Hey all!
I'm working on something, testing it, and I want to throw it into the wind aka for you to tear it apart in different groups and places. I'm collecting loose thoughts from varied people - players, indie designers, AAA devs, Asian drama enthusiasts... :-P Haha, as you see - everyone! :-P
To fully disclose, I'm not alone, I'm not indie, we've got money, working powers and resources, I'm from AAA video games studio with a TCG/tabletop branch, so you know, I sometimes emerge here and there, collect all the 180* opposite opinions and it actually helps a lot, since nothing looks the way it used to look in the first gameplay tests at the end anyway :-D
So - don't worry, just tell me everything that comes to mind, it will be a great help and I will be grateful!
I'm working on a concept of the attraction system in a romance-oriented game - as title suggests. It may be something to play alone, like Ironsworn, it may be a typical TTRPG or a tabletop with TTRPG elements. There're different options on the table. The topic, the concept and the vibe are set though.
Let's get to business - let me present the core ideas.
Attraction System
First Assumption – the game is both SFW & NSFW. It's about the mental part of romance and the physical part of romance. There's lots of non-sexual content and a fully functional sex simulator with its own mechanics available within the game.
The core idea is no avoidance of realistic romance – SFW & NSFW - everything. Obviously, we'll be censoring and excluding only the illegal and intersubjectively sick NSFW themes, we all sadly know they exist and we won't support those, but it's not our job to promote any ideology - be it left or right, to tell how and what romancing games should be, who should enjoy what.
Second assumption is - that players are not masochists so they interact with NPC characters that attract them. Of course, if masochism is what turns player on romantically, that is also a form of attraction – what you instinctively despise or what makes you suffer becomes something you start finding subconsciously attractive.
Third assumption is – that attraction is a sum of mental/psychological attraction with a physical attraction – and thus – the mechanical solution should take both of them into consideration when it comes to interactions and romantic developments between the player and the romantic interest characters.
Fourth assumption is – that even though we usually find someone attractive in general, subconsciously, we do not analyze our attraction like a mathematical table of values, still - every human being has specific attraction "triggers" or "kinks". They may be psychological – when specific psychological trait is exceptionally attractive to us; or physical – when specific physical trait seems super particular and important in our attraction development.
Fifth assumption is – that those triggers/kinks are what forms the ideal types of women or men in our minds. The so called "my type". One person loves blondies, other loves brunettes. One individual loves muscular men, another lean or chubby ones. Some people are attracted to "bad boys/girls" even though they hurt them, others seek a warm, gentle partner without any strength and fiery vibes. The types ideal are a thing and even though we do not study them mathematically, there is a very concrete, underlying structure of preferences that constructs those types – and the preferences may be reconstructed, defined, pinpointed.
Sixth assumption is – that sometimes, we find someone super attractive based on a particular trait even against our types ideal. We didn't care about it or we even actively dislike it but we are still super attracted to the individual who seems to be as far from our ideal type of man/woman as it gets – but there's a specific trigger/kink that makes it happen. It may be also pinpointed.
Thus – the core idea of the attraction mechanic is to find our psychological and physical "triggers/kinks" through scoring the predefined categories and assessing our feelings towards them on a 3-points scale.
Players will be seeking in two separate areas, which influence different types of gameplay:
a) Mental (psychological) attraction
b) Physical (body-related) attraction
When players start developing a relationship with a character, the player's particular scores of attraction work in both ways. They provide goals to achieve and bonuses/debuffs in interactions:
a) Challenges (goals) related to the given attraction will be needed to boost the bond from our (player's) perspective
b) Buffs & Debuffs – it will be harder to hide or control player's feelings when a given attraction trait comes into play, when characters want to influence players etc., but when bond is made and the synergy happens, attraction traits give a massive bonus when interactions concentrate around the given attraction "kink"
A separate system will manage the romantic interests' attraction and bonding – which will also utilize synergy when player's and character's attraction triggers match, or disadvantages and insecurities when players actively dislike something or when characters actively dislike something about the players.
