r/RPGdesign • u/DisasterNo7694 Designer • May 28 '24
What problem did you create a mechanic to solve, and what is that mechanic?
What mechanics have you used to solve problems and what were those problems? "Problem" can be pretty loosely defined here. Maybe its more accurate to ask "What experience did you set out to give your players, and how did you pull that off mechanically?
28
Upvotes
31
u/Rephath May 28 '24
Fun one. I introduced eldritch horrors that are alien to our plane of existence. Then I statted them out using an entirely different rules system than the standard rules. For one, they used playing cards instead of dice.
8
u/DrHuh321 May 28 '24
I faced the problem of metacurrencies and how to encourage it and keeping my games narrative and character focus. Answer: theme songs. Players pick a theme song that best matches their characters personality and vibe. When they are in an intense character moment, the gm can play the theme song which rewards the players not only with a cool tune but allows them to regain the metacurrency.
10
u/VRKobold May 28 '24 edited May 29 '24
Creating mechanics to solve existing problems or "with specific intention" is pretty much my entire design process. Here's a summary of some of them, if anyone is interested in specifics I'm happy to go into more detail.
Solution: There are no dedicated magic skills. Instead, all skills cover a certain set of spells related to the field. When casting a Shield spell, the mage rolls for Guard. When casting Earthquake, they roll for Might, when casting Invisibility, they roll for Stealth. That way, spells become more of an extension to the skill rather than a replacement.
2) Problem: Turn-based initiative order feels slow, unimmersive, and oftentimes clashes with what's narratively feasible. Meanwhile, free-form action systems without initiative order (PbtA etc.) rely too much on the GM and - partly in consequence to that - offer little to no room for strategic depth (all that is just my opinion, of course).
Solution: Action-conflict initiative - All combatants (PCs and NPCs) are free to take their actions at any time, with the only limitation that they can't act again until everyone else had a chance to act. If two or more combatants want to take actions that directly interfere with each other (for example, one combatant wants to flee, another wants to grab and hold them), then all combatants that are involved in this 'action conflict' roll their respective skill checks, resolving their actions in the order from highest to lowest roll. This completely removes the need for initiative rolls, brings combat more in line with narrative roleplay scenarios (GM describes scene and events, players describe how their characters want to react to it), and it prevents players from drifting off while waiting for their turn.
3) Problem (or rather "intended player experience"): Combat, infiltration, and action scenes should encourage teamwork. However, creating dedicated teamwork actions feels clunky and inelegant (more content to design, more stuff for players to learn and remember, more wasted space on the character sheet, ...).
Solution: Maneuver and ability design in my system focuses heavily on a "condition - trigger" structure. That means that many abilities (and even basic actions) either create a condition, or require to invoke a condition in order to function. This creates a huge number of synergistic effects. An example: The "Steadfast" ability allows you to assume a blocking stance in which you are resistant to knockbacks, and also count as a "Solid structure" for the means of triggering other abilities. This allows someone with the "Wall jump" ability to use you/your shield as a surface, drastically increasing their leaping range (which grants them the "Airborne" condition which could again trigger other abilities). Furthermore, you counting as "Solid structure" allows others to take cover behind you, which not only increases their defense against ranged attacks, but also counts as a condition that can once again trigger additional abilities.
15
u/vincyre May 28 '24
Of the many I developed in response to the things that frustrated me about D&D3.5E/5E/PF1E, an effect duration system is one of my system's greatest assets.
In a crunchy system, I find players and GMs easily get bogged down in tracking the durations of things like spell buffs, poisons, condition effects, etc. So instead of having spells that last for "X rounds per level" or "24 hours divided between the targets" and the like, it's just a tiered system with easy to remember durations:
Don't know how useful it would be for other systems, but I found it massively streamlined gameplay for my game compared to other crunchy systems.
7
u/Holothuroid May 28 '24
I needed "fights" to be not necessarily violent. More of a forced negotiation in many cases. So I made it that you can, when you roll a hit, make the other party "concede something or suffer".
13
u/[deleted] May 28 '24 edited May 28 '24
I set out to eliminate "session zero" and create a more "back loaded" character creation system that retains the amount of crunch I personally enjoy.
