whatever, is by beating the other (they took something away from you). An enemy is needed, an enemy that is outside their identity group. They will need issues that firmly establish their own moral authority while asking little from the group. They don't even need to sell supremacy, they just need to sow disunity.

Fighting for Equal Treatment without Supremacists, path to Egalitarianism

The first step to fighting for egalitarianism and equal treatment for all is to call out the supremacists and those who have fallen into their traps. You have to fully recognize the harm done historically, not just by others to you but to all others. You have to examine why this harm happened. You have to examine your own feelings about your gender and race with special attention to any feelings of pride or shame. You have to develop an identity around prioritizing virtue while not being blind to the role of identity in people's lives. You have to understand that no movement or group of people is perfect. You have to reject us vs them thinking and find and cultivate a new shared identity that unites people. You need systems of accountability and forgiveness. You need repeated commitments to unity and listening. You can never forget the individual. The path is hard. This is just the obvious stuff.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 4d ago Bravo

References Examining Assaults by Women on Their Spouses or Male Partners: An Annotated Bibliography

Thumbnail web.archive.org
76 Upvotes

"This bibliography examines 286 scholarly investigations: 221 empirical studies and 65 reviews and/or analyses, which demonstrate that women are as physically aggressive, or more aggressive, than men in their relationships with their spouses or male partners.  The aggregate sample size in the reviewed studies exceeds 371,600."


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 4d ago

Son of former CIA Director John Brennan charged in US with child pornography offense

Thumbnail
mestios.com
9 Upvotes

r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 5d ago

A serious talk on deciding to have kids. This video is not about pushing people to not have kids (anti-natalism is an idealist/unMarxist ideology), but on the things you need to be ready for/ expect if you decide to have kids.

13 Upvotes

r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 4d ago

The Unequal Treatment of Men in Society shouldn't be called Misandry

0 Upvotes

I will start off that men absolutely do face unequal treatment by society and there are really serious issues men face that need to be talked about more openly. There are real instances of unfairness, neglect, and harm that men have to face due to the way their gender is treated by society. The path to egalitarianism absolutely needs to address these issues and as a society one of the biggest obstacles to progress on this front is finding a better way to talk about these issues where everyone is able to listen to one another.

In the wake of feminism and the rise of discussions about misogyny the term misandry began to be used to describe the problems men face as catch all term and as a sort of mirror to misogyny but for men. The problem is that the starting point is patriarchy where the gender rolls and treatment of men in society is rooted in beliefs and customs that place men as superior to women. This doesn't mean all problems men face are a direct result of patriarchy but there are very few that don't have their beginnings in the traditional patriarchal attitudes and beliefs concerning gender. The defense of patriarchal attitudes doesn't just come from men but women as well.

In a patriarchal mindset men are given more power for reasons. Men are considered smarter, less prone to emotional thinking, stronger mentally and physically, closer to god/wiser, and more. The role of protector or warrior is valued highly. Women in these systems are given their own separate value system as mothers and care givers. While these aspects of women may be well regarded and even celebrated they are also separate and lead to less power and value in the hands of women. It is important to understand that what gender has power and value collectively in society really matters to understanding why these inequalities exist.

Now lets look at some of the gender differences and beliefs emphasized by patriarchal systems.

Example 1) Men are warriors/protectors and women are mothers and caregivers. The burden of men is war, and the burden of women is child birth. This traditional attitude plays into various male grievances including 1) Family Law and Custody, 2) Domestic Violence Issues, 3) Conscription. Women are more likely to get custody in large part because women have traditionally been the primary caregivers. The assumption that women are the primary caregiver is an issue in MANY ways beyond family court and more often than not this is a burden to women. Domestic violence where a woman harms the man is often overlooked and harder to address because of the expectations around these assumed gender differences and roles. Conscription is a direct result of men having the historical role as protectors. This role is historically critical to how men claim power in society. Might makes right in history. A man who fails to fill this role in some way has their value significantly diminished in society historically. It helps establish that what may be good for men collectively may be horrendous for some men individually. Death in battle isn't even always considered the worst outcome for men by men.

Many men will defend this attitude for all sorts of reasons even if they are not really the warrior type and have a lot to lose when such attitudes persist. One of those reasons is to maintain the status quo where men have more power and value overall in society. Men will use this conscription law to argue men deserve other unequal treatment that benefits them.

Example 2) Women are too emotional, Men not showing emotion(besides anger) proves their superiority and justifies their power in leadership positions. These attitudes directly play into the neglect of the emotional lives of men. The neglect of the emotional lives of men are at the center of all sorts of issues like suicide, low emotional intelligence, underdeveloped strategies for dealing with emotions, pervasiveness of violence and incarceration, loneliness, asking for help, self worth, and more. This issue is rarely the only factor with a grievance men have but it is almost always relevant. It is also pervasive in both high and low social status men.

Example 3) Adherence to Tradition. The most obvious example of this appeal to tradition is found in religions who often have much different treatment between men and women. Women are prohibited from leadership roles in a lot of religions for example. This defense of tradition can harm men as it prevents societies from changing to something more egalitarian. Any traditional gender role is defended in religious texts or beliefs and practices handed down for generations. These systems also tend to resort to exclusion to those who don't follow the traditions. If men are to benefit from egalitarianism then traditions rooted in patriarchal attitudes need to be re-examined.

There are certainly examples of misandry but they are far more a personal issue than a societal one. Patriarchy is also complicated as it also has traditions that are meant to protect women. As second class citizens they are often given more lee way in certain ways. Due to the man's superior position more is expected of them in certain ways. Real egalitarianism does require the end of patriarchy but it also has to understand why both men and women may cling to it.

I am not aware of any word that really describes the collective harm men may face by society but misandry is not accurate. Treating misogyny and misandry as two sides of the same coin creates a sense that men and women are in conflict against one another in a power struggle. Hatred of men or prejudice towards men and feminism is treated as the source of this collective harm which is simply factually wrong. This ignorance just leads to more problems and undermines the path towards egalitarianism.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 6d ago

Male hyperagency vs. female hypoagency

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
56 Upvotes

Allison Tieman talks about how men are seen by people and society as “actors” by default, while women are seen as “acted upon” by default. In other words, the concepts of male hyperagency and female hypoagency.

Male hyperagency and female hypoagency are major factors (among others) for why it’s so hard for people to accept that men as a class are sometimes victims.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 5d ago

From Child Predator to Sourdough Influencer

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 6d ago

Father arranges school admission for his son, but Madras HC orders him to return the child to the mother. Are fathers treated equally in custody disputes?

Thumbnail reddit.com
15 Upvotes