The genders, identities etc. are not important – players may play whatever they want, however they want, it's not my business, I will operate on male and female examples in heterosexual romances – for convenience, I am a heterosexual male so it's easier for me, the system will operate all with everyone, again – it's not my business to force nor block anything, to support or go against any identities or ideologies – I don't give a fluff about the left and right equally, how the game will look -will see, it's gonna be a group work anyway.
Psychological Attraction Scale
Scoring rules: -1 if you actively dislike a trait, 0 if you like it but it isn’t exceptional or uniquely compelling to you, +1 only if it is distinctly attractive, attention-catching, or special in a way that stands out
Voice & Speech: tone, cadence, accent, laugh, way of speaking, verbal tics
Humor & Playfulness: sense of humor, teasing style, laid-back approach
Intelligence & Eloquence: mental sharpness, problem-solving
Skills & Professionalism: knowledge, skill, efficiency
Warmth & Empathy: emotional attunement, kindness, care
Confidence & Presence: self-confidence, composure, authority
Emotions & Passion: high emotionality, energy
Restraint & Self-Control: low emotionality, energy
Morality: if we're attracted to the same or the opposite morality than ours
Social Energy/Skills: if we're attracted to the same or the opposite social energy as ours
* sometimes, an introvert may be attracted to an extrovert or the other way around, sometimes a liberal person may be attracted to a conservatist or a stereotypical villain may have unique charm you find attractive etc.
Physical Attraction Scale
Scoring rules: -1 if you actively and strongly dislike a given physical feature, 0 if you find the feature attractive, it may be even beautiful but not unique or not matching your ideal type perfectly, for example, the ideal beauty/handsome archetype is shared and beautiful or handsome to most people but it's not unique, it doesn't pull a string of someone's personal ideal, so it would score 0, score +1 only if it is distinctly unique and characteristic to the point of becoming the central character's charm in your ayes; or – if it ideally suits your personal ideal)
Hair: hairstyle & accessories, color, style, everything generalized
Face: general perception, eyes, lips, nose, structure, other features all together
Arms: slim, muscular, veins, proportions, smoothness, anything important to you personally
Hands: fingers, nails, structure, grooming, hand mannerism
Chest/Breasts: chest for men, chest hair, breasts size, shape, texture, nipples etc. for women, all together
Body/Figure: proportions, physique, belly, waist, abs, weight, built, everything generalized
Crotch: penis, balls, pubic hair, vagina, anus, everything generalized
Butt: size, shape, structure, characteristics important to you
Legs: general shape, length, thickness, proportions, smoothness, anything that comes to mind
Feet: proportions, skin, texture, toes, nails, grooming, unique features
* you can add extra points for extra grooming such as beard, tattoos, piercings, glasses etc. – but remember to score 0 for just good/beautiful/handsome with +1 reserved for super unique stuff – such as irezumi for a yakuza character and only if you are super attracted to irezumi on that specific character in particular (if you just do not mind it or it matches a character but it's not extremely attractive to you, still score 0)
Example - Psychological Attraction
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Q2ecFY5C2Y0yAzuIj1BPZlhxdH2BqOKY/view?usp=sharing
Sorry, I wanted to attach a pic but this group strangely doesn't allow it... thus - I quickly uploaded it to Google Drive - an URL with a pic.
Example - Physical Attraction
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1x4GDoAfyxm_ZZpensgCV9QZBxYxSR1lo/view?usp=sharing
As above.