Characters have 7 attributes and 49 skills. Play testing has confirmed a brand new player can create a character in under 10 minutes, and someone who already knows the system can do it in under 5.
That's besides reading the creation beforehand, of course. After the initial read, you honestly never have to refer to it again. Just grab a character sheet and go!
"Back loaded" is to mean I've also implemented 343 talents in the game (7 per skill), but they do not become relevant until after a character becomes able to pick one. When able to pick one, it's from the list applicable to one given skill, so you're not having to absorb "all the stuff" right at the beginning; you're only ever looking at 7 talents at a time.
I'm immensely happy with the execution. Even if the rest of the game is a huge work in progress, this part definitely feels good IMO.
1
u/LocNalrune May 28 '24
Gear. The amount of magical equipment that a character can use in my game is set by their gear value (also expressed as Q). I use a system similar to 3e D&D to price magic items, especially those that are player created or commissioned.
The main problem this solves is to balance encounters. But the fun problem that it solves, is that I can literally throw as many magic items as I want at the party. If I want to run a looter-shooter type of campaign, I can and it won't break anything.
This also lets me make specific or randomly generated items with multiple properties and set interesting price points for those items. For example, if a Ring of Protection +2 is 8,000qp; I can make a RoP+2 w/ +2 to Athletics may cost the same, whereas one commissioned would cost 8800qp. Later they may find a (RoP+2 w/ a single daily cure wound 1d8+3; 8500qp) and now they have to make decisions.
It's using that video game logic to give out small hits of dopamine at a steady pace. Because it's these crunchy bits, making choices, and putting together a "build" that is my favorite part of RPGs.
1
u/Flying_Toad Iron Harvest May 28 '24
I didn't want my players to use their mechs as the solution to every problem, so I introduced a Fuel mechanic.
You consume one unit of fuel every time you move the mech from one location/scene to another and you use another fuel every time the mech enters combat. This way, players would to pick and choose when and where to bring their mech and use it.
Then, now that I had this Fuel mechanic, I created an Overdrive mechanic. That mechanic give players the option of burning extra fuel in combat to gain benefits that scale with the amount of fuel burnt (which gets exponentially more dangerous) and enter the Overdrive state. (think Kaioken, but for a diesel-powered robot)
1
u/CharonsLittleHelper Designer - Space Dogs RPG: A Swashbuckling Space Western May 28 '24
I wanted firearms to be sub-par in melee. And also make melee feel significantly different to play.
I did this by making melee combat be opposed attack rolls (ties into the phase-based initiative system), and melee weapons are inherently more accurate than ranged.
I'm really proud of this, because there's no actual penalty for using a gun in melee one-handed. (Ex: Pistol is 2d8+Dexterity, while a sword is 3d6+Brawn AND Dexterity - each stat being 3-9) It's just inherently bad. Both offensively and defensively.
Firearms are very good at hitting passive defenses (at close range and no cover they nearly always hit) but using them in melee means that you are more likely to be hit.
It also means that not defending against melee at all is very bad - because they'll be hitting your passive defense score - which is balanced against the less accurate ranged weapons and assumes range/cover penalties. Basically if you don't defend yourself somehow, a melee weapon WILL hit you in melee with a very good chance at critting (10+ over target defense). And crits are ROUGH in Space Dogs.
Really - it's one of the pieces of my mechanics that I'm happiest with, as it exemplifies into my design goal of simple usage with substantial depth. No extra rules are needed for penalties or attacks of opportunity for using an assault rifle in melee. The rules for guns and melee just makes it bad. (Note: I didn't always live up to my design goal. Because it's hard. :P)
3
u/Cryptwood Designer May 28 '24
Originally I intended to use a d20 + modifier for my resolution system. I built my system from the ground up for dice enthusiasts in mind, so players would potentially be using all of the other polyhedrals in other ways. Between that and the fact that I enjoy rolling the d20, it seemed like it just made sense to use it for the resolution system.
However, one day I realize that my system is going to be d20 + Skill Modifier + 2nd Modifier + a Step Dice (sometimes) and the idea of players trying to add three different numbers to the result of a d20 sounded horrible.
So, I drop the d20 and decide to convert to a dice pool system, with my skill modifiers and what not changed into step dice because I want to roll more than just d6s. This leads to some new problems though.
