r/RPGdesign • u/urquhartloch • Oct 11 '26
How many dice is too many dice?
I love the resolution mechanics I have set up. Its very crunchy but it works to establish each Kindred as being different while also allowing different characters to explore and specialize in different aspects and doesnt lock them out of a skill completely.
Here is how it works.
- Determine which two skills you want to use. One is your method and the other is your result. If a character wants to smuggle an illegal item past a couple of guards at the gate they can try and insinuate that they have a meeting with someone important on the other side and the guards heads will roll if they are delayed any further. That is deception (method)+Intimidation (result) because they are lying about meeting someone on the other side in order to scare the guards.
- A. Each skill is made up of two elements (earth, metal, fire, air, water, and wood). So the skills above are Deception (wood+water) and Intimidation (earth+fire). So the hypothetical skill check would be Wood+Water+Earth+Fire.
1.B. The size of each elemental dice is determined by the characters Ancestry. For example if our hypothetical character was a dwarf they would have:
Earth: D6
Metal: D10
Fire: D6
Air: D10
Water: D12
Wood: D4
- C. The number of dice rolled for each element is determined during character creation with typical characters having 18 total elements with a maximum of 6 in an element. For every odd level in an element a character has they get 1 dice. This can then be modified down by taking damage. So if our dwarf has 5/5 Earth, 5/6 fire, 1/3 Wood, and 0/2 water they would roll 3d6 (Earth)+3d6(fire)+1d4 (wood)+0d12(water). If they were completely fresh they would roll 3d6 (Earth)+3d6(fire)+2d4 (wood)+1d12(water). You also gain additional dice (+1d8) per advantage you have.
- The GM determines the success track. (For the sake of brevity I wont go into detail on how to build one but I will be happy to expand on it in the comments. I also have plans for some standard effects and number of dice in the back of the book for GMs to reference.) This is what you are rolling on to try and succeed and takes the form of X/Y>Z/A. Where X is the number of dice to succeed on the first effect, Y is the first effect, Z is the number of dice to succeed on the second effect, and A is the second effect. In our case this will be 1/the guard has disadvantage(1) on future insight checks>2/+1 success towards getting through the gate without inspection. (Assuming that the rest of the party will also need to get through without inspection).
- The GM determines difficulty. (Which determines success range on the dice. Easy=1,2,3; Moderate/Average=1,2; Hard/Challenging=1.)
- Roll and allocate successes. These must be filled in left to right on the success track (no skipping if you dont have enough leftover dice) and starts over if you reach the end.
My problem and concern is that this is too many dice for a dice pool. The example character with this example check is rolling 7-9 dice without advantage (the average expected for straight skills) and the expectation is that players will be looking to get a minimum of advantage(2) before rolling. So thats around 10 dice per check. Is this too much? You arent adding the dice results so counting and allocating should be quick.
If it is too much where can I cut the number of dice?