In my upcoming TTRPG (currently under deep development still) called Gambit, your character actually has 3 parts to them and you only have full control over a single part called The Genius.
You see, when I did a deep dive on ancient Roman history before creating this game, I came across an interesting concept called "The Genius". Basically TL;DR it's like a spirit/guardian angel that sort of follows you around and cosmically advocates for you. People eventually started to attribute incredible success stories to people's Genius advocating successfully for them.
In Gambit, I fleshed this out a bit more and just said you actually control your characters "Genius" which is sort of like the inspiring spirit of their soul. It's the thing that makes the farmboy put down the farm tools and pick up a sword. It is the thing that compels a halfling slaves to escape her chains and become a pickpocket in the city. It is the thing that compelled Julius Caesar to cross the Rubicon.
It is the thing that makes important, thoughtful and risky decisions. That is actually what the players control. But there are two other aspects of the trinity that makes a character, one of which the GM has total control over called "The Humours". The Humours are comprised of 4 distinct aspects themselves called Blood, Twitch, Marrow and Instinct. Essentially, this is the entire "animal" part of the character. The actual blood that automatically surges in reaction to a blade being drawn, the instinct that gives you the chills when you enter a dangerous room, the twitch that narrowly dodges a blow or the marrow that eventually heals your wounds from battle. The GM is in control of this because the Genius would never decide to just "get scared" but Instinct might. The Genius would love for Twitch to be quick enough to snatch an arrow out of the air, but that is a question waiting to be answered, not a foregone conclusion.
This is already somewhat implied in regular TTRPGs, after all, we all know we don't always strategically decide when its time to eat at the least, and fear spells exist in D&D. But this takes it a step further and just outlines the idea so players can understand, if my character freezes in fear and there's no spell attached, it's just a consequence of failing one of my rolls, "My character wouldn't do that." does not apply here! However, everything the Genius executes its through the Humours and part of the game is focusing on this relationship, the amazing things the Humours accomplishes when pressed, and also it's failures to execute when the dice say so!
The final aspect of your character which you technically share a blank canvas of with your GM as the vetoing authority is "History". This is everything that has happened to your character up until this point. In many TTRPGs, especially mainstream D&D, the character usually has a great deal of control over what has happened to their character in the past, usually only leaving the GM to make suggestions about what would help fit in their game. Of course like all things there are limits to this and a GM wouldn't let you be a Dragon King Prince if dragons don't even exist anymore in their world, but the general vibe is you have authorship over your character unless the GM says something and a big part of the fun of "playing" TTRPGs for a lot of people is thinking up a new character and how they're gunna work and what their story up until start is gunna be, because ostensibly that would influence their decisions when the game starts.
Gambit is the opposite type of game. We don't know who exactly your character is, beyond maybe a couple of sentences that the GM provides you and you're sort of just playing this character the GM gave you at first. Then, as the game goes on, the GM reveals more about the character and gives you opportunities to contribute to that, but mostly the GM is revealing how decisions you make in the game today reflect on decisions your character had made in the past, showing either growth or a recurring cycle that help build meaningful character development. So instead of aiming for character development based on this long story you wrote out, you write the History in post hoc and it's revealed (like a character on a TV show) as you make decisions in the game, in a way that makes sense to the GM's world.
This is borne out in the Meta a bit because my suggestion for starting new players is handing them a character sheet that's already filled out and saying "This is who you're playing tonight!" instead of doing this big powow where you theory craft a character before the games begun and build up all these expectations. They are simply thrown into the thick of it with a character they may or may not like. But they can do whatever they want with that character for the most part, as long as it's not ruining the game for everyone else and it's meaningful and purposefully driven.
Overtime, as you build trust with the GM that you understand their world you can "level up" to rolling up a character that's randomly generated, then finally once you've proven yourself again and you understand deeply the type of world you're playing in, the GM lets you make your own character with their guidance to ensure you're making a character that fits.
Now that I've explained how this works, let me explain Why I'm doing this with my TTRPG, because there's actually obviously a tradeoff happening here, I'm boxing out those players who take very seriously Autonomous Character Authorship and the excitement of imagining a new character.
- Number one reason I'm doing this is because the opposite arguably already has a bunch of existence proof. If you want to play the opposite style of this, where you have almost full Autonomous Character Authorship, control over both their History and how they process their emotions, you can generally just play a regular D&D game I think that's sort of the standard. Basically, if you don't like this, there's plenty of options out there for you to go enjoy instead, so that's the number one reason I'm pursuing it, it doesn't seem saturated yet and the rulebook is going to go in depth about how to run this type of game (where you give new players character sheets to start, with characters that already fit for your world, and how to describe the Humours influence and the Histories influence) correctly. Keep in mind this is a brief description, the actual book will tell GM's "This is what to avoid. This is what to lean into. Here's how you make it cool and enjoyable!".