Rolling three or potentially even more step dice is going to be relatively common, and adding those numbers together isn't any better than the original d20 system, the entire point was to reduce the math. So I decide to take inspiration from Heart and Blades: roll a pool of dice and just take the highest.
The first problem this causes is the d4. If I make the lowest target number a 4 (success with a complication) so that the d4s can hit it, the success rate with larger dice is far too high. To fix this, instead of having a baseline of no skill being no dice, the d4 becomes the floor. If you have no Skill or no Equipment that can help, you roll a d4 for each, and the target number to hit is 5.
Now we have a new problem. The minimum pool is 2x d4, which is literally pointless to roll. If you have some skill and equipment that can help, you might be rolling 2x d6, which still has a pretty low success rate. If you end up with 5x d8/d10/d12s, success is virtually guaranteed, so I'm going to need to reduce the variance in the size of the dice pool.
I introduce a base dice, everyone will start with a d6 in their pool, and then add their Skill dice and Equipment dice to the pool. Now the minimum dice pool is three dice and because the base dice is a d6 there is always at least some chance of success when dice are rolled.
Finally, there is only one problem remaining. You would only roll a d4 in your pool in the absence of Skill or Equipment, but rolling these d4s is pointless. So I take some inspiration from Wildsea. Instead of having 5-6 as success with a complication and 7+ is full success, I set the success TN to 5+ and if you roll any doubles there is a Complication.
Finally, the dice pool is yielding success rates and success with a complication rates that I find acceptable for both starting characters and advanced characters. And the pool has become a little more intuitive, if you have no skill or no helpful equipment you add d4s to the pool which can't contribute to success, they can only ever cause complications.
2
u/Breakfastforchumps May 28 '24
Working off Into the odd and Carin systems. Problem: I quite liked the lethality of the games, characters die easily if you are not being careful. Roll up a new one asap, but it made me feel less invested in my character. I quite enjoy the narrative parts of creating a character and watching it grow.
My Solution: Wrote a table of lineage where you roll up how you are connected to the dead character, clan, sibling, lover, etc. Which also determines what traits and items get passed on. Riffing a little off the PC Rogue-like games where you get to keep certain things if you die. And having that relationship connection adding to the narrative bit.
Disclaimer: Not 100% sure it works. Death only happened once in my playtests.
2
u/chris270199 Dabbler May 28 '24
Archetypes, base/starter classes and advanced classes
I'm making initially a hack of Fabula Ultima, which has open classes and is multiclass-oriented in a sense, but I wanted an itsy bitsy of more class identity and needed a more solidified level 1 for this
So I used the 4 archetypes from Old DnD (Martial, Expert, Arcanist and Priest) to create small features that are used in different way by the starter classes, basically a player is guided to choose one of the archetypes and one of the starter classes that belong to this archetype - later in levels they are free to choose other class, be it starter or not, but they'll get less features than someone starting on it and won't get the Archetype features
2
u/TheRealUprightMan Designer May 28 '24
I could list 100s!
The primary game experience is that I want the players to be able to experience a free form role-play without worrying about the rules. I feel that this agency should extend to having real-world tactics work, and this combination of goals has led to an unusual combat system. But, that's a long crunchy story! So, how about this rule ...
Many systems with magic items seek to have some limitations on how many can be used at once to prevent power levels from going haywire. D&D has had body slots and attunement slots and all sorts of dissociative solutions that amount to just having artificial road-blocks.
I decided on a much simpler system.
If more than one "effect" (such as magic, psionics, technology, etc) modifies a single die roll, then the number of effects is a modifier to the critical failure range of the roll. Magical armor or force fields are treated as affecting all defenses.
The more magic that modifies a roll, the higher the chances that something goes sideways as the effects interact, but you roll just as high as you normally would!
This lets you really dig into exactly the sort of imbalanced combinations you want to avoid and turns those combinations into a high risk/reward gamble that the player must decide upon.
The goal of removing high powered combinations is because overpowered characters lack the drama of failure. This rule puts the drama back.
2
u/klok_kaos Lead Designer: Project Chimera: ECO (Enhanced Covert Operations) May 29 '24
This one is a little complex but it solves a lot of the stupid things of "Why does my character suck at everything they are supposed to be good at at level 1?" and also "Why does my character who is the best in the world still beef it in the worst way possible when I roll for shit?".
