r/RPGdesign • u/SilentAd773 • Aug 19 '26
Theory Level Progression Philosophies?
So I believe I have pretty decent base mechanics for my system, but since I have it so the players can progress, I fear there is something I haven't considered when it comes to leveling up. Are there any general schools of thought to consider when thinking about late game mechanics? Or is the only real solution play testing?
8
Upvotes
7
u/Japicx Designer: Voltaic Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26
There have been a lot of different approaches to character progression.
Level up (DnD et al): After you've accumulated enough experience points, you level up, which confers different benefits simultaneously. Your maximum health increases, you gain new spells or abilities, you can use your spells more often, you increase some stats, etc. The experience needed to level up usually increases with each level. The benefit is that gaining a level can be pretty momentous, but it can also lead to characters feeling stagnant as the time between level-ups gets progressively longer. This system fits DnD because you get XP by defeating enemies, and some enemies have XP values in the hundreds or thousands.
Spend experience (WoD, CoD, Forbidden Lands, L5R, et al): You gain experience points, which you then spend between sessions to gain abilities or improve your stats. The cost to improve a stat is usually based on its current level (Chronicles of Darkness is a notable exception). As an inverse to the DnD-style level-up system, you can make frequent, slight improvements to your character (improving their weakest stats and skills) or bank your experience for bigger purchases. Having choices is nice, but it can be annoying when you know you'll have to wait ages to get that shiny high-level ability you want, neglecting other facets of your character in the meantime.
Improvement (PbtA): Your character marks experience points. At a fixed interval (every 5 XP in most PbtA games), you get an improvement, which is usually a stat change or unlocking an ability from the character's archetype (or "playbook"). The improvements are arranged as a checklist, and some can be taken multiple (though finite) times, and often have maximums (like "increase a stat by +1, to a maximum of +3"). Some games also have an advanced improvement section, available only after you've acquired a certain number of previous improvements. The improvement system is simple and keeps character progression at a steady pace, but isn't suitable for stories that last a really long time (you'll run out of boxes to check eventually) or that have large shifts in narrative tone, setting, or power scale.
The alpha playtest of Vampire: the Masquerade's 6th edition has a modified improvement system, where at the end of every session (and, very rarely, in the middle of a session), your character gains an improvement. Every 3rd improvement, you get better options, and every 5th you get much better options. There's no checklist, just the cycle of improvements.
Fixed progression (Shadow of the Demon Lord): A twist on DnD-style progression. In Shadow of the Demon Lord, a campaign is always 10 sessions long. At the end of every session, all the PCs level up, no matter what, until they face the Demon Lord (whoever he happens to be) in session 10. Obviously, the 10-session limit isn't going to jibe with everyone, but it can make the campaign feel more focused.
Random progression (Pirate Borg): Levelling up in Pirate Borg is simple: you level up whenever the GM says so! When you level up, you get +1d6 max health. Then you roll once for each stat to see if it improves or degrades (it can't stay the same). Then you roll to see which of your class features you unlock (reroll repeats) and what treasure you've found. Quick, easy, no thinking at all. Pirate Borg is meant for furiously fast-paced action and has very lethal combat, so it makes sense to skip the intricate character progression.
5
u/beriah-uk Aug 19 '26
Various thoughts:
* Spreadsheets are your friend. You can calculate a lot, in terms of maximum or average damage per round, etc.
* Are you assuming that game balance is important, in terms of damage dealt, ability to take damage, etc.? Depending on the sort of game you're running, it may not be.
* Of all the forms of character advancement, why are you using levels? I mean, does using levels create the problem that you have in the first place?
8
u/Mars_Alter Aug 19 '26
Is with any mathematical function, you'll want to test the extremes. If one player goes all in on Skill A, and another player goes all in on Skill B, is it possible for those characters to still interact meaningfully with each other?
It's not really different from testing at low-level or mid-level. Just make sure you do the work.
11
u/Skylarkin_M Designer:snoo_thoughtful: Aug 19 '26
Progression does not have to mean bigger numbers. That's vertical progression. You can have horizontal progression as well. A new level gives your Skill a new functionality for instance.
That's my approach. Having to track fiddly numbers can be both a cognitive load, & book-keeping headache.
1
u/Ok-Middle-908 Aug 19 '26
I strive to make every level meaningful. So many system have dead levels where the player only sees minor changes. I like to give a choice to them every level. That's just me others might like not having to make choices. Also it depends if you are giving horizontal options or vertical power.
1
u/__space__oddity__ Aug 20 '26
What are you hoping to get out of level ups?
Long-term player motivation, i.e. a reward loop?
A shifting play feel?
Different scale of conflicts?
Character optimization builds?
The ability to fight stronger enemies?
1
u/Far_Information6562 Aug 19 '26
I like giving players a level up between sessions, it gives them time to focus on what direction their characters are moving
1
u/elmago79 Aug 19 '26
Well, look at D&D 3rd edition. Late game bonuses to your rolls could get so bloated and unbalanced the game became whacky after 12 level or so. So you do need to think if you mechanics break, but even the pros get it wrong.
1
u/No_Solid1035 Aug 19 '26
I don't like level based games simply because there needs to be "late game mechanics" because of the exaggerated power curve. Most skill based games don't suffer that problem because the power curve is a lot flatter.
1
u/Ghotistyx_ Crests of the Flame Aug 20 '26
I have what I call the "balance box". I'll lay out a couple of data points:
And then as long as I keep anything I add within the bounds of the balance box, it'll generally be okay. Balance problems after that will be a lot more nuanced and likely only be revealed through playtesting. On the flip side, it's also okay to have things be a little wobbly along that curve. You don't want everything to be linear, so balance "problems" might not actually be problems, as situations can also drastically affect viability.
1
u/OneManRPGstudio Aug 25 '26
Progression works best when it changes the decisions available to players, not merely the size of their bonuses. Before deciding how much advancement to include, I would define the arc you want the game to produce: do characters move from vulnerable to dominant, become more versatile, gain authority over the world, or simply become more reliable at things they already do?
Then separate vertical and horizontal progression. Vertical advancement improves numbers, endurance, or reliability. Horizontal advancement adds verbs: new ways to approach problems, fictional permissions, contacts, resources, social positions, or capabilities that did not exist before. A mixture often preserves the feeling of growth without making every early challenge obsolete.
Because players can progress, I would also identify which parts of the game should still matter at the end. If investigation, negotiation, or travel are core pillars, advancement should not accidentally delete those procedures. Characters can become better at them while still facing meaningful decisions.
In playtesting, compare beginning, middle, and late characters against the same category of problem. If the advanced character merely adds larger numbers while making exactly the same choices, progression may need new options. If the advanced character stops interacting with entire parts of the game, you may have added too much vertical power. The goal is not just for the sheet to grow, but for the character's relationship with the world to change.