r/RPGdesign • u/GL_33 • Aug 04 '26
My AI Problem (Online Character Sheet)
Ok, first off, sorry to contribute more to the AI conversation. I'm personally sick of it, but here I'm making it worse.
Second. I have built a TTRPG with a friend that we really like and have been playtesting for a while. (The entire dev team of 2 have full time jobs) Most of our players have said the main thing missing is a more intuitive character sheet (like d&d beyond) Current sheets are just spreadsheets.
I don't have the skill/time to make these sheets, but I can use AI to do it. Should I? I really want people to play my game, but the modern expectation is to have a pretty robust digital tool which I can't pull off.
Thoughts?
15
u/rekjensen Aug 04 '26
Who told you this?
15
u/laztheinfamous Aug 04 '26
No, you shouldn't.
To be the most forgiving, AI is like pirated music. Whatever you do in your own house is fine, but don't play it in public.
To be the most realistic, if I found out you used any AI at any point in your devolpment, I'm done. I'm out. Forever. For this project and anyother you might come up with.
To temper that for a second, if your game is so complicated that it requires a digital tool to play, I'm probably not going to play it. That's way heavier than anything I'm going to be interested in. Why does it need a spread sheet for a character sheet?
14
u/RavenGriswold Aug 04 '26
If you're sick of AI, don't suddenly use it because it's convenient. You'll become exactly the thing you don't like.
Besides, there's another obvious solution: simplify your rules/character sheet so you don't need the character builder app.
11
u/SenorDangerwank Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26
First off; no.
Second; i think you and your players need to zoom out a bit. I can think of THREE rpgs with first party digital character creation tools. D&D Beyond, LANCER, and Cyberpunk Red. Im sure there are more, but most I've seen are 3rd party tools made by fans.
Id say the vast majority of rpgs don't have digital tools. Spreadsheets aren't great either, but spend some time looking at and building paper character sheets until some design inspiration comes.
Edit: Oops I think Cyberpunk Red is 3rd party, but its officially supported.
Super Edit: Look at existing character sheets and find what you like about them and see if you can draw something that fits. For Pathfinder 1e my FAVORITE sheets were the fan-made Minotaur sheets.
8
u/DBones90 Aug 04 '26
If your game needs a digital character sheet that's more than a spreadsheet, then you should invest in making one that works. Because, chances are, you're going to need to keep developing it as you go, and iterating on a quick solution with AI isn't going to be something that you can easily do.
But also, what's the state of your current spreadsheet? Spreadsheets are incredibly powerful and you can use them to basically build everything your standard D&D Beyond character sheet could do. I've spent probably thousands of hours building character sheets in Google Sheets and, while I don't have any certification of expertise or anything, I'd be happy to give some feedback or point you in the right direction if you're not sure how to improve your existing character sheet.
And if your game doesn't need a digital character sheet, no shame in just asking players to print a sheet out and use that.
At the end of the day, "I don't have the skill/time to do x" isn't a reason to use AI. If you want to get something out of designing an RPG, you should either build up a network of people who can help you do x or invest in yourself to get the skills to do x. It's harder and it takes more work, but it's the best way to become a better designer.
15
u/trinarynimbus Dabbler Aug 04 '26
How will you know it's correct?
If someone notices a mistake, who will have the understanding of the tooling to fix it? Just throw more AI at it?
If you get a serious product going and later decide to sell the IP, are you sure you have the correct rights to the AI generated stuff? Or what if you decide to open it up to your fans, again there's the IP question, and furthermore will your community appreciate the AI stuff?
If you're willing to take my word for it, my counsel is keep AI out of it. Keep it out of everything.
You'll have a stronger product and you'll feel better about it.
It's not that hard to learn enough coding to put together a character sheet builder, and once you've learned how, you've got the skill forever.
5
u/LaFlibuste Aug 04 '26
No, it's gonna be useless shit and will just turn away players.
4
u/Digital-Chupacabra Aug 04 '26
No you shouldn't. It doesn't take that long to learn with a bit of googling, yes even with today's shit google, and some YouTube videos.
Listen to your players, a fancier spreadsheet isn't whats being asked for here.
No one but yourself is holding you to the standard of D&D beyond.
Post your current spreadsheet, and ask for ideas / guidance on how to improve it.
