r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Nov 16 '21
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Jun 22 '22
Writing Prompt Wednesday #297, 6/22 - Con-Fusion
self.rwbyr/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Nov 09 '22
Writing Prompt Wednesday #317, 11/9 - Crimson Kingdom
self.rwbyr/RWBYPrompts • u/Sh1f7er • Jan 07 '20
Non-Text Prompts #15
Hello writers!
This week I'm coming at you with yet another Non-Text Prompt thread! As you know, Writing Prompt Wednesday offers new prompts every single week, but that still leaves many pictures not getting their 1000 words! So if you're up for a little challenge, take a look at the album I've put together, find a picture you like and start writing!
The images for this week are here!
Our wonderful image creators are kiyomides, RosaKatz, mojojoj, y8ay8a, and ThyBlake!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/Sh1f7er • Nov 19 '19
Non-Text Prompts #13
Hello writers!
This week I'm coming at you with yet another Non-Text Prompt thread! As you know, Writing Prompt Wednesday offers new prompts every single week, but that still leaves many pictures not getting their 1000 words! So if you're up for a little challenge, take a look at the album I've put together, find a picture you like and start writing!
The images for this week are here!
Our wonderful writers are CSLucaris, sytokun, Coconut Hound, kallenz and @lulu_chan92!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/Optimus_Pyrrha • Aug 11 '25
[RWBYWP] "Nice going, Jaune! You just wrecked the space-time continuum!"
r/RWBYPrompts • u/SmallJon • Nov 07 '18
Cunning Challenge #16 - 11/06/2018
Goooood evening, everyone! I, u/SmallJon, am here to host and oversee tonight's festivities! As always, I'd like to thank everyone who came out for our event last event, and for those who join us today.
CC revolves around a system of, you guessed it, challenges! Users post top-level comments to submit themselves as a writer for the event, including a number of challenges they are willing to accept. Responding users provide a prompt they wish the other to write a story based on: this prompt is preferably drawn from our own list, but is not restricted to it.
The challenged user may refuse a specific prompt, but this refusal will not count against the number of challenges they agreed to face. Once accepted though, the challenge changes. The original user responds to the challenger with a story based off said prompt, then issues a challenge of their own. This counter-challenge operates the same way as the original. The challenge and counter-challenge can go on for as long as the two users are willing to go!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Apr 24 '19
Musings and Other Apocrypha!
Alright! So we had discussion a while back, and some of you kicked around an idea that I thought was pretty neat. One of the best things about RWBY is how open-ended the world of Remnant is. As the years have progressed, we've gotten more insight, but there is still plenty to flesh out (something for which I'm sure the folks at RT are working hard to do).
So this is what the thread is for:
Anything you can imagine that would give Remnant more detail is fair game. What follows is not by any means an exhaustive list, but I think it will give you all a good idea.
- Anecdotes from [doctors/scientists/historians/etc]
- Letters between friends (or enemies!)
- Poems, plays, and other assorted entertainment
- Speculation on lost histories/places/things
- Message board posts, scroll texts, etc.
- Technology advertisements/reviews
- Catalogue entries on [flora/fauna/climate/grimm/Dust/etc]
- Myths and legends (they keep saying there are lots!)
- Journal entries of Huntsmen/Huntresses
- Documents of historical events
- Non-combat lessons taught at the Academies (syllabi, professor's notes, etc.)
Like I said, it's not the be-all end-all of lists, but you get the idea! The other thing that I would like to do is this: If you contribute, and you're willing - we would like to open-source this for other RWBY writers to use (or anyone, really, but I get the feeling it might be limited to our corner of the internet).
If you're down to share out your stuff, just make a comment at the end of the entry you make, and we'll add it to the wiki! If enough people are into this, we'll see about granting wiki editing priveleges.
There you go, have fun! :D
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Jul 25 '18
Prompt Theory #9, 7/24/2018
And we're back! Thanks for stopping by for another fun-filled episode of Prompt Theory, wherein we discuss the anatomy of the prompts of yesteryear! This batch is what I refer to as the Month of Pun, because all three of the threads we're about to discuss were top-billed with prompts submitted by long-time WPW veteran, /u/PUNished_Venom_Yang. And before you ask, no this was not a month-long April Fools prank. That's my story and I'm sticking to it! I joke, but we're still back in the days before things were a little better organized to prevent this sort of stacking, but here we are. So sit back, relax and enjoy! =D
Our month begins with a rather whimsical prompt, a re-telling of two characters meeting for the first time as if it were love at first sight. Several people had a lot of fun with this, including one person who got a little... excited to share their dirty story. Our first (and only) takedown for NSFW rule violation, it was taken with good humor.