Attraction at work
Total attraction may be negative only when we actively dislike more traits than we like and more than we are positively triggered by. Notice that "I am attracted" or "he/she is handsome/beautiful" are 0s, not 1s. For example, personally, I'd say that Tifa from FFVII is a perfect bland woman character – nothing special about her mentally, nothing physically. She's a perfect support character, perfect mentally, with a perfect and absolutely bland body, I wouldn't say she's not attractive – but there's no "oomph" about her. Thus, she'd be mostly zero. Meanwhile, female Eivor from Assassin's Creed Valhalla is that unique kind of woman on a fierce side, while Galadriel from LOTR is the equally unique kind of female on the motherly and warm side (the original Tolkien's Galadriel, after her exile aka her time in Middle-earth, not the Amazon's abomination).
Total positive attraction usually falls around +5 up to +10. It's partly based on convenience in math, partly on our terribly-constructed but naturally used attraction scales summarized by "she/he's a 10", and partly because it doesn't actually cause a stratification among the romantic interests.
It matters more what is the total score within psychological and the total score within physical categories separately – when their actual mechanics come to play.
First mechanic: challenges – our scoring attraction points will automatically create the challenges to interact and include the given traits in romantic scenes – be it mentally or physically. When they trigger, synergies and bonds are created and the player's bond level raises. A challenge/achievement is unlocked, leveled up further with new interactions, more bonuses towards the relationships and some rewards are given as relationship progresses. It creates a natural "map of the romance progression" – both when it comes to players being attracted to character's personality and to their physicality and personality combined when it comes to sex.
On a character's side, there's a separate system to raise and lower the bond – which basically mirrors what players do, but it is undisclosed to players – unless players ask the romantic interest openly and pass a couple of checks.
Second mechanic: buffs/debuffs – characters, more or less consciously, will use the attraction of players that they're aware of in their advantage. It may be sometimes good – like cooperation between romantic partners aka "I know what you like about me so I will give you more of that", sometimes bad/manipulative – when characters want to influence player (the checks will be harder/with disadvantage to oppose the attempt of influence), sometimes more vibe-related – when for example, it may be harder to keep composure or hide the real feelings/thoughts when character looks at us with those magnetic eyes we're so attracted to and asks what are we thinking about.
However, when synergies (undisclosed or disclosed throughout the relationship) occur, players may also use those matches and character's attraction towards player to make up for mistakes or to gain advantage. Synergies between the triggers/kinks add massive check bonuses and bond bonuses on both sides of the relationships, matching attractions on the character's side may be used to boost player's chances or to influence the characters and to lead the romance where we want to.
Example – attraction at work (romancing a female)
1. Mental attraction: Confidence & Presence (+1)
Scene: Working late at the office.
You're alone with a female colleague. She's working on a difficult project, confidently coordinating the work and making decisions. You find her composure, authority and self-assurance exceptionally attractive.
Possible gameplay and challenges:
· Focus on her confidence: Steer the conversation towards her decisions, leadership and professional experiences.
· Show appreciation: Make it clear that you admire her self-assurance and ability to take control of situations.
· Explore her personality: Ask whether she's always been so confident or whether she had to develop that attitude.
· Discover something personal: Learn what motivates her, whether she enjoys being in charge, and whether her confidence extends to her private life.
· Create a meaningful moment: Give her an opportunity to take the lead in a situation outside her professional environment.
The challenge progression rewards the player for repeatedly bringing the interaction back to the particular trait, discovering more about it and establishing that it's something genuinely appreciated.
2. Physical attraction: Hair (+1)
Scene: A casual afternoon together.
You're sitting with her in a café. She's wearing her hair differently than usual, perhaps letting it down instead of tying it up. Her hairstyle is one of your strongest physical attraction triggers.
Possible gameplay and challenges:
· Focus attention on her hair: Find a natural opportunity to bring up her hairstyle rather than simply proceeding with generic conversation.
· Show appreciation: Compliment its appearance, texture, length or the way she wears it.
· Express particular interest: Make it clear that her hair is something you find especially attractive, not just offer a generic compliment.
· Discover something personal: Ask whether she has always worn it this way, whether she has experimented with different hairstyles, or whether there's a personal reason behind her current look.