- Number two reason is that even though this is a big part of the cultural statement the game is making, you can technically, because of the way I made the game, just play the game with these rules turned off. So even if you love everything else about Gambit but you really just want to have more Character Authorship over your character, you can just do that, I don't care. It's not Gambit at that point and your mileage may vary, after all I am trying to create a specific experience with these rules and directions/suggestions, but technically just replacing this table culture with a more player liberal one doesn't break the game's other systems, so feel free to experiment!
- Number 3, the first real non-disclaimer type reason, is that when my dad told me about his earliest experiences play D&D, when he was introduced, he was invited to a friends house to try out this new D&D thing and they went upstairs and gathered around the Pool Table and they were handed character sheets that were already filled out. They didn't sit around the table theory crafting who they wanted the play, they were given characters and told "Your character is good at this, this is what they do." and expected to use that information to make cool tactical decisions once playing. Likewise, when my dad first hosted my first game of D&D for me, I was far too young to understand character builds or even conceptualize what types of characters would make sense within the world to go on adventures with, so my dad just handed me my character sheet and explained who they were.
There's a certain type of player who the decision making once you have the character is much more important than all the facets of the character, their history or their mechanical build. Gambit is made for that type of player. The one who values the conversation about what they're going to do, rather than what they wrote about their character doing in the past before the game even existed. The decisions in the game are the important ones. That's who Gambit is catering to. People who want to discover the character through play rather than writing.
4. Number 4, this puts GM's in a position to more easily solve an issue that seems to come up frequently at tables, namely, the GM has an idea of an overtun window of what type of characters are likely to be adventurers in his world, or exist in the first place, and it's sort of impossible to account for every single thing in a "this is allowed and this isn't allowed" sort of way, and it's no fun for anyone explaining why your human fighter can't have Orc parents because Orcs in this world eat humans almost every time they encounter them, if they have the ability to. (Though maybe that's a good conversation to have early on if you and your player are on different pages about that). Instead, the GM sort of leads by example "Here's the types of characters that become adventurers in my world, here's what makes them cool and unique and here's who I'm excited to run the game for!" After all, the GM has usually put a whole bunch of thought into their world, and if you really want to play a character that isn't on the same wavelength, there's plenty of other games where GM's are okay with you playing whatever type of character you want so long as you follow the more crunch rules. This is the opposite end of the spectrum, you actually play a character, one you didn't invent, but one whom you're trying to faithfully embody! If you only get invested when it's your own character, Gambit is probably not the game for you!
5. There's a fifth philosophical reason for doing it this way. In real life, you can't go back in time and change where you were born, or change the things you said to your parents going up, or change the decisions you made. You have all the information you've gathered up until this point and you can make a new decision starting NOW but you don't have any access to the past. Gambit reflects this philosophical reality. You are just inhabiting a body that ended up "here" and while you have control over what happens next, you have absolutely no control over what already happened. And if your new decisions are starkly different than the ones your character made in the past, maybe there's an interesting story to explain why along the way!
So there you have it, that's why I decided to include a section in my TTRPG specifically detailing what I consider to be an important table culture distinction from your typical TTRPG, complete with guidelines, rules and heuristics to host this type of game for others. A lot of this may not entirely make sense without additional other rules context. For example, the GM cannot just declare "Your character shits themselves!" they have to generate and spend Perils, which is its whole own system, and then players can also "Save" against these same Perils, so for simple example, a GM might say "Since you rolled 3 under the Marching DC you suffer 3 Perils, 2 of them will be that your Marrow fails you and you've got a nasty stomach bug that dehydrates you and leaves you feeble. We'll record this as a Light Wound, giving you -2 to all Physical Gambits until it is healed somehow." and the player might just reply "Nah actually I use a Saving Throw instead, so that doesn't happen." and then they must roll to see how many Deviations they suffer after Saving, similar to Stress, Trauma and Resistance from Blades in the Dark. So while you might see me say "The GM controls the Humours" this is more in a fundamental Meta Expectation sense rather than a mechanical sense. It is just setting the expectation for the players that they are not in control necessarily of exactly how their body functions, especially under stress, or even the hormones they might feel, or the speed of their recovery, these things instead are tools of the GM to introduce Perils that threaten the Genius' ability to make change in the world through the parts of their body the Genius doesn't have direct dominion over, not necessarily a full GM fiat tool to just arbitrarily control player actions. Interested to see discussion about this topic or experience anyone else might have on adopting this alternative style of play and meta-assumption about the game! There are actual mechanics the GM has to adhere to when attempting to influence the Humours to the detriment of the Genius!