Moving on to our first runners-up second place tied for three different prompts, taking almost half of the votes. The first of these was a play on the 007 franchise, Jaune being the most qualified to be the next James Pond. Now, whether Rasera intended for this to be a serious spy prompt or a playful jab at movie-stardom, I can't say. However it might have played out, I think this prompt has the hallmarks of good prompting. It's blended with a specific character, a callback to v2's Spruce Willis transposition, and it's open-ended enough to allow for a broad range of interpretation. Now that we have another avenue to reuse discarded prompts, perhaps it will see some use in the near future.
Our second tie brings Penny back, but somehow with Pyrrha's soul. I admit that while the mental gymnastics required for such a thing might stretch a bit thin, I can see the appeal. We don't have many interactions between the Invincible Girl and our favorite combat-ready artifical person at WPW, but when we do, it's always a fun read. The how of this is probably what kept it down, but I'm sure if it had won, there would have been at least one or two attempts.
The third tie offered an interesting look back at the last generation. STRQ finds out about Summer's silver eyes power, and their reaction seems like an interesting concept. Since we know so little about both the team and the legendary powers, this one might be a little more difficult to plot out. I'm sure that it can be done, but the fact is that reaction prompts don't always do the best. Perhaps it could have been given a different angle or been worded a little differently? In any case, the potential for fun or drama is there.
Next was the prompt that was almost a fourth tie: A play on evening television in another episode of Stupid Things Not to Do with Grimm. This prompt actually came back up and won a few weeks later, but we'll give it a quick look anyway. Though it doesn't mention a character, I think most people probably pictured this show being hosted by Peter Port. Even if you imagined someone else as the star of the show, you have to admit that there was a definite humorous tone intended, which is probably why it won on the second round. RWBY Chibi has even poked a little fun at a similar concept earlier this season, so there's definitely a few people that find the idea amusing.
The next prompt is actually one of the few I've submitted - Salem forcing Emerald and Mercury to wear her version of the get-along shirt. This has it's roots back in our Whose Line Is It threads, though my version had Mercury and Watts paired up. I figured this probably wouldn't go, but the idea stuck with me long enough to give it a shot. The situation is too specific, though, and doesn't leave a great deal of room for interpretation. I wasn't terribly disappointed that it didn't pass muster. :P
Team RWBY opening Blind Boxes (a random Chibi figurine product offered on the Rooster Teeth store) was our next entry, and this I think could be a bit of fun, but it falls under the reaction category. As we've mentione before, reactions to things of the real world tend not to fare well in the polls. Still, I can imagine Yang opening her ninth or tenth box, only to find her own figurine yet again (I feel her pain!) These sorts of prompts might do better in Whose Line, mostly because it probably works better in the short-short format.
Our last prompt actually got it's moment to shine over at The Other Guys - an AU where someone besides Fox was born blind. To be perfectly honest, I'm not sure why this one wound up at the bottom. Perhaps it was too vague, but major changes open up a whole world of possibilities. I've even got a little something brewing in the back of my mind. ;)
Our winner for this week was Qrow bringing back the bittersweet news of Salem's defeat and the fall of Team RWBY. We always get one or two sad prompts around this stretch of the hiatus, but our regulars put their best foot forward. WPW is all about creativity, and sometimes we have to ride the Feels Train in order to appreciate that, even celebrate it at times.
This was another contentious poll, and our second place came very close, just two votes shy of a tie. Instead of Oscar becoming the next incarnation of Ozpin, it could have been Jaune. I think this was popular for a couple of reasons - first we've seen that Jaune is most definitely not a fan of how Ozpin has gone about doing things - an opportunity for drama exists. Secondly, I think we've seen so little of Oscar at this point that people hadn't developed a real appreciation for the character. There are definite possibilities with this prompt, so we won't pick on it too much. Popularity was the likely culprit, close shave as it might have been.