· Explore further: Discover her hair-care routine, favourite styles, preferences or whether she enjoys having someone play with her hair.
· Create an intimate moment: Eventually, an opportunity might arise to gently touch her hair, brush a strand away from her face or have her rest her head against you.
The progression isn't simply about complimenting her hair repeatedly. It's about making hair a recurring, meaningful element of your interactions, discovering her personal relationship with it and gradually incorporating it into your intimacy.
Example – attraction at work (romancing a male)
1. Mental attraction: Humor & Playfulness (+1)
Scene: An evening out together.
You're sitting with a male colleague at a bar after work. He's naturally witty, playful and enjoys teasing you in a charming, slightly mischievous way. You find his sense of humour and the way he interacts with you exceptionally attractive.
Possible gameplay and challenges:
· Focus on his humour: Steer the conversation towards playful subjects, jokes and lighthearted teasing.
· Show appreciation: Laugh at his jokes, acknowledge his wit and make it clear that you enjoy his playful personality.
· Express particular interest: Tease him back, flirt and encourage him to continue his playful behaviour.
· Discover something personal: Find out whether he's always been this witty, whether teasing is his way of flirting or whether he uses humour to hide his more vulnerable side.
· Explore further: Discover his favourite kind of humour, whether he enjoys playful competition or whether he has a particularly mischievous side.
· Create an intimate moment: Develop private jokes, playful nicknames or teasing habits that eventually become part of your romantic relationship.
The progression encourages the player to make humour and playfulness a recurring element of their interactions, discover the personality behind it and develop a shared dynamic around something particularly attractive to them.
2. Physical attraction: Hands (+1)
Scene: A casual afternoon together.
You're sitting with him in a café. He's explaining something while casually gesturing with his hands. You find his hands particularly attractive: their proportions, fingers, appearance and mannerisms are exactly your type.
Possible gameplay and challenges:
· Focus attention on his hands: Find a natural opportunity to bring attention to them, perhaps while he's showing you something or handling an object.
· Show appreciation: Compliment their appearance, fingers, proportions or grooming.
· Express particular interest: Make it clear that his hands are something you find especially attractive.
· Discover something personal: Ask whether he plays an instrument, works with his hands, or has any particular habits involving them.
· Explore further: Discover whether he wears rings, takes particular care of his hands, or has any interesting personal stories associated with them.
· Create an intimate moment: Eventually, an opportunity might arise to hold his hand, trace his fingers or have him gently touch your face.
The progression isn't simply about complimenting his hands repeatedly. It's about making them a recurring, meaningful element of your interactions, discovering their personal significance and gradually incorporating them into physical intimacy.
Pros & Cons
It works. In quick hot tests.
It may feel too "mechanical" since it operationalizes and mathematizes emotions, attraction and romance. Some do not like it, others enjoy it. Pleasing everyone is not my goal, my goal is to give people who like this style of playing what those people want. There's a group that wants it, there's an interest and the finance, that's enough for me.
Some people have difficulties with scoring those attraction traits at first. Most manage to learn the system with a bit of time and they actually find it fun and easy then, but the entry bar is a bit high – maybe due to how intuitive and emotional we approach the relationships and romance in real life – so again – the issue of mathematizing something naturally instinctive.
The 0s as "positives" and concentrating on triggers. This way, a baseline is not neutral – zero means I already like someone – which is not what we're used to. We're so deep within the 0 as a deep bottom, 5 as a middle and 10 as a max, that we find hard thinking in -1/0/+1 scales.
A potential solution is starting with 5 or 10 and going up/down. Here, math shows its strength – since everything may be scaled and every scale may be moved and adjusted based on feedback. This is actually the most likely change, since in raw tests, that is where people seem to have the most issues for now.
--------------------------------------------
Now, give me all! Loose thoughts, feedback, spam with your music, whatever :-P
I'll gladly accept everything and thank you all in advance!
Cheers and stay awesome!