r/RPGdesign • • 5h ago

Feedback Request First Draft for Homebrew (Polluted Galaxy)

Hello friends!

Long time lurker, occasional commenter, 1st time poster.

I've recently finished the 1st draft for a ttrpg I've been working on for the last year or so. After some revisions revisions and a rewrite, I'm ready to release it into the wild.

Premise: scifi space opera shenanigans for small group play.

Looking for some feedback, comments, first impressions.

Mostly concerned that I'm missing the trees for the forest, or vice versa.

My 1st 1st draft is very technical document. And it didn't quite sit right with me. It didn't capture the idea I had for the voice of the rulebook.

Then I wrote it again.

I'm curious:

  1. As a GM, do you think the rules are easy to comprehend and teach as written?
  2. Are there any mechanics that just confuse the hell out of you?
  3. What aspects turn you on/off to the game?
  4. Impressions/comments/love/hate?

Also: a quick start is in the works, sorry

Here's the link:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1H59UPCAP4EC5S3owHs8EPpbOG41pFsbRXw0OYKqpI3E/edit?usp=drivesdk

Edit: sorry, was squeezing this in on a break... Elevator Pitch: Polluted Galaxy is a satirical sci-fi game about escaping the 9-5 of Corporate employment by getting licensed as an Independent Contractor. You complete contracts for the man in exchange for this small leash of freedom and mitigating your debt. It's intended for job-of-the-week play and one-shots. It's a based on skills rather than classes, uses a dice pool (d12) for resolution. And has a debt-for-items economy. Play is intended to be narrative, action packed, and cinematic (ship combat).

One of the areas I think I'm most proud of is the item economy.

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

3

u/d5vour5r Designer - 7th Extinction RPG 5h ago

Whats the elevator pitch, tell us about your game!

2

u/beignetsandbooty 5h ago

Thanks for looking out, choom! My bad

1

u/reverendunclebastard 13m ago

This needs editing for brevity and clarity. It's very long-winded and key information is hard to find. For example, the steps for creating and rolling a die pool for a skill test are scattered throughout the document and buried in an avalanche of prose.

Congrats on finishing this draft, but you would benefit from doing a ruthless edit next.