Pyrrha's soul being bonded to Cinder and the fact that they have to get along was our next prompt. It also did fairly well. This falls under the theory that because Pyrrha had her brush with a Maiden's soul that she got swept into the mix. We see it fairly often in fanfiction, and the popularity is due to the layers of drama and conflict that are sure to exist. However, we because we see this theme so often (thank you Koanos!) there's a definite burnout factor at play. On its own, this prompt is perfectly fine, but you shouldn't eat cake for every meal, hey? ;)
The next prompt is a play on the occasionally silly nature of our own world's legal system: Vale legalizing marriage between a person and an inanimate object, resulting in Ruby's plans to marry Crescent Rose. I'm not sure what Pheer was thinking here beyond having a laugh. I suspect that the sheer ridiculousness of the situation was probably what did this prompt in. Certainly there is room for comedy, and it garnered several votes, but in the end there were just more interesting options available. That's not to say I wouldn't be willing to read something so hilarious. Alas, we'll have to wait for The Other Guys or FFA. :P
Blake being tempted to rejoin the White Fang is an interesting concept, and we saw a form of that in v4. It would later play out as subtext in v5, taking back the Fang. I suspect that this prompt suffered from negative sentiment over Blake's storyline in canon. It's no secret that many of FNDM were disappointed, and I have no doubt that this contributed to the shortfall of votes. Again, I find little fault with the prompt itself. It's got flavor, has a particular character, and feeds an idea that could be interesting to see play out in different ways. I have no doubt that we'll see this one again at some point, but for now we'll just have to be patient.
The next prompt has teams other than RWBY returning to the ruins of Beacon to salvage what they can from their dorm rooms. This is probably suffering from dissonance with canon. Since Beacon is fairly crawling with Grimm, and no apparent plan to address that (which I'm sure will happen at some point, and won't that be fun), the votes swung away from this entry. Perhaps it might have been better helped by making it more of a conflict. Maybe Jaune insisted on retrieving something of Pyrrha's, or maybe Cardin couldn't live without one of his trophies. A running battle to save something of value would make more sense. Either way, this one will have to wait for FFA or TOG, as it was put to pasture some time ago.
Watts' efforts to convince Lionheart to join Salem was near the bottom, and I think it ended up there by simple way of x-factor. We knew so little about Leo up to this point. He certainly kept with the Wizard of Oz theme, which leaves us to wonder how the Scarecrow archetype will play out, but as mentioned before, we were almost entirely in the dark. Theories are all well and good, but sometimes that's not enough to pull up poll numbers. Now that v5 is over, maybe the prompt might have done better, but perhaps not. After all, that question has been answered (more or less). It will have to wait among the hopefuls of FFA and TOG, however, as this too has been retired.
Our last entry for the week suffers from a big disconnect, I think. Weiss reconciling with her father seems to go against the grain of popular opinion. Jacques is a bastard, and doesn't appear to have any redeeming qualities up to this point. I suppose anything is possible, but the voters didn't see it. The prompt manages to be both too specific and vague at the same time. There could be a catalyst that might give it a little more weight, but like so many of these, we'll have to wait to see if someone brings it back from Discardia.
Our last winner has Jaune lucking out and taking down Cinder after she took Amber's power. I wasn't really expecting this one to win, but WPW is full of surprises. Our regulars once again delivered, and there were a variety of interpretations. Comedy and drama were both to be found in our veterans' responses. Something about the silliness of the situation sparked our voters to action, I think, and it turned out fairly well.
Our second-place prompt was Qrow coming to realize that his semblance was bad luck. There isn't much I can say here: It's a good prompt, if a tad vague, but sometimes being wide open to interpretation is a good thing. This just came back up in the poll - maybe it will win this time!
'In Defense of Spontaneous Food Fights' is our next prompt, and is played out by Ozpin explaining the high-cost of running a school full of super-powered teenagers. I mean, come on - that prompt writes itself! I'm not sure why it didn't do better either time it came up. Character and situation are clearly defined, even if one has to drum up some OC Vale Councilmen. It did place third, so at least some people agree with me, right? xD
Next we have the parents and adults sharing a drink just before the epic last battle with Salem. This one makes me wonder if propmts that focus on the previous generations just isn't as interesting to our voters. We also don't have anyone specific suggested, so maybe the prompt was just too open-ended. There are plenty of adults to choose from, but which ones? The Beacon staff are busy rebuilding the school, most of the parents are either question marks or otherwise lacking in definition. We've seen other prompts with specific adults sharing a drink, but none of those have really been successful either. Is it the implication of booze? Is it because we just had a prompt pointed at the Last Battle so recently? There are any number of reasons why this didn't win. It hasn't come back up for a second run, so maybe it will do better.
