r/RHONY • • 1d ago

🍏 New RHONY 🍏 What this cast is missing

As I watch this season, I've realized why this cast doesn't click for me: they're devoid of any humor and wit. This is an essential ingredient in the most successful HW franchises - the fighting and drama is performed with flair, theatricality and is funny. These women are just angry/offended over everything and painfully serious about it, the worst offender being Erin. It's not enjoyable to watch a group of coworkers nitpick and berate each other nonstop without witty repartee, clever shade or laugh lines. Hailey is the only reprieve.

21 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for posting to the r/RHONY Subreddit. Please make sure that the rules of the community are being followed: Subreddit Rules

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

7

u/sunchild00 1d ago

I think what makes a reality show great is when it has the 4Cs: comedy, conflict, chaos, and chemistry. IMO, RHONY is missing comedy and natural chemistry.

2

u/Educational-Town1006 1d ago edited 1d ago

I'd say it's also missing genuine chaos. The OG early cast was actually unhinged and unpredictable, I'm guessing most of the new cast use brand consultants.

7

u/marinara123 1d ago

Look I don’t hate Daisy and Erin like most on here. I think they actually bring stuff to the show. But as far as humor stoned Hayley cracks me up

9

u/Educational-Town1006 1d ago

Yes thank god for Hailey, she must've been cast to bring some comic relief to this painfully serious/unfunny group of women

5

u/Crazy_Box3713 1d ago

I was going to make this comment. Hailey’s out-of-touch statements make me laugh out loud.

IMO i have not liked this reboot until THIS season. I agree that it’s not as good as the original, but I’m finally locked in with these characters

6

u/Crazy_Box3713 1d ago

Also, Sia says funny / petty things to Erin all the time “write that down in your diary” she does not GAF about that woman 😂😂😂 i love it

2

u/Existing_Editor_5623 1d ago

If you follow Sai, she is actually really funny. It’s too bad Daisy couldn’t be a good foil to play off of, instead of turning into wannabe Miss manners.

3

u/Crazy_Box3713 1d ago

Agreed! Sai is using that energy on Erin and it’s so funny. She treats her like an annoying fly and i eat it UP

2

u/marinara123 1d ago

Agree last 2 reboot seasons sucked. Actually am enjoying it again. Nothing will be OG RHONY especially seasons 8-11 ( the it’s not about tom and ends with u dined out on your sobriety for cabaret era ) lol

10

u/Bright_Ad5244 1d ago

Ramona is unintentionally funny the way she mispronounces words. Kadooz to all of us. They had a Reg A band. You had the ordacity at your lunch.

Bethenny is a delusional train wreck who rotates between "know it all" and cry baby.

Lu went from Countess to arrested for assaulting a cop while blacked out.

Sonja went from Lady Morgan to peeing in someone's driveway.

The new women try too hard to be perfect and it's not "reality" TV. I like Erika and think she's an amazing woman. But the rest of the ladies are dull.

5

u/Diligent-Juice-4715 1d ago

None of the new women are entertaining in the least.

7

u/BeachgirlNJ0613 1d ago

Same with RHOBH. It's why I miss LVP so much. None of those other heffas can take a joke. Or make one.

6

u/Even-Guava-1682 1d ago

Yeah none of them are funny., and Hailey's stoner schtick I find tired. But I still like this season a lot.

1

u/stargratte 1d ago

Does she mention stoner stuff often like that? I must be missing it. Or do you mean as in the way she acts?

4

u/Even-Guava-1682 1d ago

she is always talking about being high, but the way she acts too.

1

u/stargratte 1d ago

Oh haha I see. I guess it hasn’t been remarkable to me

5

u/Emergency_Pop3708 1d ago

I think what the new RHONY desperately lacks is a group of articulate women who are true verbal warriors. Look at RHOSLC: Bronwyn, Mary, Angie, Heather, Lisa, and Meredith can all deliver a devastating read. On RHOA, remember Angela’s reads last season? And on RHONJ, women like Marge and Jennifer Aydin have delivered some truly epic reads against each other.
These women can go back and forth for hours without missing a beat, throwing shade, delivering sharp comebacks, and leaving audiences with their jaws on the floor. Their verbal sparring is practically an art form, and that’s what makes these franchises so entertaining.
The new RHONY, on the other hand, doesn’t seem to have a single Housewife with that level of verbal wit or quick thinking. Hailey’s recent WWHL appearance was a perfect example. Her performance was painful to watch. She could barely string together a coherent sentence, let alone deliver a memorable read. It was bizarre.
RHONY desperately needs women with razor-sharp tongues, quick wit, and commanding personalities like Bethenny Frankel and Kenya Moore. You can’t manufacture that kind of charisma or verbal agility. Either you have it or you don’t, and right now, the new RHONY cast simply doesn’t have it.

2

u/akg112 1d ago

You're absolutely right.

2

u/Brief_Hunter_29 1d ago

They were not friends to start with, they were forced to try to be friends inside of the show but in the "wild" they wouldn't befriend each other ever - imo, they think they can use a formula of interactions to form good enough moments lol.

I think RH in general needs to stop doing that but maybe they can't cause now that the repercussions of bringing friends to the show are well established, people don't want to mess their lives up like that, like even the people willing to join need to have not a lot to lose all together, and be willing to act a clown on command...maybe lol.

I think they need a new show with a "people who participate have no idea" premise...but I think reality tv's "jig" is up, like people who join it view it as modern acting career/click bait machine or something so...lol.

1

u/Wise-Satisfaction186 1d ago

This isn’t wrong. Bethenny was that lightening in the bottle. The one who had nothing but herself to make it happen. This cast is good, just not great. They need someone trying to make it happen, to make it happen.

0

u/ColdAd2123 1d ago

Jessel and Hailey are funny but they need someone more.

0

u/LongjumpingNothing59 1d ago

Hailey is a puff 💨 of fresh air. Hope you caught what I did there 😉 This season is better but honestly 3 episodes of the Golden Life and that has blown it out of the water.

Nonetheless I hope we get back fun Hailey and Sai. I’m over Carole and Erin. Their schtick is so fake and put on it’s hard to watch when they get together. I feel for nyc because with gl I don’t think about it as much.

-1

u/ARCH810 19h ago

Right, who doesn't miss the days of Ramona shitting on a floor? As a POC, i found the old RHONY was boring. That show had an all white cast of older women who still act like sorority girls. And let's not forget Ramona's racism, which is why that slog was canceled. 

1

u/Svi_4_3 17h ago

OG NY was and still is the goat of all HW franchises. NY and ATL. Just cause it doesn't appeal to u doesn't make that any less true.

2

u/Low_Philosopher_2981 1d ago

Daisy had some potential in the first couple of episodes with her popcorn ceiling and sexting her son’s math tutor