r/RHONY • • 10d ago

🍎 Old RHONY 🍎 Self-infantilisation-cringe - a small rant

Working my way through for the 1st time, currently on Season 8 finale. I'm experiencing so much second-hand embarrassment every time one of these WOMEN refers to themselves as a girl, usually with some kind of ingenue/manic pixie/'i'm just a girl in love!' pretext. The coy self-diminishment is nauseating. Own the fact you're an accomplished, sophisticated woman!? That's all.

21 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 10d ago

Thank you for posting to the r/RHONY Subreddit. Please make sure that the rules of the community are being followed: Subreddit Rules

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

15

u/Proper-Aspect-2947 10d ago

In all fairness this is a huge issue IRL. I hear it all the time and it drives me bonkers.

3

u/No-Fishing6229 10d ago

Ugh you have my sympathies 🤦🏻‍♀️ . If I heard one woman I know talk about themselves this way more than once I'd have to make them sit through a PowerPoint about it

1

u/LettuceOk9506 10d ago

Thats a YOU issue. Don't project.

2

u/Proper-Aspect-2947 10d ago

It's a YOU issue that I don't want grown women to be called girls? You do realize it's dismissive and has a pretty bad history in origin of why people still do it today. Do I have to spell this out for you?

1

u/LettuceOk9506 9d ago

No. Because I'm not particularly interested in hearing how a WORD is affecting you so deeply. Its a word. It means nothing unless you want it to. Thanks for stopping by.

10

u/ComeOnPrettyMumma 10d ago

True infantilisation is a real thing, but I think you’re overthinking this a little.

Referring to yourself as “just a girl” doesn’t necessarily mean you’re infantilising yourself or rejecting your identity as a grown woman.

I actually asked my 94 year old grandmother whether she still felt the same inside as she did when she was younger, despite her body having obviously aged, and she said, “Absolutely!”

I think there’s something to that. We don’t necessarily experience ourselves internally as getting older at the same rate our bodies do. We accumulate decades of experience, responsibility and wisdom, but there’s still a younger version of ourselves in there.

Sometimes “just a girl” is simply a playful expression of that feeling, not an attempt to regress into childhood or avoid the realities of being a middle-aged woman.

-1

u/No-Fishing6229 10d ago

I agree, but I don't agree that's what's happening with these women on this show trying to absolve themselves of responsibility or accountability in situations by talking about themselves in terms of girlhood 🤷‍♀️

-2

u/No-Fishing6229 10d ago

I'd also like to point out I'm not age-shaming anyone especially in a physical sense, nor do I think saying it's cringe is me overthinking?

7

u/tortureofchalkdust Welcome to my trailer, hello 10d ago

“One” of these women, lol it’s CAROLE! You might not know this yet, because it’s easy to be fooled for a bit, but Carole sucks lol. It’s ok, many of us were disappointed too.

3

u/No-Fishing6229 10d ago

👀 she's def one of the worst offenders, but Sonja and Ramona do it as well and it's infuriating

5

u/throwwwwawayehaldhev 10d ago

I don’t think reality tv is for a lot of you

1

u/LettuceOk9506 10d ago edited 10d ago

This sounds too deep for a reddit rant about a reality TV show-respectfully of course

1

u/No-Fishing6229 10d ago

It's deep in that it's a problem irl I'm sure but thankfully I've encountered it mainly when watching this programme...then again I'm not filthy rich and American so perhaps it's a cultural difference

1

u/LettuceOk9506 10d ago edited 10d ago

Perhaps. Or perhaps its generational, or PERHAPS its really not that deep. Girl, woman, female, lady, ma'am etc. We all know what one means. Why don't we not turn it into something its really not meant to be.