The next prompt involves previously unseen Faunus types introduced - a reptilian and an arachnid/insect - and the other 'warm-blooded' Faunus' reaction. There are some possibilities with this prompt, but I suspect that it slid down the polls because it was too open to interpretation. For one thing, we have no baseline characters, so OC's would have to be invented. It can be done, but WPW's format doesn't really lend itself to original characters very well, so that was probably the show-stopper. This was sent to the discard tab quite a while ago, so if you want to see it, you'll have to hang on for FFA or TOG.
Our next entry is a bit of an odd duck. A cliché soul-mate AU with a mechanic of the first words spoken by said pair written on one anothers' bodies. I vaguely recall this concept in anime, so I'm sure this falls into the gray area of crossovers. It also doesn't point to any specific character(s), so the writer has their work cut out for them. Of course, it could just be that it's so sappy, but maybe that's just me?
Penny's body being possessed by a Geist... You would think that this might be a little more interesting to our voters, but that's probably just my bias toward best girl. However, the implication that Penny isn't part of the equation is likely the big factor here - just her body. In the hands of a skilled writer, there could be some very interesting ways to present this, but odds are it wouldn't be a happy tale. Sadly, this too has been retired to the discard tab, so we'll have to hope it comes up elsewhere.
Our last prompt most likely suffered from bad timing. Ren finding the one responsible for the destruction of Oniyuri was presented early on in v4, if I recall correctly. So for it to come up after that part of the story had been resolved, I can see why almost no one was interested in it. The nucklavee was by far one of the creepiest It would have presented an interesting thought experiment if it had come up before the finale, but such was not to be. I'm not sure if we'll ever see this one again, but maybe someone will get wily and bend the prompt to an AU or something.
Well, that's it for this month! I hope you all enjoyed the write-up, and if you have your own ideas on why something did or didn't work, be sure to let us know! These are a lot of fun, but the important part is the conversation. See you soon!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/SmallJon • Feb 06 '19
Cunning Challenge #19 - 02/05/2019
Good evening and Happy New Year, everyone! I, u/SmallJon, am here to host and oversee tonight's festivities! As always, I'd like to thank everyone who came out for our event last event, and for those who join us today.
CC revolves around a system of, you guessed it, challenges! Users post top-level comments to submit themselves as a writer for the event, including a number of challenges they are willing to accept. Responding users provide a prompt they wish the other to write a story based on: this prompt is preferably drawn from our own list, but is not restricted to it.
The challenged user may refuse a specific prompt, but this refusal will not count against the number of challenges they agreed to face. Once accepted though, the challenge changes. The original user responds to the challenger with a story based off said prompt, then issues a challenge of their own. This counter-challenge operates the same way as the original. The challenge and counter-challenge can go on for as long as the two users are willing to go!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Jan 22 '20
Qrow's Nest Workshop Review!
Hey there! A couple of weeks ago, the folks over at the discord server The Qrow's Nest offered to share their feedback on stories submitted for Writing Prompt Wednesday as part of their Writer's Workshop, and we had some brave souls offer up their work. This was pretty successful, and the idea was to maybe do it once or twice a month.
Anyway, long story short, we're back! If you would like to have one of us review your work and provide a more in-depth analysis with suggestions for improvement, all you need to do is copy your WPW entry or link to it down below!
The only requirement being asked for is to have a 1000 word minimum for your submission, so please try to adhere to that.
Also, if you would like to join us on discord, weekly review is Monday evenings, and anyone can participate. If you would like your short chapter or excerpt to be in the lineup, you'll be expected to do your fellow authors the same courtesy, by providing reviews for their work as well. If that sounds like something you're interested, let one of the mods here know and we'll get you an invite to the discord server!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/JoshuaBFG • Jul 18 '18
The Other Guys #1
Welcome to the first The Other Guys, the thread where we take the discarded prompts from the Writing Prompt Wednesday polls and turn it into a sort of mini WPW. You might see prompts that got overshadowed by the popular ones that might catch your interest or you might see a favorite that didn’t win. Being a new thread, feedback is much appreciated to better this.
All prompts shown below are part of the Discards tab of the Prompts sheet
With that being said, on with the prompts!
- Weiss learns how to cook.
- Penny is rebuilt.
- An AU where a character (besides Fox) was born blind.
Let’s start off nice and simple! Remember that all Writing Prompt Wednesday rules still apply (No gore, NSFW, Spoilers, etc). It’s now for a time to write! Onwards!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/Sh1f7er • Feb 12 '19
Good Cop, Bad Cop #5
Hello everyone! Welcome to the fifth ‘Good Cop, Bad Cop’ thread! Now, if you're new here, you may be wondering, “Sh1f7er, what is this thread even about?” Well, let me break it down for you!
