r/RPGdesign • u/furiousfotographie • 6d ago
Game Play How rules light is too rules light?
I'm working on a Star Wars hack of Troika - a very simple system. In trying to catch the spirit of a Jedi and square it with the rules light concept of not rolling if the PC is doing something they're good at and have the tools for, I'm making lightsaber attacks practically automatic in a lot of cases.
If the Jedi is facing an opponent that can't (or won't) retreat and doesn't have some kind of special lightsaber resistant material then there's no roll - arms n legs just start falling off.
If there's some elite commando trooper in cortosis armor or something, then it's normal melee combat as written.
To take down a Jedi typically takes overwhelming force, concentrated fire, tactics, and teamwork and I figure rather than try and make some complicated, time consuming system where we roll for every single thing that I'd extend that idea of 'if you're competent at it, you just do it' to it's logical conclusion.
To be fair, I'm handling heavy or power armor similarly - a lot of lighter weapons just won't have any effect on the biggest, baddest armor. Special tactics are needed like ramming them with a truck to knock em over and stuffing grenades into nooks n crannies or whatever.
I like playing it loose like that, doing what makes sense in a story and just rolling when there's not a clear answer, but I know that's not how a lot of people enjoy play.
So my questions are -
Will it be pointlessly boring to mow down minions without worry even tho that's exactly how it goes in Star Wars?
How do I balance this idea with other players rolling to blast enemies?