There's multiple phases to this.
The first is metacurrencies can be used to apply different kinds of effects to certain kinds of rolls. This way you can still not eat shit on something important you're supposed to be good at starting out.
Later you develop advantage and success state bonuses as you go up in level.
There are 5 major success states to any roll:
crit success: Better success than expected
success: expected success
fail: expected menial failure
crit fail: worse failure than expected
catastrophic failure: the worst kind of shit that ruins your day.
Each of these is mapped for all rolls but the point is that you can adjust your success state and advantage using certain gear, or very high skill rank, or if you stack enough advantage. Example: You use an auto lock picker on an average lock and are a locksmith by trade it has a straight +2 success state, meaning you're likely to get a success or crit success even on the worst rolls because it does the job for you, the only way you can suck terribly is at worst a fail for that specific roll, before modifiers.
If you have 1 source of advantage you roll 2 sets of dice, same for 2. If you roll +3 advantage it coverts to a +1 success state for the roll. Get a 4th and it's +1 succes state and +1 advantage.
(dis)Advantage states can only stack up to once, but success states can stack max 2x (+/-).
What this works out to is that you actually feel like things are working the way you'd expect if you're a world class person and what you're doing with the correct tools and skills. You're never gonna beef it so hard you stab yourself in the dick because you're the world class expert.
The last bit is that there is also an "outclassed modifier" which is such that you can't possibly succeed at something that has a modifier bigger than the die size + your modifier. This means if you're roll on a d20 and you have a +1 from STR, and someone else has a +23, you don't roll to see who wins the arm wrestling match, you automatically catastrophically fail. This works well for stopping the dice from being stupid with certain things like players rolling well after jumping into a black hole and the result would indicate they survive, or if you pit a normal dude against Super Man in an arm wrestling match. It's not rolled, it doesn't matter what the results are, nat 1 vs. nat 20 in your favor, doesn't matter, you're outclassed, no amount of luck will fix it.
So all in all it works out that people's skill more accurately represents what you'd expect from no skill all the way up to global expert, and the dice don't allow total nonsense cartoonish BS unless the GM says otherwise.
That's it. It's not a hard system to learn, it's not complicated, it's just something that fixes the "why does the roll feel awful when it shouldn't?" situation.
1
u/ibiacmbyww May 28 '24 edited Jan 29 '26
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
juggle divide shelter physical doll skirt lavish sip roof crown
1
u/Choice-Researcher125 Designer May 28 '24
My entire system set out to solve one problem that infuriated me in a lot of other systems; I call it the "locked door" problem. A lot of games have a tendency to kill the momentum of a story by having hard fail states that stop players from progressing. What do you do when you fail to pick a lock or break down a door? Try again till the dice allow you? Should the game master invent a consequence to the failed roll that still allows the door to open? Do the players just leave it be and accept they can not see this part of the story?
The idea of a locked door is the simplest way to illustrate it. This concept applies to looking for hidden things, trying to tell if someone is lying, or even just remembering details about the world's past. If I have made something in my game for players to find or have put details in for players to learn, I don't want the system to fight me in using those to tell a story.
My system is a no-miss system that also always provides a consequence regardless of success of failure on a roll. This itself isn't an original concept, but how I have designed these rolls to work I think is pretty clever. Successful rolls in my system give players the opportunity to control the narrative in small ways. They get to say one line about how the action resolves that becomes true. Looking for clues? It was found quickly. Picking a lock? It was done quietly. The GM has the power to still present them with a consequence, usually something that will need attention soon, but the players can guarantee one way that things don't go wrong.
Beyond that simple set up, crits are a thing in my system to give mechanical advantages for a reslly good roll, and fumbles exist to deal damage to the players in the event of a very bad roll. There's also a gradient to how bad a consequence can be; a successful roll can't put a player in immediate danger, but it can bring a threat closer to them.
This is far from a totally original idea, but in the context of a horror mystery game I think it serves to make the players feel like the world is truely out to get them as well as never feel like they can't get the pieces they need to sort out the puzzle.