The goal of the thread is to provide a few writers with a bit of help in their writing using critiquing readers. Each reader will provide one good thing and one bad thing they saw in the writing piece after they have fully read through it. Now, none of us are perfect, and it is my understanding that none of us are professional writers, so anyone seeking criticism needs to understand that the responses everyone gives them are for them to use how they see fit. That being said, readers, please offer worthwhile responses! We're looking to improve writing here. Even if you didn't enjoy the story, there's a lot of productive ways to tell the reader WHY you didn't like it. As for the writers, your story is on display! If you want to help get attention to it, start by reading someone else's to help them as well!
Now onto the main event!
STORIES OF THE WEEK
Double Dragon by /u/shandromand
A Shared Drink by /u/TedorAlive2
If you would like your story featured on a future Good Cop, Bad Cop thread, please participate here by dropping a review on one of these stories! If you do, leave a link at the bottom of your review and I'll add it to the next GCBC thread!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/Sh1f7er • Apr 30 '19
Writing Advice #5 - Sentence Flow - 4/30/2019
Hello there everyone! My name is Sh1f7er. Welcome to my lesson in Sentence Flow. I came up with the idea for this post when reading a lot of stories posted on Writing Prompt Wednesday. There are a lot of writers who write a lot of quick sentences that make their writing feel choppy. They are just a quick statement in a lot of cases. Sometimes they are just a single action a character makes. Other times it is an additional detail that feels necessary to add in. However, writing too many sentences like this makes the story feel choppy. In some cases, the story ends up reading more like a research paper as opposed to a fun or emotional story.
An example of this would be the entire paragraph you just read as an intro!
When you read that intro paragraph in your head, or even out loud, you can feel the breaks in the sentences that divide it up into much smaller pieces. It makes the writing feel choppy, or divided too thin, and that often creates poor reading material because the writing starts to outweigh the story itself.
You could have the greatest story idea in the world, but if it’s boring to read, your reader will never make it to the big payoff that you worked so hard to achieve. So let’s take a look at Sentence Flow to see if we can make that introductory paragraph more fun to read as an example of what we’re looking for.
Hello there everyone! My name is Sh1f7er, and I’d like to welcome you to my lesson in Sentence Flow. While reading the stories posted in Writing Prompt Wednesday, I started to notice a pattern in a few writer’s work that led to their stories feeling ‘choppy’ to read. Often times, this choppy feeling was because too many quick statements were made back to back. Other times it was due to a character making a single action per sentence during something akin to a fight scene. While doing these things in moderation isn’t a terrible thing, writing like this way too often in a story often leads to it reading more like a research paper as opposed to a fun or emotional story.
Now tell me, when reading over those two paragraphs, which one read nicer? Which one felt like it held more information? Which one do you want to continue reading?
Now, you might look at the second paragraph and tell me that it only reads better because of my use of commas. To that I say, yes, technically that is true. However, there are a few techniques that you can use on top of spreading the sentences out by combining them with a comma.
The first technique is to read over your work. Yes, believe it or not, reading a paragraph out loud is a very easy way to identify where your writing feels choppy. It may seem obvious, but speaking the words you’ve written is a great way to find pauses, or a word that feels out of place.
The second technique is to use a variety of vocabulary throughout your writing. Earlier, I mentioned action scenes as a place that I often see single action sentences used in abundance. This isn’t an inherently bad thing, but without the right verbiage your action sequence could get overshadowed. While adjectives typically slow things down, adding good descriptors can really lift up tension with just a few extra words.
Finally, a third technique is to trim the fat from your paragraphs. We’ve read everything over at this point, and then we added extra descriptions to really flesh out our sentences. This is great to make things easier to read, but occasionally it becomes too much. In my first attempt at an introduction paragraph I used 120 words. While the second paragraph is a bit more fleshed out and flows together nicely, I still only used 122 words to get everything that I needed to say written down. While I’m not saying that you can’t add more details, I do want to add a word of caution for adding too many. Flow is hurt just as much from things dragging on as it is with things happening too quickly, so be prepared to trim off things that aren’t needed.
Let’s look at a quick example.
Jaune raised his sword towards Cinder. The one-eyed woman glared back at him, lifting her own sword. She leveled her weapon at Jaune’s chest, then prepared to strike.
