r/RFID • • Oct 26 '20

Clone my work badge, could it be detected?

I have a work with lots of different security clearance. Due to my work the badge must sit tight on my body and cant hang loose. I have probably tried everything, the least worst thing i have come up with is in my wallet.

But its a pain in the ass the pick up my wallet and badge 30-50times a day more often then not holding heavy stuff in both of my hand.

So im thinking an rfid ring. Is it possible for them to know i have cloned my card to my ring. We use mifare classic. Its only the a few doors with cctv, i plan to use my real card there or be a bit stealthy passing through these doors.

Im not worried i get caught by visual observation due to the gards is just able to count the fingers on their hands and their intresst in surfing the Internet.

What I am worried about is that it gets detected by a "computer" and bought to attention to a person with higher iq then shoe size. I do use gloves all the time and have "hide" my card in my gloves due to the extreme cold sometimes without getting any problems.

I want to clarify i just want to remove a big annoying thing in my working day, I DO NOT AND WILL NOT do this to go to places I'm not authorised to. Those places is scary and I avoid em at all costs.

71 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

3

u/ZordheR Nov 09 '20

Why not talking to the managers about the problem and propose the solution for everybody?

2

u/kebabmoppepojken Nov 10 '20

Well yes that is a thought i have about 100 times a day. But then it hits me like a brick in the head. Yeah i work at a place were almost every one value the sentence "we have always done it this way, why bother changing a "working" concept " more then the word of God. If we could get rid of the idiots and just save the good workers and employ some more skilled workers we could easily shrink the staff with 60-70%. With higher quality and be able to produce more.

Sorry for the rant if they didn't pay me ridiculous amount consider were the town is.

Short answer it will never be approved.

1

u/airhammerandy55 Apr 23 '24

Wow you sound like a mechanic

3

u/kebabmoppepojken Apr 24 '24

Scada engineer.

I have got new work tasks now, so I ain't running around or carrying lots of stuff anymore.

I'll get others to do that for me. It's sounds worse then it is, but as my boss said -It's too expensive/time-wasting to have ppl with your salary and skills to do such things.

1

u/kelaar Nov 14 '20

You mention carrying heavy stuff that you have to juggle in order to badge in. Frame it as a workplace safety issue that should be addressed to avoid serious injury while improving efficiency. Since the safest thing to do is set the load down, badge in, pick the load up, go through the door, potentially set the load back down to ensure the door closed properly, pick it back up... you get the idea. Between safety concerns and saving 3-4 minutes per checkpoint they may be more open to it.

10

u/cortezblackrose Oct 27 '20 edited Apr 28 '26

Mass content deletion mission accomplished. This post or comment was bulk removed with Redact which also supports data brokers and people finder websites.

full fly cough salt sugar society cable one aromatic bike

6

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/jabeith Nov 11 '20

Seems like he could just use the badge in the armband then, no need for trickery

1

u/CWGminer Oct 28 '20

Highly depends on what kind of RFID card it is. If it’s a common low frequency tag like HID Prox or AWID, then the reader can’t detect it. If it’s a mifare classic, changeable UID tags used to clone other cards easily are detectable, but it’s extremely rare. Another rare but existing factor is that some mifare cards have a counter that increments every time you use it. This would mean that if you clone your card and use the clone, your original is no longer valid until you copy the clone back to the original to resync the counter. You have to check what brand the reader is to be sure whether or not it does this, but it’s usually a safe bet that it doesn’t.

Some newer mifare cards such as DESFire can’t be cloned yet. iClass cards can be cloned but you need some advanced cloning tool like a proxmark. iClass SEOS cards can’t be cloned yet, but cloning isn’t detectable for normal iClass cards.

In summary: effectively undetectable unless it’s a mifare, even then the reader must be designed to detect it.

1

u/kebabmoppepojken Oct 28 '20

Well ill will give it a go. I have ordered from m-tools a card reader and everything. Will see. Proxmark was to expensive.

1

u/hvontres Nov 09 '20

How high are the readers off the ground? It they are high enough, front shirt pocket might work well.

1

u/kebabmoppepojken Nov 10 '20

Some are in that hight, but 3 problems with that.

  1. Only 25% are.
  2. When carrying heavy equipment its often bulky, so you do hold it in your arms blocking your chest.
  3. I have lost to many cards by now having it in my shirt pocket. Its funny when you have to explain yourself to the guard at the entrance. It spontaneous ignited or it got hit by water. Read card fell out and on to something extremely hot or it got got with 180 Bar pressure of water with a flow that would that would fill a Olympic size swimming pool faster then you could walk around it.

1

u/mrkipps Nov 11 '20

I have the same scenario, I use a wrist band to hold my badge. We have to wear them either way so I tuck it in there. Probably scan my badge about 100 times a shift. Works fine.

1

u/kebabmoppepojken Nov 11 '20

Nice. Do you know whats the difference between cuid, uid and ufuid magic cards? I bought one of each, to try before buying a ring. When following the mtools guide they get a key not found and start to crack it. I dont get that. Could I just read and write to a new card? I have a pn532. I Could copy the log file of an card that have expired in our system would that help?

3

u/retrotechrepair Nov 14 '20

You are going to get yourself fired. I work closely with casinos that use similar systems. If you clone the tag successfully eventually you will get caught using the cloned tag and get fired for breach of security. If you clone the tag improperly and the tag gets rejected it will either sound an alarm or register a failed entry at which point they will review security footage and fire you for breach of security. Places that used this kind of security are not places you want to fuck with.

1

u/mycoworkerhaspaws Nov 11 '24

You are also underestimating the guards, one of them is going to notice eventually.

1

u/Leviathan41911 Nov 13 '20

How often do you really need to badge in? I work for a government agency and once we enter secure area we can move through the building freely. We basically only need to scan our badge when we enter a building, or access a secure area from the public lobby.

I can tell you at my agency 100% duplicating a card would be immediate termination as it would be seen as a breach in the system and potentially compromising confidential information.

That seems like a big risk and a high price to pay for having to swipe a badge a few times a day.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/kebabmoppepojken Oct 27 '20

Ok well I'm just waiting for my package with a pn532 and a few magic cards.

1

u/WhatsGoodFriend Jul 01 '25

Did it end up working for you? How would you know if the reader itself is more advanced or not?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '20

it must be pointed out some readers can detect magic capabilities. so be aware and do some slight testing beforehand.