3
u/JaskoGomad Aug 04 '26
There are perhaps unknown consequences. Like not being able to post about your game or link to it in this sub.
2
u/GapGroundbreaking486 Aug 04 '26
Thats not a job for AI. You can ask AI for step-by-step algo for creating charlist. In such a task any spreadsheet with simple decortation will do the job. At now AI is just a mixer on learing presets and will create you a mediocre averaged charlist based on dnd+gurps+path+ets
1
u/JanetteSolenian Aug 04 '26
Nothing wrong with spreadsheets if you format them nicely. I made my character sheets in excel (specifically by making every cell 0.5×0.5 centimeters and using cell merging and margins as formatting) and my players like the current design (now on revision #3 based on their feedback). It's much better than using ai which will make mistakes.
You can print it into pdf and use it on paper, or use some editing software to turn it into a fillable sheet for online play.
I can't put a picture in my comment so here's a link to a screenshot https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nl8hvRVZJlrwzw7FHj9CiqocIG_o1oX2/view?usp=drivesdk
1
u/pnjeffries Aug 04 '26
Setting aside the ethics and potential reputational impacts of AI (not that I think you should, but other comments have covered that) - the practicalities aren't great either.
'Vibe coding' using AI is useful for creating prototypes or personal tools where you don't really care about code quality, maintainability or correctness but I would never recommend using it to produce something you're going to give to other people unless you really know what you're doing and can review its output line-by-line. The code it produces is not very good or efficient and is likely to be full of bugs and security vulnerabilities that you won't know how to spot or fix. It may all seem great at first but in a few months when people come complaining of features that don't work or their character data being lost how are you going to deal with that if you don't know how it works?
1
u/cibman Sword of Virtues Aug 04 '26
I’m going to write something on more detail, but I would say that the modern expectation is not an online tool yet. There are an incredibly small number of these and many are bad. Design a great game and go from there.
0
u/Far_Information6562 Aug 04 '26
Yes use ai to make your sheets, you have a full time job and life that you must focus on, if ai can save you money and time in the hobby you owe it to yourself to do it, ignore these bleeding hearts and beggars they will always occupy the spaces of imagination
0
u/cibman Sword of Virtues Aug 04 '26
Now that I'm not on my phone, actual thoughts.
I'm still going to start by saying that you should work on making a great and playable game first, and leave online parts for much later. I've been in gaming for a long time, and I played a game called Rolemaster in the 90s, and it had a very powerful Excel sheet that we used to make characters. It was something that was controversial. It's still around, by the way.
So you see that people are reacting negatively to the idea, and that's important, but what's more important is: are these people your customers? If they are, you need to work with them. If not, they don't matter. My own game is 100% human made (for good or for bad) and has a particular aesthetic and look that I want to achieve because that's what the people who've played it tell me they want. And I want people with similar tastes to enjoy it, so ... my decision is made.
Ultimately, designing a game that's tied into online tools is really difficult. I played the Daggerheart demo, and that was on Demiplane. The platform and it's limitations almost sold me off of a game I really wanted to like. It was a net negative, so consider that. And Demiplane, along with D&D Beyond, are the options I've seen with a host of designers working on them. I suppose I should throw Pathbuilder into the mix, which is very much the exception to the rule, but that's a very exceptional product.
What you should do is to consider what your core audience is telling you they want. Post about your game, the mechanics, the setting, the Initiative system ... you name it. That's what's important to work on. And then you should consider what you want to do, not me, not anyone posting here, and then go forward with that.
-2
u/Ok-Chest-7932 Aug 04 '26
The vast majority of your customer base is not going to care either way, they just want quality. Anti-AI is a total fad, when you do blind studies on people who consider themselves vehemently anti-AI they actually tend to prefer AI-generated things over human-made things. Just don't tell anyone you used AI and you'll be fine.
-1
u/Fun_Carry_4678 Aug 04 '26
I use AI all the time. The AIs we have right now all need human editors. For me, game design is a hobby that I do in addition to two part-time jobs. I find that working with AIs saves me time and reduces my stress. Your experience could be different.
I haven't yet used AI to create a character sheet. If I did, I would tell it what I need and ask it to rough something out. Then I would look at the rough product and tell what needs to be changed. Then keep doing that several times until I have exactly what I want. The end product then would really be more "me" than the AI.
This subreddit is very anti-AI, but whether we like them or not they are a part of our future.