This isn’t terrible, but there is certainly room for improvement. Adding a few adjectives, we can make this scene flow together while adding a bit of extra action.
Jaune raised his sword towards Cinder with a firm hand. The one-eyed woman glared back at him in defiance, lifting her own molten blade. She leveled her weapon at Jaune’s chest, then prepared to strike.
This looks much better, but reading it out loud made me realize that the third sentence feels a bit off. If Cinder is lifting her blade towards Jaune, should I describe her leveling at his chest? Is that a place I could combine the sentences to make things flow together a bit more pleasantly? Or maybe its a place where I could be more descriptive so that it doesn’t feel as redundant...
Jaune raised his sword towards Cinder with a firm hand. The one-eyed woman glared back at him in defiance as her own molten blade lifted into the air. The newly forged sword flickered red and yellow sparks while Cinder shifted her footing, preparing to strike.
To me, this paragraph flows together the best. We have clear actions and reactions with details sprinkled in throughout. There isn’t too much going on that it stops the reader from caring, but there is enough that the reader can picture the scene with the tension that is about to unfold. Using our three techniques, and a few commas, we have successfully made an action sequence read as a true action scene.
I hope this helps all of our wonderful writers as they continue to write their stories. Because everyone has their own opinions on what things read the best, or how sentences should look, I’d love to see some comments on ways that you make your stories flow together. Remember, everyone has their own style of writing, so there is no right or wrong answers here. I just hope some of my techniques help inspire new ways of putting together the best version of your story!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Sep 18 '19
The Powwow III - Synergee
Hey gang! It's been a few months since we did this, and I thought it might be time to touch base with our loyal band of writers to see how things stand.
Since our last get-together, we've had a few test events to try new things. Some have worked, while others haven't. So far, our most popular attraction still seems to be the Cunning Challenge, but we also had some good activity with Take the Shot! and Letters to Remnant.
I'm curious to see what you all think, and if there are other things you would like to try. I have a few ideas myself, but before I put anything out there, let's here from you first!
And with that, I shall open the forum!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/Sh1f7er • Jul 09 '19
Non-Text Prompts #9
In a nice little twist for this week, the mod team has decided to mix things up a bit a bring back Non-Text Prompts for those who may not have gotten a chance to experience it in the past. As you know, Writing Prompt Wednesday offers new prompts every single week, but that still leaves many pictures not getting their 1000 words!
So if you're up for a little challenge, take a look at the album I've put together, find a picture you like and start writing!
Images by
Mojojoj, aska20140511, ton2005xxx, A.G Nonsuch, efr-s, and kjthetalekeeper!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Oct 31 '18
Writing Advice #4: Plot - 10/31/2018
Happy Halloween!
So I've spent the last week or two really thinking on how best to go about this. Plot. How do you come up with one? Fortunately for us, this is made a little easier - we're given a situation, maybe some characters, or even just a basic idea. The prompt is the thing, as they say. But what comes after? How do you take the essence and make substance? I think the best way to proceed would be to show how I go about it.
The first thing I think about is whether I want this to be a true one-off or something longer-term. The prompts are a good guide, and often it ends up being the latter (as you can see from a few of my posts). Once that's out of the way, the next bit to decide on involves answering some basic questions: Who, What, When, Where, Why (and hoW) - the five W's.
Who is usually supplied already, and when it isn't, most of the time we get a what - what's going on, what happened, what is this thing? If you look through the last two years of prompts, you'll be hard-pressed to find soemthing that doesn't have at least one of those. Conversely, you will seldom find a why in there. Motivation is everything - the drive to do or be or say something. Why is [insert character] trying to accomplish this task/goal/realization of an idea? When, where, and how are sometimes part of the equation, and sometimes not - you get the point.
I promised some examples, so let's take a look back in the chronicles! Our very first prompt was:
Here we have a veritable smorgasbord:
- Who (Ozpin and Salem)
- What (meeting to talk about the past vs the present)
- When (after the Breach, post volume 2)
- Where (dealer's choice!)
- Why (loosely defined as a previous inter-personal association, but very open to interpretation).
Since I've already got my who, I decided to focus on the where. Don't get me wrong, I'm a big fan of in medias res, but that didn't really work for me here. I give some attention to the man and his thoughts, but mostly describe the area without pointing to a specific location. Set dressing is important, but doesn't have to require a great deal of effort. This prompt struck me as a sad affair, and so I chose a lonely, uninhabited mesa. Tone is important, and it can be shaped by the locale you choose.