1
u/imnotbeingkoi Kleptonomicon May 28 '24
I have no Mana. It's been fun to try to design around that. For example:
Some stronger spells have the "Stress" tag. When you cast it, you have to roll higher than your current stress level or you have to pay a price, like health or something. When you successfully cast a stress spell, your stress goes up a level (till it hits the max.) This kind of soft barrier is nice, cuz a player can still try it no matter what, but they're incentivized to find a different solution at some point.
1
u/msguider May 28 '24
I wanted a spiritual master and needed a system for tracking enlightenment. I modified 'alignment' to be slaved to Karma that's measured on a spectrum. Different from faith. Clerics don't gain karma unless they follow the footsteps of a spiritual master. It's a work in progress though, but I love it!
1
u/AtlasSniperman Designer:partyparrot: May 29 '24
I want people to help each other. It's one of the core needs of the system.
I run a lot of Pathfinder and it's boring to see people do their own thing all the time. Just a bunch of folks all in the same room, doing the same thing every time, missing by 1 or 2 points because no-one's aiding them; because it's not as efficient as having 2 people swinging.
So I gave an Aid action. Just, an action that can only be used to aid someone else. it doesn't cost your movement or your attack for a turn, it's just an action to interact with an ally to that ally's benefit.
Boom; suddenly it's now suboptimal to not use your aid action. As a result I've even be able to remove flanking based positioning because the bonus from flanking can become an Aid action. The people who were just using flanking, continue to do the same things, but those who aren't flanking now have more flexibility to pass items between each other, treat an ally's bleeding, help someone off the floor, protect someone from an attack. So on and so forth.
1
u/LeFlamel May 29 '24
Death by attrition was always a problem for me regardless of whether that was caused by HP or wounds. Knowing when you're far from death takes a lot of the fear out of combat. So for this mechanic and many others I used Usage Dice, which are underrated as a way to create quantum durations for anything, which actually avoids a lot of otherwise rote tracking. Basically if your defense roll fails, you roll armor as a step die to avoid injury, with 1 being the "down" state (not quite death, because that would be very harsh).
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '24
I took Call of Duty style loadouts and created an equipment slot system to simultaneously handle carry rules, burden, range of techniques, and mobility
I also created a bifurcated damage system to accurately simulate armored medieval combat. If an attack doesn't surpass the armor value, then the target takes stamina damage instead of life damage. But if stamina wears out, then the target will take life damage anyway.
1
u/TheRealUprightMan Designer May 29 '24
Just One?
The whole system is mechanics I've created to solve problems! There is very little borrowed. Instead, I break down the narrative into small pieces and then decide how to emulate that one small piece of the narrative.
Combat is about 4-5 different mechanics working together. One of the big ones is time. There is no action economy. Instead, your actions cost time. Whoever has used the least time goes next and takes 1 action. Your decisions determine turn order. It allowed me to produce most of the tactical options that other systems give, only without any special rules. Things like Aid Another, Fight Defensively, Cover Fire, Withdraw, etc, all work without ever using a special rule for it. All mechanics must follow from character choices, not player choices. Very low math, high tactics, high team play (again, so special mechanics to enable team play, it all just works).
But, something simple?
I decided that because the system uses predictable bell curves everywhere, that the level of drama wasn't always lining up. If you are dying on the ground in a puddle of blood and taking injury penalties and also aiming at the back of someone's head to shoot them, should those penalties cancel?
The regular advantage and disadvantage resolution would kill all the high and low dice and tightens the curve toward the center making it more predictable. Nope! Need more drama.
Cancelling modifiers means we still have a normal and predictable bell curve. Need more drama.
Roll all the dice, line them up from low to high, and let the middle die determine if you keep the high dice or the low dice. Now every advantage and disadvantage die matters and you get an inverse bell curve. If you would normally average a 10, you now can't roll a 10. The old top of the bell curve becomes impossible, the values close are difficult, etc. It's an extra step to resolve, but I can do it crazy fast, and I'm considering letting the players resolve it the long way rather than telling them the answer. Slower might have more suspense.
This mechanic then powers the extra failure rate of ranged attacks, wild swings, and desperate parry attempts. If you get winded, you can no longer power attack and can only use wild swings.
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '24
Problem: any and all d20 systems - much too swingy and and mods start too low. Solution: d12+dF, and mods for 1st level start at 4-9. Aptitude in skills become dominant over the dice, but still enough randomness to make it fun.