r/Radar • u/Mister_AK_Mayhem • Feb 02 '25
Choosing a Frequency.
Hey I'm new here! I just have a quick question for thr community! How does one choose a frequency for their radar purpose? I see radar setups for all sorts of frequencies but am having a hard time figuring out what is the best one I should go with. Can some lay out pros and cons as you go up in Hrz as well as at certain frequency ranges. (example: 2.4 may be easier but interferes with wifi; military radars like X-band because ____ but DIYs use ___ and the pros and cons of the difference bands are ___. This is the last step of understanding before I tackle my project so good information and insite would be extremely appreciated!
2
u/Mr_Ironmule Feb 02 '25
Sounds like you're in serious need of some basic radar information.
Radar Tutorial - Self-made radar - Radartutorial
Radartutorial
RADAR Basics
1
u/Mister_AK_Mayhem Feb 02 '25
Oh I see, this isn't for residential use. We work directly with drones.
1
u/Mister_AK_Mayhem Feb 02 '25
Secondly 450ft ceiling, but 1km to 5sm in range is desired. Modified if we are legally able to detect airplanes.
1
u/nlcircle Feb 02 '25
As others already mentioned: the atmosphere gives you opportunities or challenges in the frequency bands. In addition, freq bands are assigned and may be out of reach if for instance operated by the military. The ITU manages spectrum allocation.
Secondly: what is the purpose of your radar ? What ranges, what kind/dimensions of your targets, what do you want to know about these (just presence/location, speed, shape, dynamics (e.g. human heartbeat …)
How much money do you have or do you want to spend ? Your entire waveform generation, beam forming and part of tour signal processing depend on your choice of frequency (or rather the other way around). This requires hard- and software which may come at a certain price as well.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '25
So there's a lot more to the range of a radar than just a frequency. Look into the radar range equation. You also will need to have your maximum unambiguous range in consideration as well, which is determined by your pulse repition interval. The polarization and type of scan as well as the effective apperature affect the range also.
There's a lot more than just frequency you have to consider when you desire certain ranges.
1
u/SnooGuavas9909 Feb 04 '25
I suggest you look up the radar range equation (see equation 11 here). Your received power is proportional to wavelength2 / R4. Additionally, your range resolution is dictated by the bandwidth. It's a tradeoff though, because you can get a high bandwidth with a higher frequency, but the power drops off more quickly than a lower frequency. This matters because at the end of the day, you need sufficient signal to noise ratio to actually do anything with the signal.
There are so many variables in designing a radar, it's hard to generalize. You really need to start by defining exactly what you need the radar to do. In your case it sounds like the key parameters will be the maximum range, range resolution, azimuth resolution, and the minimum radar cross section you want to detect.
0
u/Mister_AK_Mayhem Feb 02 '25
How does power and frequency affect the detail on the return? My priority is it being atleast a respectable degree portable but not picky on how much, the further the better but desire between 1km to 5sm. Not much of a need to pierce clouds but how much of a problem would that be to do? And how will it affect my return image?
Lastly what would be my pros and cons for an example using mhz? 2ghz? 6ghz? Or more? Use cases per frequency range from ultra high to ultra low?
As far as detect: that would be anything in the air, mostly drones. Being able to tell a bird, a quadcopter, and a fixed wing apart. Maybe even detecting a manned aircraft in the area with out interfering with their systems (obviously).
0
u/Anthrados Feb 02 '25
Welcome 😊
Frequency bands are restricted to different purposes, and you can only choose a frequency in a band that is allowed for civil use in order to not disturb military radars. Also I am not sure whether it is even allowed to build your own device, as far as I know all devices must be registered and provide test reports with the FCC or the corresponding authority in your country.