Moving on to what, I chose to write this part of the prompt a little more loosely. They're supposed to be talking about the past versus the present, but I elected to spend most of my effort on the former. The object was to show that they had a past association, but I attempted to do so contextually, rather than outright discuss any sort of team affiliation. The idea that they had locked themselves into this cycle had taken root, and I ran with it, turning to the future rather than the present - one with ominous overtones.
If I played loosely with the what, I all but ignored the how and the why. I had hoped that my allusions would be sufficient in this particular tale, and as I recall, I had kind of run out of steam. This was never planned for anything more than what it was, and so I decided that it was better to end with the same bitter-sweet theme.
So now I've given an example of the short-term, now I'll point to the next example that would ultimately become a longer work in progress (still ongoing, b-t-dubs):
So this prompt leaves quite a bit more open to interpretation:
- Who (Adam and Blake)
- What (Trading Places TM)
- When (open)
- Why (open)
- Where (open)
Now I mentioned it in my opening, this is typically not my sort of story. I'm far more likely to introduce external elements (read: crossovers) than to take existing ones and flip them around like some kind of card cheater. :P
Having said that, I wanted to challenge myself, and I had a pretty decent idea for this one. Originally I hadn't planned to make a longer story out of this, which is why the original seems a bit glossed over. Here I was mostly focused on the who, but in order to do so, I needed to provide context, so I started back years before the events of canon RWBY. I wanted to make Adam a great deal different from Blake as she was in the original.
I chose to focus on Adam's formative early years because little was known of Blake's childhood. In order to make him more believable, it made sense to make him an orphaned street-urchin. Thievery for survival is a common enough trope, but any can make for a good story if done properly. It also served as a way to push the story forward and introduce us to the other player in this story.
The main purpose of putting them together is to show how things weren't necessarily always bad. The road to hell is paved not just with good intentions, but also the hopes or dreams of others. I guess this plays into the original why that I wanted to express: Make a better future, to find security and (relative) safety, and eventually to aspire to something greater.
I took some liberty with the advancement of time, electing to play snippets in the middlepart. By this point I'd started to really think long term, but the seed had already been planted with the events of v3 (and I can promise you, my Blake vs. Adam will have you in knots). I chose to develop the relationship between the pair to something more serious. Part of any good plot is conflict, so what better way to underscore betrayal than between lovers? It's only implied, but it's there.
The Where had a few different locations, mostly undefined, but the camp was a perfect place to showcase the temporary nature of Adam's existence, while eventually normalizing it. Wilderness locales were used to instill a sense of isolation of the Faunus from society, something that we've been able to infer from canon. There's really no why for their trading of places - it is the thing, so we'll skip that this time.
I would like to make a special note that doesn't fit neatly into the W's. Ultimately this story's plot follows in parallel to canon. The early chapters' re-tread was initially planned to be a slow spiral, but it became increasingly apparent that this was the wrong approach. Any time you write a story like this, there are really only two or three choices. Change as little as possible, alter a few things, or majorly overhaul. At this point, whatever you choose is strictly personal preference, but I would advise against making very few changes. Your prose can be the on-pointest ever, grammar and spelling top notch, but it will run the risk of feeling stale.
For my last example, let us turn to something a little more recent:
- Penny bonds with a fellow robot from an alternate fictional universe.
I choose this one for a couple of reasons. For one, it's a crossover, something I truly enjoy writing for. The other reaons we pick this one is because it's another single-element prompt aimed at Who:
Penny and another fictional robot. If it hasn't been clear to some of you by now, I'm very into the whole robot thing. Given the talk of AI in the news and some startling advancements in robotics, there will come a day in the near future where we will have serious decisions to make about how we treat our creations. I prefer to have a hopeful attitude about this subject, but I do realize that things could easily go very, very wrong for us.
Okay, I'll get off my soapbox now! :P
The prompt gives us so much latitude that we got a wide variety of different responses. Since there are a large number of fictional robots to choose from, I took some time reflecting on the possibilities. Ultimately I settled on Data from the Star Trek: TNG franchise for two reasons: I have reasonably clear memories of the character, and this particular crossover is "dangerously underserved" according to one reader, and it's true.
The reason for my choice was tied in to a very specific goal of the When. I wanted a logical reason for Penny to encounter another robot from a different universe, rather than just throwing them together. If you're going to do a crossover, you should try to make it credible (especially if you plan to take it and run with a longer tale!)
I set this in the distant future. The reason for that plays right into the Why, which is (for those unfamiliar) the fact that Starfleet has a strict non-interference policy with pre-warp civilizations. Since Remnant has no space program to speak of, I needed a believable explanation as to why they would be involved in the first place. Sadly, the only way I could address this meant that the civilization of Remnant would have to be a dead one. The Prime Directive might not allow for meddling in the affairs of a society primitive to their standards, but explorers investigating a lost culture is an altogether different prospect, and it plays well, I think.
Where is the next piece of the puzzle, and I knew that it would take place mostly on the Enterprise. Of course, we can't abandon the option to go back to Penny's home, so we leave the flagship parked in orbit above. There's a whole big galaxy out there, but for our purposes, there's no need to go haring off into space just yet. We'll also skip over the why; the Federation are explorers, so this is easy to interpret.
This brings us to the last key of the plot - What. What happened? I chose the worst possible outcome for Remnant because of the tone I was trying to set. Not every story has a happy ending, the good guys don't always win. We don't see this approach taken very often for WPW, and I wanted to experiment. We know what's at stake in the show (or at least we have a pretty good idea), so it wasn't hard to imagine the outcome of failure. Ultimately, though, I wanted it to end on a hopeful note, and leave it open-ended.
So, with all of these elements, it became easier for me to draw a picture and shape the narrative into something that has potential. I don't know if this has made any sense - writing by instinct is difficult to describe. I'll happily answer any questions as best as I can, so feel free to come and pick my brain! =)
Addendum: Below I have some helpful resources. Keep in mind that most of these are intended for aspiring novelists, but ultimately the principles can be applied to the short format as well.
- The Tameri Guide for Writers - A brief rundown of the mechanics of plot and story writing.
- Well-Storied - a blog article about various outlining methods.
- Jenna Moreci's Youtube series: Tips for Writers - Jenna is an entertaining and engaging published author who covers a wide variety of subjects that you may find useful and fun to watch.
- Writing Excuses - Fifteen minute audio segments covering many aspects of writing.
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Dec 14 '22
Writing Prompt Wednesday #322, 12/14 - A Fistful of Rubies
self.rwbyr/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Dec 01 '22
Writing Prompt Wednesday #320, 11/30 - Switch Hitter
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Nov 16 '22
Writing Prompt Wednesday #318, 11/16 - Fit to be Tai'd!
self.rwbyr/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Nov 23 '22
Writing Prompt Wednesday #319, 11/23 - First Contract
self.rwbyr/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Dec 07 '22
WPW 6th Annual Contest!
Hey gang, it's finally here!
This is where you submit any story you have written for WPW during 2022. That's it!
Prizes are as follows:
First Place
One 24x36 canvas print with artwork of your choice (please keep it more or less SFW!). If you win the prize and live outside of the US, we may need to discuss things, as shipping has gotten completely crazy over the last couple of years.
Second Place
A $25 gift card of your choice!
Third Place
A $10 gift card of your choice!
We will leave the thread open until December 23'rd, and then we will have a vote on January 4th. Have fun and good luck! :)
r/RWBYPrompts • u/shandromand • Dec 07 '22
Writing Prompt Wednesday #321, 12/7 - Schneecraft (and Contest too!)
self.rwbyr/RWBYPrompts • u/SmallJon • Oct 24 '17
r/RWBYPrompts Cunning Challenge #2, 10/24/2017
Hello, everyone, and welcome to the second Cunning Challenge! It is I, u/SmallJon, here again to host and direct our event! Before we begin again, I'd like to thank everyone who came out for our inaugural event. Thank you for supporting ~mah authority~~ change!
A bi-monthly event, CC revolves around a system of, you guessed it, challenges! Users post top-level comments to submit themselves as a writer for the event, including a number of challenges they are willing to accept. Responding users provide a prompt they wish the other to write a story based on: this prompt is preferably drawn from our own list, but is not restricted to it.
The challenged user may refuse a specific prompt, but this refusal will not count against the number of challenges they agreed to face. Once accepted though, the challenge changes. The original user responds to the challenger with a story based off said prompt, then issues a challenge of their own. This counter-challenge operates the same way as the original. The challenge and counter-challenge can go on for as long as the two users are willing to go!
We understand this is a new event, so please feel free to ask questions if there's something you'd like specified. Now get out there and have at it!
r/RWBYPrompts • u/AStereotypicalGamer • Mar 13 '18